The Best Albums of 2004

The best-reviewed albums of 2004, ranked by Breakdown. An album needs at least 5 reviews to make the list.

Album cover for Van Lear Rose by Loretta LynnNumber one of 2004Loretta LynnVan Lear Rose92 Heavy Rotation10 critics · 100% approval · Broad agreement · A-Side
  1. 1Album cover for Van Lear Rose by Loretta Lynn
    Loretta Lynn, Van Lear RoseApril 27, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    92Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Smile by Brian Wilson
    Brian Wilson, SmileSeptember 28, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    92Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Supergrass is 10 by Supergrass
    Supergrass, Supergrass is 10June 7, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  4. 4Album cover for Funeral by Arcade Fire
    Arcade Fire, FuneralSeptember 14, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  5. 5Album cover for Leviathan by Mastodon
    Mastodon, LeviathanAugust 31, 2004 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  6. 6Album cover for No Said Date by Masta Killa
    Masta Killa, No Said DateJune 1, 2004 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    86Heavy Rotation
  7. 7Album cover for Franz Ferdinand by Franz Ferdinand
    Franz Ferdinand, Franz FerdinandFebruary 9, 2004 · 13 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    86Heavy Rotation
  8. 8Album cover for From a Basement on the Hill by Elliott Smith
    Elliott Smith, From a Basement on the HillOctober 18, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    85Heavy Rotation
  9. 9Album cover for Legend of the Wu-Tang Clan by Wu-Tang Clan
    Wu-Tang Clan, Legend of the Wu-Tang ClanOctober 26, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    85Heavy Rotation
  10. 10Album cover for Panopticon by Isis
    Isis, PanopticonOctober 19, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper

Where 2004's albums land

Share of albums at each verdict. Heavy Rotation is 85 and up, Back of the Crate is below 55.

2004

Heavy Rotation3%
Keeper49%
Mixed Bag38%
Back of the Crate10%

Every year

Heavy Rotation10%
Keeper54%
Mixed Bag30%
Back of the Crate7%
  1. 11Album cover for Madvillainy by Madvillain
    Madvillain, MadvillainyMarch 19, 2004 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  2. 12Album cover for A Grand Don’t Come for Free by The Streets
    The Streets, A Grand Don’t Come for FreeMay 10, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  3. 13Album cover for Last Exit by Junior Boys
    Junior Boys, Last ExitJune 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  4. 14Album cover for Once by Nightwish
    Nightwish, OnceJune 7, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  5. 15Album cover for Silent Alarm by Bloc Party
    Bloc Party, Silent Alarm2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  6. 16Album cover for Archetype by Fear Factory
    Fear Factory, ArchetypeApril 19, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  7. 17Album cover for Beautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2 by Jill Scott
    Jill Scott, Beautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2August 30, 2004 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  8. 18Album cover for Future Perfect by Autolux
    Autolux, Future PerfectOctober 26, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  9. 19Album cover for Anniemal by Annie
    Annie, AnniemalSeptember 28, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  10. 20Album cover for Showtime by Dizzee Rascal
    Dizzee Rascal, ShowtimeSeptember 6, 2004 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  11. 21Album cover for The Blue Notebooks by Max Richter
    Max Richter, The Blue NotebooksFebruary 26, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  12. 22Album cover for Get Lifted by John Legend
    John Legend, Get LiftedOctober 25, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  13. 23Album cover for The College Dropout by Kanye West
    Kanye West, The College DropoutFebruary 9, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  14. 24Album cover for The Dirty South by Drive-By Truckers
    Drive-By Truckers, The Dirty SouthAugust 24, 2004 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  15. 25Album cover for Bubblegum by Mark Lanegan
    Mark Lanegan, BubblegumAugust 2, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper

Where 2004 sits

Average Breakdown, for albums with five or more reviews.

