The Best Albums of 2005

The best-reviewed albums of 2005, ranked by Breakdown. An album needs at least 5 reviews to make the list.

Album cover for This Godless Endeavor by NevermoreNumber one of 2005NevermoreThis Godless Endeavor93 Heavy Rotation6 critics · 100% approval · Broad agreement · A-Side
  1. 1Album cover for This Godless Endeavor by Nevermore
    Nevermore, This Godless EndeavorJuly 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    93Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Ghost Reveries by Opeth
    Opeth, Ghost ReveriesAugust 26, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    92Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Annihilation of the Wicked by Nile
    Nile, Annihilation of the WickedMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    88Heavy Rotation
  4. 4Album cover for Illinois by Sufjan Stevens
    Sufjan Stevens, IllinoisJuly 4, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    88Heavy Rotation
  5. 5Album cover for The Woods by Sleater-Kinney
    Sleater-Kinney, The WoodsMay 24, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    87Heavy Rotation
  6. 6Album cover for Devils & Dust by Bruce Springsteen
    Bruce Springsteen, Devils & DustApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    87Heavy Rotation
  7. 7Album cover for Candlemass by Candlemass
    Candlemass, CandlemassMay 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    86Heavy Rotation
  8. 8Album cover for Deadwing by Porcupine Tree
    Porcupine Tree, DeadwingMarch 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    86Heavy Rotation
  9. 9Album cover for Home Sweet Home by Kano
    Kano, Home Sweet HomeJune 27, 2005 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Alien by Strapping Young Lad
    Strapping Young Lad, AlienMarch 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper

Where 2005's albums land

Share of albums at each verdict. Heavy Rotation is 85 and up, Back of the Crate is below 55.

2005

Heavy Rotation3%
Keeper51%
Mixed Bag38%
Back of the Crate9%

Every year

Heavy Rotation10%
Keeper54%
Mixed Bag30%
Back of the Crate7%
  1. 11Album cover for Tyranny of Souls by Bruce Dickinson
    Bruce Dickinson, Tyranny of SoulsMay 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  2. 12Album cover for I Am a Bird Now by ANOHNI and the Johnsons
    ANOHNI and the Johnsons, I Am a Bird NowFebruary 1, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  3. 13Album cover for Arular by M.I.A.
    M.I.A., ArularFebruary 22, 2005 · 14 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  4. 14Album cover for Late Registration by Kanye West
    Kanye West, Late RegistrationMarch 2005 · 14 reviews · 93% approval · Divided
    84Keeper
  5. 15Album cover for Z by My Morning Jacket
    My Morning Jacket, ZOctober 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  6. 16Album cover for Oceans Apart by The Go-Betweens
    The Go-Betweens, Oceans ApartApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  7. 17Album cover for Chávez Ravine by Ry Cooder
    Ry Cooder, Chávez RavineJune 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    83Keeper
  8. 18Album cover for Robyn by Robyn
    Robyn, RobynMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    83Keeper
  9. 19Album cover for I, Monarch by Hate Eternal
    Hate Eternal, I, MonarchJune 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  10. 20Album cover for Be by Common
    Common, BeMay 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    83Keeper
  11. 21Album cover for LCD Soundsystem by LCD Soundsystem
    LCD Soundsystem, LCD SoundsystemJanuary 19, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  12. 22Album cover for Aerial by Kate Bush
    Kate Bush, AerialOctober 3, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  13. 23Album cover for Descent into Chaos by Nightrage
    Nightrage, Descent into ChaosApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  14. 24Album cover for Vietnam: Reflections by Billy Bang
    Billy Bang, Vietnam: ReflectionsMay 4, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    82Keeper
  15. 25Album cover for Apologies to the Queen Mary by Wolf Parade
    Wolf Parade, Apologies to the Queen MarySeptember 27, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper

Where 2005 sits

Average Breakdown, for albums with five or more reviews.

