Select

Select’s 608 album reviews that count toward Breakdowns, going back to 1990, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Print magazine, closed in 2001

Top critics

See all 86 critics

69 reviews with no named critic yet.

What it reviews

  • Rock 33%
  • Indie & Alternative 22%
  • Electronic 13%
  • Pop 9%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 9%

By the numbers

69average score it gives, on the 0 to 100 scale (608 reviews)
57%of its reviews score an album 70 or higher
22points: how far a typical review lands from its own average score
How its scores spread
  • 0–49130
  • 50s0
  • 60s130
  • 70s0
  • 80s248
  • 90+100

Its top scores

  1. The Jesus LizardLiar 100 Andrew Perry
  2. SepulturaArise 100 Neil Perry
  3. SuicideSuicide: Alan Vega and Martin Rev 100 Ian Johnston
  4. Boogie Down ProductionsEdutainment 100 Russell Brown
  5. The Go-BetweensLiberty Belle and the Black Diamond Express 100 Andrew Male
  6. Aztec CameraHigh Land, Hard Rain 100 Andrew Collins
  7. Billy BraggDon’t Try This at Home 100 Michele Kirsch
  8. RideGoing Blank Again 100 David Cavanagh

Its newest 200 reviews

Critic
Manic Street PreachersThis Is My Truth Tell Me Yours“This fan page is dedicated to the Welsh band Manic Street Preachers. We want to retell the history of the band and offer you an insight into their music.”Roy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5772021
John Lee HookerThe Real Folk BluesMark Prendergast
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5812019
MomusHippopotamomusTed Kessler
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5572018
Graham CoxonThe Golden DSteve Lowe
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5582017
Angelo BadalamentiMusic of Twin PeaksGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5752014
Meat Beat Manifesto99%Russell Brown
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712011
Brenda RussellKiss Me with the WindClodagh O'Connell
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5642010
FreestylersWe Rock HardIan Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5732010
808 StateGorgeousRupert Howe
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5642008
Parliament-FunkadelicDope DogsCaspar Smith
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5782008
Snap!World PowerAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5612008
Monie LoveDown to EarthMichele Kirsch
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5722008
Robert CrayMidnight StrollPaul Sexton
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792008
Anita BakerCompositionsPaolo Hewitt
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5662008
Cabaret VoltaireRed MeccaLeo Finlay
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5802008
The BelovedHappinessGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5762008
Ian GillanNaked ThunderMeo Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5442007
Tanita TikaramEverybody’s AngelPaul Sexton
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5422007
Bell Biv DeVoePoisonPaolo Hewitt
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712007
Dead MilkmenMetaphysical GraffitiLeo Finlay
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5502007
LushLovelifeMark Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712007
LushSplitRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5732007
Betty BooBoomaniaAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5522007
Paul YoungOther VoicesNick Griffiths
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5472007
The Allman Brothers BandSeven TurnsMark Prendergast
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712007
Michael FrantiHomeMatt Hall
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832006
The Jesus LizardLiarAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5842006
The Lovin' SpoonfulHums of the Lovin’ SpoonfulDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5752006
SepulturaAriseNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5922006
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the DarkLiberatorDave Morrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5502006
Drive Like JehuYank Crimenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5782006
Kirsty MacCollElectric LandladyPaul Sexton
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5672006
The TheDuskDanny Scott
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5802006
7 Year Bitch¡Viva Zapata!Siån Pattenden
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5732006
SlowdiveJust for a DayDan Maier
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5672006
SlowdivePygmalionGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5752006
The Blow MonkeysSpringtime for the WorldCatriona O'Shaughnessy
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5532006
The GloveBlue SunshineNick Griffiths
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5762006
Yo La TengoFakebookGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782006
Yo La TengoPresident Yo La TengoMark Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792006
SuicideSuicide: Alan Vega and Martin RevIan Johnston
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5852006
Crosby, Stills & NashLive It UpClodagh O'Connell
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5352006
BananaramaPop LifeAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5552006
SadeLove DeluxeWilliam Shaw
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712006
Paul WellerPaul WellerAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5712006
The OrbOrblivionAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782006
John HiattStolen MomentsO'Connell Clodagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5772006
The Black DogSpannersGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5842006
Boogie Down ProductionsEdutainmentRussell Brown
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5782006
The Go-BetweensTallulahAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832006
The Go-BetweensLiberty Belle and the Black Diamond ExpressAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5862006
The Go-BetweensBefore HollywoodAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5782006
The Go-BetweensSpring Hill FairAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842006
X ClanTo the East, BlackwardsAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5712006
BiohazardState of the World AddressClark Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5702006
BiohazardUrban DisciplineJeremy Clarke
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5742006
Cheap TrickBustedChris Marlowe
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5472006
Cheap TrickWoke up with a MonsterGina Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5552006
