John Mellencamp Albums Ranked

John Mellencamp’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 8 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 65 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is John Mellencamp’s best album?

By the critics, it’s Scarecrow (1985), with a B-Side Breakdown of 85 (Heavy Rotation) from 5 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: Uh-Huh (78) and Cuttin’ Heads (77). Lowest rated: Chestnut Street Incident (28).

John Mellencamp albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Scarecrow (1985): 85 Heavy Rotation
  2. 2. Uh-Huh (1983): 78 Keeper
  3. 3. Cuttin’ Heads (2001): 77 Keeper
  4. 4. John Mellencamp (1998): 69 Mixed Bag
  5. 5. Trouble No More (2003): 61 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. Rough Harvest (1999): 60 Mixed Bag
  7. 7. American Fool (1982): 58 Mixed Bag
  8. 8. Chestnut Street Incident (1976): 28 Back of the Crate

John Mellencamp discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every John Mellencamp album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

1010070likedChestnut Street Incident (1976): 28281976American Fool (1982): 58581982Uh-Huh (1983): 78781983Scarecrow (1985): 85851985John Mellencamp (1998): 69691998Rough Harvest (1999): 60601999Cuttin’ Heads (2001): 77772001Trouble No More (2003): 61612003

Every John Mellencamp studio album, oldest first. 2 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1976Album cover for Chestnut Street Incident by John MellencampChestnut Street Incident28 Back of the Crate
  2. 1979John CougarNo Breakdown yet
  3. 1982Album cover for American Fool by John MellencampAmerican Fool58 Mixed Bag
  4. 1983Album cover for Uh-Huh by John MellencampUh-Huh78 Keeper
  5. 1985Album cover for Scarecrow by John MellencampScarecrow85 Heavy Rotation
  6. 1998Album cover for John Mellencamp by John MellencampJohn Mellencamp69 Mixed Bag
  7. 1999Album cover for Rough Harvest by John MellencampRough Harvest60 Mixed Bag
  8. 2001Album cover for Cuttin’ Heads by John MellencampCuttin’ Heads77 Keeper
  9. 2003Album cover for Trouble No More by John MellencampTrouble No More61 Mixed Bag
  10. 2023Orpheus DescendingNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love John Mellencamp, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 John Mellencamp albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

AllMusic8 albums+4
  1. Chestnut Street Incident 197620 vs 30 from 3 others −10
  2. American Fool 198270 vs 53 from 2 others +18
  3. Uh-Huh 198390 vs 73 from 2 others +18
  4. Scarecrow 198590 vs 84 from 4 others +6
  5. John Mellencamp 199860 vs 72 from 3 others −12
  6. Rough Harvest 199960 vs 60 from 2 others +1
  7. Cuttin’ Heads 200180 vs 76 from 4 others +4
  8. Trouble No More 200370 vs 60 from 6 others +10

All AllMusic reviews

The Rolling Stone Album Guide3 albums+4
  1. Chestnut Street Incident 197640 vs 23 from 3 others +17
  2. Scarecrow 198580 vs 87 from 4 others −7
  3. Rough Harvest 199960 vs 60 from 2 others +1

All The Rolling Stone Album Guide reviews

Entertainment Weekly4 albums+2
  1. John Mellencamp 199865 vs 70 from 3 others −5
  2. Rough Harvest 199959 vs 60 from 2 others −1
  3. Cuttin’ Heads 200175 vs 78 from 4 others −3
  4. Trouble No More 200375 vs 59 from 6 others +16

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

Robert Christgau4 albums−8
  1. American Fool 198265 vs 55 from 2 others +10
  2. Uh-Huh 198365 vs 85 from 2 others −20
  3. Scarecrow 198575 vs 88 from 4 others −13
  4. Trouble No More 200355 vs 63 from 6 others −8

All Robert Christgau reviews

Rolling Stone6 albums−10
  1. Chestnut Street Incident 19760 vs 37 from 3 others −37
  2. American Fool 198240 vs 68 from 2 others −28
  3. Uh-Huh 198380 vs 78 from 2 others +3
  4. John Mellencamp 199880 vs 65 from 3 others +15
  5. Cuttin’ Heads 200170 vs 79 from 4 others −9
  6. Trouble No More 200360 vs 62 from 6 others −2

All Rolling Stone reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home