Stuart Maconie

Stuart Maconie

Stuart Maconie’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 55 reviews, going back to 1990, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Photo: Bryan Ledgard from Yorkshire, UK, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia CommonsSend us your own photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

  • Q 1993–2011 · 30 reviews
  • Select 1993–2006 · 14 reviews
  • NME 1990–2006 · 10 reviews
  • Blender 2002 · 1 review

What they review

  • Pop 36%
  • Rock 31%
  • Indie & Alternative 20%
  • Electronic 7%

Find Stuart Maconie

By the numbers

5A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
7albums given a perfect score
22years of their reviews we track, 1990 to 2011
How their scores spread
  • 0–4910
  • 50s1
  • 60s8
  • 70s0
  • 80s28
  • 90+8

Their favorites

  1. The Blue NilePeace at Last 100 Q
  2. Joy DivisionUnknown Pleasures 100 Select
  3. Joy DivisionCloser 100 Select
  4. Black FrancisFrank Black 100 Select
  5. New OrderLow-Life 100 Q

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

5 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 5 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Joni MitchellTaming the TigerQ via Wikipedia80 4/5692011
Samantha FoxI Wanna Have Some FunNME via Wikipedia30 3/10302006
Elvis CostelloThe Juliet LettersNME via Wikipedia80 8/10672006
Prefab SproutSwoonSelect via Wikipedia80 4/5752006
The Blue NilePeace at LastQ via Wikipedia100 5/5652006
LowSecret NameQ via Wikipedia80 4/5782006
Wham!FantasticQ via Wikipedia60 3/5582005
The Jesus and Mary ChainHoney’s DeadNME via Wikipedia90 9/10822005
UnklePsyence FictionQ via Wikipedia80 4/5812005
PrinceEmancipationQ via Wikipedia80 4/5762005
Tracy ChapmanMatters of the HeartNME via Wikipedia30 3/10492004
ElasticaElasticaQ via Wikipedia80 4/5862004
Joy DivisionUnknown PleasuresSelect via Wikipedia100 5/5952003
OasisDefinitely MaybeQ via Wikipedia80 4/5922002
ColdplayA Rush of Blood to the HeadBlender via Wikipedia80 4/5812002
MarillionAnoraknophobiaQ via Wikipedia40 2/5652001
DidoNo AngelQ via Wikipedia60 3/5642001
Lou ReedEcstasyQ via Wikipedia40 2/5652000
RadioheadKid AQ via Wikipedia60 3/5812000
LambchopNixonQ via Wikipedia80 4/5842000
Primal ScreamXTRMNTRQ via Wikipedia80 4/5822000
MadonnaRay of LightQ via Wikipedia80 4/5811999
XTCApple Venus Volume 1Q via Wikipedia80 4/5801999
Wham!Make It BigQ via Wikipedia80 4/5731999
JamiroquaiSynkronizedQ via Wikipedia80 4/5661999
Ace of BaseFlowersQ via Wikipedia40 2/5471998
The Divine ComedyA Short Album About LoveQ via Wikipedia80 4/5751997
My Bloody ValentineIsn’t AnythingQ via Wikipedia80 4/5861996
Elvis CostelloBrutal YouthQ via Wikipedia80 4/5721994
SuedeDog Man StarSelect via Wikipedia80 4/5821994
R.E.M.MonsterQ via Wikipedia60 3/5831994
BlurParklifeQ via Wikipedia80 4/5901994
OrbitalSnivilisationSelect via Wikipedia80 4/5791994
Saint EtienneTiger BaySelect via Wikipedia80 4/5761994
New OrderBrotherhoodQ via Wikipedia60 3/5821993
Joy DivisionCloserSelect via Wikipedia100 5/5991993
Billy IdolCyberpunkSelect via Wikipedia20 1/5391993
JamiroquaiEmergency on Planet EarthSelect via Wikipedia80 4/5731993
Black FrancisFrank BlackSelect via Wikipedia100 5/5761993
Manic Street PreachersGold Against the SoulSelect via Wikipedia80 4/5731993
Janet JacksonJanet.Select via Wikipedia60 3/5721993
New OrderLow-LifeQ via Wikipedia100 5/5901993
New OrderPower, Corruption & LiesQ via Wikipedia80 4/5871993
SuedeSuedeQ via Wikipedia80 4/5851993
New OrderTechniqueQ via Wikipedia100 5/5831993
Van MorrisonToo Long in ExileSelect via Wikipedia40 2/5651993
Pet Shop BoysVerySelect via Wikipedia100 5/5871993
Agnetha FältskogWrap Your Arms Around MeSelect via Wikipedia20 1/5501993
Peter GabrielUsNME via Wikipedia50 5/10701992
Dire StraitsOn Every StreetNME via Wikipedia60 6/10541992
GenesisWe Can’t DanceNME via Wikipedia10 1/10521991
Rick AstleyFreeNME via Wikipedia30 3/10401991
The La'sThe La’sNME via Wikipedia80 8/10871990
George MichaelListen Without Prejudice Vol. 1NME via Wikipedia60 6/10751990
Sigur RósÁgætis byrjunQ via Wikipedia80 4/582

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home