Jonathan Keefe

Jonathan Keefe’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 244 reviews, going back to 2005, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

  • Slant 2005–2023 · 244 reviews

What they review

  • Folk, Country & Americana 36%
  • Indie & Alternative 24%
  • Pop 16%
  • Rock 16%

Find Jonathan Keefe

By the numbers

1A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
5albums given a perfect score
19years of their reviews we track, 2005 to 2023
How their scores spread
  • 0–4939
  • 50s39
  • 60s46
  • 70s65
  • 80s36
  • 90+19

Their favorites

  1. Animal CollectiveMerriweather Post Pavilion 100 Slant
  2. Willie NelsonStardust 100 Slant
  3. PJ HarveyWhite Chalk 100 Slant
  4. Miranda LambertCrazy Ex-Girlfriend 100 Slant
  5. Sufjan StevensIllinois 100 Slant

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

1 album that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 1 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Taylor SwiftSpeak Now (Taylor’s Version)Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5772023
Taylor SwiftFearless“The maturity and control of the singer’s voice re-contexualizes the songs from the original album.”Slant60 3/5712021
The ChicksGaslighter“The band’s first album in 14 years is steeped in personal and political rage.”Slant80 4/5812020
Ashley MonroeLike a Rose“Monroe knows that there’s a story behind every scar, and Like a Rose proves her to be a skilled, versatile storyteller.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5862013
SoundgardenKing Animal“King Animal doesn’t contain any standout tracks that justify Soundgarden’s comeback.”Slant60 3/5712012
Phillip PhillipsThe World from the Side of the Moon“The World from the Side of the Moon often plays like Mumford & Sons’ Babel with training wheels.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5572012
Green Day¡Dos!“The best tracks on ¡Dos! embrace a hedonistic spirit.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5662012
Robbie WilliamsTake the Crown“Take the Crown might stand as a stronger “comeback” statement if more of its tracks came across as a bit less desperate to be loved.”Slant50 2.5/5602012
Jamey JohnsonLiving for a Song: A Tribute to Hank Cochran“Living for a Song allows Johnson to challenge himself artistically even as he pays tribute to a dear friend.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5792012
Beth OrtonSugaring Season“Sugaring Season features some of the strongest songs of Orton’s career.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5732012
Meshell NdegeocelloPour une Âme Souveraine: A Dedication to Nina Simone“The album honors what’s made Simone such an enduring icon.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5702012
Tori AmosGold Dust“Tori Amos's 'Gold Dust' has the feel of a concert album, and is thus inessential to everyone but her die-hard fans.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5672012
Mumford & SonsBabel“Much like Sigh No More before it, Babel is just too serious.”Slant50 2.5/5612012
Band of HorsesMirage Rock“Even when Ben Bridwell threatens to get a little too AAA and formal, Mirage Rock is never less than pleasant.”Slant70 3.5/5602012
The RaveonettesObservator“They’ve left Hot Topic, but they don’t seem to know where they’re headed next.”Slant50 2.5/5632012
Alanis MorissetteHavoc and Bright Lights“Morissette’s trademark songwriting idiosyncrasies are very deliberately scaled back on Havoc and Bright Lights.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5542012
Joss StoneThe Soul Sessions Vol. 2“What carries the album are Stone’s performances, which highlight her development into a singer of real grit and depth.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5622012
Old Crow Medicine ShowOld Crow Medicine Show“On Carry Me Back, Old Crow Medicine Show rediscovers the mojo they lost on 2008’s dour, self-serious Tennessee Pusher.”Slant80 4/5672012
Zac Brown BandUncaged“Zac Brown Band’s third major-label album, Uncaged, has very little to do with country music in any meaningful sense.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5762012
JapandroidsCelebration Rock“Celebration Rock finds a band that had previously claimed they “just wanna worry about those sunshine girls” with a few bigger ideas on their minds.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5832012
Josh TurnerPunching Bag“Turner settles back into a comfortable and familiar style that balances traditional country conventions with slickly modern recording techniques.”Slant50 2.5/5552012
Scissor SistersMagic Hour“If there’s one thing Scissor Sisters have never wanted for, it’s a distinct voice.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5632012
Scissor SistersScissor Sisters“If there’s one thing Scissor Sisters have never wanted for, it’s a distinct voice.”Slant50 2.5/5752012
Regina SpektorWhat We Saw from the Cheap Seats“Beneath the yelps, gasps, and exaggerated accents, Regina Spektor is a romantic.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5752012