Next to the years around it

200169
200270
200368
2004 (this year)69
200569
200669
200769

By genre

Folk, Country & Americana75
Metal & Punk74
Indie & Alternative72
Electronic69
Hip-Hop & Rap69
Rock67
R&B & Soul64
Pop64
  1. 26Album cover for Good News for People Who Love Bad News by Modest Mouse
    Modest Mouse, Good News for People Who Love Bad NewsApril 5, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  2. 27Album cover for Medúlla by Björk
    Björk, MedúllaAugust 25, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  3. 28Album cover for The End of Heartache by Killswitch Engage
    Killswitch Engage, The End of HeartacheMay 3, 2004 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  4. 29Album cover for Venice by Fennesz
    Fennesz, VeniceMarch 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  5. 30Album cover for The Grind Date by De La Soul
    De La Soul, The Grind DateOctober 4, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  6. 31Album cover for The Futureheads by The Futureheads
    The Futureheads, The FutureheadsJuly 12, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  7. 32Album cover for You’re a Woman, I’m a Machine by Death from Above 1979
    Death from Above 1979, You’re a Woman, I’m a MachineSeptember 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  8. 33Album cover for Murs 3:16: The 9th Edition by Murs
    Murs, Murs 3:16: The 9th EditionMarch 23, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  9. 34Album cover for A Long Hot Summer by Masta Ace
    Masta Ace, A Long Hot SummerAugust 3, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  10. 35Album cover for Audit in Progress by Hot Snakes
    Hot Snakes, Audit in ProgressOctober 5, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  11. 36Album cover for The Pretty Toney Album by Ghostface Killah
    Ghostface Killah, The Pretty Toney AlbumApril 20, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  12. 37Album cover for Mm.. Food by MF DOOM
    MF DOOM, Mm.. FoodNovember 16, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  13. 38Album cover for Our Endless Numbered Days by Iron & Wine
    Iron & Wine, Our Endless Numbered DaysMarch 23, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  14. 39Album cover for Aw Cmon by Lambchop
    Lambchop, Aw CmonFebruary 9, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Unanimous
    78Keeper
  15. 40Album cover for La maison de mon rêve by CocoRosie
    CocoRosie, La maison de mon rêveMarch 9, 2004 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  16. 41Album cover for To tha X-Treme by Devin the Dude
    Devin the Dude, To tha X-TremeJuly 13, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  17. 42Album cover for Satanic Panic in the Attic by of Montreal
    of Montreal, Satanic Panic in the AtticMarch 24, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  18. 43Album cover for Jeanius by Jean Grae
    Jean Grae, Jeanius2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  19. 44Album cover for Bright Like Neon Love by Cut Copy
    Cut Copy, Bright Like Neon LoveApril 5, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  20. 45Album cover for Cee-Lo Green… Is the Soul Machine by CeeLo Green
    CeeLo Green, Cee-Lo Green… Is the Soul MachineFebruary 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  21. 46Album cover for Antics by Interpol
    Interpol, AnticsSeptember 24, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  22. 47Album cover for What I Do by Alan Jackson
    Alan Jackson, What I DoSeptember 7, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  23. 48Album cover for Absence by Dälek
    Dälek, Absence2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  24. 49Album cover for High by The Blue Nile
    The Blue Nile, HighAugust 30, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  25. 50Album cover for This Week by Jean Grae
    Jean Grae, This WeekSeptember 21, 2004 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    77Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Franz Ferdinand by Franz Ferdinand
    Franz Ferdinand, Franz FerdinandFebruary 9, 2004 · 13 reviews · 100% approval · Some debate
    86Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Bright Like Neon Love by Cut Copy
    Cut Copy, Bright Like Neon LoveApril 5, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for What Will the Neighbours Say? by Girls Aloud
    Girls Aloud, What Will the Neighbours Say?November 29, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    75Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Want Two by Rufus Wainwright
