The best-reviewed albums of 2005, ranked by Breakdown. An album needs at least 5 reviews to make the list.
- 1

Nevermore, This Godless EndeavorJuly 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 93Heavy Rotation
- 2

Opeth, Ghost ReveriesAugust 26, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate 92Heavy Rotation
- 3

Nile, Annihilation of the WickedMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 88Heavy Rotation
- 4

Sufjan Stevens, IllinoisJuly 4, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 88Heavy Rotation
- 5

Sleater-Kinney, The WoodsMay 24, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 87Heavy Rotation
- 6

Bruce Springsteen, Devils & DustApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 87Heavy Rotation
- 7

Candlemass, CandlemassMay 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 86Heavy Rotation
- 8

Porcupine Tree, DeadwingMarch 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 86Heavy Rotation
- 9

Kano, Home Sweet HomeJune 27, 2005 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 10

Strapping Young Lad, AlienMarch 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 84Keeper
Where 2005's albums land
Share of albums at each verdict. Heavy Rotation is 85 and up, Back of the Crate is below 55.
2005
Heavy Rotation3%
Keeper51%
Mixed Bag38%
Back of the Crate9%
Every year
Heavy Rotation10%
Keeper54%
Mixed Bag30%
Back of the Crate7%
- 11

Bruce Dickinson, Tyranny of SoulsMay 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 12

ANOHNI and the Johnsons, I Am a Bird NowFebruary 1, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 13

M.I.A., ArularFebruary 22, 2005 · 14 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 14

Kanye West, Late RegistrationMarch 2005 · 14 reviews · 93% approval · Divided 84Keeper
- 15

My Morning Jacket, ZOctober 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 16

The Go-Betweens, Oceans ApartApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 17

Ry Cooder, Chávez RavineJune 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 83Keeper
- 18

Robyn, RobynMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 83Keeper
- 19

Hate Eternal, I, MonarchJune 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 20

Common, BeMay 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 83Keeper
- 21

LCD Soundsystem, LCD SoundsystemJanuary 19, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 22

Kate Bush, AerialOctober 3, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 23

Nightrage, Descent into ChaosApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 24

Billy Bang, Vietnam: ReflectionsMay 4, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 82Keeper
- 25

Wolf Parade, Apologies to the Queen MarySeptember 27, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
Where 2005 sits
Average Breakdown, for albums with five or more reviews.
Next to the years around it
200270
200368
200469
2005 (this year)69
200669
200769
200869
657075
By genre
Metal & Punk76
Indie & Alternative72
Electronic69
Hip-Hop & Rap69
R&B & Soul68
Folk, Country & Americana68
Pop66
Rock66
6065707580
- 26

Vashti Bunyan, LookafteringOctober 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
- 27

Animal Collective, FeelsOctober 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 28

Trisha Yearwood, Jasper CountySeptember 13, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
- 29

Gojira, From Mars to SiriusSeptember 27, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 30

Annihilator, Schizo DeluxeOctober 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 81Keeper
- 31

Super Furry Animals, Love KraftAugust 22, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 32

Okkervil River, Black Sheep BoyApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 33

The New Pornographers, Twin CinemaAugust 23, 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 34

Eels, Blinking Lights and Other RevelationsApril 25, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement 81Keeper
- 35

Bolt Thrower, Those Once LoyalNovember 11, 2005 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 36

Amorphis, EclipseDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 37

Fiona Apple, Extraordinary MachineMarch 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 38

81Keeper
- 39

Richard Hawley, Coles CornerSeptember 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 80Keeper
- 40

Silver Jews, Tanglewood NumbersOctober 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 80Keeper
- 41

Neil Diamond, 12 SongsNovember 8, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided 80Keeper
- 42

Bright Eyes, I’m Wide Awake, It’s MorningJanuary 19, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided 80Keeper
- 43

Amerie, Because I Love It2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 44

Ladytron, Witching HourJuly 2005 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 80Keeper
- 45

Neil Young, Prairie WindSeptember 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 46

System of a Down, MezmerizeMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 47

Blackalicious, The CraftSeptember 27, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 48

Sage Francis, A Healthy DistrustFebruary 8, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement 79Keeper
- 49

Audio Adrenaline, Until My Heart Caves InAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 50

Will Oldham, SuperwolfJanuary 7, 2005 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 79Keeper
- 1

ANOHNI and the Johnsons, I Am a Bird NowFebruary 1, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 2

Robyn, RobynMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 83Keeper
- 3

Super Furry Animals, Love KraftAugust 22, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 4