GarbageNot Your Kind of People“The album adheres so doggedly to formula that it often sounds dated.”Slant60 3/5642012
Willie NelsonHeroesSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672012
Adam LambertTrespassingSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5692012
KeaneStrangeland“The hollowness of Strangeland’s I’m-okay-you’re-okay writing might be a more forgivable offense were the album’s production not so consistently garish.”Slant20 1/5532012
Norah JonesLittle Broken Hearts“Jones is usually at her best when she looks to the past for inspiration.”Slant70 3.5/5742012
Carrie UnderwoodBlown Away“Underwood rises to the occasion when given the opportunity to tackle multifaceted, well-written material.”Slant60 3/5572012
Alabama ShakesBoys & Girls“Boys & Girls is curiously and deliberately subdued.”Slant60 3/5752012
MonicaNew Life“Monica’s on-point vocal turns are squandered on some cliché-addled songs and embarrassingly cheap-sounding production.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5522012
various artistsThe Hunger Games: Songs from District 12 and BeyondSlant via Wikipedia80 4/5712012
Esperanza SpaldingEsperanza“Radio Music Society makes it clear that Spalding’s a fine, intuitive singer and a natural bandleader.”Slant60 3/5692012
Esperanza SpaldingRadio Music Society“Radio Music Society makes it clear that Spalding’s a fine, intuitive singer and a natural bandleader.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5672012
The PiercesYou & I“While You & I loses some of the distinctive details of its predecessor, the duo pulls off “conventional” just as well as they do twisted.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5642012
The Ting TingsSounds from Nowheresville“The Ting Tings give the impression that they’ve set out to fail deliberately, as some kind of juvenile attempt at punk.”Slant20 1/5502012
Sinéad O'ConnorHow About I Be Me (And You Be You)?“The inconsistencies in the quality of the singer's songwriting keep the set from being as powerful as her earlier work.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5712012
Tim McGrawEmotional Traffic“Emotional Traffic only works in its moments of restraint and relative good taste, and those are exceedingly rare.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5592012
Kellie PicklerKellie Pickler“What impresses most about 100 Proof is the extent to which it capitalizes on Pickler’s relative strengths as a performer.”Slant70 3.5/5642012
Kathleen EdwardsVoyageur“The persona Edwards creates over the course of the album is consistently hamstrung by doubt and hesitation.”Slant70 3.5/5712012
Ani DiFranco¿Which Side Are You On?“Because so many of her political songs miss their marks, it’s a good thing DiFranco comes up with a couple of genuinely moving love songs.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5672012
The Little WilliesFor the Good Times“If the song selection wants for inspiration, the Little Willies’s performances never do.”Slant70 3.5/5772012
The Black KeysEl Camino“The Black Keys have replaced their sometimes insular focus on blues formalism with an emphasis on pop hooks.”Slant80 4/5812011
DaughtryBreak the Spell“Daughtry’s third album reaffirms that the band is defined by competence rather than ambition or creativity.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5572011
Pistol AnniesHell on Heels“Whereas many side projects ultimately amount to little more than artistically inert, self-indulgent one-offs, Miranda Lambert’s Pistol Annies is true to her reputation of defying expectations.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5792011
Meshell NdegeocelloWeather“em>Weather is such a heady album because of how unflinchingly Ndegeocello has turned her keen observational eyes toward herself.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5822011
Miranda LambertFour the RecordSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762011
Toby KeithClancy’s Tavern“Clancy’s Tavern is a fairly rote reiteration of the same album that Toby Keith has been re-recording once a year since 2005.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5752011
Vince GillGuitar Slinger“Guitar Slinger makes up for its lack of focus with some truly inspired songwriting and performances.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762011
ColdplayMylo Xyloto“Coldplay’s Mylo Xyloto perpetuates at least some of the progressive influence that Brian Eno brought to their last album.”Slant60 3/5632011
Kelly ClarksonStrongerSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5582011
Joe JonasFastlife“At least Jonas and his team had the smarts to enlist producers who know how to construct solid pop songs.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5612011
Ryan AdamsAshes & Fire“Ryan Adams goes full-on into sensitive troubadour mode on Ashes & Fire.”Slant50 2.5/5762011
