Melvins Albums Ranked

Melvins’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 19 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 66 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is Melvins’ best album?

By the critics, it’s A Walk with Love & Death (2017), with a B-Side Breakdown of 80 (Keeper) from 4 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: Houdini (78) and Five Legged Dog (77). Lowest rated: Honky (27).

Melvins albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. A Walk with Love & Death (2017): 80 Keeper
  2. 2. Houdini (1993): 78 Keeper
  3. 3. Five Legged Dog (2021): 77 Keeper
  4. 4. Tarantula Heart (2024): 73 Keeper
  5. 5. Nude with Boots (2008): 73 Keeper
  6. 6. Hold It In (2014): 72 Keeper
  7. 7. The Bride Screamed Murder (2010): 72 Keeper
  8. 8. (A) Senile Animal (2006): 72 Keeper
  9. 9. Stoner Witch (1994): 70 Keeper
  10. 10. Pinkus Abortion Technician (2018): 69 Mixed Bag
  11. 11. Everybody Loves Sausages (2013): 69 Mixed Bag
  12. 12. Tres Cabrones (2013): 68 Mixed Bag
  13. 13. Freak Puke (2012): 65 Mixed Bag
  14. 14. Basses Loaded (2016): 62 Mixed Bag
  15. 15. Stag (1996): 60 Mixed Bag
  16. 16. Hostile Ambient Takeover (2002): 59 Mixed Bag
  17. 17. The Crybaby (2000): 59 Mixed Bag
  18. 18. Prick (1994): 43 Back of the Crate
  19. 19. Honky (1997): 27 Back of the Crate

Melvins discography, in release order

Every Melvins studio album, oldest first. 15 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1986Six SongsNo Breakdown yet
  2. 1987Gluey Porch TreatmentsNo Breakdown yet
  3. 1989OzmaNo Breakdown yet
  4. 1991BullheadNo Breakdown yet
  5. 1991EggnogNo Breakdown yet
  6. 1992LysolNo Breakdown yet
  7. 1993Album cover for Houdini by MelvinsHoudini78 Keeper
  8. 1994Album cover for Prick by MelvinsPrick43 Back of the Crate
  9. 1994Album cover for Stoner Witch by MelvinsStoner Witch70 Keeper
  10. 1996Album cover for Stag by MelvinsStag60 Mixed Bag
  11. 1997Album cover for Honky by MelvinsHonky27 Back of the Crate
  12. 1999The BootlickerNo Breakdown yet
  13. 1999The MaggotNo Breakdown yet
  14. 2000Album cover for The Crybaby by MelvinsThe Crybaby59 Mixed Bag
  15. 2001ElectroretardNo Breakdown yet
  16. 2002Album cover for Hostile Ambient Takeover by MelvinsHostile Ambient Takeover59 Mixed Bag
  17. 2004Never Breathe What You Can't SeeNo Breakdown yet
  18. 2004Pigs of the Roman EmpireNo Breakdown yet
  19. 2005Sieg Howdy!No Breakdown yet
  20. 2006Album cover for (A) Senile Animal by Melvins(A) Senile Animal72 Keeper
  21. 2008Album cover for Nude with Boots by MelvinsNude with Boots73 Keeper
  22. 2010Album cover for The Bride Screamed Murder by MelvinsThe Bride Screamed Murder72 Keeper
  23. 2012Album cover for Freak Puke by MelvinsFreak Puke65 Mixed Bag
  24. 2013Album cover for Everybody Loves Sausages by MelvinsEverybody Loves Sausages69 Mixed Bag
  25. 2013Album cover for Tres Cabrones by MelvinsTres Cabrones68 Mixed Bag
  26. 2014Album cover for Hold It In by MelvinsHold It In72 Keeper
  27. 2016Album cover for Basses Loaded by MelvinsBasses Loaded62 Mixed Bag
  28. 2017Album cover for A Walk with Love & Death by MelvinsA Walk with Love & Death80 Keeper
  29. 2018Album cover for Pinkus Abortion Technician by MelvinsPinkus Abortion Technician69 Mixed Bag
  30. 2021Album cover for Five Legged Dog by MelvinsFive Legged Dog77 Keeper
  31. 2022Bad Mood RisingNo Breakdown yet
  32. 2024Album cover for Tarantula Heart by MelvinsTarantula Heart73 Keeper
  33. Dale CroverNo Breakdown yet
  34. King BuzzoNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love Melvins, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Melvins albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Punknews.org3 albums+14
  1. (A) Senile Animal 200680 vs 70 from 6 others +10
  2. Freak Puke 201280 vs 62 from 5 others +18
  3. Pinkus Abortion Technician 201880 vs 67 from 7 others +13