Fiona Apple, Extraordinary MachineMarch 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 5

Richard Hawley, Coles CornerSeptember 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 80Keeper
- 6

Róisín Murphy, Ruby BlueMay 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 7

Madonna, Confessions on a Dance FloorNovember 11, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Divided 75Keeper
- 8

Girls Aloud, ChemistryDecember 5, 2005 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Divided 74Keeper
- 9

Shakira, Fijación Oral, Vol. 1June 3, 2005 · 8 reviews · 63% approval · Some debate 72Keeper
- 10

Mariah Carey, The Emancipation of MimiApril 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate 72Keeper
- 11

Sugababes, Taller in More WaysOctober 10, 2005 · 7 reviews · 43% approval · Some debate 71Keeper
- 12

Depeche Mode, Playing the AngelOctober 11, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate 71Keeper
- 13

Paul McCartney, Chaos and Creation in the BackyardSeptember 12, 2005 · 12 reviews · 58% approval · Broad agreement 71Keeper
- 14

Switchfoot, Nothing Is SoundSeptember 13, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Divided 70Keeper
- 15

The Bad Plus, Suspicious Activity?September 20, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Divided 69Mixed Bag
- 16

Shakira, Oral Fixation, Vol. 2November 28, 2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate 69Mixed Bag
- 17

The Cardigans, Super Extra GravityOctober 14, 2005 · 9 reviews · 56% approval · Some debate 66Mixed Bag
- 18

Dave Matthews Band, Stand UpMay 10, 2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate 65Mixed Bag
- 19

The All-American Rejects, Move AlongJuly 6, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Broad agreement 64Mixed Bag
- 20

Sean Paul, The TrinitySeptember 26, 2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate 64Mixed Bag
- 1

Bruce Springsteen, Devils & DustApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 87Heavy Rotation
- 2

Bruce Dickinson, Tyranny of SoulsMay 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 3

Ry Cooder, Chávez RavineJune 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 83Keeper
- 4

The New Pornographers, Twin CinemaAugust 23, 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 5

Eels, Blinking Lights and Other RevelationsApril 25, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement 81Keeper
- 6

Neil Diamond, 12 SongsNovember 8, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided 80Keeper
- 7

Audio Adrenaline, Until My Heart Caves InAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 8

Will Oldham, SuperwolfJanuary 7, 2005 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 79Keeper
- 9

Boris, PinkNovember 12, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Divided 79Keeper
- 10

The Decemberists, PicaresqueMarch 21, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided 79Keeper
- 11

Casting Crowns, LifesongAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided 78Keeper
- 12

Wolfmother, WolfmotherOctober 31, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 13

Anberlin, Never Take Friendship PersonalJanuary 1, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement 77Keeper
- 14

Beck, GueroMarch 16, 2005 · 13 reviews · 77% approval · Some debate 77Keeper
- 15

Josh Rouse, NashvilleFebruary 22, 2005 · 11 reviews · 73% approval · Broad agreement 76Keeper
- 16

Funeral for a Friend, HoursJune 8, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 76Keeper
- 17

Fantômas, Suspended AnimationApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 75Keeper
- 18

Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, HowlAugust 22, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Broad agreement 74Keeper
- 19

Elbow, Leaders of the Free WorldJanuary 1, 2005 · 12 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 74Keeper
- 20

Thrice, VheissuOctober 18, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 74Keeper
- 1

Sufjan Stevens, IllinoisJuly 4, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 88Heavy Rotation
- 2

Sleater-Kinney, The WoodsMay 24, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 87Heavy Rotation
- 3

Porcupine Tree, DeadwingMarch 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 86Heavy Rotation
- 4

My Morning Jacket, ZOctober 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 5

The Go-Betweens, Oceans ApartApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 6

Kate Bush, AerialOctober 3, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 7

Wolf Parade, Apologies to the Queen MarySeptember 27, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
- 8

Animal Collective, FeelsOctober 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 9

Okkervil River, Black Sheep BoyApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 10

81Keeper
- 11

Silver Jews, Tanglewood NumbersOctober 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 80Keeper
- 12

Bright Eyes, I’m Wide Awake, It’s MorningJanuary 19, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided 80Keeper
- 13

The National, AlligatorApril 11, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 14

Franz Ferdinand, You Could Have It So Much BetterSeptember 15, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 15

Spoon, Gimme FictionMay 9, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 16

The Fall, Fall Heads RollOctober 3, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 17

