Caroline Sullivan’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 204 reviews, going back to 2001, each next to the album’s Breakdown.
Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.Writes for
The Guardian 2001–2022 · 204 reviews
What they review
- Pop 36%
- Rock 24%
- Indie & Alternative 20%
- R&B & Soul 8%
Find Caroline Sullivan
By the numbers
4A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
4albums given a perfect score
22years of their reviews we track, 2001 to 2022
51%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (204 albums)
12points, on average, between their release-week reviews and where the other critics ended up (39 reviews)
How their scores spread
- 0–4929
- 50s0
- 60s112
- 70s3
- 80s56
- 90+4
Their favorites
PortisheadPortishead 100 The Guardian
The Stone RosesSecond Coming 100 The Guardian
PJ HarveyTo Bring You My Love 100 The Guardian
The VerveUrban Hymns 100 The Guardian
Depeche ModeMemento Mori 80 The Guardian
Artists they keep coming back to
Their scores for each artist, in release order.
- Kelly Clarkson 5 reviews40Breakaway60Thankful60My December60Wrapped in Red60Piece by Piece
- Depeche Mode 4 reviews80Ultra60Playing the Angel60Delta Machine80Memento Mori
- Manic Street Preachers 4 reviews80Generation Terrorists80Everything Must Go60Lifeblood80Journal for Plague Lov…
- Blur 3 reviews80The Great Escape80Blur8013
- Nelly Furtado 3 reviews60Whoa, Nelly!60Folklore60The Spirit Indestructi…
- Lady Gaga 2 reviews80Cheek to Cheek60Joanne
A-Sides they reviewed
4 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 4 of them 75 or higher.
Every review
| Outlet | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Depeche ModeMemento Mori | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | 2022 |
 Lady GagaJoanne“The singer strips back the excess image to produce a rootsy album that showcases her powerful voice and maybe brings us closer to the real Stefani Germanotta” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 68 | 2016 |
 OneRepublicOh My My | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 61 | 2016 |
 LordePure Heroine“Ella "Lorde" Yelich-O'Connor, at just 16, could be a whole new pop archetype, and her songs are great, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | 2013 |
 Miley CyrusBangerz | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | 2013 |
 StingThe Last Ship“Sting's new album is a companion piece to his play about the decline of the north-east's shipyards; it's not totally convincing, but done in a good spirit, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 63 | 2013 |
 Elton JohnThe Diving Board“Elton John's latest is a thoroughly conservative singer-songwriter album, but a terrifically good one nonetheless, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 78 | 2013 |
 Backstreet BoysIn a World Like This | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 54 | 2013 |
 Depeche ModeDelta Machine“This album may be overly bleak, but there's beauty here, too, balancing lushness and minimalism to stunning effect, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2013 |
 HurtsExile | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | 2013 |
 KeshaWarrior“A guest spot from Iggy Pop livens up an otherwise very so-so new album from Kesha, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 72 | 2012 |
 The Script#3 | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 40 | 2012 |
 Jason DeruloFuture History“You want an album that sounds like every other chart album? Caroline Sullivan can tell you about one” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 60 | 2011 |
 The KooksJunk of the Heart | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 58 | 2011 |
 T.I.No Mercy“T.I. combines lapses of judgment with dour, generic, music, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 56 | 2011 |
 Cyndi LauperMemphis Blues“Cyndi Lauper's got the blues. Caroline Sullivan meets her at the crossroads.” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 45 | 2010 |
 Brandon FlowersFlamingo | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | 2010 |
 Jay SeanAll or Nothing | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 58 | 2009 |
 ShakiraShe Wolf“She looks like a diva and has the sales to match, but Shakira is too eccentric to be lumped in with the Whitneys and Mariahs, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 71 | 2009 |
 MikaThe Boy Who Knew Too Much“The Boy Who Knew Too Much also makes a case for Mika being one of the most underrated pop mavericks, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | 2009 |
 LenkaLenka | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 61 | 2009 |
 Regina SpektorFar“The follow-up to 2006's Begin to Hope is shinier, but just as whimsical, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 69 | 2009 |
 Black Eyed PeasThe E.N.D“Electronic clicks and buzzes are used lavishly, just don't expect to love it immediately, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 57 | 2009 |
 Manic Street PreachersJournal for Plague Lovers“It's taken the band 14 years to put music to what turned out to be Richey Edwards last words, and you can see why, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 77 | 2009 |
 Yeah Yeah YeahsIt’s Blitz!“The band's glittery new disco sound suits them very well. It's all cool, brittle catchiness, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | 2009 |
 AkonFreedom“Despite his hip-hop roots and the presence of guest rappers, it's Akon's buoyant pop sensibility that prevails” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 55 | 2008 |
