Melvins’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 19 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 66 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.
What is Melvins’ best album?
By the critics, it’s A Walk with Love & Death (2017), with a B-Side Breakdown of 80 (Keeper) from 4 reviews. 100% of them liked it.
Next best: Houdini (78) and Five Legged Dog (77). Lowest rated: Honky (27).
Melvins albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
A Walk with Love & Death201780 Keeper - 2
Houdini199378 Keeper - 3
Five Legged Dog202177 Keeper - 4
Tarantula Heart202473 Keeper - 5
Nude with Boots200873 Keeper - 6
Hold It In201472 Keeper - 7
The Bride Screamed Murder201072 Keeper - 8
(A) Senile Animal200672 Keeper - 9
Stoner Witch199470 Keeper - 10
Pinkus Abortion Technician201869 Mixed Bag - 11
Everybody Loves Sausages201369 Mixed Bag - 12
Tres Cabrones201368 Mixed Bag - 13
Freak Puke201265 Mixed Bag - 14
Basses Loaded201662 Mixed Bag - 15
Stag199660 Mixed Bag - 16
Hostile Ambient Takeover200259 Mixed Bag - 17
The Crybaby200059 Mixed Bag - 18
Prick199443 Back of the Crate - 19
Honky199727 Back of the Crate
Melvins discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Melvins album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Melvins studio album, oldest first. 15 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.
- 1986Six SongsNo Breakdown yet
- 1987Gluey Porch TreatmentsNo Breakdown yet
- 1989OzmaNo Breakdown yet
- 1991BullheadNo Breakdown yet
- 1991EggnogNo Breakdown yet
- 1992LysolNo Breakdown yet
- 1993
Houdini78 Keeper - 1994
Prick43 Back of the Crate - 1994
Stoner Witch70 Keeper - 1996
Stag60 Mixed Bag - 1997
Honky27 Back of the Crate - 1999The BootlickerNo Breakdown yet
- 1999The MaggotNo Breakdown yet
- 2000
The Crybaby59 Mixed Bag - 2001ElectroretardNo Breakdown yet
- 2002
Hostile Ambient Takeover59 Mixed Bag - 2004Never Breathe What You Can't SeeNo Breakdown yet
- 2004Pigs of the Roman EmpireNo Breakdown yet
- 2005Sieg Howdy!No Breakdown yet
- 2006
(A) Senile Animal72 Keeper - 2008
Nude with Boots73 Keeper - 2010
The Bride Screamed Murder72 Keeper - 2012
Freak Puke65 Mixed Bag - 2013
Everybody Loves Sausages69 Mixed Bag - 2013
Tres Cabrones68 Mixed Bag - 2014
Hold It In72 Keeper - 2016
Basses Loaded62 Mixed Bag - 2017
A Walk with Love & Death80 Keeper - 2018
Pinkus Abortion Technician69 Mixed Bag - 2021
Five Legged Dog77 Keeper - 2022Bad Mood RisingNo Breakdown yet
- 2024
Tarantula Heart73 Keeper - Dale CroverNo Breakdown yet
- King BuzzoNo Breakdown yet
Which critics love Melvins, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Melvins albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Punknews.org3 albums+14
- (A) Senile Animal 200680 vs 70 from 6 others +10
- Freak Puke 201280 vs 62 from 5 others +18
- Pinkus Abortion Technician 201880 vs 67 from 7 others +13
musicOMH6 albums+8
- The Bride Screamed Murder 201080 vs 70 from 7 others +10
- Everybody Loves Sausages 201380 vs 67 from 5 others +13
- Hold It In 201490 vs 63 from 2 others +28
- Basses Loaded 201670 vs 61 from 5 others +9
- A Walk with Love & Death 201780 vs 80 from 3 others 0
- Pinkus Abortion Technician 201860 vs 70 from 7 others −10
The Skinny3 albums+7
- Nude with Boots 200880 vs 72 from 5 others +8
- Everybody Loves Sausages 201380 vs 67 from 5 others +13
- A Walk with Love & Death 201780 vs 80 from 3 others 0
AllMusic17 albums+6
- Houdini 199390 vs 74 from 3 others +16
- Prick 199450 vs 40 from 2 others +10
- Stoner Witch 199480 vs 68 from 5 others +12
- Stag 199680 vs 55 from 4 others +25
- Honky 199760 vs 10 from 2 others +50
- The Crybaby 200060 vs 59 from 2 others +2
- Hostile Ambient Takeover 200260 vs 58 from 2 others +2
- (A) Senile Animal 200670 vs 72 from 6 others −2
- Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
- The Bride Screamed Murder 201070 vs 72 from 7 others −2
- Freak Puke 201270 vs 64 from 5 others +6
- Tres Cabrones 201370 vs 68 from 4 others +3
- Hold It In 201470 vs 73 from 2 others −3
- Basses Loaded 201660 vs 63 from 5 others −3
- A Walk with Love & Death 201770 vs 83 from 3 others −13
- Pinkus Abortion Technician 201870 vs 69 from 7 others +1
- Tarantula Heart 202470 vs 75 from 2 others −5
Collector's Guide to Heavy Metal3 albums+5
- Houdini 199370 vs 81 from 3 others −11
- Stoner Witch 199470 vs 70 from 5 others 0
- Stag 199680 vs 55 from 4 others +25
The Line of Best Fit4 albums+3
- Freak Puke 201265 vs 65 from 5 others 0
- Basses Loaded 201660 vs 63 from 5 others −3
- A Walk with Love & Death 201790 vs 77 from 3 others +13
- Pinkus Abortion Technician 201870 vs 69 from 7 others +1
PopMatters10 albums−2
- (A) Senile Animal 200680 vs 70 from 6 others +10
- Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
- The Bride Screamed Murder 201080 vs 70 from 7 others +10
- Freak Puke 201260 vs 66 from 5 others −6
- Everybody Loves Sausages 201350 vs 73 from 5 others −23
- Tres Cabrones 201360 vs 70 from 4 others −10
- Basses Loaded 201670 vs 61 from 5 others +9
- Pinkus Abortion Technician 201850 vs 71 from 7 others −21
- Five Legged Dog 202180 vs 75 from 2 others +5
- Tarantula Heart 202480 vs 70 from 2 others +10
Pitchfork8 albums−3
- Houdini 199377 vs 78 from 3 others −1
- The Crybaby 200067 vs 55 from 2 others +12
- Hostile Ambient Takeover 200256 vs 60 from 2 others −4
- (A) Senile Animal 200673 vs 72 from 6 others +2
- Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
- The Bride Screamed Murder 201052 vs 74 from 7 others −22
- Freak Puke 201267 vs 64 from 5 others +3
- Basses Loaded 201655 vs 64 from 5 others −9
Spin3 albums−6
- Stag 199660 vs 60 from 4 others 0
- The Crybaby 200050 vs 64 from 2 others −14
- Nude with Boots 200870 vs 74 from 5 others −4
Consequence4 albums−12
- Freak Puke 201247 vs 68 from 5 others −21
- Tres Cabrones 201370 vs 68 from 4 others +3
- Hold It In 201455 vs 80 from 2 others −25
- Basses Loaded 201659 vs 63 from 5 others −4
Encyclopedia of Popular Music3 albums−16
- Prick 199420 vs 55 from 2 others −35
- Stag 199660 vs 60 from 4 others 0
- (A) Senile Animal 200660 vs 74 from 6 others −14
NME3 albums−28
- Stag 199620 vs 70 from 4 others −50
- Honky 199710 vs 35 from 2 others −25
- Tres Cabrones 201360 vs 70 from 4 others −10
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.
