Anthony Fantano

Anthony Fantano’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 133 reviews, going back to 2015, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Pop 24%
  • Indie & Alternative 23%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 21%
  • Rock 8%

By the numbers

2A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
3albums given a perfect score
12years of their reviews we track, 2015 to 2026
How their scores spread
  • 0–4926
  • 50s15
  • 60s17
  • 70s36
  • 80s29
  • 90+10

Their favorites

  1. ClipseLet God Sort Em Out 100 The Needle Drop
  2. Charli XCXBrat 100 The Needle Drop
  3. Lauryn HillThe Miseducation of Lauryn Hill 100 The Needle Drop
  4. PISSYou Made Me/Skin On Linen 90 The Needle Drop
  5. Bill CallahanMy Days of 58 90 The Needle Drop

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

2 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 2 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
2hollisPirouette“Pirouette is a genuinely multi-faceted album that shows off 2hollis' potential as a songwriter and producer.”The Needle Drop70 7/1068Nov 17, 2026
twisted teensThe Holy Cross Tigers“The weakest of the three albums Twisted Teens have dropped this year is still very solid.”The Needle Drop70 7/1080Nov 16, 2026
Rachel ChinouririI think I spoke too soon“There're some great highlights and a lot to appreciate about 'I think I spoke too soon.”The Needle Drop70 7/1074Nov 6, 2026
brakencemarroW“brakence returns with an even more abrasive album than hypochondriac.”The Needle Drop20 2/10not yetNov 6, 2026
PISSYou Made Me/Skin On Linen“One of the best debuts not only of the year, but this decade.”The Needle Drop90 9/1088Nov 5, 2026
Queens of the Stone AgePerfecth“Sadly this is QOTSA's weakest album by a wide margin.”The Needle Drop30 3/1075Nov 4, 2026
HMLTDFANGS“At the very least, FANGS isn’t a boring listen.”The Needle Drop50 5/1068Nov 2, 2026
The Olivia Tremor ControlThe Same Place“After 27 years, the Olivia Tremor Control are back in the Same Place.”The Needle Drop80 8/1083Nov 2, 2026
Shabazz PalacesIt’s A Style Sport“SP's strongest showing since their first couple of albums.”The Needle Drop70 7/1074Oct 29, 2026
Fontaines D.C.Dopamine Chamber“Fontaines D.C. take their sound in a darker, more ethereal direction that works for them on Dopamine Chamber.”The Needle Drop70 7/1081Oct 22, 2026
Remi WolfMud“Sadly an underwhelming album from Remi.”The Needle Drop40 4/1069Oct 19, 2026
Alabama ShakesI Must Be Dreaming“Alabama Shakes' comeback album is kind of carried by its great singles.”The Needle Drop60 6/1073Oct 16, 2026
GodfleshDecay“This penultimate album is signaling a consummate end for the Godflesh project.”The Needle Drop80 8/1081Oct 14, 2026
Ella LangleyDandelion“As far as chart-topping country music goes, you could do way, way worse.”The Needle Drop60 6/1077Aug 5, 2026
Jack WhiteFrozen Charlotte“More or less a shoddier version of what Jack was doing on No Name.”The Needle Drop60 6/1078Jul 15, 2026
Vince StaplesCry Baby“The stylistic risk Vince takes on Cry Baby is commendable, but his lyrics have much more bite than the rock instrumentation.”The Needle Drop60 6/1080Jun 12, 2026
Kim PetrasDetourThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/1064Jun 12, 2026
KneecapFenian“KNEECAP are sounding rightfully triumphant on 'FENIAN.”The Needle Drop80 8/1080May 11, 2026
Kacey MusgravesMiddle of Nowhere“Hi everyone, Lookthony Outtano here, the internet's busiest music nerd, and it's time for a review of this new Kacey Musgraves album, Middle of Nowhere. This is the newest and…”The Needle Drop70 7/1074May 11, 2026
