Matt Collar

Matt Collar’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 259 reviews, going back to 2005, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Pop 32%
  • Indie & Alternative 25%
  • Jazz 19%
  • Rock 16%

By the numbers

1A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
2albums given a perfect score
22years of their reviews we track, 2005 to 2026
How their scores spread
  • 0–490
  • 50s2
  • 60s19
  • 70s53
  • 80s136
  • 90+49

Their favorites

  1. Adele21 100 AllMusic
  2. ParamoreAfter Laughter 100 AllMusic
  3. Paul McCartneyThe Boys of Dungeon Lane 90 AllMusic
  4. Conan GrayWishbone 90 AllMusic
  5. LordeVirgin 90 AllMusic

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

1 album that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 1 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Graham CoxonCastle ParkAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/579Jun 12, 2026
Paul McCartneyThe Boys of Dungeon LaneAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/579May 29, 2026
SlayyyterWorst Girl in AmericaAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577Mar 27, 2026
Sophie Ellis-BextorPerimenopopAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/583Sep 26, 2025
Sabrina CarpenterMan’s Best FriendAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/568Aug 29, 2025
Maroon 5Love Is LikeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/548Aug 15, 2025
Conan GrayWishboneAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/578Aug 15, 2025
LordeVirginAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/578Jun 27, 2025
Benson BooneAmerican HeartAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/549Jun 20, 2025
YungbludIdolsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5592025
Willie NelsonLast Leaf on the TreeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5792024
The Smashing PumpkinsAghori Mhori MeiAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5742024
Conan GrayFound HeavenAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5782024
Jon BatisteWorld Music RadioAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5692023
The Smashing PumpkinsAtum: A Rock Opera in Three ActsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5612023
Caroline PolachekDesire, I Want to Turn Into YouAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5872023
ParamoreThis Is WhyAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5872023
Cécile McLorin SalvantGhost SongAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5882023
Joshua RedmanWhere Are WeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5722023
Paolo NutiniLast Night in the BittersweetAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5832022
Conan GraySuperacheAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5802022
EditorsEBMAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5732022
Maggie RogersSurrenderAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5772022
Rex Orange CountyWho Cares?AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5722022
Years & YearsNight CallAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5722022
Tate McRaeI Used to Think I Could FlyAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5712022
Biffy ClyroThe Myth of the Happily Ever AfterAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5882021
Angels & AirwavesLifeformsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5762021
Japanese BreakfastJubileeAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5862021
Teenage FanclubEndless ArcadeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5762021
Joe LovanoGarden of ExpressionAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5822021
5 Seconds of SummerCalmAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5752020
Conan GrayKid KrowAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5772020
Meghan TrainorTreat MyselfAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5542020
Carla BleyLife Goes OnAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5862020
Brad MehldauSuite: April 2020AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5742020
John ScofieldSwallow TalesAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5812020
Melody GardotThe AbsenceAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5722020
Mark TurnerLathe of HeavenAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5872019
Miles KaneCoup de GraceAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5592018
Cécile McLorin SalvantThe WindowAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5762018
Fifth HarmonyFifth HarmonyAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5602017
Camila CabelloCamilaThe Independent via Wikipedia80 4/5712017
Pat MethenyCuong Vu Trio Meets Pat MethenyAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5802017
Carla BleyAndando el TiempoAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5792016
Marina DiamandisFrootAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5802015
Brandon FlowersThe Desired EffectAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5732015
José GonzálezVestiges and ClawsAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5722015
Bette MidlerIt’s the Girls!AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5652014
Manchester OrchestraCopeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5682014
SwitchfootFading WestAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5762014
Natalie GrantHurricaneAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5782013
Touché AmoréIs Survived ByAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5802013
Ariana GrandeYours TrulyAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5792013
John MayerParadise ValleyAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5692013
Fitz and the TantrumsMore Than Just a DreamAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5592013
OneRepublicNativeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5692013
AsiaGravitasAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5632013
Kate NashGirl TalkAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5572013
AFIBurialsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5672013
PlaceboLoud Like LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5552013
JLSEvolutionAllMusic via Wikipedia50 2.5/5542012
P.O.D.Murdered LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5642012
Of Monsters and MenMy Head Is an AnimalAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5782012
Rebecca FergusonHeavenAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5812011
Manchester OrchestraSimple MathAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5722011
Katie MeluaThe HouseAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5632010
Teenage FanclubShadowsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5782010
Black Rebel Motorcycle ClubBeat the Devil’s TattooAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5632009
LightsThe ListeningAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5572009
Matt CostaUnfamiliar FacesAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5512007
Teenage FanclubMan-MadeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5752005
Katie MeluaIn WinterAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5782005
INXSSwitchAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5522005
Jamie CullumCatching TalesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5602005
P.O.D.TestifyAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5562005
JamiroquaiDynamiteAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5592005
