Mariah Carey’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 16 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 64 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.
What is Mariah Carey’s best album?
By the critics, it’s Daydream (1995), with a B-Side Breakdown of 78 (Keeper) from 7 reviews. 71% of them liked it.
Next best: Caution (77) and The Emancipation of Mimi (71). Lowest rated: Charmbracelet (47).
Mariah Carey albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
Daydream199578 Keeper - 2
Caution201877 Keeper - 3
The Emancipation of Mimi200571 Keeper - 4
Here for It All202570 Keeper - 5
Rainbow199968 Mixed Bag - 6
Butterfly199768 Mixed Bag - 7
Mariah Carey199068 Mixed Bag - 8
Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel200965 Mixed Bag - 9
E=MC²200864 Mixed Bag - 10
Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse201463 Mixed Bag - 11
Emotions199161 Mixed Bag - 12
Merry Christmas199459 Mixed Bag - 13
Merry Christmas II You201057 Mixed Bag - 14
Music Box199355 Mixed Bag - 15
Glitter200153 Back of the Crate - 16
Charmbracelet200247 Back of the Crate
Mariah Carey discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Mariah Carey album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Mariah Carey album we track, oldest first.
- 1990
Mariah Carey68 Mixed Bag - 1991
Emotions61 Mixed Bag - 1993
Music Box55 Mixed Bag - 1994
Merry Christmas59 Mixed Bag - 1995
Daydream78 Keeper - 1997
Butterfly68 Mixed Bag - 1999
Rainbow68 Mixed Bag - 2001
Glitter53 Back of the Crate - 2002
Charmbracelet47 Back of the Crate - 2005
The Emancipation of Mimi71 Keeper - 2008
E=MC²64 Mixed Bag - 2009
Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel65 Mixed Bag - 2010
Merry Christmas II You57 Mixed Bag - 2014
Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse63 Mixed Bag - 2018
Caution77 Keeper - 2025
Here for It All70 Keeper
Which critics love Mariah Carey, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Mariah Carey albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Blender3 albums+12
- Glitter 200160 vs 52 from 6 others +8
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200580 vs 69 from 8 others +11
- E=MC² 200880 vs 62 from 7 others +18
Chicago Tribune3 albums+11
- Mariah Carey 199088 vs 65 from 6 others +23
- Emotions 199175 vs 59 from 7 others +16
- Butterfly 199763 vs 69 from 8 others −6
AllMusic15 albums+10
- Mariah Carey 199080 vs 66 from 6 others +14
- Emotions 199180 vs 59 from 7 others +21
- Music Box 199380 vs 48 from 4 others +32
- Merry Christmas 199480 vs 55 from 5 others +25
- Daydream 1995100 vs 75 from 6 others +25
- Butterfly 199790 vs 65 from 8 others +25
- Rainbow 199960 vs 70 from 5 others −10
- Glitter 200150 vs 54 from 6 others −4
- Charmbracelet 200250 vs 46 from 5 others +4
- E=MC² 200860 vs 65 from 7 others −5
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200970 vs 64 from 8 others +6
- Merry Christmas II You 201060 vs 55 from 2 others +5
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201470 vs 62 from 7 others +8
- Caution 201880 vs 77 from 9 others +3
- Here for It All 202570 vs 70 from 10 others +1
Pitchfork6 albums+9
- Merry Christmas 199473 vs 56 from 5 others +17
- Daydream 199579 vs 78 from 6 others +1
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200590 vs 68 from 8 others +22
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201477 vs 61 from 7 others +16
- Caution 201875 vs 77 from 9 others −2
- Here for It All 202570 vs 70 from 10 others +1
The Guardian5 albums+7
- Charmbracelet 200240 vs 48 from 5 others −8
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200580 vs 69 from 8 others +11
- E=MC² 200880 vs 62 from 7 others +18
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200980 vs 63 from 8 others +17
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201460 vs 64 from 7 others −4
Slant10 albums+1
- Butterfly 199790 vs 65 from 8 others +25
- Glitter 200160 vs 52 from 6 others +8
- Charmbracelet 200260 vs 44 from 5 others +16