 PinkFunhouse | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 68 | 2008 |
 The SaturdaysChasing Lights“They are good enough to win Girls Aloud-style plaudits, and Chasing Lights is a reasonably promising debut” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2008 |
 Alanis MorissetteFlavors of Entanglement | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | 2008 |
 Janet JacksonDiscipline | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 66 | 2008 |
 Dave GahanHourglass | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 70 | 2007 |
 Beach HouseBeach House | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | 2007 |
 Mutya BuenaReal Girl | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 53 | 2007 |
 Sophie Ellis-BextorTrip the Light Fantastic | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2007 |
 Kaiser ChiefsYours Truly, Angry Mob | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 59 | 2007 |
 Fall Out BoyInfinity on High | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 73 | 2007 |
 Gwen StefaniThe Sweet Escape | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 57 | 2006 |
 McFlyMotion in the Ocean | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2006 |
 Meat LoafBat Out of Hell III: The Monster is Loose | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 56 | 2006 |
 KeaneUnder the Iron Sea | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2006 |
 Mary J. BligeThe Breakthrough | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 78 | 2005 |
 R. KellyTP.3 Reloaded | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 71 | 2005 |
 JamiroquaiDynamite | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 59 | 2005 |
 Mariah CareyThe Emancipation of Mimi | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | 2005 |
 Billy IdolDevil’s Playground | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 57 | 2005 |
 Tears for FearsEverybody Loves a Happy Ending | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 55 | 2005 |
 The KillsNo Wow | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 78 | 2005 |
 MorrisseySouthpaw Grammar | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | 2005 |
 Wyclef JeanThe Carnival | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 78 | 2004 |
 John LegendGet Lifted | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | 2004 |
 KT TunstallEye to the Telescope | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 78 | 2004 |
 MadonnaRay of Light | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 84 | 2004 |
 Joss StoneMind Body & Soul | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | 2004 |
 Paul McCartneyRun Devil Run | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 74 | 2004 |
 UsherConfessions | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 70 | 2004 |
 Courtney LoveAmerica’s Sweetheart | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 62 | 2004 |
 Enrique Iglesias7“1 star (Interscope)” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 20 1/5 | 53 | 2003 |
 The DarknessPermission to Land | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | 2003 |
 The LemonheadsCar Button Cloth | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 73 | 2003 |
 Missy ElliottUnder Construction | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 75 | 2002 |
 Justin TimberlakeJustified | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 67 | 2002 |
 Michelle BranchThe Spirit Room“Susana Baca sings up a riot, Luke Slater buffs up electro, and Michelle Branch dreams up poems. Plus the rest of the new pop.” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 75 | 2002 |
 Geri HalliwellScream If You Wanna Go Faster“Old Spice meets the boys in black eyeliner in this week's CDs” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 33 | 2001 |
 Oasis(What’s the Story) Morning Glory? | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 78 | |
 Blur13 | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 79 | |
 Bruno Mars24K Magic | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
 Amy MacdonaldA Curious Thing“Amy Macdonald's second album lacks the killer punch, reckons Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 63 | |
 Céline DionA New Day Has Come | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 58 | |
 Tori AmosAmerican Doll Posse | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 79 | |
 AnastaciaAnastacia | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | |
 Avril LavigneAvril Lavigne | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 BeyoncéB’Day | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 71 | |
 Jordin SparksBattlefield | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 60 | |
 Donald GloverBecause the Internet | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 61 | |
 Pet Shop BoysBilingual | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 74 | |
 BlurBlur | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | |
 Robin ThickeBlurred Lines | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 63 | |
 Body CountBorn Dead | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 25 1/4 | 56 | |
 Kelly ClarksonBreakaway | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 72 | |
 Red Hot Chili PeppersCalifornication | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 HoleCelebrity Skin | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 80 | |
 Lady GagaCheek to Cheek | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 64 | |
 CherCloser to the Truth“Cher has been complaining about getting old lately, but she seems fuller than energy than ever, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 56 | |