The Script#3AllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/540
Esperanza Spalding12 Little SpellsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Adele21AllMusic via Wikipedia100 5/577
5 Seconds of Summer5 Seconds of SummerAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/570
5 Seconds of Summer5SOS5AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Manchester OrchestraA Black Mile to the SurfaceAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/577
The 1975A Brief Inquiry Into Online RelationshipsAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/584
GoGo PenguinA Humdrum StarAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/583
Samara JoyA Joyful HolidayAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Paloma FaithA Perfect ContradictionAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/556
Abbey LincolnAbbey Sings AbbeyAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/580
Terence BlanchardAbsenceAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/573
Brad MehldauAfter BachAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
ParamoreAfter LaughterAllMusic via Wikipedia100 5/579
Katie MeluaAlbum No. 8AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/574
IvyAll HoursAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/550
Gregory PorterAll RiseAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/580
HalseyBadlandsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/563
Kings of LeonBecause of the TimesAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/575
The 1975Being Funny in a Foreign LanguageAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
White LiesBig TVAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
Reneé RappBite MeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Bryan FerryBitter-SweetAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
IllitBombAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
RumerBoys Don’t CryAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
Terence BlanchardBreathlessAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/561
Blaqk AudioBright Black HeavenAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/560
DodieBuild a ProblemAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Camila CabelloC,XOXOAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/560
Kings of LeonCan We Please Have FunAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/572
Miles KaneChange the ShowAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
King PrincessCheap QueenAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
The VampsCherry BlossomAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
Brad MehldauChris Thile & Brad MehldauAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/577
Diana KrallChristmas SongsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/572
P.O.D.CirclesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/573
Megan MoroneyCloud 9AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/573
Years & YearsCommunionAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/568
Charles TolliverConnectAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
John MayerContinuumAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/567
Rauw AlejandroCosa nuestraAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/573
AFICrash LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/568
DNCEDNCEAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
Jimmy Eat WorldDamageAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/571
Panic! at the DiscoDeath of a BachelorAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/564
Ellie GouldingDeliriumAllMusic via Wikipedia71 7.1/1065
The Black KeysDelta KreamAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/566
HurtsDesireAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/560
Boz ScaggsDown Two Then LeftAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/558
Hayley WilliamsEgo Death at a Bachelorette PartyAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/590
Esperanza SpaldingEmily’s D+EvolutionAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/581
5 Seconds of SummerEveryone’s a Star!AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
The Last Shadow PuppetsEverything You’ve Come To ExpectAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/571
HurtsExileAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/563
Camila CabelloFamiliaAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
Norah JonesFeels Like HomeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
The WombatsFix Yourself, Not the WorldAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/565
FlumeFlumeAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/573
Japanese BreakfastFor Melancholy Brunettes (& Sad Women)AllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/585
The ScriptFreedom ChildAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/560
White LiesFriendsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/556
Diana KrallFrom This Moment OnAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Two Door Cinema ClubGameshowAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/566
Little MixGet WeirdAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/562
Little MixGlory DaysAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
Nate RuessGrand RomanticAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/561
WaterparksGreatest HitsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/586
P.O.D.Greatest Hits: The Atlantic YearsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Jonas BrothersGreetings from Your HometownAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/550
Melanie MartinezHadesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/565
Ellie GouldingHalcyonAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/569
BustedHalf Way ThereAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
Alexandra BurkeHeartbreak on HoldAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/553
Teenage FanclubHereAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Mark RonsonHere Comes the FuzzAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/564
David ByrneHere Lies LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
The ChatsHigh Risk BehaviourAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
The DarknessHot CakesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/568
Mannequin PussyI Got HeavenAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/586
The 1975I like it when you sleep, for you are so beautiful yet so unaware of itAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/573
Magdalena BayImaginal DiskAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/584
EditorsIn DreamAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
HumInletAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/583
RumerInto ColourAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
Death from Above 1979Is 4 LoversAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
Brad MehldauJacob’s LadderAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/569
Two Door Cinema ClubKeep On SmilingAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/560
Little MixLM5AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/571
Imelda MayLife Love Flesh BloodAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/573
Eliane EliasLight My FireAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/573
Samara JoyLinger AwhileAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Joshua RedmanLongGoneAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/578