Noah KahanThe Great Divide“Noah has certainly stepped his songwriting game up on The Great Divide, but the whole album is too bloated and washed-out for its own good.”The Needle Drop50 5/1053May 1, 2026
ThundercatDistracted“The best Thundercat album since his debut.”The Needle Drop80 8/1075Apr 13, 2026
Angine de PoitrineVol. II“At least half of the jams on Vol. II seriously kick ass.”The Needle Drop70 7/1081Apr 7, 2026
RayeThis Music May Contain Hope.“THIS MUSIC MAY CONTAIN HOPE. is riddled with musical and conceptual speed bumps.”The Needle Drop30 3/1078Apr 3, 2026
SlayyyterWorst Girl in AmericaThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia60 6/1077Apr 2, 2026
YeatADLThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia30 3/1048Mar 31, 2026
NeurosisAn Undying Love for a Burning World“An enthralling and ambitious step forward for the legendary sludge metal band.”The Needle Drop80 8/1090Mar 30, 2026
BTSArirang“The Bangtan Boys mount an awkward and nondescript return with ARIRANG.”The Needle Drop30 3/1069Mar 26, 2026
UnderscoresU“April is confidently in her popstar era on U.”The Needle Drop80 8/1087Mar 25, 2026
James BlakeTrying Times“James Blake continues dropping consistent and beautiful projects even in these trying times.”The Needle Drop80 8/1078Mar 23, 2026
Kim GordonPlay Me“PLAY ME mostly sounds like leftovers or afterthoughts from Kim's previous and great album The Collective.”The Needle Drop50 5/1073Mar 19, 2026
Bill CallahanMy Days of 58“Bill Callahan's latest album is full of wit and sprightliness.”The Needle Drop90 9/1078Mar 16, 2026
Harry StylesKiss All the Time. Disco, Occasionally.The Needle Drop40 4/1065Mar 11, 2026
MitskiNothing’s About to Happen to Me“A pretty good follow-up to The Land Is Inhospitable.”The Needle Drop70 7/1081Mar 6, 2026
GorillazThe Mountain“In a lot of ways The Mountain could be seen as Gorillaz's most ambitious album so far.”The Needle Drop70 7/1080Mar 5, 2026
Bruno MarsThe Romantic“Listening to 'The Romantic' mostly just makes you want to listen to the classic soul artists from whom Bruno is clearly pulling inspiration.”The Needle Drop50 5/1063Mar 4, 2026
Jill ScottTo Whom This May Concern“A gorgeous and inspiring return.”The Needle Drop90 9/1079Feb 27, 2026
ConvergeLove Is Not Enough“After all these years, Converge's performances and songwriting are just as high-impact as those of the best up-and-comers in the metalcore scene.”The Needle Drop80 8/1090Feb 21, 2026
hemlocke springsthe apple tree under the sea“hemlocke springs knocks it out of the park on her whimsical debut album.”The Needle Drop80 8/1074Feb 19, 2026
J. ColeThe Fall-Off“If this is in fact J. Cole's last album, it's a pretty high note to end on.”The Needle Drop70 7/1068Feb 13, 2026
Mandy, IndianaURGH“Mandy, Indiana outdoes their debut on all fronts on URGH.”The Needle Drop80 8/1082Feb 13, 2026
JojiPiss In The Wind“Piss in the Wind is shockingly low-effort.”The Needle Drop30 3/1060Feb 12, 2026
PoppyEmpty Hands“Empty Hands is a slight step down from Negative Spaces.”The Needle Drop60 6/1074Feb 2, 2026
Zach BryanWith Heaven on Top“With Heaven on Top feels like just the residuals of what made Zach's previous material so good.”The Needle Drop50 5/1067Jan 27, 2026
De La SoulCabin In The Sky“De La Soul delivers a celebratory and bittersweet posthumous album with 'Cabin in the Sky'.”The Needle Drop80 8/1079Nov 27, 2025
Oneohtrix Point NeverTranquilizer“A culmination of much of Lopatin's work since the early 2010s.”The Needle Drop80 8/1081Nov 25, 2025
FKA twigsEusexua Afterglow“A lot of Afterglow doesn't stick.”The Needle Drop50 5/1075Nov 19, 2025
RosalíaLux“LUX is commendably ambitious and often gorgeous, but doesn't go the distance with all of its ideas.”The Needle Drop70 7/1089Nov 17, 2025
