Manchester Orchestra

Manchester Orchestra’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 6 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 73 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.

What is Manchester Orchestra’s best album?

By the critics, it’s A Black Mile to the Surface (2017), with a B-Side Breakdown of 77 (Keeper) from 9 reviews. 67% of them liked it.

Next best: Mean Everything to Nothing (76) and The Million Masks of God (74). Lowest rated: Simple Math (67).

Manchester Orchestra albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. A Black Mile to the Surface (2017): 77 Keeper
  2. 2. Mean Everything to Nothing (2009): 76 Keeper
  3. 3. The Million Masks of God (2021): 74 Keeper
  4. 4. I’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child (2006): 74 Keeper
  5. 5. Cope (2014): 69 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. Simple Math (2011): 67 Mixed Bag

Manchester Orchestra discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every Manchester Orchestra album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

5010070likedI’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child (2006): 74742006Mean Everything to Nothing (2009): 76762009Simple Math (2011): 67672011Cope (2014): 69692014A Black Mile to the Surface (2017): 77772017The Million Masks of God (2021): 74742021

Every Manchester Orchestra album we track, oldest first.

  1. 2006Album cover for I’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child by Manchester OrchestraI’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child74 Keeper
  2. 2009Album cover for Mean Everything to Nothing by Manchester OrchestraMean Everything to Nothing76 Keeper
  3. 2011Album cover for Simple Math by Manchester OrchestraSimple Math67 Mixed Bag
  4. 2014Album cover for Cope by Manchester OrchestraCope69 Mixed Bag
  5. 2017Album cover for A Black Mile to the Surface by Manchester OrchestraA Black Mile to the Surface77 Keeper
  6. 2021Album cover for The Million Masks of God by Manchester OrchestraThe Million Masks of God74 Keeper

Which critics love Manchester Orchestra, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Manchester Orchestra albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Alternative Press3 albums+18
  1. Mean Everything to Nothing 2009100 vs 72 from 6 others +28
  2. Cope 201480 vs 68 from 6 others +13
  3. A Black Mile to the Surface 201790 vs 75 from 8 others +15

All Alternative Press reviews

Paste4 albums+6
  1. Mean Everything to Nothing 200991 vs 74 from 6 others +17
  2. Simple Math 201164 vs 68 from 5 others −4
  3. Cope 201479 vs 68 from 6 others +11
  4. The Million Masks of God 202175 vs 74 from 8 others +1

All Paste reviews

Sputnikmusic3 albums+6
  1. I’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child 200680 vs 71 from 2 others +10
  2. Mean Everything to Nothing 200980 vs 76 from 6 others +5
  3. Simple Math 201170 vs 67 from 5 others +3

All Sputnikmusic reviews

AllMusic5 albums+4
  1. Mean Everything to Nothing 200960 vs 79 from 6 others −19
  2. Simple Math 201170 vs 67 from 5 others +3
  3. Cope 201480 vs 68 from 6 others +13
  4. A Black Mile to the Surface 201790 vs 75 from 8 others +15
  5. The Million Masks of God 202180 vs 74 from 8 others +6

All AllMusic reviews

NME3 albums0
  1. Mean Everything to Nothing 200970 vs 77 from 6 others −7
  2. Cope 201470 vs 69 from 6 others +1
  3. The Million Masks of God 202180 vs 74 from 8 others +6

All NME reviews

Pitchfork4 albums−21
  1. I’m Like a Virgin Losing a Child 200651 vs 85 from 2 others −34
  2. Mean Everything to Nothing 200952 vs 80 from 6 others −28
  3. Cope 201456 vs 72 from 6 others −16
  4. A Black Mile to the Surface 201770 vs 78 from 8 others −8

All Pitchfork reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home