Next to the years around it

200270
200368
200469
2005 (this year)69
200669
200769
200869

By genre

Metal & Punk76
Indie & Alternative72
Electronic69
Hip-Hop & Rap69
R&B & Soul68
Folk, Country & Americana68
Pop66
Rock66
  1. 26Album cover for Lookaftering by Vashti Bunyan
    Vashti Bunyan, LookafteringOctober 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  2. 27Album cover for Feels by Animal Collective
    Animal Collective, FeelsOctober 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  3. 28Album cover for Jasper County by Trisha Yearwood
    Trisha Yearwood, Jasper CountySeptember 13, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  4. 29Album cover for From Mars to Sirius by Gojira
    Gojira, From Mars to SiriusSeptember 27, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  5. 30Album cover for Schizo Deluxe by Annihilator
    Annihilator, Schizo DeluxeOctober 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  6. 31Album cover for Love Kraft by Super Furry Animals
    Super Furry Animals, Love KraftAugust 22, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  7. 32Album cover for Black Sheep Boy by Okkervil River
    Okkervil River, Black Sheep BoyApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  8. 33Album cover for Twin Cinema by The New Pornographers
    The New Pornographers, Twin CinemaAugust 23, 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  9. 34Album cover for Blinking Lights and Other Revelations by Eels
    Eels, Blinking Lights and Other RevelationsApril 25, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  10. 35Album cover for Those Once Loyal by Bolt Thrower
    Bolt Thrower, Those Once LoyalNovember 11, 2005 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  11. 36Album cover for Eclipse by Amorphis
    Amorphis, EclipseDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  12. 37Album cover for Extraordinary Machine by Fiona Apple
    Fiona Apple, Extraordinary MachineMarch 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  13. 38Album cover for Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not by Arctic Monkeys
    Arctic Monkeys, Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Contentious
    81Keeper
  14. 39Album cover for Coles Corner by Richard Hawley
    Richard Hawley, Coles CornerSeptember 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    80Keeper
  15. 40Album cover for Tanglewood Numbers by Silver Jews
    Silver Jews, Tanglewood NumbersOctober 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  16. 41Album cover for 12 Songs by Neil Diamond
    Neil Diamond, 12 SongsNovember 8, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  17. 42Album cover for I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning by Bright Eyes
    Bright Eyes, I’m Wide Awake, It’s MorningJanuary 19, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  18. 43Album cover for Because I Love It by Amerie
    Amerie, Because I Love It2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  19. 44Album cover for Witching Hour by Ladytron
    Ladytron, Witching HourJuly 2005 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  20. 45Album cover for Prairie Wind by Neil Young
    Neil Young, Prairie WindSeptember 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  21. 46Album cover for Mezmerize by System of a Down
    System of a Down, MezmerizeMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  22. 47Album cover for The Craft by Blackalicious
    Blackalicious, The CraftSeptember 27, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  23. 48Album cover for A Healthy Distrust by Sage Francis
    Sage Francis, A Healthy DistrustFebruary 8, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  24. 49Album cover for Until My Heart Caves In by Audio Adrenaline
    Audio Adrenaline, Until My Heart Caves InAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  25. 50Album cover for Superwolf by Will Oldham
    Will Oldham, SuperwolfJanuary 7, 2005 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    79Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for I Am a Bird Now by ANOHNI and the Johnsons
    ANOHNI and the Johnsons, I Am a Bird NowFebruary 1, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Robyn by Robyn
    Robyn, RobynMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    83Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Love Kraft by Super Furry Animals
    Super Furry Animals, Love KraftAugust 22, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Extraordinary Machine by Fiona Apple
    Fiona Apple, Extraordinary MachineMarch 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Coles Corner by Richard Hawley
    Richard Hawley, Coles CornerSeptember 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    80Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Ruby Blue by Róisín Murphy
    Róisín Murphy, Ruby BlueMay 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Confessions on a Dance Floor by Madonna
    Madonna, Confessions on a Dance FloorNovember 11, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Divided
    75Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Chemistry by Girls Aloud
    Girls Aloud, ChemistryDecember 5, 2005 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Divided
    74Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Fijación Oral, Vol. 1 by Shakira
    Shakira, Fijación Oral, Vol. 1June 3, 2005 · 8 reviews · 63% approval · Some debate
    72Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for The Emancipation of Mimi by Mariah Carey