FeistMetals“However gorgeous and warm the singer's voice may be, Feist's 'Metals' is just too dull for her to overcome.”Slant60 3/5762011
Seth MacFarlaneMusic Is Better Than Words“Sincerity marks a refreshing change of pace for MacFarlane.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5502011
LeAnn RimesLady & Gentlemen“Lady & Gentlemen finds the singer taking real risks and making better music than many of her contemporaries.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5702011
LeAnn RimesLeAnn Rimes“Lady & Gentlemen finds the singer taking real risks and making better music than many of her contemporaries.”Slant70 3.5/5682011
Blink-182NeighborhoodsSlant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5642011
The BanglesSweetheart of the Sun“If there’s a knock on Sweetheart of the Sun, it’s in the individual lead vocals.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5672011
Tori AmosNight of Hunters“The more direct songs on Tori Amos's 'Night of Hunters' transcend the trappings of the album’s rigid construct.”Slant60 3/5722011
Lady AOwn the NightSlant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5572011
Hank Williams IIIAttention Deficit Domination“The album never sounds like the work of a proper band, since there’s no actual interplay between any of the instrumental performances.”Slant50 2.5/5632011
George StraitHere for a Good Time“Here for a Good Time is both a good time and a new peak for Strait.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752011
Fountains of WayneFountains of Wayne“Ultimately, it’s a matter of aesthetic choices that just don’t play to Fountains of Wayne’s considerable strengths.”Slant60 3/5752011
Fountains of WayneSky Full of Holes“Ultimately, it’s a matter of aesthetic choices that just don’t play to Fountains of Wayne’s considerable strengths.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5752011
Blake SheltonRed River Blue“Red River Blue proves that Blake Shelton is a capable singer who chooses to sing some lackluster songs.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5652011
Brad PaisleyThis Is Country Music“This Is Country Music plays out as a survey course, both in form and content.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5802011
Stevie NicksIn Your Dreams“A new solo album from rock legend and beloved quasi-mystical figure Stevie Nicks should be cause for celebration.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5692011
Emmylou HarrisHard BargainSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5722011
Steve EarleI’ll Never Get Out of This World Alive“Steve Earle has worked hard to perfect his image as one of Nashville’s true outsiders.”Slant70 3.5/5772011
Jason Isbell and the 400 UnitHere We Rest“The album loses entirely too many of the elements that made the singer-songwriter such a singular Southern artist.”Slant50 2.5/5682011
Alison KraussPaper Airplane“Alison Krauss & Union Station’s 'Paper Airplane' doesn’t offer an 'in' for the unconverted.”Slant60 3/5702011
R.E.M.Collapse into Now“Considering how its style draws from each era of R.E.M.’s evolution, Collapse Into Now plays as something of a greatest-hits package.”Slant50 2.5/5702011
Avril LavigneGoodbye Lullaby“It’s ultimately on Lavigne’s slight shoulders that Goodbye Lullaby is such a strident, ineffectual attempt at a serious pop record.”Slant50 2.5/5542011
Lucinda WilliamsBlessed“Blessed finds Lucinda Williams remembering that she’s supposed to be one of America’s greatest songwriters.”Slant60 3/5782011
Drive-By TruckersGo-Go Boots“Go-Go Boots suggests that one of America’s finest rock bands is in a full-on slump.”Slant40 2/5742011
the JaneDear girlsThe JaneDear girls“Another week, another shrill country duo making a horrible first impression.”Slant20 1/5502011
The DecemberistsThe King Is Dead“To the Decemberists’s credit, they’re committed to the idea of challenging themselves.”Slant70 3.5/5762011
Natasha BedingfieldStrip Me“It may not be the year’s worst pop album, but Strip Me might just be the most exhausting and heavy-handed.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5552010
RobynBody Talk“Robyn’s Body Talk is one of the year’s finest, most progressive pop albums, but it’s also something of a minor letdown as a standalone project.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5842010
Keith UrbanGet CloserSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5722010
Taylor SwiftSpeak NowSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5732010
SugarlandThe Incredible Machine“The Incredible Machine stands to be a transitional album for Sugarland.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5552010
Darius RuckerCharleston, SC 1966“It’s hard to imagine that Charleston, SC 1966 won’t continue Rucker’s hot streak within the country genre.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5672010
Pete YornPete Yorn“It’s hard to think of Pete Yorn as the start of a new direction for Yorn.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5602010