Danny BrownStardust“On 'Stardust', Danny continues proving himself as one of the boldest creatives in hip hop and beyond.”The Needle Drop80 8/1076Nov 14, 2025
Florence + the MachineEverybody Scream“Everybody Scream has some of the best and boldest performances and production on any Florence + The Machine album so far.”The Needle Drop70 7/1081Nov 6, 2025
DaveThe Boy Who Played the Harp“Some of Dave's best and most thoughtful writing to date.”The Needle Drop70 7/1082Nov 2, 2025
Lily AllenWest End Girl“West End Girl is compellingly candid, but suffers from some musical blandness and writing that's sometimes too on-the-nose.”The Needle Drop60 6/1077Oct 30, 2025
The Last Dinner PartyFrom the Pyre“While still pretty good, From the Pyre is maybe coming too soon after TLDP's previous album to really develop their sound.”The Needle Drop70 7/1085Oct 22, 2025
Tame ImpalaDeadbeat“Deadbeat blows The Slow Rush out of the water as the worst Tame Impala project to date.”The Needle Drop20 2/1058Oct 21, 2025
Mobb DeepInfinite“Infinite is a rare posthumous album that is actually commendable and very solid on its own merits.”The Needle Drop70 7/1075Oct 14, 2025
Taylor SwiftThe Life of a Showgirl“A surprisingly immature album from Taylor at this point in her life and career.”The Needle Drop40 4/1059Oct 7, 2025
Jens LekmanSongs for Other People’s Weddings“While it's occasionally cumbersome and very mannerly, Songs for Other People's Weddings is a pretty and conceptual listen.”The Needle Drop60 6/1075Oct 3, 2025
Doja CatVie“Doja's most consistently fun album so far.”The Needle Drop70 7/1073Oct 2, 2025
GeeseGetting Killed“Geese get even wilder on Getting Killed.”The Needle Drop80 8/1086Oct 1, 2025
The HivesThe Hives Forever Forever the Hives“Another reason to put respect on The Hives' name.”The Needle Drop80 8/1079Sep 29, 2025
Cardi BAm I the Drama?“A sophomore slump seven years in the making.”The Needle Drop40 4/1068Sep 23, 2025
Twenty One PilotsBreach“While Breach could have more boldly capped off this lengthy chapter of the duo's career, it delivers at least a handful of truly great tracks.”The Needle Drop60 6/1073Sep 16, 2025
SombrI Barely Know Her“A very promising starting point for sombr.”The Needle Drop60 6/1073Sep 12, 2025
Big ThiefDouble Infinity“Big Thief don't play to their strengths on Double Infinity.”The Needle Drop50 5/1081Sep 9, 2025
Sabrina CarpenterMan’s Best Friend“More of a mixed bag than Short n' Sweet.”The Needle Drop50 5/1068Sep 2, 2025
DeftonesPrivate Music“deftones are sounding as heavy as ever on private music.”The Needle Drop70 7/1086Aug 29, 2025
Earl SweatshirtLive Laugh Love“One of Earl's strongest releases.”The Needle Drop80 8/1080Aug 28, 2025
LaufeyA Matter of Time“There are several highlights on A Matter of Time, but for the most part Laufey's takes on classic pop sounds still yield mixed results.”The Needle Drop50 5/1078Aug 27, 2025
Ethel CainWilloughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You“Hayden comes through with a pretty powerful prequel that improves upon its predecessor in many respects.”The Needle Drop70 7/1082Aug 15, 2025
Tyler, the CreatorDon’t Tap the Glass“DON'T TAP THE GLASS is simply a great time.”The Needle Drop80 8/1074Jul 24, 2025
Alex GHeadlights“Headlights only has a few highlights.”The Needle Drop50 5/1076Jul 23, 2025
Wet LegMoisturizer“Not the moistest album you'll hear this year.”The Needle Drop60 6/1078Jul 21, 2025
ClipseLet God Sort Em OutThe Needle Drop100 10/1080Jul 16, 2025
KeshaPeriodThe Needle Drop40 4/1065Jul 10, 2025
LordeVirgin“Virgin is Lorde's headiest and most subtle-sounding album yet, but she could have dug deeper into the album's lyrical themes.”The Needle Drop60 6/1078Jul 2, 2025
