Evan Sawdey

Evan Sawdey’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 58 reviews, going back to 2004, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 28%
  • Pop 26%
  • Rock 18%
  • Electronic 16%

Find Evan Sawdey

By the numbers

1album given a perfect score
19years of their reviews we track, 2004 to 2022
55%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (58 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–4916
  • 50s5
  • 60s9
  • 70s17
  • 80s7
  • 90+4

Their favorites

  1. WeezerPinkerton 100 PopMatters
  2. Phil CollinsFace Value 90 PopMatters
  3. Beth OrtonCentral Reservation 90 PopMatters
  4. The Moody BluesDays of Future Passed 90 PopMatters
  5. Beth OrtonWeather Alive 80 PopMatters

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Tove LoDirt Femme“Free of major-label constraints, Tove Lo turns her dark sex-positive pop into something wiser and mature. Yet fans need not worry as Dirt Femme's BPM still kicks.”PopMatters70 7/10732022
Beth OrtonWeather Alive“Having only put out five albums in the past two decades, Beth Orton's Weather Alive embraces her electro-folk past while embracing a weathered, gorgeous future.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10842022
Confidence ManTILT“Australia's mystery-goof quartet Confidence Man unleashed a supremely confident debut in 2018, but after years of waiting, they're finally back with a '90s sheen on TILT.”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10772022
Aesop RockGarbology“Aesop Rock finally reunites with his longtime producer Blockhead for a hip-hop record less focused on nostalgia and more about depicting our paranoid present.”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10752021
PinkBeautiful TraumaPopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10652017
Mac DeMarcoThis Old Dog“I'm not old, I'm a kid. If I feel old now, I don't know how the hell I'm going to feel when I'm really old … that will be strange.”PopMatters80 8/10762017
The Flaming LipsOczy Mlody“That's just what you do," Coyne notes, surmising his overall do-anything philosophy. "You get into a state of mind, you obsess, and you push as hard as you”PopMatters40 4/10722017
Phil Collins…But SeriouslyPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10562016
Phil CollinsBoth SidesPopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10622016
Phil CollinsFace ValuePopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10822016
Phil CollinsHello, I Must Be Going!“In the '80s, you seemed to be everywhere. What do you remember about that time?”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10722016
Eric PrydzOpusPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10742016
Ryan Adams1989“One cold day in late 2006, Ryan Adams decided, for whatever reason, to release 11 albums at the same time.”PopMatters60 6/10732015
Death Cab for CutieKintsugi“Kintsugi may very well go down as one of the most depressing rock albums of all time. No, not because of any sort of notable catharsis it achieves, but”PopMatters30 3/10632015
iamamiwhoamiBLUE“When all has gone to blazes I start to run / Until I find places where nobody's gone”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10702014
PrincePlectrumelectrum“The internet's completely over. I don't see why I should give my new music to iTunes or anyone else. They won't pay me an advance for it and then they…”PopMatters70 7/10682014
M83Dead Cities, Red Seas & Lost Ghosts“When Anthony Gonzalez started out making music, he probably didn't anticipate that he'd eventually be producing singles for the Killers, scoring Tom Cruise”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10802014
M83M83“When Anthony Gonzalez started out making music, he probably didn't anticipate that he'd eventually be producing singles for the Killers, scoring Tom Cruise”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10682014
Beth OrtonCentral Reservation“Remember that time when Beth Orton released one of the greatest albums of the modern era? No? Well, don't get too worried: you're not the only one who missed”PopMatters90 9/10812014
"Weird Al" YankovicMandatory Fun“Parody is, almost by nature, disposable," Yankovic says. "And yet, people like it so much. Especially if you hear it at a certain point in your life, and”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10752014
Yeah Yeah YeahsMosquito“The greatest trick the Yeah Yeah Yeahs ever pulled was making us believe that they were a rock band.”PopMatters30 3/10652013
Maroon 5OverexposedPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10572012
The Flaming LipsThe Flaming Lips and Heady Fwends“I wouldn’t say we know a lot about music, but we know a lot about the way our audience listens to music, because they’re like us. So you know, when…”PopMatters70 7/10752012
LMFAOSorry for Party Rocking“If you're contemplating buying an album called Sorry for Party Rocking, then let's be honest: you know exactly what you're getting into.”PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10412011
WeezerPinkerton“Weezer has always been a mess of contradictions.”PopMatters via Wikipedia100 10/10812010
