Every year’s best albums, ranked by B-Side Breakdown. A year’s numbers count its albums with five or more reviews, so they shift as our back catalog fills in.
This year
The best albums of 2026 so far
Average Breakdown 75. 80% of albums liked. So far it rates higher than 75% of past years.
Years that stand out
Highest-rated year1969Average Breakdown of 82, the highest of any year here.Number one: The Band, The BandLowest-rated year2009Average Breakdown of 68, the lowest of any year here.Number one: Jars of Clay, The Long Fall Back to EarthMost A-Sides196940% of its albums earned an A-Side, the critics' top tier.Number one: The Band, The BandMost divisive year199042% of its albums split the critics: Divided or Contentious.Number one: Public Enemy, Fear of a Black Planet
Average Breakdown, year by year
Years with at least 25 albums of five or more reviews. This year is in red. Tap a bar for that year’s list.
Every year
2020s
2026Neurosis, An Undying Love for a Burning WorldAverage 75
2025Converge, Love Is Not EnoughAverage 74
2024Charles Lloyd, The Sky Will Still Be There TomorrowAverage 75
2023Amaarae, Fountain BabyAverage 75
2022Black Country, New Road, Ants from Up ThereAverage 75
2021Leprous, AphelionAverage 76
2020Fiona Apple, Fetch the Bolt CuttersAverage 752010s
2019Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, GhosteenAverage 74
2018Rahim Redcar, ChrisAverage 73
2017Cécile McLorin Salvant, Dreams and DaggersAverage 72
2016Big Star, Third/Sister LoversAverage 73
2015Kendrick Lamar, To Pimp a ButterflyAverage 71
2014D’Angelo, Black MessiahAverage 71
2013Wayne Shorter, Without a NetAverage 71
2012Kendrick Lamar, Good Kid, M.A.A.D CityAverage 69
2011Amon Amarth, Surtur RisingAverage 68
2010Kanye West, My Beautiful Dark Twisted FantasyAverage 702000s
2009Jars of Clay, The Long Fall Back to EarthAverage 68
2008John McLaughlin, Floating PointAverage 68
2007Burial, UntrueAverage 69
2006Jars of Clay, Good MonstersAverage 69
2005Opeth, Ghost ReveriesAverage 69
2004Loretta Lynn, Van Lear RoseAverage 69
2003Opeth, DamnationAverage 68
2002Isis, OceanicAverage 69
2001Converge, Jane DoeAverage 70
2000OutKast, StankoniaAverage 711990s
1998Lucinda Williams, Car Wheels on a Gravel RoadAverage 72
1996DJ Shadow, Endtroducing…..Average 72
1995Tricky, MaxinquayeAverage 71
1994Johnny Cash, American RecordingsAverage 74
1993Liz Phair, Exile in GuyvilleAverage 73
1992R.E.M., Automatic for the PeopleAverage 73
1991Massive Attack, Blue LinesAverage 72
1990Public Enemy, Fear of a Black PlanetAverage 721980s
1989Beastie Boys, Paul’s BoutiqueAverage 74
1988Public Enemy, It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us BackAverage 75
1987Prince, Sign “O” the TimesAverage 73
1986Paul Simon, GracelandAverage 74
1985Tom Waits, Rain DogsAverage 74
1984The Replacements, Let It BeAverage 73
1983R.E.M., MurmurAverage 75
1982Richard Thompson, Shoot Out the LightsAverage 73
1981X, Wild GiftAverage 75
1980Joy Division, CloserAverage 781970s
1979Joy Division, Unknown PleasuresAverage 76
1978Willie Nelson, StardustAverage 75
1977Television, Marquee MoonAverage 80
1976Ramones, RamonesAverage 76
1975Patti Smith, HorsesAverage 79
1973Stevie Wonder, InnervisionsAverage 78
1972The Rolling Stones, Exile on Main St.Average 81
1971Joni Mitchell, BlueAverage 82
1970Neil Young, After the Gold RushAverage 791960s
1969The Band, The BandAverage 82
1968The Band, Music from Big Pink
1967Albert King, Born Under a Bad Sign
1966The Beach Boys, Pet Sounds
1965Bob Dylan, Highway 61 Revisited
1964Herbie Hancock, Empyrean Isles
1963Bob Dylan, The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan
1962Ray Charles, Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music
1961Oliver Nelson, The Blues and the Abstract Truth
1960John Coltrane, Giant Steps
1
2
3
4
5