All Punknews.org reviews

musicOMH6 albums+8
  1. The Bride Screamed Murder 201080 vs 70 from 7 others +10
  2. Everybody Loves Sausages 201380 vs 67 from 5 others +13
  3. Hold It In 201490 vs 63 from 2 others +28
  4. Basses Loaded 201670 vs 61 from 5 others +9
  5. A Walk with Love & Death 201780 vs 80 from 3 others 0
  6. Pinkus Abortion Technician 201860 vs 70 from 7 others −10

All musicOMH reviews

The Skinny3 albums+7
  1. Nude with Boots 200880 vs 72 from 5 others +8
  2. Everybody Loves Sausages 201380 vs 67 from 5 others +13
  3. A Walk with Love & Death 201780 vs 80 from 3 others 0

All The Skinny reviews

AllMusic17 albums+6
  1. Houdini 199390 vs 74 from 3 others +16
  2. Prick 199450 vs 40 from 2 others +10
  3. Stoner Witch 199480 vs 68 from 5 others +12
  4. Stag 199680 vs 55 from 4 others +25
  5. Honky 199760 vs 10 from 2 others +50
  6. The Crybaby 200060 vs 59 from 2 others +2
  7. Hostile Ambient Takeover 200260 vs 58 from 2 others +2
  8. (A) Senile Animal 200670 vs 72 from 6 others −2
  9. Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
  10. The Bride Screamed Murder 201070 vs 72 from 7 others −2
  11. Freak Puke 201270 vs 64 from 5 others +6
  12. Tres Cabrones 201370 vs 68 from 4 others +3
  13. Hold It In 201470 vs 73 from 2 others −3
  14. Basses Loaded 201660 vs 63 from 5 others −3
  15. A Walk with Love & Death 201770 vs 83 from 3 others −13
  16. Pinkus Abortion Technician 201870 vs 69 from 7 others +1
  17. Tarantula Heart 202470 vs 75 from 2 others −5

All AllMusic reviews

Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal3 albums+5
  1. Houdini 199370 vs 81 from 3 others −11
  2. Stoner Witch 199470 vs 70 from 5 others 0
  3. Stag 199680 vs 55 from 4 others +25

All Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal reviews

The Line of Best Fit4 albums+3
  1. Freak Puke 201265 vs 65 from 5 others 0
  2. Basses Loaded 201660 vs 63 from 5 others −3
  3. A Walk with Love & Death 201790 vs 77 from 3 others +13
  4. Pinkus Abortion Technician 201870 vs 69 from 7 others +1

All The Line of Best Fit reviews

PopMatters10 albums−2
  1. (A) Senile Animal 200680 vs 70 from 6 others +10
  2. Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
  3. The Bride Screamed Murder 201080 vs 70 from 7 others +10
  4. Freak Puke 201260 vs 66 from 5 others −6
  5. Everybody Loves Sausages 201350 vs 73 from 5 others −23
  6. Tres Cabrones 201360 vs 70 from 4 others −10
  7. Basses Loaded 201670 vs 61 from 5 others +9
  8. Pinkus Abortion Technician 201850 vs 71 from 7 others −21
  9. Five Legged Dog 202180 vs 75 from 2 others +5
  10. Tarantula Heart 202480 vs 70 from 2 others +10

All PopMatters reviews

Pitchfork8 albums−3
  1. Houdini 199377 vs 78 from 3 others −1
  2. The Crybaby 200067 vs 55 from 2 others +12
  3. Hostile Ambient Takeover 200256 vs 60 from 2 others −4
  4. (A) Senile Animal 200673 vs 72 from 6 others +2
  5. Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
  6. The Bride Screamed Murder 201052 vs 74 from 7 others −22
  7. Freak Puke 201267 vs 64 from 5 others +3
  8. Basses Loaded 201655 vs 64 from 5 others −9

All Pitchfork reviews

Spin3 albums−6
  1. Stag 199660 vs 60 from 4 others 0
  2. The Crybaby 200050 vs 64 from 2 others −14
  3. Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4

All Spin reviews

Consequence4 albums−12
  1. Freak Puke 201247 vs 68 from 5 others −21
  2. Tres Cabrones 201370 vs 68 from 4 others +3
  3. Hold It In 201455 vs 80 from 2 others −25
  4. Basses Loaded 201659 vs 63 from 5 others −4

All Consequence reviews

Encyclopedia of Popular Music3 albums−16
  1. Prick 199420 vs 55 from 2 others −35
  2. Stag 199660 vs 60 from 4 others 0
  3. (A) Senile Animal 200660 vs 74 from 6 others −14

All Encyclopedia of Popular Music reviews

NME3 albums−28
  1. Stag 199620 vs 70 from 4 others −50
  2. Honky 199710 vs 35 from 2 others −25
  3. Tres Cabrones 201360 vs 70 from 4 others −10

All NME reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home