Mew, And the Glass Handed KitesSeptember 14, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 18

Sigur Rós, Takk…September 7, 2005 · 13 reviews · 85% approval · Broad agreement 77Keeper
- 19

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, Clap Your Hands Say YeahSeptember 13, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Broad agreement 76Keeper
- 20

Mindless Self Indulgence, You’ll Rebel to AnythingApril 12, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 76Keeper
- 1

Kano, Home Sweet HomeJune 27, 2005 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 2

Kanye West, Late RegistrationMarch 2005 · 14 reviews · 93% approval · Divided 84Keeper
- 3

Common, BeMay 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 83Keeper
- 4

Blackalicious, The CraftSeptember 27, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 79Keeper
- 5

Sage Francis, A Healthy DistrustFebruary 8, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement 79Keeper
- 6

Little Brother, The Minstrel ShowSeptember 13, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Divided 78Keeper
- 7

Three 6 Mafia, Most Known UnknownSeptember 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 78Keeper
- 8

Bun B, TrillOctober 18, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Unanimous 78Keeper
- 9

Lil Wayne, Tha Carter IIDecember 6, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 10

Cage, Hell’s WinterSeptember 20, 2005 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Some debate 77Keeper
- 11

DANGERDOOM, The Mouse and the MaskOctober 11, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate 76Keeper
- 12

Jim Jones, Harlem: Diary of a SummerAugust 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 75Keeper
- 13

Roots Manuva, Awfully DeepJanuary 31, 2005 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate 74Keeper
- 14

9th Wonder, ChemistryJuly 12, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement 74Keeper
- 15

Jeezy, Let’s Get It: Thug Motivation 101July 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Broad agreement 74Keeper
- 16

The Game, The DocumentaryJanuary 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 74Keeper
- 17

Twista, The Day AfterOctober 3, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate 73Keeper
- 18

Atmosphere, You Can’t Imagine How Much Fun We’re HavingOctober 4, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Contentious 73Keeper
- 19

AZ, A.W.O.L.September 6, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Some debate 72Keeper
- 20

Slim Thug, Already PlatinumJuly 12, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement 72Keeper
- 1

Amerie, Because I Love It2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 2

Anthony Hamilton, Ain’t Nobody Worryin’December 13, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate 78Keeper
- 3

Mary J. Blige, The BreakthroughDecember 9, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate 73Keeper
- 4

Keyshia Cole, The Way It Is2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Broad agreement 70Keeper
- 5

Brooke Valentine, Chain LetterMarch 15, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided 69Mixed Bag
- 6

Earth, Wind & Fire, IlluminationSeptember 19, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided 69Mixed Bag
- 7

Amerie, TouchApril 26, 2005 · 10 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate 68Mixed Bag
- 8

Ne-Yo, In My Own Words2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate 68Mixed Bag
- 9

R. Kelly, TP.3 ReloadedJuly 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 56% approval · Divided 67Mixed Bag
- 10

Stevie Wonder, A Time to LoveOctober 18, 2005 · 10 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate 67Mixed Bag
- 11

Toni Braxton, LibraSeptember 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate 66Mixed Bag
- 12

Parliament-Funkadelic, How Late Do U Have 2BB4UR Absent?September 6, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Divided 64Mixed Bag
- 13

Chris Brown, Chris BrownNovember 29, 2005 · 7 reviews · 14% approval · Broad agreement 61Mixed Bag
- 14

112, Pleasure & PainMarch 29, 2005 · 5 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate 58Mixed Bag
- 15

Jamie Foxx, UnpredictableDecember 20, 2005 · 11 reviews · 27% approval · Divided 57Mixed Bag
- 1

M.I.A., ArularFebruary 22, 2005 · 14 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 84Keeper
- 2

LCD Soundsystem, LCD SoundsystemJanuary 19, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 3

Ladytron, Witching HourJuly 2005 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 80Keeper
- 4

Patrick Wolf, Wind in the WiresFebruary 21, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate 78Keeper
- 5

Gorillaz, Demon DaysMay 11, 2005 · 15 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 77Keeper
- 6

Vitalic, OK CowboyApril 2, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 76Keeper
- 7

Boards of Canada, The Campfire HeadphaseOctober 12, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate 76Keeper
- 8

Goldfrapp, SupernatureAugust 17, 2005 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 76Keeper
- 9

Saint Etienne, Tales from Turnpike HouseJune 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided 75Keeper
- 10

Dan Snaith, The Milk of Human KindnessApril 18, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 75Keeper
- 11