 SiaColour the Small One | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | |
 SuedeComing Up | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 77 | |
 TLCCrazySexyCool | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | |
 D12D12 World | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 61 | |
 NickelbackDark Horse | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 20 1/5 | 48 | |
 Destiny's ChildDestiny Fulfilled | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 51 | |
 Robert PlantDreamland | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 Screaming TreesDust | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 80 | |
 David BowieEarthling | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 75 3/4 | 73 | |
 Elliott SmithElliott Smith | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 88 | |
 Manic Street PreachersEverything Must Go | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 91 | |
 TLCFanMail | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 77 | |
 Snow PatrolFinal Straw | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 73 | |
 Fall Out BoyFolie à Deux | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 Nelly FurtadoFolklore | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | |
 KornFollow the Leader | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 76 | |
 Foo FightersFoo Fighters | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 83 | |
 Norah JonesForeverly | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 Tori AmosFrom the Choirgirl Hotel | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 79 | |
 GarbageGarbage | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 87 | |
 Manic Street PreachersGeneration Terrorists | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 83 | |
 Leona LewisGlassheart | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 58 | |
 Patti SmithGone Again | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 77 | |
 The CardigansGran Turismo | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 Shawn MendesHandwritten“He started out covering Justin Bieber songs online, but Shawn Mendes’s debut album suggests there’s much more to him than that” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 57 | |
 Beastie BoysHello Nasty | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 86 | |
 BjörkHomogenic | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 86 | |
 AerosmithHonkin’ on Bobo | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 69 | |
 Melanie BrownHot | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 63 | |
 Def LeppardHysteria | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 92 | |
 Ashlee SimpsonI Am Me | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 44 | |
 My Chemical RomanceI Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 Susan BoyleI Dreamed a Dream“This album is where sentiment clashes with the question of whether Susan's Boyle got what it takes, says Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 52 | |
 The NeighbourhoodI Love You | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 50 | |
 Foo FightersIn Your Honor | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 69 | |
 PJ HarveyIs This Desire? | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 82 | |
 Busta RhymesIt Ain’t Safe No More… | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 73 | |
 Jason DeruloJason Derulo | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 68 | |
 JAŸ‐ZKingdom Come | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 70 | |
 Carly Rae JepsenKiss | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 64 | |
 Elvis CostelloKojak Variety | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 59 | |
 Natalie ImbrugliaLeft of the Middle | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 69 | |
 Ne-YoLibra Scale | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
 Manic Street PreachersLifeblood | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | |
 MorrisseyMaladjusted | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 58 | |
 Mike OldfieldMan on the Rocks“Mike Oldfield's first album in six years is an unashamedly retro but very likable re-enactment of classic 70s radio rock, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 50 | |
 Mariah CareyMe. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | |
 Marilyn MansonMechanical Animals | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 78 | |
 MogwaiMogwai Young Team | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 83 | |
 Calvin HarrisMotion | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 58 | |
 BeckMutations | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 85 | |
 Kate NashMy Best Friend Is You | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 Kelly ClarksonMy December | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | |
 Ariana GrandeMy Everything | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 Mary J. BligeMy Life | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 75 3/4 | 67 | |
 R.E.M.New Adventures in Hi-Fi | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 88 | |
 Pearl JamNo Code | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 74 | |
 RadioheadOK Computer | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 91 | |
 George MichaelOlder | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 David GuettaOne Love | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 67 | |
 Girls AloudOut of Control | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | |
 Maroon 5Overexposed“Maroon 5's precision-tooled new album doesn't contain anything wildly exciting, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 59 | |
