Matthew Cole

Matthew Cole’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 72 reviews, going back to 2009, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

  • Slant 2009–2012 · 72 reviews

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 29%
  • Rock 19%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 15%
  • R&B & Soul 14%

Find Matthew Cole

By the numbers

2albums given a perfect score
4years of their reviews we track, 2009 to 2012
53%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (72 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–4913
  • 50s12
  • 60s14
  • 70s12
  • 80s13
  • 90+8

Their favorites

  1. Tune-YardsWhokill 100 Slant
  2. JapandroidsPost-Nothing 100 Slant
  3. Patrick WolfLupercalia 90 Slant
  4. Arcade FireThe Suburbs 90 Slant
  5. Flying LotusCosmogramma 90 Slant

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Cloud NothingsAttack on Memory“On their latest, Cloud Nothings have never sounded so sure of their abilities.”Slant70 3.5/5802012
The WeekndEchoes of Silence“The Weeknd's 'Echoes of Silence' sounds and feels like something left over from a particularly creepy Halloween party.”Slant70 3.5/5752012
CommonThe Dreamer/The Believer“The reunion of Common and No I.D. sounds terrific, though the latter impresses more frequently.”Slant70 3.5/5722011
Oneohtrix Point NeverReplica“If Daniel Lopatin has made any concessions to accessibility this time out, they figure mostly into Replica’s abstractly rhythmic qualities.”Slant80 4/5792011
WaleAmbition“The question confronting Ambition isn’t whether Wale’s got the drive.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5662011
Jedi Mind TricksViolence Begets Violence“The only real argument for listening to Jedi Mind Tricks's 'Violence Begets Violence' is as historical curio.”Slant via Wikipedia10 0.5/5562011
Jane's AddictionThe Great Escape Artist“The majority of The Great Escape Artist is more likely to be uninvolving than outright bad.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5552011
BjörkBiophilia“Björk seems to have given the 10 songs that constitute Biophilia a supporting role in the New-Age-goes-New-Media Biophilia experience.”Slant70 3.5/5772011
MisfitsThe Devil’s RainSlant via Wikipedia40 2/5452011
J. ColeCole World: The Sideline Story“The only thing Cole World really wants for is the kind of out-of-the-park highlight that would pull the whole album together.”Slant60 3/5722011
MastodonThe Hunter“These metal auteurs haven’t stepped back from their love of all things mystical and psychedelic.”Slant80 4/5842011
The WeekndThursdaySlant via Wikipedia80 4/5742011
Lil WayneTha Carter IV“The repetition and the generally sluggish pace of delivery make it clear that Wayne’s not in exhilarating top form.”Slant60 3/5552011
ThundercatThe Golden Age of ApocalypseSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5722011
The War on DrugsSlave Ambient“Overcast but unmistakably warm, the War on Drugs's 'Slave Ambient' comes on like a rainy summer day in the rust belt.”Slant60 3/5782011
The HorrorsSkying“Skying’s sound is derived more from the jangle and hum of ’80s Cure and ’90s My Bloody Valentine than ’60s anything.”Slant80 4/5802011
LloydKing of Hearts“Lloyd fares best when he stays on the sillier, sexier side of things.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5732011
Joss StoneLP1“Joss Stone’s fifth album continues the British soul singer’s tendency to present every release as a brand new beginning.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5572011
Lil BI’m Gay (I’m Happy)Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672011
Patrick WolfLupercalia“RIAA be damned, Lupercalia is a golden record if ever we’ve heard one.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5762011
BattlesGloss Drop“No matter how you do the math, Battles is still blowing the curve.”Slant80 4/5782011
Death Cab for CutieCodes and Keys“Thanks in no small part to Death Cab, there’s now a permanent niche for indie pop that’s smart, sad, and refined, and Codes and Keys fills it nicely.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5692011
Danger MouseRome“It's a minutely detailed and evocative recreation of what, to generations of filmgoers, will always be the sound of the Old West.”Slant60 3/5702011
Tune-YardsWhokill“w h o k i l l proves that Merrill Garbus isn’t just a brainy artiste with a killer voice”Slant100 5/5822011
AtmosphereThe Family Sign“Eschewing the dynamic pop and soul flourishes that made Lemons something of a crossover vehicle, The Family Sign is simply flat.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5632011
Wiz KhalifaRolling Papers“Never an especially technical rapper, Khalifa doesn’t take his game up on Rolling Papers.”Slant50 2.5/5562011
Jennifer HudsonI Remember Me“I Remember Me makes tepid improvements on Jennifer Hudson’s self-titled debut.”Slant50 2.5/5672011
Lupe FiascoLasers“Lupe’s half-assed, club-ready radicalism is ultimately the most frustrating thing about Lasers.”Slant50 2.5/5532011
MogwaiHardcore Will Never Die, But You Will“The album finds Mogwai going easier on the ears than they have since 2003’s Happy Songs for Happy People.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5732011
Cut CopyZonoscope“Is it possible that Cut Copy has played things a little too cool?”Slant70 3.5/5722011
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadTao of the Dead“Trail of Dead's 'Tao of the Dead' further bloats their repertoire with songs calibrated to induce despair.”Slant40 2/5702011
Social DistortionHard Times and Nursery Rhymes“If only Mike Ness was as concerned with keeping his own sound fresh as with giving patronizingly modern “updates” on the work of his forbears.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5672011
M.I.A.Vicki Leekx“With this mixtape, M.I.A. has made great strides toward liberating her music from herself.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5692011
CiaraBasic Instinct“Basic Instinct strictly observes a no-ballads policy.”Slant70 3.5/5622010
Plain White T'sWonders of the YoungerSlant via Wikipedia40 2/5562010