KT TunstallTiger Suit“When given the opportunity, Tunstall manages to showcase that she’s actually a damn fine singer.”Slant40 2/5722010
Jimmy Eat WorldInvented“On Invented, Jimmy Eat World, now 16 years into their career, sounds like they’ve started to outgrow emo.”Slant50 2.5/5602010
Zac Brown BandYou Get What You GiveSlant via Wikipedia80 4/5792010
Brandon FlowersFlamingo“Flamingo makes a pretty strong case that Flowers doesn’t have the best grasp of what it is he does well.”Slant50 2.5/5572010
Fantasia BarrinoBack to MeSlant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5622010
John MellencampJohn Mellencamp“No Better Than This works as well as it does because it plays to Mellencamp’s strengths.”Slant70 3.5/5692010
Sheryl Crow100 Miles from Memphis“100 Miles from Memphis' proves that Sheryl Crow may have an affinity for Southern soul, but she doesn’t necessarily have an aptitude for it.”Slant50 2.5/5652010
Scissor SistersNight Work“By matching their sound so adriotly to the content of their songs, Scissor Sisters makes Night Work an album of real structural sophistication.”Slant80 4/5682010
Cyndi LauperMemphis Blues“Memphis Blues is a disappointment because it doesn’t play to Lauper’s considerable strengths.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5492010
SiaWe Are BornSlant via Wikipedia80 4/5742010
Sarah McLachlanLaws of Illusion“The album is never less than beautiful and perfectly performed, but most of it is the recorded equivalent of Lunesta.”Slant40 2/5612010
Dierks BentleyUp on the Ridge“Up on the Ridge is an example of what modern country music ought to sound like.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5782010
HansonShout It Out“Other than the trio’s weakness for trite turns of phrase, the major flaw on Shout It Out is its spit-polished production.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5602010
The FutureheadsThe Futureheads“The Futureheads demonstrate meaningful growth on The Chaos.”Slant70 3.5/5802010
Merle HaggardI Am What I Am“I Am What I Am an honest reflection of who Merle Haggard has become in his twilight years.”Slant60 3/5792010
Willie NelsonCountry Music“That Nelson is in especially fine vocal form only heightens the impression that the album was recorded decades ago.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5782010
Kate NashMy Best Friend Is You“Kate Nash’s sophomore effort proves that she’s still the best of the lot when it comes to balancing her pop hooks with a compelling persona.”Slant60 3/5632010
Mindy McCreadyI’m Still Here“McCready is going to have to exercise better taste in material if she wants to make a full-fledged comeback.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5562010
Mindy McCreadyMindy McCready“McCready is going to have to exercise better taste in material if she wants to make a full-fledged comeback.”Slant50 2.5/5542010
The KnifeTomorrow, in a Year“The question that hangs over the project is whether or not it works on a level other than that of a clinical academic remove.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752010
AthleteBlack Swan“As with most of those serial dramas, Black Swan adheres to a predictable formula and familiar emotional terrain.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5432010
Josh TurnerHaywire“Josh Turner has struggled to this point in his career to find material that is equally as distinctive.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5642010
Lady ANeed You Now“Someone forgot to tell country trio Lady Antebellum that “sophomore slumps” are now gauche.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5632010
KeshaAnimal“Just about the only thing Ke$ha makes convincing on Animal is that the current crop of party girls are every bit as soulless as they let on.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5612010
Mary J. BligeStronger with Each Tear“Blige, as always, does her damnedest to sell every clichéd platitude and mixed metaphor.”Slant50 2.5/5652009
John MayerBattle StudiesSlant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5592009
Kris AllenKris Allen“This is exactly the kind of pleasant and ultimately forgettable album that most of Kris Allen’s Idol performances predicted he would make.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5482009
Robbie WilliamsReality Killed the Video Star“The album arrives stateside unburdened by any expectations for an artistic or commercial rebound.”Slant50 2.5/5602009
Norah JonesThe Fall“The album is about as edgy as recent albums by Aimee Mann and Rosanne Cash.”Slant60 3/5652009
AmerieIn Love & War“In Love & War is deserving of greater commercial impact than it is likely to earn.”Slant70 3.5/5702009
Carrie UnderwoodPlay OnSlant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5562009
Toby KeithAmerican RideSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5632009
The Flaming LipsEmbryonic“Even when the band pulls back for one of their quirky love songs, it’s something of a disaster.”Slant50 2.5/5732009