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200570 vs 71 from 8 others −1
- E=MC² 200860 vs 65 from 7 others −5
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200960 vs 66 from 8 others −6
- Merry Christmas II You 201050 vs 60 from 2 others −10
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201460 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- Caution 201870 vs 78 from 9 others −8
- Here for It All 202560 vs 71 from 10 others −11
Rolling Stone13 albums−2
- Emotions 199160 vs 62 from 7 others −2
- Music Box 199360 vs 53 from 4 others +7
- Butterfly 199760 vs 69 from 8 others −9
- Rainbow 199960 vs 70 from 5 others −10
- Glitter 200160 vs 52 from 6 others +8
- Charmbracelet 200240 vs 48 from 5 others −8
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200550 vs 73 from 8 others −23
- E=MC² 200860 vs 65 from 7 others −5
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200988 vs 62 from 8 others +26
- Merry Christmas II You 201060 vs 55 from 2 others +5
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201460 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- Caution 201880 vs 77 from 9 others +3
- Here for It All 202560 vs 71 from 10 others −11
musicOMH3 albums−2
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200950 vs 67 from 8 others −17
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201450 vs 65 from 7 others −15
- Caution 2018100 vs 74 from 9 others +26
Entertainment Weekly14 albums−2
- Mariah Carey 199059 vs 70 from 6 others −11
- Emotions 199151 vs 63 from 7 others −12
- Music Box 199355 vs 55 from 4 others +1
- Merry Christmas 199451 vs 61 from 5 others −10
- Daydream 199565 vs 81 from 6 others −16
- Butterfly 199759 vs 69 from 8 others −10
- Rainbow 199975 vs 67 from 5 others +8
- Glitter 200151 vs 53 from 6 others −2
- Charmbracelet 200251 vs 46 from 5 others +5
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200565 vs 71 from 8 others −6
- E=MC² 200885 vs 61 from 7 others +24
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200965 vs 65 from 8 others 0
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201465 vs 63 from 7 others +2
- Caution 201875 vs 77 from 9 others −2
Los Angeles Times11 albums−6
- Emotions 199150 vs 63 from 7 others −13
- Music Box 199338 vs 59 from 4 others −21
- Merry Christmas 199450 vs 61 from 5 others −11
- Daydream 199575 vs 79 from 6 others −4
- Butterfly 199775 vs 67 from 8 others +8
- Rainbow 199988 vs 64 from 5 others +24
- Glitter 200150 vs 54 from 6 others −4
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200550 vs 73 from 8 others −23
- E=MC² 200850 vs 66 from 7 others −16
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200963 vs 65 from 8 others −2
- Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse 201463 vs 63 from 7 others 0
PopMatters3 albums−6
- The Emancipation of Mimi 200570 vs 71 from 8 others −1
- E=MC² 200840 vs 68 from 7 others −28
- Here for It All 202580 vs 69 from 10 others +12
The Rolling Stone Album Guide6 albums−8
- Mariah Carey 199060 vs 70 from 6 others −10
- Emotions 199160 vs 62 from 7 others −2
- Music Box 199340 vs 58 from 4 others −18
- Daydream 199560 vs 82 from 6 others −22
- Butterfly 199780 vs 67 from 8 others +14
- Charmbracelet 200240 vs 48 from 5 others −8
Encyclopedia of Popular Music6 albums−9
- Mariah Carey 199060 vs 70 from 6 others −10
- Emotions 199160 vs 62 from 7 others −2
- Merry Christmas 199440 vs 63 from 5 others −23
- Daydream 199580 vs 78 from 6 others +2
- Rainbow 199960 vs 70 from 5 others −10
- Glitter 200140 vs 55 from 6 others −15
NME3 albums−12
- Butterfly 199740 vs 72 from 8 others −32
- Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel 200950 vs 67 from 8 others −17
- Here for It All 202580 vs 69 from 10 others +12
Robert Christgau3 albums−14
- Mariah Carey 199051 vs 71 from 6 others −20
- Emotions 199155 vs 62 from 7 others −7
- Butterfly 199755 vs 70 from 8 others −15
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.
