Mac DeMarco Albums Ranked

Mac DeMarco’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 5 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 74 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.

What is Mac DeMarco’s best album?

By the critics, it’s Salad Days (2014), with a B-Side Breakdown of 82 (Keeper) from 14 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: This Old Dog (76) and 2 (75). Lowest rated: Here Comes the Cowboy (66).

Mac DeMarco albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Salad Days (2014): 82 Keeper
  2. 2. This Old Dog (2017): 76 Keeper
  3. 3. 2 (2012): 75 Keeper
  4. 4. Another One (2015): 69 Mixed Bag
  5. 5. Here Comes the Cowboy (2019): 66 Mixed Bag

Mac DeMarco discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every Mac DeMarco album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

5010070liked2 (2012): 75752012Salad Days (2014): 82822014Another One (2015): 69692015This Old Dog (2017): 76762017Here Comes the Cowboy (2019): 66662019

Every Mac DeMarco album we track, oldest first.

  1. 2012Album cover for 2 by Mac DeMarco275 Keeper
  2. 2014Album cover for Salad Days by Mac DeMarcoSalad Days82 Keeper
  3. 2015Album cover for Another One by Mac DeMarcoAnother One69 Mixed Bag
  4. 2017Album cover for This Old Dog by Mac DeMarcoThis Old Dog76 Keeper
  5. 2019Album cover for Here Comes the Cowboy by Mac DeMarcoHere Comes the Cowboy66 Mixed Bag

Which critics love Mac DeMarco, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Mac DeMarco albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

NME5 albums+9
  1. 2 201280 vs 74 from 10 others +6
  2. Salad Days 201490 vs 82 from 13 others +8
  3. Another One 201580 vs 68 from 13 others +12
  4. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  5. Here Comes the Cowboy 201980 vs 64 from 13 others +16

All NME reviews

Uncut3 albums+9
  1. 2 201280 vs 74 from 10 others +6
  2. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  3. Here Comes the Cowboy 201980 vs 64 from 13 others +16

All Uncut reviews

Mojo4 albums+7
  1. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  2. Another One 201580 vs 68 from 13 others +12
  3. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201980 vs 64 from 13 others +16

All Mojo reviews

AllMusic5 albums+5
  1. 2 201270 vs 75 from 10 others −5
  2. Salad Days 2014100 vs 81 from 13 others +19
  3. Another One 201580 vs 68 from 13 others +12
  4. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  5. Here Comes the Cowboy 201960 vs 66 from 13 others −6

All AllMusic reviews

Pitchfork5 albums+4
  1. 2 201282 vs 74 from 10 others +8
  2. Salad Days 201485 vs 82 from 13 others +3
  3. Another One 201573 vs 69 from 13 others +4
  4. This Old Dog 201779 vs 75 from 14 others +4
  5. Here Comes the Cowboy 201967 vs 65 from 13 others +2

All Pitchfork reviews

Q4 albums+2
  1. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  2. Another One 201560 vs 70 from 13 others −10
  3. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201980 vs 64 from 13 others +16

All Q reviews

PopMatters4 albums−1
  1. Salad Days 201470 vs 83 from 13 others −13
  2. Another One 201570 vs 69 from 13 others +1
  3. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201970 vs 65 from 13 others +5

All PopMatters reviews

The Guardian5 albums−2
  1. 2 201260 vs 76 from 10 others −16
  2. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  3. Another One 201580 vs 68 from 13 others +12
  4. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  5. Here Comes the Cowboy 201960 vs 66 from 13 others −6

All The Guardian reviews

musicOMH4 albums−3
  1. 2 201280 vs 74 from 10 others +6
  2. Salad Days 201490 vs 82 from 13 others +8
  3. Another One 201540 vs 71 from 13 others −31
  4. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5

All musicOMH reviews

The Observer4 albums−3
  1. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  2. Another One 201560 vs 70 from 13 others −10
  3. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201960 vs 66 from 13 others −6

All The Observer reviews

The Line of Best Fit4 albums−3
  1. 2 201280 vs 74 from 10 others +6
  2. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  3. This Old Dog 201775 vs 76 from 14 others −1
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201950 vs 67 from 13 others −17

All The Line of Best Fit reviews

Slant3 albums−4
  1. Another One 201570 vs 69 from 13 others +1
  2. This Old Dog 201760 vs 77 from 14 others −17
  3. Here Comes the Cowboy 201970 vs 65 from 13 others +5

All Slant reviews

DIY3 albums−5
  1. 2 201260 vs 76 from 10 others −16
  2. Salad Days 201480 vs 82 from 13 others −2
  3. This Old Dog 201780 vs 75 from 14 others +5

All DIY reviews

Rolling Stone4 albums−6
  1. Salad Days 201470 vs 83 from 13 others −13
  2. Another One 201570 vs 69 from 13 others +1
  3. This Old Dog 201760 vs 77 from 14 others −17
  4. Here Comes the Cowboy 201970 vs 65 from 13 others +5

All Rolling Stone reviews

The A.V. Club3 albums−6
  1. Salad Days 201485 vs 82 from 13 others +3
  2. Another One 201565 vs 69 from 13 others −4
  3. This Old Dog 201759 vs 77 from 14 others −18

All The A.V. Club reviews

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home