Brian Eno, Another Day on EarthJune 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate 74Keeper
- 12

Jamie Lidell, MultiplyJune 13, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate 73Keeper
- 13

Imogen Heap, Speak for YourselfJuly 18, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement 72Keeper
- 14

Four Tet, Everything Ecstatic2005 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement 71Keeper
- 15

CSS, Cansei de Ser SexyOctober 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate 70Keeper
- 16

Röyksopp, The UnderstandingJune 22, 2005 · 12 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate 70Keeper
- 17

Meat Beat Manifesto, At the CenterMay 24, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Unanimous 69Mixed Bag
- 18

Scott Herren, Surrounded by SilenceMarch 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Some debate 68Mixed Bag
- 19

Fischerspooner, OdysseyApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Unanimous 67Mixed Bag
- 20

Tiga, SexorDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 40% approval · Some debate 67Mixed Bag
- 1

Vashti Bunyan, LookafteringOctober 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
- 2

Trisha Yearwood, Jasper CountySeptember 13, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 82Keeper
- 3

Neil Young, Prairie WindSeptember 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 4

Martha Wainwright, Martha WainwrightApril 12, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 78Keeper
- 5

The Magic Numbers, The Magic NumbersJune 8, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 77Keeper
- 6

Nickel Creek, Why Should the Fire Die?August 9, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 75Keeper
- 7

Brad Paisley, Time Well WastedAugust 16, 2005 · 8 reviews · 75% approval · Some debate 75Keeper
- 8

Animal Collective, Prospect HummerMay 16, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 71Keeper
- 9

Tracy Chapman, Where You LiveSeptember 5, 2005 · 8 reviews · 63% approval · Some debate 68Mixed Bag
- 10

Dolly Parton, Those Were the DaysOctober 11, 2005 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Broad agreement 67Mixed Bag
- 11

Ani DiFranco, Knuckle DownJanuary 25, 2005 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Unanimous 64Mixed Bag
- 12

Gretchen Wilson, All Jacked UpSeptember 27, 2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Contentious 64Mixed Bag
- 13

Carrie Underwood, Some HeartsNovember 15, 2005 · 5 reviews · 40% approval · Some debate 64Mixed Bag
- 14

Toby Keith, Honkytonk UniversityMay 17, 2005 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Divided 62Mixed Bag
- 15

Ryan Adams, 29December 20, 2005 · 10 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate 60Mixed Bag
- 16

Kenny Chesney, The Road and the RadioNovember 7, 2005 · 6 reviews · 0% approval · Broad agreement 53Back of the Crate
- 17

Willie Nelson, CountrymanJuly 12, 2005 · 9 reviews · 0% approval · Some debate 48Back of the Crate
- 18

Faith Hill, FirefliesAugust 2, 2005 · 7 reviews · 0% approval · Contentious 47Back of the Crate
- 1

Nevermore, This Godless EndeavorJuly 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 93Heavy Rotation
- 2

Opeth, Ghost ReveriesAugust 26, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate 92Heavy Rotation
- 3

Nile, Annihilation of the WickedMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 88Heavy Rotation
- 4

Candlemass, CandlemassMay 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 86Heavy Rotation
- 5

Strapping Young Lad, AlienMarch 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 84Keeper
- 6

Hate Eternal, I, MonarchJune 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 83Keeper
- 7

Nightrage, Descent into ChaosApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 8

Gojira, From Mars to SiriusSeptember 27, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement 82Keeper
- 9

Annihilator, Schizo DeluxeOctober 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 81Keeper
- 10

Bolt Thrower, Those Once LoyalNovember 11, 2005 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 11

Amorphis, EclipseDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate 81Keeper
- 12

System of a Down, MezmerizeMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate 80Keeper
- 13

Municipal Waste, Hazardous MutationSeptember 20, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous 78Keeper
- 14

Chimaira, ChimairaAugust 9, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 15

Alkaline Trio, CrimsonMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement 78Keeper
- 16

System of a Down, HypnotizeNovember 18, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate 76Keeper
- 17

Scum, Gospels for the Sick2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate 75Keeper
- 18

The Black Dahlia Murder, MiasmaJuly 12, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided 74Keeper
- 19

Children of Bodom, Are You Dead Yet?September 14, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate 73Keeper
- 20

Extol, The Blueprint DivesFebruary 21, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Contentious 73Keeper
← 2004 · Every year, back to the 1950s · 2006 →
B-Side Breakdowns home