Bill Callahan’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 13 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 76 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.
What is Bill Callahan’s best album?
By the critics, it’s Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest (2019), with a B-Side Breakdown of 85 (Heavy Rotation) from 10 reviews. 100% of them liked it.
Next best: Knock Knock (83) and Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle (82). Lowest rated: Sewn to the Sky (60).
Bill Callahan albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest201985 Heavy Rotation - 2
Knock Knock199983 Keeper - 3
Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle200982 Keeper - 4
Dream River201380 Keeper - 5
Wild Love199580 Keeper - 6
Julius Caesar199380 Keeper - 7
My Days of 58202678 Keeper - 8
Dongs of Sevotion200078 Keeper - 9
Apocalypse201174 Keeper - 10
Red Apple Falls199773 Keeper - 11
Blind Date Party202172 Keeper - 12
The Doctor Came at Dawn199669 Mixed Bag - 13
Sewn to the Sky199060 Mixed Bag
Bill Callahan discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Bill Callahan album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Bill Callahan studio album, oldest first. One doesn't have a Breakdown yet; it gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.
- 1990
Sewn to the Sky60 Mixed Bag - 1992Forgotten FoundationNo Breakdown yet
- 1993
Julius Caesar80 Keeper - 1995
Wild Love80 Keeper - 1996
The Doctor Came at Dawn69 Mixed Bag - 1997
Red Apple Falls73 Keeper - 1999
Knock Knock83 Keeper - 2000
Dongs of Sevotion78 Keeper - 2009
Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle82 Keeper - 2011
Apocalypse74 Keeper - 2013
Dream River80 Keeper - 2019
Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest85 Heavy Rotation - 2021
Blind Date Party72 Keeper - 2026
My Days of 5878 Keeper
Which critics love Bill Callahan, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Bill Callahan albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Mojo6 albums+12
- Knock Knock 1999100 vs 80 from 9 others +20
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 2009100 vs 81 from 13 others +19
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Dream River 2013100 vs 78 from 12 others +22
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201980 vs 85 from 9 others −5
- Blind Date Party 202180 vs 70 from 5 others +10
Pitchfork9 albums+8
- Sewn to the Sky 199080 vs 53 from 3 others +27
- Knock Knock 199997 vs 81 from 9 others +16
- Dongs of Sevotion 200093 vs 76 from 8 others +17
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200981 vs 82 from 13 others −1
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Dream River 201385 vs 80 from 12 others +5
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201985 vs 84 from 9 others +1
- Blind Date Party 202175 vs 71 from 5 others +4
- My Days of 58 202678 vs 78 from 8 others 0
AllMusic12 albums+5
- Sewn to the Sky 199060 vs 60 from 3 others 0
- Julius Caesar 199380 vs 80 from 3 others 0
- Wild Love 199590 vs 75 from 2 others +15
- The Doctor Came at Dawn 199680 vs 67 from 5 others +13
- Red Apple Falls 199790 vs 70 from 5 others +20
- Knock Knock 199990 vs 81 from 9 others +9
- Dongs of Sevotion 200080 vs 78 from 8 others +2
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200980 vs 82 from 13 others −2
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Dream River 201370 vs 81 from 12 others −11
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201980 vs 85 from 9 others −5
- Blind Date Party 202180 vs 70 from 5 others +10
The A.V. Club3 albums+3
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200985 vs 82 from 13 others +3
- Apocalypse 201175 vs 74 from 12 others +1
- Dream River 201385 vs 80 from 12 others +5
The Independent4 albums+1
- Knock Knock 199980 vs 82 from 9 others −2
- Dongs of Sevotion 200080 vs 78 from 8 others +2
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Dream River 201380 vs 80 from 12 others 0
NME8 albums−1
- Julius Caesar 199380 vs 80 from 3 others 0
- The Doctor Came at Dawn 199660 vs 71 from 5 others −11
- Red Apple Falls 199780 vs 72 from 5 others +8
- Knock Knock 199980 vs 82 from 9 others −2
- Dongs of Sevotion 200080 vs 78 from 8 others +2
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200980 vs 82 from 13 others −2
- Dream River 201380 vs 80 from 12 others 0
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201980 vs 85 from 9 others −5
The Guardian4 albums−2
- Red Apple Falls 199760 vs 76 from 5 others −16
- Dongs of Sevotion 200060 vs 80 from 8 others −20
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 2019100 vs 83 from 9 others +17
- Blind Date Party 202180 vs 70 from 5 others +10
Spin3 albums−2
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200980 vs 82 from 13 others −2
- Apocalypse 201170 vs 75 from 12 others −5
- Dream River 201380 vs 80 from 12 others 0
Uncut7 albums−3
- Red Apple Falls 199740 vs 80 from 5 others −40
- Knock Knock 199960 vs 85 from 9 others −25
- Dongs of Sevotion 2000100 vs 75 from 8 others +25
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200980 vs 82 from 13 others −2
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201990 vs 84 from 9 others +6
- Blind Date Party 202180 vs 70 from 5 others +10
The Rolling Stone Album Guide7 albums−3
- Sewn to the Sky 199040 vs 67 from 3 others −27
- Julius Caesar 199380 vs 80 from 3 others 0
- Wild Love 199570 vs 85 from 2 others −15
- The Doctor Came at Dawn 199670 vs 69 from 5 others +1
- Red Apple Falls 199790 vs 70 from 5 others +20
- Knock Knock 199990 vs 81 from 9 others +9
- Dongs of Sevotion 200070 vs 79 from 8 others −9
PopMatters4 albums−4
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200980 vs 82 from 13 others −2
- Apocalypse 201170 vs 75 from 12 others −5
- Dream River 201380 vs 80 from 12 others 0
- My Days of 58 202670 vs 79 from 8 others −9
Select3 albums−5
- Red Apple Falls 199780 vs 72 from 5 others +8
- Knock Knock 199980 vs 82 from 9 others −2
- Dongs of Sevotion 200060 vs 80 from 8 others −20
musicOMH5 albums−9
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200960 vs 84 from 13 others −24
- Apocalypse 201180 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- Dream River 201360 vs 82 from 12 others −22
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201980 vs 85 from 9 others −5
- My Days of 58 202680 vs 78 from 8 others +2
Q7 albums−9
- Julius Caesar 199380 vs 80 from 3 others 0
- Wild Love 199580 vs 80 from 2 others 0
- Dongs of Sevotion 200080 vs 78 from 8 others +2
- Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle 200960 vs 84 from 13 others −24
- Apocalypse 201140 vs 77 from 12 others −37
- Dream River 201380 vs 80 from 12 others 0
- Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest 201980 vs 85 from 9 others −5
Rolling Stone3 albums−10
- Knock Knock 199970 vs 84 from 9 others −14
- Apocalypse 201170 vs 75 from 12 others −5
- Dream River 201370 vs 81 from 12 others −11
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.
