Elliott Smith’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 5 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 79 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.
What is Elliott Smith’s best album?
By the critics, it’s From a Basement on the Hill (2004), with a B-Side Breakdown of 85 (Heavy Rotation) from 11 reviews. 100% of them liked it.
Next best: Elliott Smith (83) and XO (80). Lowest rated: Roman Candle (74).
Elliott Smith albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
From a Basement on the Hill200485 Heavy Rotation - 2
Elliott Smith199583 Keeper - 3
XO199880 Keeper - 4
Figure 8200075 Keeper - 5
Roman Candle199474 Keeper
Elliott Smith discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Elliott Smith album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Elliott Smith studio album, oldest first. One doesn't have a Breakdown yet; it gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.
Which critics love Elliott Smith, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Elliott Smith albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Los Angeles Times3 albums+19
- XO 1998100 vs 75 from 7 others +25
- Figure 8 200088 vs 73 from 9 others +15
- From a Basement on the Hill 2004100 vs 84 from 9 others +16
AllMusic5 albums+6
- Roman Candle 199480 vs 74 from 10 others +6
- Elliott Smith 199590 vs 81 from 5 others +9
- XO 199890 vs 77 from 7 others +13
- Figure 8 200070 vs 75 from 9 others −5
- From a Basement on the Hill 200490 vs 85 from 9 others +5
The Guardian4 albums+1
- Roman Candle 199460 vs 76 from 10 others −16
- Elliott Smith 199580 vs 83 from 5 others −3
- Figure 8 200080 vs 74 from 9 others +6
- From a Basement on the Hill 2004100 vs 84 from 9 others +16
Pitchfork5 albums0
- Roman Candle 199478 vs 74 from 10 others +4
- Elliott Smith 199595 vs 80 from 5 others +15
- XO 199881 vs 78 from 7 others +3
- Figure 8 200069 vs 75 from 9 others −6
- From a Basement on the Hill 200472 vs 87 from 9 others −15
Spin3 albums−1
- XO 199880 vs 78 from 7 others +2
- Figure 8 200070 vs 75 from 9 others −5
- From a Basement on the Hill 200485 vs 85 from 9 others 0
NME5 albums−6
- Roman Candle 199460 vs 76 from 10 others −16
- Elliott Smith 199570 vs 85 from 5 others −15
- XO 199870 vs 79 from 7 others −9
- Figure 8 200080 vs 74 from 9 others +6
- From a Basement on the Hill 200490 vs 85 from 9 others +5
Entertainment Weekly3 albums−11
- XO 199865 vs 80 from 7 others −15
- Figure 8 200059 vs 76 from 9 others −17
- From a Basement on the Hill 200485 vs 85 from 9 others 0
Rolling Stone3 albums−14
- XO 199860 vs 81 from 7 others −21
- Figure 8 200070 vs 75 from 9 others −5
- From a Basement on the Hill 200470 vs 87 from 9 others −17
From B-Side Guys
- The Cage You Built Together: Living Too Late’s “Starting To Be” February 17, 2026
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.