Eliane EliasLove StoriesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Eliane EliasMade in BrazilAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/583
Kings of LeonMechanical BullAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
Magdalena BayMercurial WorldAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Esperanza SpaldingMilton + EsperanzaAllMusic via Wikipedia86 8.6/1081
Chick CoreaMirror MirrorAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/586
Cécile McLorin SalvantMélusineAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/585
Gregory PorterNat King Cole & MeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/566
Brad MehldauNearnessAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Olly MursNever Been BetterAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/558
Clap Your Hands Say YeahNew FragilityAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
MonicaNew LifeAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/552
BustedNight DriverAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
YunaNocturnalAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4.0/580
Little BootsNocturnesAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/571
The 1975Notes on a Conditional FormAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/570
Teenage FanclubNothing Lasts ForeverAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
The Smashing PumpkinsOceaniaAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/574
Cécile McLorin SalvantOh SnapAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/578
Blink-182One More Time…AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
Pat MethenyOne Quiet NightAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/570
Biffy ClyroOppositesAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/570
Rufus WainwrightOut of the GameAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Caroline PolachekPangAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/580
White LungParadiseAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/579
ParamoreParamoreAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/577
The Naked and FamousPassive Me, Aggressive YouAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/575
KeshaPeriodAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/565
Hayley WilliamsPetals for ArmorAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Rex Orange CountyPonyAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/575
Melanie MartinezPortalsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
Panic! at the DiscoPray for the WickedAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/563
Christian McBridePrimeAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/584
Eliane EliasQuietudeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
WeezerRaditudeAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/556
The Naked and FamousRecoverAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/582
Duran DuranRed Carpet MassacreAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/557
Fifth HarmonyReflectionAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/574
JamiroquaiRock Dust Light StarAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/569
Camila CabelloRomanceAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/564
Foster the PeopleSacred Hearts ClubAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/557
Little MixSaluteAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/563
Shawn MendesShawnAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/567
Sabrina CarpenterShort n’ SweetAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/576
StarsailorSilence Is EasyAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/555
Fall Out BoySo Much (For) StardustAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Teenage FanclubSongs from Northern BritainAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/572
5 Seconds of SummerSounds Good Feels GoodAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/564
Black Rebel Motorcycle ClubSpecter At The FeastAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/565
Melody GardotSunset in the BlueAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/579
Foster the PeopleSupermodelAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/559
HurtsSurrenderAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/559
One DirectionTake Me HomeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/567
The 1975The 1975AllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/565
Paloma FaithThe ArchitectAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/564
The Bad PlusThe Bad Plus Joshua RedmanAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Joe KeeryThe CruxAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/578
Robert Downey Jr.The FuturistAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/558
Red Hot Chili PeppersThe GetawayAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/562
JoJoThe High RoadAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/562
The ChurchThe HypnogogueAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/581
Manchester OrchestraThe Million Masks of GodAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
The NeighbourhoodThe NeighbourhoodAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/562
AmarantheThe NexusAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/566
Papa RoachThe Paramour SessionsAllMusic via Wikipedia50 2.5/550
EditorsThe Weight of Your LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/558
Pat MartinoThink TankAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
TwiceThis Is ForAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/568
Panic! at the DiscoToo Weird to Live, Too Rare to Die!AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/565
Foster the PeopleTorchesAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/566
Meghan TrainorToy with MeAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/544
Imelda MayTribalAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/569
Joe LovanoTrio TapestryAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/574
Oliver TreeUgly Is BeautifulAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/563
Adam LambertVelvetAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
SwitchfootVice VersesAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/585
EditorsViolenceAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Panic! at the DiscoViva Las VengeanceAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/573
Kings of LeonWallsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/560
Rufus WainwrightWant TwoAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Jon BatisteWe AreAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/583
Brad MehldauWhere Do You StartAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/578
PassengerWhispersAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/567
Papa RoachWho Do You Trust?AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/558
The NeighbourhoodWiped Out!AllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/556
Cécile McLorin SalvantWith Every Breath I TakeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Kenny BarronWithout DeceptionAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
The WantedWord of MouthAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/553
Black Rebel Motorcycle ClubWrong CreaturesAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
5 Seconds of SummerYoungbloodAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/563

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home