Backstreet BoysThis Is Us“On paper, Backstreet Boys enlisted all of the right people for the third album of their thus-far ineffectual comeback.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5562009
Miranda LambertRevolutionSlant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5802009
MikaThe Boy Who Knew Too Much“However talented Mika may be, he’s going to burn out fast unless he learns how to rein in some of his more repellant instincts.”Slant30 1.5/5682009
Willie NelsonAmerican Classic“American Classic finds Nelson sounding as soulful and youthful as he has in years.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5642009
George StraitTwangSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5742009
The Dead WeatherHorehound“Horehound establishes the Dead Weather as a fully realized band with a sufficiently distinctive point of view.”Slant70 3.5/5742009
Brad PaisleyAmerican Saturday Night“American Saturday Night stands as perhaps the most consistent set of material Paisley has committed to record.”Slant80 4/5832009
Jonas BrothersLines, Vines and Trying Times“The album suggests that the Jonas Brothers simply don’t have the chops to make it once the current teen-pop bubble bursts.”Slant40 2/5492009
Mandy MooreAmanda Leigh“Moore’s good taste has finally translated into a mature and, yes, credible album that stands on its own merits.”Slant70 3.5/5702009
Tori AmosAbnormally Attracted to Sin“Tori Amos's 'Abnormally Attracted to Sin' emerges as a thoughtful, dense exploration of matters of faith, sanctimony, and vice.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5642009
PJ HarveyA Woman a Man Walked By“The album illustrates how deeply two long-time collaborators understand each other’s creative restlessness and their flair for the dramatic.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762009
Keith UrbanDefying GravitySlant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5612009
Gavin DeGrawFree“The album may not have any standout hooks to give him another inescapable radio hit, but it does suggest that DeGraw has finally found a style that suits him well.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5632009
Gavin DeGrawGavin DeGraw“The album may not have any standout hooks to give him another inescapable radio hit, but it does suggest that DeGraw has finally found a style that suits him well.”Slant60 3/5542009
Martina McBrideShine“The restraint that McBride shows in both her vocal performances and her song selection are a refreshing change of pace.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5612009
Neko CaseMiddle Cyclone“As Neko Case’s brand of macabre, modern American gothic music has become more obtuse and difficult, she’s only seen her popularity expand.”Slant80 4/5802009
Kelly ClarksonAll I Ever Wanted“That nearly every song has a point of comparison that exists outside of the album’s context itself makes for a scattershot, confused listen.”Slant60 3/5652009
Jason Isbell and the 400 UnitJason Isbell and The 400 Unit“The album is one of tremendous sadness.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5812009
Dan AuerbachKeep It Hid“The musician incorporates a variety of distinct influences, from smooth Memphis soul to heavily distorted psychedelia.”Slant70 3.5/5762009
Melinda DoolittleComing Back to You“On the whole, Mangini’s production choices successfully recreate an old-school R&B vibe.”Slant70 3.5/5732009
Franz FerdinandTonight: Franz Ferdinand“If not boasting the most sophisticated of concepts, the record does have an overarching narrative about seemingly endless nights spent out on the club circuit.”Slant70 3.5/5672009
Animal CollectiveMerriweather Post Pavilion“Animal Collective's 'Merriweather Post Pavilion' finds the band finally and gloriously figuring it all out.”Slant100 5/5882009
The FiremanElectric Arguments“The album impresses most for its lack of inhibitions.”Slant80 4/5722008
Brad PaisleyPlaySlant via Wikipedia80 4/5682008
PinkFunhouse“As divorce albums go, no one will mistake Funhouse as a Blood on the Tracks-style emotional bloodletting.”Slant70 3.5/5672008
Kenny ChesneyLucky Old Sun“Albums about breakups don’t have to be downers.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5502008
Hank Williams IIIDamn Right, Rebel Proud“It reaffirms that it’s far more than just his name that makes Williams one of the genre’s most vital artists.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5772008
Lee Ann WomackLee Ann Womack“Acclaimed vocalist Lee Ann Womack’s seventh studio album, Call Me Crazy, is aptly named.”Slant70 3.5/5732008
of MontrealSkeletal Lamping“On Skeletal Lamping, Kevin Barnes offers something of a treatise on modern sexual politics.”Slant80 4/5732008
KeanePerfect Symmetry“Perfect Symmetry is an album characterized by its heavy-handedness.”Slant50 2.5/5572008
Darius RuckerLearn to Live“Darius Rucker’s Learn to Live makes a concerted effort to sound like a modern country album.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5572008