Benson BooneAmerican Heart“Benson's got the singing and backflipping chops, but not so much the songwriting chops yet.”The Needle Drop30 3/1049Jun 24, 2025
Aesop RockBlack Hole Superette“Further proof Aesop Rock can rap about anything.”The Needle Drop80 8/1077Jun 23, 2025
TurnstileNever Enough“Never Enough, while still a good album, is a little atered-down compared to Glow On.”The Needle Drop70 7/1082Jun 16, 2025
Little SimzLotus“Even with its potentially confounding detours, Lotus delivers the impressive bars and production Little Simz is known for.”The Needle Drop80 8/1086Jun 12, 2025
Addison RaeAddison“Addison shows potential, but most of this album sounds like it's still in the incubation stage.”The Needle Drop40 4/1072Jun 10, 2025
SparksMad!“At almost 80 now, the Maels still got it.”The Needle Drop80 8/1081Jun 9, 2025
SwansBirthing“The final "big sound" Swans album contains some of the most surreal and uplifting spots in the band's discography.”The Needle Drop70 7/1085Jun 4, 2025
Miley CyrusSomething Beautiful“Easily Miley's best album to date.”The Needle Drop80 8/1070Jun 3, 2025
Morgan WallenI’m the Problem“This album's not helping.”The Needle Drop10 1/1052May 30, 2025
StereolabInstant Holograms on Metal Film“A very good comeback from Stereolab.”The Needle Drop70 7/1081May 28, 2025
Kali UchisSincerely“While some bolder vocal performances would have made it even better, Sincerely, is Kali Uchis' most mature and personal project so far.”The Needle Drop70 7/10792025
Sleep TokenEven in Arcadia“What novelty Sleep Token had is already starting to wear off.”The Needle Drop20 2/10652025
GhostSkeletá“A glammy step up from the band's previous album.”The Needle Drop60 6/10742025
Viagra BoysViagr Aboys“Viagra Boys' most meta album so far.”The Needle Drop80 8/10842025
Bon IverSABLE, fABLE“One of Justin Vernon's most beautiful projects ever.”The Needle Drop80 8/10802025
Black Country, New RoadForever Howlong“Life is a grand performance on the new Black Country, New Road album.”The Needle Drop80 8/10802025
Imperial TriumphantGoldstarThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia90 9/10862025
Playboi CartiMusic“It's a whole lotta music, and some of it's not the best music.”The Needle Drop40 4/10672025
Rebecca BlackSalvation“While not one of the heftiest pop albums you'll hear all year, 'Salvation' is still a bunch of pretty great songs.”The Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/10552025
SpiritboxTsunami Sea“Spiritbox returns with their second album of progressive djent alt metal pop mayhem with a slightly industrial twist here and there.”The Needle Drop60 6/10872025
Lady GagaMayhem“MAYHEM is pretty much peak Gaga until losing a bit of steam in its last leg.”The Needle Drop70 7/10752025
LisaAlter Ego“A pretty solid solo debut from BLACKPINK'S LISA.”The Needle Drop70 7/10562025
Tate McRaeSo Close to What“A lot less laughable than Tate's previous album.”The Needle Drop50 5/10682025
Mac MillerBalloonerism“Balloonerism puts Mac Miller's wit, poignancy, and freewheeling creativity on full display; it being able to reach more ears now is only a good thing.”The Needle Drop80 8/10772025
Rachel ChinouririWhat a Devastating Turn of Events“One of the most solid singer-songwriter debuts to come out of the UK this year.”The Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/10792024
Father John MistyMahashmashana“Josh Tillman rebounds nicely on Mahashmashana.”The Needle Drop70 7/10832024
Kendrick LamarGNX“What you see is what you get.”The Needle Drop90 9/10832024
PoppyNegative Spaces“Poppy's most wholehearted embrace of metal so far.”The Needle Drop70 7/10832024
