Toby Keith Albums Ranked

Toby Keith’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 10 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 67 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is Toby Keith’s best album?

By the critics, it’s a tie: Clancy’s Tavern (2011) and Big Dog Daddy (2007) each have a B-Side Breakdown of 75 (Keeper).

Next best: That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy (72) and Bullets in the Gun (70). Lowest rated: Unleashed (58).

Toby Keith albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Clancy’s Tavern (2011): 75 Keeper
  2. 2. Big Dog Daddy (2007): 75 Keeper
  3. 3. That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy (2008): 72 Keeper
  4. 4. Bullets in the Gun (2010): 70 Keeper
  5. 5. Hope on the Rocks (2012): 67 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. White Trash with Money (2006): 66 Mixed Bag
  7. 7. American Ride (2009): 63 Mixed Bag
  8. 8. Honkytonk University (2005): 62 Mixed Bag
  9. 9. Shock’n Y’all (2003): 60 Mixed Bag
  10. 10. Unleashed (2002): 58 Mixed Bag

Toby Keith discography, in release order

Every Toby Keith studio album, oldest first. 12 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1993Toby KeithNo Breakdown yet
  2. 1994BoomtownNo Breakdown yet
  3. 1995Christmas to ChristmasNo Breakdown yet
  4. 1996Blue MoonNo Breakdown yet
  5. 1997Dream Walkin'No Breakdown yet
  6. 1999How Do You Like Me Now?!No Breakdown yet
  7. 2001Pull My ChainNo Breakdown yet
  8. 2002Album cover for Unleashed by Toby KeithUnleashed58 Mixed Bag
  9. 2003Album cover for Shock’n Y’all by Toby KeithShock’n Y’all60 Mixed Bag
  10. 2005Album cover for Honkytonk University by Toby KeithHonkytonk University62 Mixed Bag
  11. 2006Album cover for White Trash with Money by Toby KeithWhite Trash with Money66 Mixed Bag
  12. 2007Album cover for Big Dog Daddy by Toby KeithBig Dog Daddy75 Keeper
  13. 2007A Classic ChristmasNo Breakdown yet
  14. 2008Album cover for That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy by Toby KeithThat Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy72 Keeper
  15. 200835 Biggest HitsNo Breakdown yet
  16. 2009Album cover for American Ride by Toby KeithAmerican Ride63 Mixed Bag
  17. 2010Album cover for Bullets in the Gun by Toby KeithBullets in the Gun70 Keeper
  18. 2011Album cover for Clancy’s Tavern by Toby KeithClancy’s Tavern75 Keeper
  19. 2012Album cover for Hope on the Rocks by Toby KeithHope on the Rocks67 Mixed Bag
  20. 2013Drinks After WorkNo Breakdown yet
  21. 201535 MPH TownNo Breakdown yet
  22. 2021Peso in My PocketNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love Toby Keith, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Toby Keith albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

AllMusic10 albums+21
  1. Unleashed 200280 vs 53 from 5 others +27
  2. Shock’n Y’all 200390 vs 52 from 4 others +38
  3. Honkytonk University 200590 vs 58 from 7 others +32
  4. White Trash with Money 200690 vs 60 from 4 others +31
  5. Big Dog Daddy 200780 vs 73 from 3 others +7
  6. That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy 200880 vs 68 from 2 others +13
  7. American Ride 200970 vs 60 from 2 others +11
  8. Bullets in the Gun 201090 vs 63 from 3 others +27
  9. Clancy’s Tavern 201180 vs 74 from 6 others +6
  10. Hope on the Rocks 201280 vs 64 from 6 others +16

All AllMusic reviews

Entertainment Weekly9 albums+4
  1. Unleashed 200255 vs 58 from 5 others −3
  2. Shock’n Y’all 200365 vs 58 from 4 others +7
  3. Honkytonk University 200585 vs 59 from 7 others +26
  4. White Trash with Money 200665 vs 66 from 4 others −1
  5. Big Dog Daddy 200785 vs 71 from 3 others +14
  6. That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy 200875 vs 70 from 2 others +5
  7. American Ride 200959 vs 65 from 2 others −6
  8. Bullets in the Gun 201065 vs 71 from 3 others −6
  9. Clancy’s Tavern 201175 vs 75 from 6 others 0

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

USA Today3 albums+4
  1. Big Dog Daddy 200775 vs 75 from 3 others 0
  2. Clancy’s Tavern 201188 vs 73 from 6 others +15
  3. Hope on the Rocks 201263 vs 67 from 6 others −4

All USA Today reviews

Los Angeles Times6 albums−2
  1. Shock’n Y’all 200363 vs 59 from 4 others +4
  2. Honkytonk University 200575 vs 60 from 7 others +15
  3. White Trash with Money 200663 vs 66 from 4 others −3
  4. Bullets in the Gun 201063 vs 72 from 3 others −9
  5. Clancy’s Tavern 201163 vs 77 from 6 others −14
  6. Hope on the Rocks 201263 vs 67 from 6 others −4

All Los Angeles Times reviews

Blender4 albums−14
  1. Unleashed 200240 vs 61 from 5 others −21
  2. Shock’n Y’all 200340 vs 65 from 4 others −25
  3. Honkytonk University 200560 vs 62 from 7 others −2
  4. White Trash with Money 200660 vs 67 from 4 others −7

All Blender reviews

Rolling Stone4 albums−17
  1. Unleashed 200260 vs 57 from 5 others +3
  2. Shock’n Y’all 200340 vs 65 from 4 others −25
  3. Honkytonk University 200540 vs 65 from 7 others −25
  4. White Trash with Money 200650 vs 70 from 4 others −20

All Rolling Stone reviews

Slant4 albums−19
  1. Honkytonk University 200540 vs 65 from 7 others −25
  2. That Don’t Make Me a Bad Guy 200860 vs 78 from 2 others −18
  3. American Ride 200960 vs 65 from 2 others −5
  4. Clancy’s Tavern 201150 vs 79 from 6 others −29

All Slant reviews

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home