    Mariah Carey, The Emancipation of MimiApril 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    72Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Taller in More Ways by Sugababes
    Sugababes, Taller in More WaysOctober 10, 2005 · 7 reviews · 43% approval · Some debate
    71Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Playing the Angel by Depeche Mode
    Depeche Mode, Playing the AngelOctober 11, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate
    71Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Chaos and Creation in the Backyard by Paul McCartney
    Paul McCartney, Chaos and Creation in the BackyardSeptember 12, 2005 · 12 reviews · 58% approval · Broad agreement
    71Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Nothing Is Sound by Switchfoot
    Switchfoot, Nothing Is SoundSeptember 13, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Divided
    70Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Suspicious Activity? by The Bad Plus
    The Bad Plus, Suspicious Activity?September 20, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Divided
    69Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for Oral Fixation, Vol. 2 by Shakira
    Shakira, Oral Fixation, Vol. 2November 28, 2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate
    69Mixed Bag
  17. 17Album cover for Super Extra Gravity by The Cardigans
    The Cardigans, Super Extra GravityOctober 14, 2005 · 9 reviews · 56% approval · Some debate
    66Mixed Bag
  18. 18Album cover for Stand Up by Dave Matthews Band
    Dave Matthews Band, Stand UpMay 10, 2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate
    65Mixed Bag
  19. 19Album cover for Move Along by The All-American Rejects
    The All-American Rejects, Move AlongJuly 6, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Broad agreement
    64Mixed Bag
  20. 20Album cover for The Trinity by Sean Paul
    Sean Paul, The TrinitySeptember 26, 2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate
    64Mixed Bag
  1. 1Album cover for Devils & Dust by Bruce Springsteen
    Bruce Springsteen, Devils & DustApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    87Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Tyranny of Souls by Bruce Dickinson
    Bruce Dickinson, Tyranny of SoulsMay 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Chávez Ravine by Ry Cooder
    Ry Cooder, Chávez RavineJune 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    83Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Twin Cinema by The New Pornographers
    The New Pornographers, Twin CinemaAugust 23, 2005 · 12 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Blinking Lights and Other Revelations by Eels
    Eels, Blinking Lights and Other RevelationsApril 25, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for 12 Songs by Neil Diamond
    Neil Diamond, 12 SongsNovember 8, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Until My Heart Caves In by Audio Adrenaline
    Audio Adrenaline, Until My Heart Caves InAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Superwolf by Will Oldham
    Will Oldham, SuperwolfJanuary 7, 2005 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    79Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Pink by Boris
    Boris, PinkNovember 12, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Divided
    79Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Picaresque by The Decemberists
    The Decemberists, PicaresqueMarch 21, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Divided
    79Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Lifesong by Casting Crowns
    Casting Crowns, LifesongAugust 30, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    78Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Wolfmother by Wolfmother
    Wolfmother, WolfmotherOctober 31, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Never Take Friendship Personal by Anberlin
    Anberlin, Never Take Friendship PersonalJanuary 1, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Guero by Beck
    Beck, GueroMarch 16, 2005 · 13 reviews · 77% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Nashville by Josh Rouse
    Josh Rouse, NashvilleFebruary 22, 2005 · 11 reviews · 73% approval · Broad agreement
    76Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for Hours by Funeral for a Friend
    Funeral for a Friend, HoursJune 8, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for Suspended Animation by Fantômas
    Fantômas, Suspended AnimationApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Howl by Black Rebel Motorcycle Club
    Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, HowlAugust 22, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Leaders of the Free World by Elbow
    Elbow, Leaders of the Free WorldJanuary 1, 2005 · 12 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for Vheissu by Thrice
    Thrice, VheissuOctober 18, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Illinois by Sufjan Stevens
    Sufjan Stevens, IllinoisJuly 4, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    88Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for The Woods by Sleater-Kinney
    Sleater-Kinney, The WoodsMay 24, 2005 · 12 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    87Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Deadwing by Porcupine Tree
    Porcupine Tree, DeadwingMarch 28, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    86Heavy Rotation
  4. 4Album cover for Z by My Morning Jacket
    My Morning Jacket, ZOctober 4, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Oceans Apart by The Go-Betweens