Linkin ParkFrom Zero“Linkin Park returns with a handful of decent songs and a void that can't fully be filled.”The Needle Drop50 5/10712024
The CureSongs of a Lost World“Comeback albums after so long are rarely this solid.”The Needle Drop70 7/10892024
Lil Uzi VertEternal Atake 2“EA2 doesn't hold a candle to the first one, which didn't even set the bar that high.”The Needle Drop20 2/10432024
Laura MarlingPatterns in Repeat“A continuation of everything that made 'Song for Our Daughter' beautiful.”The Needle Drop90 9/10882024
Tyler, the CreatorChromakopia“Tyler continues his creative streak on 'Chromakopia'.”The Needle Drop80 8/10792024
HalseyThe Great Impersonator“The Great Impersonator' fails to do much with its various sources of inspiration.”The Needle Drop10 1/10722024
Amyl and the SniffersCartoon Darkness“Amyl and the Sniffers are great when they're in their wheelhouse, but that's still pretty narrow.”The Needle Drop60 6/10792024
The SmileCutouts“A marked step down from Wall of Eyes.”The Needle Drop50 5/10772024
SophieSophie“SOPHIE's posthumous album tragically doesn't do justice to her unparalleled vision as a songwriter and producer.”The Needle Drop30 3/10722024
Katy Perry143The Needle Drop20 2/10362024
Sabrina CarpenterShort n’ Sweet“Things are moving in a pretty good direction for Sabrina Carpenter.”The Needle Drop60 6/10762024
Post MaloneF-1 Trillion“Post Malone's country pivot could have turned out much better than this.”The Needle Drop40 4/10692024
BeabadoobeeThis Is How Tomorrow Moves“The third studio album from singer-songwriter beabadoobee”The Needle Drop70 7/10782024
TinasheQuantum Baby“It takes a while for Quantum Baby to start dishing out its best songs.”The Needle Drop50 5/10712024
Orville PeckStampede“While not every crossover on Stampede is fireworks, most of them land in the OK to great range.”The Needle Drop70 7/10672024
JPEGMafiaI Lay Down My Life for You“Arguably Peggy's most instrumentally lush and emotionally dynamic album to date.”The Needle Drop via Wikipedia80 8/10772024
Porter RobinsonSmile! :D“Such a colorful, catchy, and emotionally compelling set of songs.”The Needle Drop80 8/10742024
Ice SpiceY2K!The Needle Drop40 4/10602024
Charli XCXBrat“Hi, everyone. Bratthony Greentano here, the internet's busiest music nerd and it's time for a review of this new record, Brat, from Charli XCX. Here we have the sixth official…”The Needle Drop100 10/10842024
Willow SmithEmpathogen“Hi, everyone. Sickthony Boytano here, the internet's most nauseous music nerd. It's time for a review of this new Willow album, Empathogen. Newest LP from singer, songwriter, and multi-instrumentalist, Ms.…”The Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/10752024
Ken CarsonA Great ChaosThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia30 3/10672023
Ab-SoulHerbertThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia60 6/10642023
BladeeSpiderrThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/10762022
Ken CarsonXThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia0 0/10362022
Toro y MoiMahalThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7/10722022
JPEGMafiaLP!The Needle Drop via Wikipedia90 9/10842021
Megan Thee StallionFeverThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia70 7.0/10782019
C418Minecraft – Volume AlphaThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia80 8/10802018
Juice WrldGoodbye & Good RiddanceThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia50 5/10622018
Lauryn HillThe Miseducation of Lauryn HillThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia100 10/10892018
Kid CudiSpeedin’ Bullet 2 HeavenThe Needle Drop via Wikipedia0 0/10422015

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home