    Rufus Wainwright, Want TwoNovember 16, 2004 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Scissor Sisters by Scissor Sisters
    Scissor Sisters, Scissor SistersFebruary 2, 2004 · 11 reviews · 73% approval · Divided
    75Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Happenstance by Rachael Yamagata
    Rachael Yamagata, HappenstanceJune 8, 2004 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Who Killed…… The Zutons? by The Zutons
    The Zutons, Who Killed…… The Zutons?April 9, 2004 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    71Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Peachtree Road by Elton John
    Elton John, Peachtree RoadNovember 8, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement
    71Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Unwritten by Natasha Bedingfield
    Natasha Bedingfield, UnwrittenSeptember 6, 2004 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Broad agreement
    71Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Finally Woken by Jem
    Jem, Finally WokenMarch 23, 2004 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Broad agreement
    69Mixed Bag
  11. 11Album cover for Love. Angel. Music. Baby. by Gwen Stefani
    Gwen Stefani, Love. Angel. Music. Baby.November 22, 2004 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    68Mixed Bag
  12. 12Album cover for Still Not Getting Any… by Simple Plan
    Simple Plan, Still Not Getting Any…October 26, 2004 · 9 reviews · 56% approval · Some debate
    67Mixed Bag
  13. 13Album cover for Nouvelle Vague by Nouvelle Vague
    Nouvelle Vague, Nouvelle VagueMay 11, 2004 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Contentious
    66Mixed Bag
  14. 14Album cover for Colour the Small One by Sia
    Sia, Colour the Small OneJanuary 12, 2004 · 7 reviews · 43% approval · Some debate
    66Mixed Bag
  15. 15Album cover for Free Me by Emma Bunton
    Emma Bunton, Free MeFebruary 9, 2004 · 6 reviews · 17% approval · Some debate
    64Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for Because I Can by Katy Rose
    Katy Rose, Because I CanJanuary 27, 2004 · 5 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate
    62Mixed Bag
  17. 17Album cover for Harmonium by Vanessa Carlton
    Vanessa Carlton, HarmoniumJanuary 1, 2004 · 9 reviews · 22% approval · Some debate
    57Mixed Bag
  18. 18Album cover for Winning Days by The Vines
    The Vines, Winning DaysMarch 17, 2004 · 10 reviews · 20% approval · Divided
    54Back of the Crate
  19. 19Album cover for Astronaut by Duran Duran
    Duran Duran, AstronautOctober 4, 2004 · 10 reviews · 0% approval · Some debate
    52Back of the Crate
  20. 20Album cover for Autobiography by Ashlee Simpson
    Ashlee Simpson, AutobiographyJanuary 1, 2004 · 6 reviews · 17% approval · Some debate
    50Back of the Crate
  1. 1Album cover for Smile by Brian Wilson
    Brian Wilson, SmileSeptember 28, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    92Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Supergrass is 10 by Supergrass
    Supergrass, Supergrass is 10June 7, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Future Perfect by Autolux
    Autolux, Future PerfectOctober 26, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for The Dirty South by Drive-By Truckers
    Drive-By Truckers, The Dirty SouthAugust 24, 2004 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for The Futureheads by The Futureheads
    The Futureheads, The FutureheadsJuly 12, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Aw Cmon by Lambchop
    Lambchop, Aw CmonFebruary 9, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Unanimous
    78Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for High by The Blue Nile
    The Blue Nile, HighAugust 30, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Let It Die by Feist
    Feist, Let It DieMay 18, 2004 · 9 reviews · 78% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Happiness in Magazines by Graham Coxon
    Graham Coxon, Happiness in MagazinesMay 4, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    76Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for The Delivery Man by Elvis Costello
    Elvis Costello, The Delivery ManSeptember 21, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Rubber Factory by The Black Keys
    The Black Keys, Rubber FactorySeptember 7, 2004 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb by U2