Willie NelsonStardust“Nelson is capable of taking unexpected material and tailoring it to his strengths as a performer and interpreter.”Slant100 5/5962008
The Dandy Warhols…Earth to the Dandy Warhols…“The sheer quality of the Dandy Warhols’s songcraft on Earth goes a long way toward earning them a measure of goodwill.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5432008
Jonas BrothersA Little Bit Longer“A Little Bit Longer is hard to envision as an album that will allow the Jonas Brothers to transcend their place in this teen-pop cycle.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5612008
SugarlandLove on the InsideSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5762008
Jamey JohnsonThat Lonesome Song“That Lonesome Song is one of the best, purest country albums to come out of Nashville in ages.”Slant80 4/5852008
CSSDonkey“CSS’s sophomore effort, Donkey, is one of the year’s biggest disappointments.”Slant40 2/5572008
ColdplayViva la Vida or Death and All His Friends“The album’s supposed revolutionary approach to Coldplay’s trademark sadrock has been greatly exaggerated.”Slant70 3.5/5762008
JewelPerfectly ClearSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5662008
Cyndi LauperBring Ya to the Brink“Bring Ya to the Brink recaptures Lauper’s artistic relevance and stands as a hipper alternative to Madonna’s Hard Candy.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5682008
Neil DiamondHome Before Dark“The album works as a full-fledged commercial comeback but also continues the artistic resurgence started by its predecessor.”Slant70 3.5/5662008
DuffyRockferry“Rockferry is a pretty nifty party trick of a record, but it’s not enough to justify Duffy’s Next Big Thing billing.”Slant60 3/5712008
Lady ALady AntebellumSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5702008
R.E.M.Accelerate“The album certainly sounds like a deliberate attempt at a comeback.”Slant70 3.5/5772008
Ashton ShepherdSounds So Good“Sounds So Good is an unapologetically country country album.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752008
Kathleen EdwardsAsking for Flowers“Kathleen Edwards’s pen is at its sharpest on her third album.”Slant70 3.5/5782008
Alan JacksonGood TimeSlant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5662008
The RaveonettesLust Lust Lust“These songs don’t sound like love songs because they aren’t love songs.”Slant90 4.5/5792008
Kula ShakerStrangefolk“Strange Folk should play well to the diehards who remain from Kula Shaker’s once-sizable fanbase.”Slant60 3/5422008
Nada SurfLucky“What works so well about Lucky is the interplay between the band’s buoyant arrangements and lyrics that reflect a pronounced anxiety.”Slant80 4/5772008
Aesop RockNone Shall Pass“Aesop’s indomitable presence and knotty co-production make what he says incidental to how he says it.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5782007
Panda BearPerson Pitch“Panda Bear, everyone’s favorite endangered species and Animal Collectivist, masters problems of scope on Person Pitch.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5832007
EaglesLong Road Out of EdenSlant via Wikipedia40 2/5532007
The HivesThe Black and White Album“Black and White finds the Hives making their first real effort toward diversifying their sound.”Slant70 3.5/5742007
Trisha YearwoodTrisha Yearwood“Heaven, Heartache, and the Power of Love is an album characterized by significant departures for Trisha Yearwood.”Slant90 4.5/5822007
Carrie UnderwoodCarnival Ride“Carnival Ride simply doesn’t offer anything for the unconverted in terms of Underwood’s growth either as a vocalist or as an artist.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5672007
Jimmy Eat WorldChase This Light“Chase This Light is also a return to form for the band in terms of their ingratiating power-pop.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5682007
PJ HarveyWhite Chalk“Harvey’s eighth studio album is a triumph of both micro- and macro-level structure.”Slant100 5/5762007
KT TunstallDrastic Fantastic“The only thing working against Drastic Fantastic, really, is its lame title.”Slant70 3.5/5732007
The New PornographersChallengers“Challengers speaks to the real breadth of the New Pornographers’s skill with all manners of pop styles.”Slant80 4/5692007
M.I.A.Kala“Kala seems aware of the potential of pop and hip-hop to empower those who have been denied a voice.”Slant70 3.5/5812007
The White StripesIcky Thump“It almost entirely ignores what it is that gives the duo its claim as perhaps the greatest rock act of its generation.”Slant70 3.5/5812007
Gretchen WilsonOne of the Boys“With a few exceptions, Gretchen Wilson’s One of the Boys doesn’t go out of its way to debase women or pander to the neo-con demo.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5642007
Joan OsborneBreakfast in Bed“Both as a writer and a vocalist, Osborne has the chops to record a killer soul album, but this tasteful-to-a-fault effort isn’t it.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5552007