Miley CyrusCan’t Be Tamed“Amidst a storming array of percolating synths and stomping dance beats, Miley Cyrus' third album under her own name opens with a declarative mantra: "Don't”PopMatters via Wikipedia20 2/10472010
SpoonTransference“When you remove the layers of hype, walk away from the number of "Best of the Decade" lists that the band keeps popping up on these days, and just look…”PopMatters80 8/10772010
Basement JaxxScarsPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10702009
KleerupKleerup“If pop music history was just and fair (which it isn't), then Robyn's self-titled 2008 album (available internationally for years prior) will go down as one”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10672009
Beth OrtonTrailer Park“The problem with re-evaluating Beth Orton's debut album is simple: Trailer Park isn't actually her debut album. Then again, such a detail as that only adds to”PopMatters80 8/10812009
The Bad PlusFor All I Care“There really hasn't been a deal-breaker like this in a long, long time. The Bad Plus, as bad-ass a drum/bass/piano jazz trio as there ever was, have done the”PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10632009
Kevin RudolfIn the City“Let's start with the obvious: "Let It Rock" is one monster of a single.”PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10532009
Lady GagaThe FamePopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10672009
NickelbackDark HorsePopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10462008
Nikka CostaPebble to a Pearl“When you're the goddaughter of Frank Sinatra, there are naturally going to be some expectations about you. Often times, though, these expectations are not”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10712008
of MontrealSkeletal Lamping“Last year was pretty much the coming out party for Kevin Barnes, as exuberant an indie musician as there is, finally getting his due. In January of that year,”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10732008
The Dandy Warhols…Earth to the Dandy Warhols…PopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10432008
Death Cab for CutieNarrow Stairs“At what point does a band become something more than "just a band" to someone? At what point do they begin to directly affect someone's day-to-day life?”PopMatters70 7/10722008
Mariah CareyE=MC²PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10662008
The RaconteursConsolers of the Lonely“It all started with a phone call. A very angry phone call… to DJ Electra.”PopMatters60 6/10732008
KelisThe HitsPopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10662008
OneRepublicDreaming Out LoudPopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10492008
Angels & AirwavesI-Empire“Whenever you stand in a famous spot — like the Walk of Fame in Hollywood or the Space Needle in Seattle — do you get that strange rush knowing that…”PopMatters via Wikipedia75 7.5/10592008
She Wants RevengeThis Is Forever“Apparently, gloom-rockers can play it safe.”PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10412007
Soulja BoySouljaboytellem.com“Crank That". You've probably heard it somewhere. In a club. Out of a passing car. On YouTube (or, even better, on YouTube while mixed with video clips from”PopMatters30 3/10422007
Blaqk AudioCexCellsPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10562007
Electric SixI Shall Exterminate Everything Around Me That Restricts Me from Being the Master“When the Electric Six first appeared in 2003, they were hailed as front-runners for the title of Most Ridiculous Band of the New Millenium. After all, they”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10652007
The PipettesWe Are The Pipettes“Imagine, if you will: a world in which The B-52s were produced by Phil Spector, where "Mister Sandman" is as popular as Britney Spears' "Toxic", and”PopMatters70 7/10742007
Bat for LashesFur and GoldPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10832007
Simian Mobile DiscoAttack Decay Sustain Release“There are moments when the group brings out school ground rhymes in its (occasional) lyrics, blatantly recalling the kaleidoscopic retro-funk of another great”PopMatters70 7/10702007
The Bad PlusProgPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10792007
JoJoThe High Road“Having worked in music retail for several years, I've come across multiple people — even during the advent of iTunes — that simply didn't want to buy an”PopMatters via Wikipedia20 2/10622006
Paul McCartneyEcce Cor Meum“The biggest problem that Paul McCartney faces as a classical composer is the fact that he’s Paul McCartney. He needn’t ever release another album — he’s Paul”PopMatters50 5/10602006
Jesse McCartneyRight Where You Want MePopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10432006
Band of HorsesEverything All the TimePopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10752006
The Moody BluesDays of Future PassedPopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10902004
The VeronicasHook Me UpPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/1077
KeshaWarriorPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/1068

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home