    U2, How to Dismantle an Atomic BombNovember 17, 2004 · 11 reviews · 73% approval · Divided
    76Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for A Ghost Is Born by Wilco
    Wilco, A Ghost Is BornJune 21, 2004 · 13 reviews · 54% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Peace, Love, Death Metal by Eagles of Death Metal
    Eagles of Death Metal, Peace, Love, Death MetalMarch 22, 2004 · 8 reviews · 75% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Eye to the Telescope by KT Tunstall
    KT Tunstall, Eye to the TelescopeDecember 13, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for The Silent Force by Within Temptation
    Within Temptation, The Silent ForceNovember 12, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for Sonic Nurse by Sonic Youth
    Sonic Youth, Sonic NurseJune 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Hot Fuss by The Killers
    The Killers, Hot FussJune 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Divided
    73Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge by My Chemical Romance
    My Chemical Romance, Three Cheers for Sweet RevengeJanuary 8, 2004 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Some debate
    72Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for Mmhmm by Relient K
    Relient K, MmhmmNovember 2, 2004 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    71Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Funeral by Arcade Fire
    Arcade Fire, FuneralSeptember 14, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for From a Basement on the Hill by Elliott Smith
    Elliott Smith, From a Basement on the HillOctober 18, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    85Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Silent Alarm by Bloc Party
    Bloc Party, Silent Alarm2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Bubblegum by Mark Lanegan
    Mark Lanegan, BubblegumAugust 2, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Good News for People Who Love Bad News by Modest Mouse
    Modest Mouse, Good News for People Who Love Bad NewsApril 5, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    81Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for You’re a Woman, I’m a Machine by Death from Above 1979
    Death from Above 1979, You’re a Woman, I’m a MachineSeptember 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    80Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Audit in Progress by Hot Snakes
    Hot Snakes, Audit in ProgressOctober 5, 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Our Endless Numbered Days by Iron & Wine
    Iron & Wine, Our Endless Numbered DaysMarch 23, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for La maison de mon rêve by CocoRosie
    CocoRosie, La maison de mon rêveMarch 9, 2004 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Satanic Panic in the Attic by of Montreal
    of Montreal, Satanic Panic in the AtticMarch 24, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Antics by Interpol
    Interpol, AnticsSeptember 24, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Pawn Shoppe Heart by The Von Bondies
    The Von Bondies, Pawn Shoppe HeartFebruary 9, 2004 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Seven Swans by Sufjan Stevens
    Sufjan Stevens, Seven SwansMarch 16, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for The Libertines by The Libertines
    The Libertines, The LibertinesAugust 30, 2004 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    77Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for The Great Destroyer by Low
    Low, The Great Destroyer2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for Rejoicing in the Hands by Devendra Banhart
    Devendra Banhart, Rejoicing in the HandsMay 4, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for Desperate Youth, Blood Thirsty Babes by TV on the Radio
    TV on the Radio, Desperate Youth, Blood Thirsty BabesMarch 9, 2004 · 11 reviews · 73% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Uh Huh Her by PJ Harvey
    PJ Harvey, Uh Huh HerMay 31, 2004 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Sung Tongs by Animal Collective
    Animal Collective, Sung TongsMay 3, 2004 · 9 reviews · 78% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for American Idiot by Green Day
    Green Day, American IdiotSeptember 20, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for No Said Date by Masta Killa
