Melissa Maerz

Melissa Maerz’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 86 reviews, going back to 2004, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 33%
  • Pop 24%
  • Folk, Country & Americana 13%
  • Rock 12%

Find Melissa Maerz

By the numbers

12years of their reviews we track, 2004 to 2015
4outlets their reviews here ran in
64%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (86 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–493
  • 50s13
  • 60s23
  • 70s27
  • 80s14
  • 90+6

Their favorites

  1. Sleater-KinneyNo Cities to Love 93 Entertainment Weekly
  2. Miranda LambertPlatinum 93 Entertainment Weekly
  3. Daft PunkRandom Access Memories 93 Entertainment Weekly
  4. The CureDisintegration 93 Entertainment Weekly
  5. Animal CollectiveFall Be Kind 93 Entertainment Weekly

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Joanna NewsomDiversEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-812015
Lana Del ReyHoneymoonEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+742015
Sleater-KinneyNo Cities to LoveEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia93 A882015
Jennifer LopezA.K.A.Entertainment Weekly via Wikipedia39 D522014
Miranda LambertPlatinumEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia93 A792014
Mariah CareyMe. I Am Mariah… The Elusive ChanteuseEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B662014
PhoenixBankrupt!Entertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+742013
Daft PunkRandom Access MemoriesEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia93 A842013
Yeah Yeah YeahsMosquitoEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-652013
Blake SheltonBased on a True Story…Entertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-712013
The Band PerryPioneerEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B742013
Bruno MarsUnorthodox JukeboxEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-712012
Alicia KeysGirl on FireEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B702012
KeshaWarriorEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B682012
RihannaUnapologeticEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+602012
Christina AguileraLotusEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia47 C-592012
Calvin Harris18 MonthsEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia55 C+572012
Taylor SwiftRedEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+782012
Jamey JohnsonLiving for a Song: A Tribute to Hank CochranEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B792012
Cat PowerSunEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-772012
Mumford & SonsBabelEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-612012
No DoubtPush and ShoveEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+632012
Green Day¡Uno!Entertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B662012
The Gaslight AnthemHandwrittenEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+742012
Flo RidaWild OnesEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia47 C-542012
UsherLooking 4 MyselfEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B712012
John MayerBorn and RaisedEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B662012
Adam LambertTrespassingEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-692012
Willie NelsonLet’s Face the Music and DanceEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B732012
Norah JonesLittle Broken HeartsEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B742012
various artistsThe Hunger Games: Songs from District 12 and BeyondEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B712012
MadonnaMDNAEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-652012
GrimesVisionsEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+792012
The Black KeysEl CaminoEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-812011
Snow PatrolFallen EmpiresEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B532011
NickelbackHere and NowEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia55 C+442011
Boyz II MenTwentyEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B722011
ColdplayMylo XylotoEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia55 C+632011
Kelly ClarksonStrongerEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+582011
Ryan AdamsAshes & FireEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+762011
FeistMetalsEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+762011
WilcoThe Whole LoveEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-782011
Tori AmosNight of HuntersEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B722011
Demi LovatoUnbrokenEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+642011
DuffyEndlesslyEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B572010
RihannaLoudRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5692010
Jazmine SullivanLove Me BackEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+792010
My Chemical RomanceDanger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys“Check out our album review of Artist's Danger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5712010
KelisFlesh ToneEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+752010
Cyndi LauperMemphis BluesRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5492010
Laurie AndersonHomelandEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B832010
The CureDisintegrationEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia93 A862010
Rufus WainwrightAll Days Are Nights: Songs for LuluEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B692010
Little BootsHandsEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+692010
Massive AttackHeligolandEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-672010
Hot ChipOne Life StandEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+772010
Charlotte GainsbourgIRMEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B762010
SpoonTransference“7SPIN Rating: 7 of 10Release Date: January 15, 2010Label: MergeIf Spoon had been meant to ride a comet out of the collegiate airwaves into modern-rock”Spin via Wikipedia70 7/10772010
OK GoOf the Blue Colour of the SkyEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-692010
Mary J. BligeStronger with Each TearEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B652010
Beach HouseTeen Dream“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: January 22, 2010Label: Sub PopJonathan Richman once said the Velvet Underground didn't make music, they made”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10832009
Animal CollectiveFall Be KindEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia93 A812009
Florence + the MachineLungs“Calling all crazy ex-girlfriends: If you're gonna keep up with Florence Welch, you might need stronger meds. In the U.K., where Lungs has become 2009's”Spin via Wikipedia80 4/5782009
Scarlett JohanssonBreak UpRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5552009
Owl CityOcean EyesEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+542009
Regina SpektorFarEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+682009
Tori AmosAbnormally Attracted to SinEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B642009
Chrisette MicheleEpiphanyRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5682009
A CampColoniaEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia55 C+642009
Pet Shop BoysYesEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+722009
Depeche ModeSounds of the Universe“Check out our album review of Artist's Sounds of the Universe on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5692009
Peter Bjorn and JohnLiving Thing“Two years ago, this Swedish trio scored an international smash with "Young Folks," an indie-pop sleeper so relentlessly upbeat that everyone from Kanye”Spin via Wikipedia80 4/5652009
Bat for LashesTwo SunsRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5772009
Neko CaseMiddle CycloneSpin via Wikipedia90 9/10802009
The KillersDay & AgeRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5682008
BeckModern GuiltRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5682008
UsherHere I StandRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5642008
The RaconteursConsolers of the Lonely“Check out our album review of Artist's Consolers Of The Lonely on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5732008
Britney SpearsBlackout“Check out our album review of Artist's Blackout on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5742007
Bright EyesCassadagaSpin via Wikipedia80 4/5792007
EvanescenceFallenSpin via Wikipedia80 4/5682006
EvanescenceThe Open DoorSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10682006
Cat PowerWhat Would the Community ThinkSpin via Wikipedia80 4/5822006
My Chemical RomanceThree Cheers for Sweet RevengeThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia70 3.5/5722004
Ellie GouldingHalcyonEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia75 B+69
David ByrneHere Lies LoveEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B69

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home