 John MayerParadise Valley | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 69 | |
 Kelly ClarksonPiece by Piece | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 62 | |
 Katie MeluaPiece by Piece | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 62 | |
 PlaceboPlacebo | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 68 | |
 Depeche ModePlaying the Angel | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
| PortisheadPortishead | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 100 5/5 | 86 | |
 Take ThatProgress“Robbie's back, Take That are on top form, and Caroline Sullivan is delighted” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 76 | |
 Justin BieberPurpose | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 66 | |
 No DoubtPush and Shove | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 64 | |
 Queens of the Stone AgeRated R | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 85 | |
 UsherRaymond v. Raymond | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 55 | |
 David BowieReality | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 74 | |
 No DoubtReturn of Saturn | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 74 | |
 Elliott SmithRoman Candle | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
| The Stone RosesSecond Coming | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 100 4/4 | 65 | |
 Kelly RowlandSimply Deep | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 53 | |
 Robbie WilliamsSing When You’re Winning | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 71 | |
 Jeff BuckleySketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 84 | |
 Maroon 5Songs About Jane | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 Spice GirlsSpiceworld | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 63 | |
 Selena GomezStars Dance | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 49 | |
 Jessie JSweet Talker | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 57 | |
 Enter ShikariTake to the Skies | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 63 | |
 Willie NelsonTeatro | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 70 | |
 PavementTerror Twilight | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 81 | |
 Kelly ClarksonThankful | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 60 | |
 Black Eyed PeasThe Beginning“Not so much a beginning as more of the same, says Caroline Sullivan, but it doesn't make Black Eyed Peas any less enjoyable” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 58 | |
 BlondieThe Curse of Blondie | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 65 | |
 BlurThe Great Escape | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 90 | |
 Ja RuleThe Last Temptation | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 63 | |
 Nelly FurtadoThe Spirit Indestructible | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 62 | |
 Craig DavidThe Story Goes… | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 47 | |
 Sean PaulThe Trinity | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 PinkThe Truth About Love | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 73 | |
 Destiny's ChildThe Writing’s on the Wall | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 74 | |
 Amy MacdonaldThis Is the Life | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
 Fiona AppleTidal | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 78 | |
| PJ HarveyTo Bring You My Love | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 100 4/4 | 93 | |
 JamiroquaiTravelling Without Moving | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 68 | |
 Adam LambertTrespassing | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 70 | |
 Depeche ModeUltra | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 73 | |
 Justin BieberUnder the Mistletoe | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 59 | |
 Bruno MarsUnorthodox Jukebox“Bruno Mars's second album contains more clinically perfect songcraft, and also some rather unpleasant sentiments, writes Caroline Sullivan” | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
 Swedish House MafiaUntil Now | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 56 | |
 Natasha BedingfieldUnwritten | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 71 | |
| The VerveUrban Hymns | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 100 5/5 | 84 | |
 BjörkVespertine | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 85 | |
 OneRepublicWaking Up | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 59 | |
 Ice CubeWar & Peace Vol. 2 | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 65 | |
 Bon JoviWhat About Now | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 55 | |
 Jessie JWho You Are | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 52 | |
 Nelly FurtadoWhoa, Nelly! | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 72 | |
 The CureWild Mood Swings | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 40 2/5 | 60 | |
 BastilleWild World | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 80 4/5 | 73 | |
 Tom PettyWildflowers | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 75 3/4 | 83 | |
 PavementWowee Zowee | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 25 1/4 | 57 | |
 Kelly ClarksonWrapped in Red | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 65 | |
 Nine Inch NailsYear Zero | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 76 | |
 Sigur RósÁgætis byrjun | The Guardian via Wikipedia | 60 3/5 | 83 |
Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home