    Masta Killa, No Said DateJune 1, 2004 · 8 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    86Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Legend of the Wu-Tang Clan by Wu-Tang Clan
    Wu-Tang Clan, Legend of the Wu-Tang ClanOctober 26, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    85Heavy Rotation
  3. 3Album cover for Madvillainy by Madvillain
    Madvillain, MadvillainyMarch 19, 2004 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Showtime by Dizzee Rascal
    Dizzee Rascal, ShowtimeSeptember 6, 2004 · 12 reviews · 92% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for The College Dropout by Kanye West
    Kanye West, The College DropoutFebruary 9, 2004 · 11 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for The Grind Date by De La Soul
    De La Soul, The Grind DateOctober 4, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Divided
    80Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Murs 3:16: The 9th Edition by Murs
    Murs, Murs 3:16: The 9th EditionMarch 23, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for A Long Hot Summer by Masta Ace
    Masta Ace, A Long Hot SummerAugust 3, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    79Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for The Pretty Toney Album by Ghostface Killah
    Ghostface Killah, The Pretty Toney AlbumApril 20, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Mm.. Food by MF DOOM
    MF DOOM, Mm.. FoodNovember 16, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    79Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for To tha X-Treme by Devin the Dude
    Devin the Dude, To tha X-TremeJuly 13, 2004 · 5 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Jeanius by Jean Grae
    Jean Grae, Jeanius2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Cee-Lo Green… Is the Soul Machine by CeeLo Green
    CeeLo Green, Cee-Lo Green… Is the Soul MachineFebruary 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    78Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Absence by Dälek
    Dälek, Absence2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for This Week by Jean Grae
    Jean Grae, This WeekSeptember 21, 2004 · 6 reviews · 100% approval · Unanimous
    77Keeper
  16. 16Album cover for Street’s Disciple by Nas
    Nas, Street’s DiscipleNovember 29, 2004 · 11 reviews · 82% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  17. 17Album cover for Thug Matrimony: Married to the Streets by Trick Daddy
    Trick Daddy, Thug Matrimony: Married to the StreetsOctober 26, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Broad agreement
    75Keeper
  18. 18Album cover for Purple Haze by Cam'ron
    Cam'ron, Purple HazeDecember 7, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  19. 19Album cover for Kiss of Death by Jadakiss
    Jadakiss, Kiss of DeathJune 22, 2004 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  20. 20Album cover for To the 5 Boroughs by Beastie Boys
    Beastie Boys, To the 5 BoroughsJune 7, 2004 · 12 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  1. 1Album cover for Beautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2 by Jill Scott
    Jill Scott, Beautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2August 30, 2004 · 11 reviews · 91% approval · Broad agreement
    82Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Get Lifted by John Legend
    John Legend, Get LiftedOctober 25, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Afrodisiac by Brandy Norwood
    Brandy Norwood, AfrodisiacJune 28, 2004 · 8 reviews · 75% approval · Broad agreement
    74Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Street Signs by Ozomatli
    Ozomatli, Street SignsJune 21, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Broad agreement
    72Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Confessions by Usher
    Usher, ConfessionsMarch 22, 2004 · 11 reviews · 55% approval · Divided
    71Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Musicology by Prince
    Prince, MusicologyApril 19, 2004 · 11 reviews · 64% approval · Broad agreement
    70Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Stone Love by Angie Stone
    Angie Stone, Stone LoveJune 10, 2004 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Some debate
    67Mixed Bag
  8. 8Album cover for Hurt No More by Mario Winans
    Mario Winans, Hurt No MoreApril 20, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    65Mixed Bag
  9. 9Album cover for The 18th Day by Estelle
    Estelle, The 18th DayOctober 18, 2004 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    65Mixed Bag