    The Go-Betweens, Oceans ApartApril 25, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Aerial by Kate Bush
    Kate Bush, AerialOctober 3, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Apologies to the Queen Mary by Wolf Parade
    Wolf Parade, Apologies to the Queen MarySeptember 27, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Feels by Animal Collective
    Animal Collective, FeelsOctober 14, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Black Sheep Boy by Okkervil River
    Okkervil River, Black Sheep BoyApril 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not by Arctic Monkeys
    Arctic Monkeys, Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Contentious
    81Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Tanglewood Numbers by Silver Jews
    Silver Jews, Tanglewood NumbersOctober 5, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning by Bright Eyes
    Bright Eyes, I’m Wide Awake, It’s MorningJanuary 19, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Alligator by The National
    The National, AlligatorApril 11, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for You Could Have It So Much Better by Franz Ferdinand
    Franz Ferdinand, You Could Have It So Much BetterSeptember 15, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Gimme Fiction by Spoon
    Spoon, Gimme FictionMay 9, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for Fall Heads Roll by The Fall
    The Fall, Fall Heads RollOctober 3, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for And the Glass Handed Kites by Mew
    Mew, And the Glass Handed KitesSeptember 14, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Takk… by Sigur Rós
    Sigur Rós, Takk…September 7, 2005 · 13 reviews · 85% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Clap Your Hands Say Yeah by Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
    Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, Clap Your Hands Say YeahSeptember 13, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Broad agreement
    76Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for You’ll Rebel to Anything by Mindless Self Indulgence
    Mindless Self Indulgence, You’ll Rebel to AnythingApril 12, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    76Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Home Sweet Home by Kano
    Kano, Home Sweet HomeJune 27, 2005 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Late Registration by Kanye West
    Kanye West, Late RegistrationMarch 2005 · 14 reviews · 93% approval · Divided
    84Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Be by Common
    Common, BeMay 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    83Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for The Craft by Blackalicious
    Blackalicious, The CraftSeptember 27, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for A Healthy Distrust by Sage Francis
    Sage Francis, A Healthy DistrustFebruary 8, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for The Minstrel Show by Little Brother
    Little Brother, The Minstrel ShowSeptember 13, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    78Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Most Known Unknown by Three 6 Mafia
    Three 6 Mafia, Most Known UnknownSeptember 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Trill by Bun B
    Bun B, TrillOctober 18, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Unanimous
    78Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Tha Carter II by Lil Wayne
    Lil Wayne, Tha Carter IIDecember 6, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Hell’s Winter by Cage
    Cage, Hell’s WinterSeptember 20, 2005 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for The Mouse and the Mask by DANGERDOOM
    DANGERDOOM, The Mouse and the MaskOctober 11, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Harlem: Diary of a Summer by Jim Jones
    Jim Jones, Harlem: Diary of a SummerAugust 23, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    75Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Awfully Deep by Roots Manuva
    Roots Manuva, Awfully DeepJanuary 31, 2005 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Chemistry by 9th Wonder
    9th Wonder, ChemistryJuly 12, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Let’s Get It: Thug Motivation 101 by Jeezy
    Jeezy, Let’s Get It: Thug Motivation 101July 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for The Documentary by The Game
    The Game, The DocumentaryJanuary 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for The Day After by Twista
    Twista, The Day AfterOctober 3, 2005 · 9 reviews · 89% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for You Can’t Imagine How Much Fun We’re Having by Atmosphere
    Atmosphere, You Can’t Imagine How Much Fun We’re HavingOctober 4, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Contentious
    73Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for A.W.O.L. by AZ
    AZ, A.W.O.L.September 6, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Some debate
    72Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for Already Platinum by Slim Thug
    Slim Thug, Already PlatinumJuly 12, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    72Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Because I Love It by Amerie
    Amerie, Because I Love It2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Ain’t Nobody Worryin’ by Anthony Hamilton
    Anthony Hamilton, Ain’t Nobody Worryin’December 13, 2005 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for The Breakthrough by Mary J. Blige