DuffyEndlessly“Even without the affected singing, these ballads would still be unpalatably over-sweetened.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5572010
Kid CudiMan on the Moon II: The Legend of Mr. Rager“Pursuing genius at the expense of consistency might work out just fine for Cudi.”Slant70 3.5/5702010
Belle and SebastianBelle and Sebastian Write About Love“Write About Love' confirms that Belle and Sebastian is the type of band that’s fully capable of genius, just not reliably or often.”Slant50 2.5/5692010
Old 97'sThe Grand Theatre, Volume One“It’s great to hear the alt-country vets sounding more alternative and more country than they have in years.”Slant60 3/5692010
DeerhunterHalcyon Digest“Halcyon Digest’s finest moment suggests that Deerhunter will get by just fine without the histrionics.”Slant80 4/5822010
Katy PerryTeenage Dream“Teenage Dream is a raunchy pop nightmare.”Slant30 1.5/5612010
Arcade FireThe Suburbs“The album is another triumph of emotional generosity from the most humane and vital rock group of our generation.”Slant90 4.5/5892010
WavvesKing of the Beach“Unfortunately, Nathan Williams half-asses his leap from the collapsing edifice of the lo-fi scene.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5722010
Macy GrayThe Sellout“The Sellout doesn’t just embrace the fluffier side of the Gray persona, it smothers it in an awkward, goofy hug.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5572010
Tom Petty and the HeartbreakersMojo“From harmonicas to the honky-tonk pianos, the instrumentation isn’t much more creative than the lyrics.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5632010
Against Me!White Crosses“White Crosses proves to be a varied and exciting listen.”Slant80 4/5692010
MelvinsThe Bride Screamed Murder“The album is more or less interchangeable with 2008’s Nude with Boots both in terms of its sound and its level of quality.”Slant60 3/5722010
Janelle MonáeThe ArchAndroid“Cyber diva Janelle Monáe proves that she's only human on The ArchAndroid (Suites II and III of IV).”Slant80 4/5882010
Flying LotusCosmogramma“Steve Ellison may be all kinds of intellectual, but on Cosmogramma he never loses sight of the less reflective pleasures of his craft.”Slant90 4.5/5862010
DeftonesDiamond Eyes“When Diamond Eyes isn’t trying quite so hard to be a great record, it ends up being a pretty good one.”Slant70 3.5/5722010
Coheed and CambriaYear of the Black Rainbow“Disappointment that it is, the album still might have been saved from the outer limits of tedium were it not so mercilessly dreary.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5632010
JónsiGo“Go’s biggest surprise—that shouldn’t really be a surprise—is Jónsi’s remarkable vocal performances.”Slant90 4.5/5752010
UsherRaymond v. Raymond“The album is consistently uninspired, with each song showcasing an incredibly gifted performer grown wearyingly complacent.”Slant via Wikipedia30 1.5/5532010
The Dillinger Escape PlanOption Paralysis“Anyone who can make it through the first two tracks will probably find one of their favorite albums of the year.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5812010
Drive-By TruckersThe Big To-Do“The Big To-Do’s workmanlike consistency belies its lack of truly astonishing highs.”Slant70 3.5/5762010
LiarsSisterworld“Even taking into account the disappointing final act, Sisterworld adds up to a thrilling listen.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5772010
Joanna NewsomHave One on Me“Have One on Me is a strange and strangely pretentious mess.”Slant40 2/5792010
Fear FactoryMechanize“For much of its runtime, the album showcases Fear Factory’s leanest, most aggressive performances to date.”Slant60 3/5722010
Massive AttackHeligoland“On the majority of Heligoland, Massive Attack’s idea of heterogeneity is limited to rotating guest vocalists.”Slant60 3/5672010
Motion City SoundtrackMy Dinosaur Life“For the most part, My Dinosaur Life consists of power-pop in the proud tradition of Cheap Trick and Fountains of Wayne.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5792010
Owen PallettHeartland“With Heartland, Owen Pallett officially lays the Final Fantasy moniker to rest.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5772010
Alicia KeysThe Element of Freedom“As smart and savvy a songwriter as Keys should be able to do better than this.”Slant50 2.5/5632009
OneRepublicWaking Up“If you thought that success went to Ryan Tedder’s head, Waking Up wastes no time confirming those suspicions.”Slant30 1.5/5602009
Echo & the BunnymenThe Fountain“When taken as a whole, em>The Fountain is significantly worse than any one track would suggest.”Slant40 2/5522009
Between the Buried and MeThe Great Misdirect“The album contains substantial flaws that cannot be chalked up to prog-rock growing pains.”Slant60 3/5652009
MatisyahuLight“Lyrically, Light is an album concerned with spiritual struggle, but it’s rarely insightful.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5552009
JapandroidsPost-Nothing“While most indie messiahs tend to wear out their halos once the hype dies down, this duo’s debut seems engineered for maximum replays.”Slant via Wikipedia100 5/5802009
DaughtryLeave This Town“That the material on Leave This Town is clearly so meaningful to Chris makes the experience worse.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5492009
TortoiseBeacons of Ancestorship“Ultimately, Beacons is a funkier, more playful take on the band’s familiar sonic motifs.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5752009
MastodonCrack the Skye“The band’s affinity for harmony and subtle melodicism elevates Skye over heavier exercises in drop-tuned brutality.”Slant90 4.5/5832009
ThursdayCommon Existence“The album is tremendously affecting, but it’s also the first time a Thursday release isn’t an unambiguous improvement on its predecessor.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672009
MorrisseyYears of Refusal“As the album proceeds, Morrissey simply sounds like a superior version of the singer he’s always been.”Slant80 4/5712009

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home