  10. 10Album cover for Turning Point by Mario
    Mario, Turning PointAugust 6, 2004 · 8 reviews · 38% approval · Broad agreement
    64Mixed Bag
  11. 11Album cover for Mind Body & Soul by Joss Stone
    Joss Stone, Mind Body & SoulSeptember 15, 2004 · 8 reviews · 25% approval · Broad agreement
    63Mixed Bag
  12. 12Album cover for Damita Jo by Janet Jackson
    Janet Jackson, Damita JoMarch 22, 2004 · 10 reviews · 40% approval · Divided
    61Mixed Bag
  13. 13Album cover for Can’tneverdidnothin’ by Nikka Costa
    Nikka Costa, Can’tneverdidnothin’2004 · 5 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate
    60Mixed Bag
  14. 14Album cover for Goodies by Ciara
    Ciara, GoodiesSeptember 27, 2004 · 9 reviews · 11% approval · Broad agreement
    59Mixed Bag
  15. 15Album cover for JoJo by JoJo
    JoJo, JoJoJune 22, 2004 · 6 reviews · 17% approval · Some debate
    56Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for Unfinished Business by R. Kelly
    R. Kelly, Unfinished BusinessOctober 26, 2004 · 9 reviews · 11% approval · Some debate
    54Back of the Crate
  17. 17Album cover for It’s About Time by Christina Milian
    Christina Milian, It’s About TimeMarch 24, 2004 · 5 reviews · 0% approval · Broad agreement
    46Back of the Crate
  18. 18Album cover for Concrete Rose by Ashanti
    Ashanti, Concrete RoseDecember 13, 2004 · 10 reviews · 0% approval · Broad agreement
    45Back of the Crate
  1. 1Album cover for A Grand Don’t Come for Free by The Streets
    The Streets, A Grand Don’t Come for FreeMay 10, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  2. 2Album cover for Last Exit by Junior Boys
    Junior Boys, Last ExitJune 7, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Anniemal by Annie
    Annie, AnniemalSeptember 28, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for The Blue Notebooks by Max Richter
    Max Richter, The Blue NotebooksFebruary 26, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Medúlla by Björk
    Björk, MedúllaAugust 25, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Some debate
    81Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Venice by Fennesz
    Fennesz, VeniceMarch 2004 · 8 reviews · 88% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Talkie Walkie by Air
    Air, Talkie WalkieJanuary 21, 2004 · 10 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Ultravisitor by Squarepusher
    Squarepusher, UltravisitorMarch 3, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Push the Button by The Chemical Brothers
    The Chemical Brothers, Push the ButtonDecember 2004 · 12 reviews · 75% approval · Some debate
    71Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Destroy Rock & Roll by Mylo
    Mylo, Destroy Rock & RollMay 24, 2004 · 12 reviews · 67% approval · Contentious
    70Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for Blue Album by Orbital
    Orbital, Blue AlbumJune 21, 2004 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Divided
    69Mixed Bag
  12. 12Album cover for Summer Make Good by Múm
    Múm, Summer Make GoodFebruary 2004 · 10 reviews · 50% approval · Divided
    65Mixed Bag
  13. 13Album cover for The Equatorial Stars by Fripp & Eno
    Fripp & Eno, The Equatorial StarsMarch 28, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Contentious
    62Mixed Bag
  14. 14Album cover for No Roots by Faithless
    Faithless, No RootsJune 4, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    60Mixed Bag
  15. 15Album cover for City by Client
    Client, CitySeptember 21, 2004 · 5 reviews · 20% approval · Some debate
    58Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for Satan’s Circus by Death in Vegas
    Death in Vegas, Satan’s CircusOctober 11, 2004 · 8 reviews · 25% approval · Divided
    58Mixed Bag
  17. 17Album cover for Palookaville by Fatboy Slim
    Fatboy Slim, PalookavilleSeptember 29, 2004 · 11 reviews · 9% approval · Some debate
    54Back of the Crate
  18. 18Album cover for Baby Monkey by Moby
    Moby, Baby MonkeyJanuary 27, 2004 · 10 reviews · 0% approval · Broad agreement
    53Back of the Crate
  19. 19Album cover for Always Outnumbered, Never Outgunned by The Prodigy
    The Prodigy, Always Outnumbered, Never OutgunnedAugust 11, 2004 · 11 reviews · 0% approval · Some debate
    46Back of the Crate
  1. 1Album cover for Van Lear Rose by Loretta Lynn
    Loretta Lynn, Van Lear RoseApril 27, 2004 · 10 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    92Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for What I Do by Alan Jackson