    Mary J. Blige, The BreakthroughDecember 9, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for The Way It Is by Keyshia Cole
    Keyshia Cole, The Way It Is2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Broad agreement
    70Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Chain Letter by Brooke Valentine
    Brooke Valentine, Chain LetterMarch 15, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    69Mixed Bag
  6. 6Album cover for Illumination by Earth, Wind & Fire
    Earth, Wind & Fire, IlluminationSeptember 19, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    69Mixed Bag
  7. 7Album cover for Touch by Amerie
    Amerie, TouchApril 26, 2005 · 10 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate
    68Mixed Bag
  8. 8Album cover for In My Own Words by Ne-Yo
    Ne-Yo, In My Own Words2005 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Some debate
    68Mixed Bag
  9. 9Album cover for TP.3 Reloaded by R. Kelly
    R. Kelly, TP.3 ReloadedJuly 5, 2005 · 9 reviews · 56% approval · Divided
    67Mixed Bag
  10. 10Album cover for A Time to Love by Stevie Wonder
    Stevie Wonder, A Time to LoveOctober 18, 2005 · 10 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate
    67Mixed Bag
  11. 11Album cover for Libra by Toni Braxton
    Toni Braxton, LibraSeptember 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    66Mixed Bag
  12. 12Album cover for How Late Do U Have 2BB4UR Absent? by Parliament-Funkadelic
    Parliament-Funkadelic, How Late Do U Have 2BB4UR Absent?September 6, 2005 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Divided
    64Mixed Bag
  13. 13Album cover for Chris Brown by Chris Brown
    Chris Brown, Chris BrownNovember 29, 2005 · 7 reviews · 14% approval · Broad agreement
    61Mixed Bag
  14. 14Album cover for Pleasure & Pain by 112
    112, Pleasure & PainMarch 29, 2005 · 5 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate
    58Mixed Bag
  15. 15Album cover for Unpredictable by Jamie Foxx
    Jamie Foxx, UnpredictableDecember 20, 2005 · 11 reviews · 27% approval · Divided
    57Mixed Bag
  1. 1Album cover for Arular by M.I.A.
    M.I.A., ArularFebruary 22, 2005 · 14 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    84Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for LCD Soundsystem by LCD Soundsystem
    LCD Soundsystem, LCD SoundsystemJanuary 19, 2005 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Witching Hour by Ladytron
    Ladytron, Witching HourJuly 2005 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Wind in the Wires by Patrick Wolf
    Patrick Wolf, Wind in the WiresFebruary 21, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Demon Days by Gorillaz
    Gorillaz, Demon DaysMay 11, 2005 · 15 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for OK Cowboy by Vitalic
    Vitalic, OK CowboyApril 2, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for The Campfire Headphase by Boards of Canada
    Boards of Canada, The Campfire HeadphaseOctober 12, 2005 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Supernature by Goldfrapp
    Goldfrapp, SupernatureAugust 17, 2005 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    76Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Tales from Turnpike House by Saint Etienne
    Saint Etienne, Tales from Turnpike HouseJune 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Divided
    75Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for The Milk of Human Kindness by Dan Snaith
    Dan Snaith, The Milk of Human KindnessApril 18, 2005 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Another Day on Earth by Brian Eno
    Brian Eno, Another Day on EarthJune 13, 2005 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Multiply by Jamie Lidell
    Jamie Lidell, MultiplyJune 13, 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Speak for Yourself by Imogen Heap
    Imogen Heap, Speak for YourselfJuly 18, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement
    72Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Everything Ecstatic by Four Tet
    Four Tet, Everything Ecstatic2005 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement
    71Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Cansei de Ser Sexy by CSS
    CSS, Cansei de Ser SexyOctober 2005 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate
    70Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for The Understanding by Röyksopp
    Röyksopp, The UnderstandingJune 22, 2005 · 12 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate
    70Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for At the Center by Meat Beat Manifesto
    Meat Beat Manifesto, At the CenterMay 24, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Unanimous
    69Mixed Bag
  18. 18Album cover for Surrounded by Silence by Scott Herren
    Scott Herren, Surrounded by SilenceMarch 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 33% approval · Some debate
    68Mixed Bag
  19. 19Album cover for Odyssey by Fischerspooner
    Fischerspooner, OdysseyApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Unanimous
    67Mixed Bag
  20. 20Album cover for Sexor by Tiga
    Tiga, SexorDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 40% approval · Some debate
    67Mixed Bag
  1. 1Album cover for Lookaftering by Vashti Bunyan
    Vashti Bunyan, LookafteringOctober 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Jasper County by Trisha Yearwood
    Trisha Yearwood, Jasper CountySeptember 13, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Prairie Wind by Neil Young
