Marcy Donelson

Marcy Donelson’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 81 reviews, going back to 2014, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 73%
  • Pop 11%
  • Folk, Country & Americana 9%
  • Rock 3%

By the numbers

2albums given a perfect score
13years of their reviews we track, 2014 to 2026
78%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (81 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–490
  • 50s0
  • 60s5
  • 70s30
  • 80s36
  • 90+10

Their favorites

  1. various artistsHamilton 100 AllMusic
  2. MitskiPuberty 2 100 AllMusic
  3. MitskiBury Me at Makeout Creek 90 AllMusic
  4. Angel OlsenAll Mirrors 90 AllMusic
  5. MitskiBe the Cowboy 90 AllMusic

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Courtney BarnettCreature of HabitAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/577Jan 22, 2026
Sharon Van EttenSharon Van Etten & the Attachment TheoryAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5822025
Nadine ShahFilthy UnderneathAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5842024
Ben FoldsWhat Matters MostAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5652023
Beth OrtonWeather AliveAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5842022
AURORAThe Gods We Can TouchAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5832022
ClairoSlingAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5822021
Sam FenderSeventeen Going UnderAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5822021
girl in redIf I Could Make It Go QuietAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/5762021
AURORAA Different Kind of Human (Step 2)AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762019
Alison MoyetOtherAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5792017
Alex GBeach MusicAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/5752015
The MaccabeesMarks to Prove ItAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752015
MitskiBury Me at Makeout CreekAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5762014
The War on DrugsA Deeper UnderstandingAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/579
Adrianne LenkerAbysskissAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/579
Angel OlsenAll MirrorsAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/585
of MontrealAureate GloomAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/566
MitskiBe the CowboyAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/583
Angel OlsenBig TimeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/584
Adrianne LenkerBright FutureAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/586
Big ThiefCapacityAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Jarvis CockerChansons d’EnnuiAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Soccer MommyCleanAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Soccer MommyColor TheoryAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Julia JacklinCrushingAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/584
Alex GDSUAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/573
Ella LangleyDandelionAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
Gracie AbramsDaughter from HellAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/558
Big ThiefDouble InfinityAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/581
Big ThiefDragon New Warm Mountain I Believe in YouAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/586
BeirutGallipoliAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/573
Alex GGod Save the AnimalsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/584
various artistsHamiltonAllMusic via Wikipedia100 5/586
Alex GHeadlightsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/576
Regina SpektorHome, Before and AfterAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/579
Alex GHouse of SugarAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/583
Big Red MachineHow Long Do You Think It’s Gonna Last?AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/573
ClairoImmunityAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/574
Jacob CollierIn My RoomAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/570
MitskiLaurel HellAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
TobyMacLife After DeathAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
Madison BeerLife SupportAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/570
Snail MailLushAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Big ThiefMasterpieceAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
Alice MertonMintAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/573
Nilüfer YanyaMy Method ActorAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/582
My New Band BelieveMy New Band BelieveAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/584
Angel OlsenMy WomanAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/584
DaughterNot to DisappearAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
Finneas O'ConnellOptimistAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
WaxahatcheeOut in the StormAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/576
Nilüfer YanyaPainlessAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/579
First Aid KitPalominoAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/575
Kings of ConveniencePeace or LoveAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/573
Sufjan StevensPlanetariumAllMusic via Wikipedia60 3/570
Julia JacklinPre PleasureAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
MitskiPuberty 2AllMusic via Wikipedia100 5/584
PolyphiaRemember That You Will DieAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/576
Regina SpektorRemember Us to LifeAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/569
Brandi CarlileReturning to MyselfAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/581
Alex GRocket ((Sandy) Alex G album)AllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/578
First Aid KitRuinsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/574
WaxahatcheeSaint CloudAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/583
Madison BeerSilence Between SongsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/567
FrikoSomething Worth Waiting ForAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/582
Adrianne LenkerSongs and InstrumentalsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/585
Chris ThileThanks for ListeningAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/570
Julia JacklinThe GemAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/576
MitskiThe Land Is Inhospitable and So Are WeAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/587
Gracie AbramsThe Secret of UsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/577
Julien BakerTurn Out the LightsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/577
Big ThiefTwo HandsAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/580
Big ThiefU.F.O.F.AllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/584
Snail MailValentineAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/584
BlondshellViolinsAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/578
AURORAWhat Happened to the Heart?AllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/581
FoalsWhat Went DownAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/577
Ethel CainWilloughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love YouAllMusic via Wikipedia80 4/582
ErasureWorld Be GoneAllMusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/568
Sigur RósÁttaAllMusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/580

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home