WilcoSky Blue Sky“Even at their most retro, Wilco is among contemporary pop music’s most vital acts.”Slant80 4/5752007
Miranda LambertCrazy Ex-GirlfriendSlant via Wikipedia100 5/5852007
Tori AmosAmerican Doll PosseSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762007
Norah JonesNot Too Late“Norah Jones has given more than just an offhand indication that she’s ready to break out of her Starbucks niche.”Slant70 3.5/5682007
Arcade FireNeon Bible“Its sharp thematic focus draws from the difficult emotions surrounding specific events.”Slant70 3.5/5792007
The ShinsWincing the Night Away“The Shins experiment with their trademark sound without sacrificing any of their peerless melodicism.”Slant80 4/5772007
SugarlandEnjoy the Ride“The punchiness of the album’s sound should allow it to continue Sugarland’s commercial hot streak.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5662006
Keith UrbanLove, Pain & the Whole Crazy Thing“The album flies in the face of most every expectation that it should rank among the year’s best mainstream country offerings.”Slant30 1.5/5602006
Joan OsbornePretty Little StrangerSlant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5712006
Dierks BentleyLong Trip Alone“Long Trip Alone keeps the country genre in another pair of capable hands.”Slant70 3.5/5632006
John MayerContinuum“Continuum just doesn’t convince as a heady, soulful rock album or as Mayer’s creative quantum leap forward.”Slant50 2.5/5672006
Indigo GirlsIndigo Girls“Twenty years and 10 albums into their career, the Indigo Girls are still finding ways to tinker with their trademark formula.”Slant70 3.5/5732006
RatatatClassics“Classics lays down a consistently low-key groove that never draws attention to itself but which sustains a real sense of momentum.”Slant70 3.5/5702006
Ani DiFrancoReprieve“DiFranco takes a relatively stripped-down approach to her ever-insightful meditations on matters both personal and political.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5712006
The KnifeSilent Shout“The album foregrounds the cold-blooded calculation of its technological origin while still capturing emotions that are recognizably, powerfully human.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5812006
CSSCansei de Ser Sexy“Like former blog darlings Annie and M.I.A., CSS doesn’t have an obvious analogue on either the mainstream or indie-pop scenes.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5702006
The ChicksTaking the Long Way“Martyr complexes rarely make for real art.”Slant via Wikipedia10 0.5/5662006
KeaneUnder the Iron Sea“Keane’s Under the Iron Sea is an uncanny impression of U2 and The Bends-era Radiohead.”Slant70 3.5/5652006
Nelly FurtadoLoose“Nelly Furtado’s style-hopping nature makes her a never less-than-interesting artist.”Slant70 3.5/5722006
Joan JettSinner“Sinner finds the rock icon’s trademark sneer turned on the conservative sociopolitical climate.”Slant60 3/5572006
Camera ObscuraLet’s Get Out of This Country“The album finds Camera Obscura stepping out from the considerable shadow cast by Belle and Sebastian.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5762006
The WreckersStand Still, Look Pretty“The album is as “country” as Bon Jovi’s “Who Says You Can’t Go Home” or anything SheDaisy have ever released.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5612006
MatmosThe Rose Has Teeth in the Mouth of a Beast“For all of its insular, inscrutable put-ons, the album remains an endlessly fascinating piece of work.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5802006
Daniel PowterDaniel Powter“The self-titled debut from Daniel Powter sounds exactly the way Maroon 5 would sound were Adam Levine not scoring so much A-list ass.”Slant30 1.5/5542006
Drive-By TruckersA Blessing and a Curse“The album is a return to the band's detail-oriented form.”Slant90 4.5/5752006
CalexicoGarden Ruin“The album seems destined to be regarded as a “transitional” record a few years out.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752006
The VinesVision Valley“The Vines ultimately come off as nothing more than a proficient Nirvana cover band.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5572006
PlaceboMedsSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5622006
Yeah Yeah YeahsShow Your Bones“Yeah Yeah Yeahs have emerged with a second full-length album that, like its predecessor, captures a band unbeholden to anyone’s expectations.”Slant80 4/5762006
Neko CaseFox Confessor Brings the Flood“Case’s latest album continues down a path she first acknowledged on Blacklisted.”Slant90 4.5/5802006
Band of HorsesEverything All the Time“Band of Horses is a fitting addition to the Sup Pop roster.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752006
SparksHello Young Lovers“Both brilliant and frustrating, Hello Young Lovers is the kind of album that, for better or worse, demands a strong reaction.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672006