Bark PsychosisHexDave Morrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5872006
Prefab SproutSwoonStuart Maconie
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5752006
Chuck BerryThe London Chuck Berry SessionsPaul Sexton
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5522006
Yo La TengoElectr-O-PuraMark Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842006
The Jesus LizardGoatAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5792006
The Flying Burrito BrothersBurrito DeluxeDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5682006
SparklehorseGood Morning SpiderSteve Lowe
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832006
SpiritualizedPure PhaseDorian Lynskey
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5722006
Bill CallahanDongs of SevotionJenny Bulley
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5792006
Aztec CameraHigh Land, Hard RainAndrew Collins
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5892006
The JayhawksHollywood Town HallAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842006
Bill CallahanKnock KnockAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832006
Bill CallahanRed Apple FallsJohn Mullen
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5732006
Fun Lovin' Criminals100% ColombianSam Upton
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5712006
Guided by VoicesDo the CollapseStuart Muirhead
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5662006
TindersticksSimple PleasureGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5702006
The Lovin' SpoonfulDaydreamDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5792006
Billy BraggDon’t Try This at HomeMichele Kirsch
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5802006
Prefab SproutJordan: The ComebackGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842006
SantanaSpirits Dancing in the FleshGlenn Rice
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5662006
Killing JokeDemocracyBen Mitchell
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5612006
Killing JokeFire DancesNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5582006
Killing JokeOutside the GateNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5282006
Killing JokeRevelationsNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5682006
Van MorrisonEnlightenmentGlyn Brown
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782006
TrickyNearly GodMark Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5862006
Le TigreLe TigrePat Long
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832006
De La SoulArt Official Intelligence: Mosaic Thumpnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5732006
The Divine ComedyCasanovaAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842006
Quicksilver Messenger ServiceShady GroveAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5512005
Emmylou HarrisBrand New DanceMichele Kirsch
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5702005
Ice-TO.G. Original GangsterAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5822005
The Afghan WhigsGentlemenAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832005
RideGoing Blank AgainDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832005
The Soft BoysUnderwater MoonlightAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5932005
CornershopWhen I Was Born for the 7th TimeIan Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5842005
Wilson PhillipsWilson PhillipsGlenn Rice
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5542005
Mercury RevYerself Is SteamGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832005
Teenage FanclubHowdy!not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5762005
The OrbThe Orb’s Adventures Beyond the UltraworldRussell Brown
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5832005
The UndertonesThe UndertonesElaine Cusack
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5872005
SugarFile Under: Easy ListeningClark Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5812005
The Modern LoversThe Modern LoversDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5992005
Teenage FanclubA Catholic EducationLeo Finlay
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5642005
Sleater-KinneyCall the Doctornot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5822005
Galaxie 500This Is Our MusicAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5792005
RattDetonatorChris Marlowe
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5672005
The ReplacementsAll Shook DownGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5672005
Jurassic 5Jurassic 5Gareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5852005
Gary NumanPurenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5462005
The OrbU.F.OrbAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5852005
The Jesus and Mary ChainAutomaticSarra Manning
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5732005
The Jesus and Mary ChainDarklandsSarra Manning
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
Asian Dub FoundationCommunity MusicIan Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5852005
The CharlatansBetween 10th and 11thnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5652005
Richard ThompsonRumor and SighAndrew Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
The CharlatansSome Friendlynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5692005
The CharlatansUp to Our Hipsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5642005
The CharlatansUs and Us Onlynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5752005
Richie HawtinMusikAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832005
Paul WellerWild WoodAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5872005
Simply RedStarsGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5692005
The FallThe Infotainment ScanAndrew Collins
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5812005
The WaterboysRoom to RoamClodagh O'Connell
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5712005
Dimitri from ParisSacrebleuEmma Warren
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
The Dandy WarholsDandys Rule OKRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5452005
Soft CellNon-Stop Erotic CabaretDanny Scott
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
Killing JokePandemoniumClark Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5672005
Chris IsaakChris IsaakSue Smith
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5662005
Dexys Midnight RunnersDon’t Stand Me DownAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5902005
Living ColourTime’s UpMark Putterford
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
Spinal TapThis Is Spinal TapDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5762005
