Mastodon’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 9 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 81 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.
What is Mastodon’s best album?
By the critics, it’s Leviathan (2004), with a B-Side Breakdown of 90 (Heavy Rotation) from 7 reviews. 100% of them liked it.
Next best: Hushed and Grim (86) and Remission (86). Lowest rated: Once More ‘Round the Sun (72).
Mastodon albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
Leviathan2004
90 Heavy Rotation - 2
Hushed and Grim202186 Heavy Rotation - 3
Remission200286 Heavy Rotation - 4
The Hunter201182 Keeper - 5
Crack the Skye200982 Keeper - 6
Blood Mountain200680 Keeper - 7
Marrow Deep202679 Keeper - 8
Emperor of Sand201776 Keeper - 9
Once More ‘Round the Sun201472 Keeper
Mastodon discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Mastodon album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Mastodon album we track, oldest first.
Which critics love Mastodon, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Mastodon albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Sputnikmusic4 albums+6
- Remission 200280 vs 88 from 3 others −8
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201482 vs 71 from 9 others +11
- Emperor of Sand 201790 vs 75 from 12 others +15
- Hushed and Grim 202190 vs 86 from 12 others +4
Metal Temple4 albums+5
- Leviathan 200480 vs 91 from 6 others −11
- Crack the Skye 200990 vs 81 from 10 others +9
- The Hunter 201190 vs 82 from 13 others +8
- Hushed and Grim 2021100 vs 85 from 12 others +15
Spin3 albums+4
- Leviathan 200493 vs 89 from 6 others +4
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201480 vs 71 from 9 others +9
Exclaim!3 albums+3
- Emperor of Sand 201780 vs 76 from 12 others +4
- Hushed and Grim 202190 vs 86 from 12 others +4
- Marrow Deep 202680 vs 79 from 7 others +1
musicOMH3 albums+2
- Blood Mountain 200680 vs 80 from 7 others 0
- Crack the Skye 200990 vs 81 from 10 others +9
- The Hunter 201180 vs 83 from 13 others −3
Paste3 albums0
- Crack the Skye 200990 vs 81 from 10 others +9
- Emperor of Sand 201773 vs 77 from 12 others −4
- Marrow Deep 202675 vs 80 from 7 others −5
PopMatters6 albums0
- Blood Mountain 2006100 vs 77 from 7 others +23
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- The Hunter 201160 vs 84 from 13 others −24
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201480 vs 71 from 9 others +9
- Emperor of Sand 201770 vs 77 from 12 others −7
- Marrow Deep 202680 vs 79 from 7 others +1
AllMusic8 albums−1
- Remission 200280 vs 88 from 3 others −8
- Leviathan 2004100 vs 88 from 6 others +12
- Blood Mountain 200680 vs 80 from 7 others 0
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- The Hunter 201180 vs 83 from 13 others −3
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201460 vs 73 from 9 others −13
- Emperor of Sand 201780 vs 76 from 12 others +4
- Hushed and Grim 202190 vs 86 from 12 others +4
The Line of Best Fit4 albums−1
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201460 vs 73 from 9 others −13
- Emperor of Sand 201790 vs 75 from 12 others +15
- Hushed and Grim 202190 vs 86 from 12 others +4
- Marrow Deep 202670 vs 81 from 7 others −11
Rolling Stone5 albums−4
- Blood Mountain 200680 vs 80 from 7 others 0
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- The Hunter 201180 vs 83 from 13 others −3
- Emperor of Sand 201770 vs 77 from 12 others −7
- Hushed and Grim 202180 vs 87 from 12 others −7
Pitchfork9 albums−6
- Remission 200290 vs 84 from 3 others +6
- Leviathan 200485 vs 91 from 6 others −6
- Blood Mountain 200687 vs 79 from 7 others +8
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- The Hunter 201175 vs 83 from 13 others −8
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201463 vs 73 from 9 others −10
- Emperor of Sand 201776 vs 77 from 12 others −1
- Hushed and Grim 202157 vs 89 from 12 others −32
- Marrow Deep 202669 vs 81 from 7 others −12
Spectrum Culture4 albums−11
- Crack the Skye 200960 vs 84 from 10 others −24
- The Hunter 201174 vs 83 from 13 others −9
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201470 vs 72 from 9 others −2
- Emperor of Sand 201770 vs 77 from 12 others −7
Consequence3 albums−11
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201465 vs 73 from 9 others −8
- Emperor of Sand 201765 vs 77 from 12 others −12
- Hushed and Grim 202175 vs 87 from 12 others −12
The Guardian5 albums−16
- Blood Mountain 200620 vs 89 from 7 others −69
- Crack the Skye 200980 vs 82 from 10 others −2
- The Hunter 201180 vs 83 from 13 others −3
- Once More ‘Round the Sun 201480 vs 71 from 9 others +9
- Emperor of Sand 201760 vs 78 from 12 others −18
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.









