Carrie Underwood Albums Ranked

Carrie Underwood’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 8 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 65 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is Carrie Underwood’s best album?

By the critics, it’s My Savior (2021), with a B-Side Breakdown of 80 (Keeper) from 5 reviews. 80% of them liked it.

Next best: Storyteller (70) and Cry Pretty (67). Lowest rated: Play On (56).

Carrie Underwood albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. My Savior (2021): 80 Keeper
  2. 2. Storyteller (2015): 70 Keeper
  3. 3. Cry Pretty (2018): 67 Mixed Bag
  4. 4. Carnival Ride (2007): 67 Mixed Bag
  5. 5. Some Hearts (2005): 64 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. My Gift (2020): 57 Mixed Bag
  7. 7. Blown Away (2012): 57 Mixed Bag
  8. 8. Play On (2009): 56 Mixed Bag

Carrie Underwood discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every Carrie Underwood album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

4010070likedSome Hearts (2005): 64642005Carnival Ride (2007): 67672007Play On (2009): 56562009Blown Away (2012): 57572012Storyteller (2015): 70702015Cry Pretty (2018): 67672018My Gift (2020): 57572020My Savior (2021): 80802021

Every Carrie Underwood studio album, oldest first. One doesn't have a Breakdown yet; it gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 2005Album cover for Some Hearts by Carrie UnderwoodSome Hearts64 Mixed Bag
  2. 2007Album cover for Carnival Ride by Carrie UnderwoodCarnival Ride67 Mixed Bag
  3. 2009Album cover for Play On by Carrie UnderwoodPlay On56 Mixed Bag
  4. 2012Album cover for Blown Away by Carrie UnderwoodBlown Away57 Mixed Bag
  5. 2015Album cover for Storyteller by Carrie UnderwoodStoryteller70 Keeper
  6. 2018Album cover for Cry Pretty by Carrie UnderwoodCry Pretty67 Mixed Bag
  7. 2020Album cover for My Gift by Carrie UnderwoodMy Gift57 Mixed Bag
  8. 2021Album cover for My Savior by Carrie UnderwoodMy Savior80 Keeper
  9. 2022Denim & RhinestonesNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love Carrie Underwood, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Carrie Underwood albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

USA Today3 albums+9
  1. Some Hearts 200575 vs 62 from 4 others +14
  2. Play On 200975 vs 53 from 8 others +22
  3. Storyteller 201563 vs 71 from 6 others −8

All USA Today reviews

AllMusic7 albums+9
  1. Some Hearts 200580 vs 60 from 4 others +20
  2. Carnival Ride 200780 vs 64 from 4 others +16
  3. Play On 200950 vs 57 from 8 others −7
  4. Storyteller 201580 vs 68 from 6 others +12
  5. Cry Pretty 201890 vs 64 from 8 others +26
  6. My Gift 202060 vs 55 from 2 others +5
  7. My Savior 202170 vs 83 from 4 others −13

All AllMusic reviews

Entertainment Weekly6 albums+8
  1. Some Hearts 200551 vs 68 from 4 others −17
  2. Carnival Ride 200775 vs 65 from 4 others +10
  3. Play On 200965 vs 55 from 8 others +10
  4. Storyteller 201585 vs 67 from 6 others +18
  5. Cry Pretty 201875 vs 66 from 8 others +10
  6. My Savior 202193 vs 77 from 4 others +16

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

Rolling Stone3 albums−1
  1. Carnival Ride 200770 vs 66 from 4 others +4
  2. Storyteller 201560 vs 71 from 6 others −11
  3. Cry Pretty 201870 vs 66 from 8 others +4

All Rolling Stone reviews

PopMatters4 albums−6
  1. Carnival Ride 200770 vs 66 from 4 others +4
  2. Play On 200920 vs 60 from 8 others −40
  3. Blown Away 201270 vs 50 from 2 others +20
  4. Cry Pretty 201860 vs 67 from 8 others −7

All PopMatters reviews

Slant4 albums−13
  1. Some Hearts 200550 vs 68 from 4 others −18
  2. Carnival Ride 200740 vs 74 from 4 others −34
  3. Play On 200950 vs 57 from 8 others −7
  4. Blown Away 201260 vs 55 from 2 others +5

All Slant reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home