BushRazorblade SuitcaseEddy Lawrence
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5472005
Super Furry AnimalsMwngToby Manning
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5772005
Johnny ThundersSo AloneAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832005
Will OldhamArise ThereforeAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792005
Will OldhamThere Is No-One What Will Take Care of YouAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5812005
David BowieHoursJohn Mullen
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5592005
StereolabMars Audiac QuintetRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792005
The Jesus and Mary ChainHoney’s DeadAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5822005
Saint EtienneFoxbase AlphaDan Maier
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5812005
Saint EtienneSo ToughAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5802005
Saint EtienneSound of WaterGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5772005
Dexys Midnight RunnersSearching for the Young Soul RebelsToby Manning
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5902005
SlintTweezAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5602005
Deee-LiteWorld CliqueRichard Norris
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5802005
Big BlackSongs About FuckingAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832005
The La'sThe La’sAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5872005
Skunk AnansieParanoid and SunburntRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5692005
Sonic YouthThe Whitey AlbumRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5692005
Dinosaur Jr.Green MindGraham Linehan
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
EelsElectro-Shock BluesSteve Lowe
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792005
Ultramagnetic MCsCritical BeatdownAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5902005
The RutsThe CrackMark Prendergast
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5882005
Tin MachineTin Machine IIDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5392005
Thug LifeThug Life, Volume Inot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5712005
Mazzy StarAmong My SwanAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5632005
Mazzy StarShe Hangs BrightlyDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5812005
Stereo MCsConnectedAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5772005
OrbitalOrbital 2Andrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
Killing JokeWhat’s THIS For…!Neil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5742005
ElectronicElectronicAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5762005
XTCNonsuchAndrew Harrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782005
EelsBeautiful FreakEddy Lawrence
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5782005
Dinosaur Jr.Where You BeenAndrew Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5822005
Big BlackAtomizerAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832005
Richard AshcroftAlone with Everybodynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5612005
Mother Love BoneAppleClodagh O'Connell
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 2/5652005
Hüsker DüCandy Apple GreyDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5802005
Will OldhamPalace BrothersDave Morrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792005
The LemonheadsCome On Feel The LemonheadsDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5732005
Built to SpillKeep It Like a SecretRoy Wilkinson
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5792005
Chris IsaakHeart Shaped WorldSue Smith
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5752005
INXSXMark Putterford
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 1/5632005
KittieSpitnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5662005
Killing JokeNight TimeNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5752005
DovesLost SoulsGareth Grundy
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782005
Thee Silver Mt. ZionHe Has Left Us Alone but Shafts of Light Sometimes Grace the Corner of Our Rooms…John Mullen
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5832005
MorrisseySouthpaw GrammarMark Morris
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5632005
Super Furry AnimalsGuerrillaToby Manning
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5772005
Massive AttackProtectionMatt Hall
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5822005
Sly and the Family StoneSly and the Family Stone – Greatest HitsDavid Cavanagh
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5902005
JamiroquaiThe Return of the Space CowboyMatt Hall
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5732005
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadMadonnaNeil Davenport
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5802005
Crowded HouseWoodfaceMichele Kirsch
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5712005
Killing JokeKilling JokeNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5902005
Bolt Thrower…For VictoryDave Morrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5632005
Bolt ThrowerThe IVth CrusadeJeremy Clarke
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5722005
Elvis Costello & the AttractionsGet Happy!!Clark Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5902004
Elvis Costello & the AttractionsTrustClark Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5892004
The BreedersPodnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5762004
JamesLaidnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5792004
PoisonFlesh & BloodPaul Sexton
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5622004
The Black CrowesThe Southern Harmony and Musical CompanionAndrew Collis
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5832004
The Beta BandThe Beta BandJohn Harris
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5722004
Cibo MattoViva! La WomanAndrew Male
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5812004
Milla JovovichThe Divine ComedyTim Marsh
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5712004
Aphex TwinSurfing on Sine WavesRupert Howe
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5802004
En VogueFunky DivasAdam Higginbotham
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5722004
Screaming TreesSweet OblivionAndrew Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 5/5802004
StereolabTransient Random-Noise Bursts with AnnouncementsDave Morrison
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 3/5812004
Iggy PopBrick by BrickNeil Perry
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 4/5782004

All outlets · All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home