    Alan Jackson, What I DoSeptember 7, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    78Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Escondida by Jolie Holland
    Jolie Holland, EscondidaApril 26, 2004 · 10 reviews · 90% approval · Broad agreement
    77Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for The Milk-Eyed Mender by Joanna Newsom
    Joanna Newsom, The Milk-Eyed MenderMarch 23, 2004 · 9 reviews · 78% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for Dear Heather by Leonard Cohen
    Leonard Cohen, Dear HeatherOctober 25, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Here for the Party by Gretchen Wilson
    Gretchen Wilson, Here for the PartyMay 11, 2004 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Broad agreement
    73Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for Live Like You Were Dying by Tim McGraw
    Tim McGraw, Live Like You Were DyingAugust 24, 2004 · 6 reviews · 50% approval · Contentious
    69Mixed Bag
  8. 8Album cover for Be as You Are (Songs from an Old Blue Chair) by Kenny Chesney
    Kenny Chesney, Be as You Are (Songs from an Old Blue Chair)2004 · 7 reviews · 29% approval · Some debate
    59Mixed Bag
  1. 1Album cover for Leviathan by Mastodon
    Mastodon, LeviathanAugust 31, 2004 · 9 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    89Heavy Rotation
  2. 2Album cover for Panopticon by Isis
    Isis, PanopticonOctober 19, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    84Keeper
  3. 3Album cover for Once by Nightwish
    Nightwish, OnceJune 7, 2004 · 7 reviews · 86% approval · Some debate
    83Keeper
  4. 4Album cover for Archetype by Fear Factory
    Fear Factory, ArchetypeApril 19, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Some debate
    82Keeper
  5. 5Album cover for The End of Heartache by Killswitch Engage
    Killswitch Engage, The End of HeartacheMay 3, 2004 · 7 reviews · 100% approval · Broad agreement
    80Keeper
  6. 6Album cover for Prophecy by Soulfly
    Soulfly, ProphecyMarch 22, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Some debate
    76Keeper
  7. 7Album cover for You Fail Me by Converge
    Converge, You Fail MeSeptember 15, 2004 · 5 reviews · 80% approval · Divided
    76Keeper
  8. 8Album cover for Ashes of the Wake by Lamb of God
    Lamb of God, Ashes of the WakeAugust 26, 2004 · 6 reviews · 83% approval · Broad agreement
    76Keeper
  9. 9Album cover for Reise, Reise by Rammstein
    Rammstein, Reise, ReiseSeptember 27, 2004 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Divided
    76Keeper
  10. 10Album cover for Leaders Not Followers: Part 2 by Napalm Death
    Napalm Death, Leaders Not Followers: Part 2July 22, 2004 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    75Keeper
  11. 11Album cover for The War Within by Shadows Fall
    Shadows Fall, The War WithinSeptember 20, 2004 · 6 reviews · 67% approval · Some debate
    74Keeper
  12. 12Album cover for Miss Machine by The Dillinger Escape Plan
    The Dillinger Escape Plan, Miss MachineJuly 20, 2004 · 10 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    74Keeper
  13. 13Album cover for Tyrannosaurus Hives by The Hives
    The Hives, Tyrannosaurus HivesJuly 14, 2004 · 10 reviews · 70% approval · Some debate
    73Keeper
  14. 14Album cover for Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses) by Slipknot
    Slipknot, Vol. 3: (The Subliminal Verses)May 21, 2004 · 9 reviews · 67% approval · Broad agreement
    73Keeper
  15. 15Album cover for Nymphetamine by Cradle of Filth
    Cradle of Filth, NymphetamineSeptember 20, 2004 · 7 reviews · 71% approval · Some debate
    69Mixed Bag
  16. 16Album cover for The System Has Failed by Megadeth
    Megadeth, The System Has FailedSeptember 13, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    69Mixed Bag
  17. 17Album cover for Inferno by Motörhead
    Motörhead, InfernoJune 21, 2004 · 7 reviews · 43% approval · Some debate
    69Mixed Bag
  18. 18Album cover for They’re Only Chasing Safety by Underoath
    Underoath, They’re Only Chasing SafetyJune 15, 2004 · 5 reviews · 60% approval · Divided
    66Mixed Bag
  19. 19Album cover for Houses of the Molé by Ministry
    Ministry, Houses of the MoléJune 18, 2004 · 7 reviews · 57% approval · Contentious
    64Mixed Bag
  20. 20Album cover for Until the End by Kittie
    Kittie, Until the EndJuly 27, 2004 · 9 reviews · 44% approval · Divided
    60Mixed Bag

← 2003 · Every year, back to the 1950s · 2005 →

B-Side Breakdowns home