    Neil Young, Prairie WindSeptember 23, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Martha Wainwright by Martha Wainwright
    Martha Wainwright, Martha WainwrightApril 12, 2005 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    78Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for The Magic Numbers by The Magic Numbers
    The Magic Numbers, The Magic NumbersJune 8, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Why Should the Fire Die? by Nickel Creek
    Nickel Creek, Why Should the Fire Die?August 9, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Time Well Wasted by Brad Paisley
    Brad Paisley, Time Well WastedAugust 16, 2005 · 8 reviews · 75% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Prospect Hummer by Animal Collective
    Animal Collective, Prospect HummerMay 16, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    71Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Where You Live by Tracy Chapman
    Tracy Chapman, Where You LiveSeptember 5, 2005 · 8 reviews · 63% approval · Some debate
    68Mixed Bag
  10. 10Album cover for Those Were the Days by Dolly Parton
    Dolly Parton, Those Were the DaysOctober 11, 2005 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Broad agreement
    67Mixed Bag
  11. 11Album cover for Knuckle Down by Ani DiFranco
    Ani DiFranco, Knuckle DownJanuary 25, 2005 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Unanimous
    64Mixed Bag
  12. 12Album cover for All Jacked Up by Gretchen Wilson
    Gretchen Wilson, All Jacked UpSeptember 27, 2005 · 8 reviews · 50% approval · Contentious
    64Mixed Bag
  13. 13Album cover for Some Hearts by Carrie Underwood
    Carrie Underwood, Some HeartsNovember 15, 2005 · 5 reviews · 40% approval · Some debate
    64Mixed Bag
  14. 14Album cover for Honkytonk University by Toby Keith
    Toby Keith, Honkytonk UniversityMay 17, 2005 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Divided
    62Mixed Bag
  15. 15Album cover for 29 by Ryan Adams
    Ryan Adams, 29December 20, 2005 · 10 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate
    60Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for The Road and the Radio by Kenny Chesney
    Kenny Chesney, The Road and the RadioNovember 7, 2005 · 6 reviews · 0% approval · Broad agreement
    53Back of the Crate
  17. 17Album cover for Countryman by Willie Nelson
    Willie Nelson, CountrymanJuly 12, 2005 · 9 reviews · 0% approval · Some debate
    48Back of the Crate
  18. 18Album cover for Fireflies by Faith Hill
    Faith Hill, FirefliesAugust 2, 2005 · 7 reviews · 0% approval · Contentious
    47Back of the Crate
  1. 1Album cover for This Godless Endeavor by Nevermore
    Nevermore, This Godless EndeavorJuly 25, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    93Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Ghost Reveries by Opeth
    Opeth, Ghost ReveriesAugust 26, 2005 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    92Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Annihilation of the Wicked by Nile
    Nile, Annihilation of the WickedMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    88Heavy Rotation
  4. 4Album cover for Candlemass by Candlemass
    Candlemass, CandlemassMay 2, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    86Heavy Rotation
  5. 5Album cover for Alien by Strapping Young Lad
    Strapping Young Lad, AlienMarch 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for I, Monarch by Hate Eternal
    Hate Eternal, I, MonarchJune 27, 2005 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Descent into Chaos by Nightrage
    Nightrage, Descent into ChaosApril 5, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for From Mars to Sirius by Gojira
    Gojira, From Mars to SiriusSeptember 27, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Schizo Deluxe by Annihilator
    Annihilator, Schizo DeluxeOctober 21, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Those Once Loyal by Bolt Thrower
    Bolt Thrower, Those Once LoyalNovember 11, 2005 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Eclipse by Amorphis
    Amorphis, EclipseDecember 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Mezmerize by System of a Down
    System of a Down, MezmerizeMay 16, 2005 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Hazardous Mutation by Municipal Waste
    Municipal Waste, Hazardous MutationSeptember 20, 2005 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    78Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Chimaira by Chimaira
    Chimaira, ChimairaAugust 9, 2005 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Crimson by Alkaline Trio
    Alkaline Trio, CrimsonMay 23, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for Hypnotize by System of a Down
    System of a Down, HypnotizeNovember 18, 2005 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for Gospels for the Sick by Scum
    Scum, Gospels for the Sick2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Miasma by The Black Dahlia Murder
    The Black Dahlia Murder, MiasmaJuly 12, 2005 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    74Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Are You Dead Yet? by Children of Bodom
    Children of Bodom, Are You Dead Yet?September 14, 2005 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for The Blueprint Dives by Extol
    Extol, The Blueprint DivesFebruary 21, 2005 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Contentious
    73Keeper

← 2004 · Every year, back to the 1950s · 2006 →

B-Side Breakdowns home