Kris KristoffersonThis Old Road“Kristofferson’s comeback album takes its cue from the stripped-down aesthetic that’s served so many veteran artists”Slant70 3.5/5662006
MudhoneyUnder a Billion Suns“Under A Billon Suns actively undermines expectations, in the way great modern rock albums are supposed to.”Slant50 2.5/5682006
GossipStanding in the Way of Control“Gossip’s beats propulsive enough to get the sk8er kids to drop the self-conscious posturing and dance a little.”Slant70 3.5/5722006
TrainFor Me, It’s You“The album is pretty good and perhaps even a little bit progressive for Train but still woefully underwhelming by any other measure of quality.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5532006
Belle and SebastianThe Life Pursuit“The Life Pursuit' is not only a career-defining album for Belle and Sebastian, it’s the first essential album of 2006.”Slant90 4.5/5792006
Neil Diamond12 Songs“As strong an album as it is, 12 Songs suggests that the follow-up could be even better.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5802005
Cyndi LauperThe Body Acoustic“What keeps The Body Acoustic from being perhaps as essential as it could have been is the inconsistency of the guest stars.”Slant70 3.5/5652005
Sheryl CrowWildflower“Sheryl Crow remains a strong writer and singer, to the extent that 'Wildflower' earns more than just a passing recommendation.”Slant70 3.5/5582005
Gretchen WilsonAll Jacked Up“Gretchen Wilson’s All Jacked Up sounds like a collection of b-sides and outtakes from last year’s Here For The Party.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5642005
The Dandy WarholsOdditorium or Warlords of Mars“The album illustrates that coming up with an airtight, fascinating thesis can present an unclearable hurdle of its own.”Slant30 1.5/5522005
Sigur RósTakk…“Takk… often sounds like a faithful reproduction of the outsized pop of Radiohead’s The Bends.”Slant80 4/5772005
Nada SurfThe Weight Is a Gift“Nada Surf have handled their newfound expectations for quality output with refreshing confidence.”Slant70 3.5/5652005
The CoralThe Invisible Invasion“The Invisible Invasion is a pleasant enough album that ultimately does nothing to distinguish itself from the efforts of countless other bands.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5682005
The New PornographersTwin Cinema“The individual songs run just a measure or two too long, and at 14 tracks there are simply too many soundalike songs on the album.”Slant80 4/5812005
Brad PaisleyTime Well Wasted“Time Well Wasted at least has the decency to provide an excess of material, both for better and for worse.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5752005
Hootie & the BlowfishLooking for Lucky“The album could give Hootie & the Blowfish the kind of commercial relevance they haven’t had in a decade.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5602005
Nickel CreekNickel Creek“Nickel Creek’s selling point remains their technical gifts and, again, Why Should the Fire Die? showcases a phenomenal learning curve.”Slant80 4/5832005
Nickel CreekWhy Should the Fire Die?“Nickel Creek’s selling point remains their technical gifts and, again, Why Should the Fire Die? showcases a phenomenal learning curve.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5752005
Jason MrazMr. A–Z“Mr. A-Z is too often marred by Jason Mraz’s self-aggrandizing tendencies.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5482005
Faith HillFireflies“Fireflies is less an “album” than a goddamn dissertation on everything rotten at the core of mainstream country music.”Slant via Wikipedia0 0/5472005
Sufjan StevensIllinois“The album is pop-art of the highest caliber, cementing Stevens as one of the most vital voices in music today.”Slant100 5/5882005
Jamie LidellMultiply“If Multiply is all an elaborate, ironic put-on, it’s executed so flawlessly that Lidell’s intentions barely even matter.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5712005
ColdplayX&Y“X&Y promises to make it even easier to resent Coldplay’s success.”Slant60 3/5732005
Little Big TownA Place to Land“The album suggests that Little Big Town is perhaps the only currently popular band in mainstream country worth following.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/578
Jessica SimpsonDo You Know“That Simpson is audibly at least a quarter-pitch sharp on at least half of the album makes a good case for the use of Autotune.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/551
Josh TurnerEverything Is Fine“The album places Turner in the company of mainstream country acts like Brad Paisley, LeAnn Rimes, and Dierks Bentley”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/572
Dierks BentleyFeel That Fire“Having good taste in collaborators and influences doesn’t make up for how often Bentley repeats himself.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/560
Willie NelsonLast of the BreedSlant via Wikipedia80 4/575
JewelSweet and WildSlant via Wikipedia40 2/560

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home