Robert Hilburn

Robert Hilburn

Robert Hilburn’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 115 reviews, going back to 1984, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Photo: ChrisMorris333, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia CommonsSend us your own photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Rock 31%
  • Indie & Alternative 19%
  • Folk, Country & Americana 14%
  • R&B & Soul 12%

Find Robert Hilburn

By the numbers

7A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
46albums given a perfect score
42years of their reviews we track, 1984 to 2025
How their scores spread
  • 0–492
  • 50s5
  • 60s7
  • 70s17
  • 80s38
  • 90+46

Their favorites

  1. Franz FerdinandYou Could Have It So Much Better 100 Los Angeles Times
  2. Gretchen WilsonAll Jacked Up 100 Los Angeles Times
  3. Kanye WestLate Registration 100 Los Angeles Times
  4. The White StripesGet Behind Me Satan 100 Los Angeles Times
  5. Bright EyesI’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning 100 Los Angeles Times

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

7 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 7 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Freddie KingGetting Ready…Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia50 2.5/5602025
Meat PuppetsMeat Puppets IILos Angeles Times via Wikipedia83 83/100902006
Franz FerdinandYou Could Have It So Much BetterLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4812005
Gretchen WilsonAll Jacked Up“Gretchen Wilson "All Jacked Up" (Epic) * * * * IT was easy to dismiss this late bloomer from Illinois when she exploded onto the country music scene last year…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4642005
Kanye WestLate Registration“Kanye West "Late Registration" (Roc-A-Fella/Def Jam) * * * * POP crossover isn't always a bad thing.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4832005
Faith HillFireflies“Faith Hill "Fireflies" (Warner Bros.) ** 1/2 . Forget "Fireflies.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4472005
MudhoneyPiece of CakeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4582005
The White StripesGet Behind Me SatanLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4742005
MobyHotel“Mary Gauthier "Mercy Now" (Lost Highway) *** 1/2 This fortysomething's resume doesn't prepare you for the intensity and depth of her stark, weather-beaten songs — at least not the part…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4522005
Frankie Goes to HollywoodWelcome to the PleasuredomeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4732005
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadWorlds Apart“And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead "Worlds Apart" (Interscope) *** 1/2 When a rock band follows an album as spectacular as 2002's "Source Tags and Codes"…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4632005
Bright EyesDigital Ash in a Digital Urn“Bright Eyes "Digital Ash in a Digital Urn" (Saddle Creek) *** 1/2 Unlike Bruce Springsteen and Guns N' Roses in the early '90s, Conor Oberst isn't releasing separate albums on…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4642005
Bright EyesI’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning“Conor Oberst takes stock of the political and cultural landscape with eloquence and insight in a new acoustic set from Bright Eyes.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4802005
Rufus WainwrightWant Two“Rufus Wainwright "Want Two" (DreamWorks/Geffen) **** Recorded at the same time as his engrossing 2003 album, "Want One," the 12 songs in this collection were left off that album because…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4752004
U2How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb“U2 "How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb" (Interscope) ****”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4762004
Jill ScottBeautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2“Gifted as vocalist and writer, Jill Scott makes music that recalls past masters of R&B; yet is wholly her own.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4802004
Lloyd BanksThe Hunger for MoreLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4692004
The HivesTyrannosaurus Hives“The Hives "Tyrannosaurus Hives" (Interscope) *** One reason this Swedish quintet was such a refreshing arrival here two years ago was that it came with a secret weapon: a smile.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4732004
Angie StoneStone Love“The Polyphonic Spree "Together We're Heavy" (Hollywood) *** 1/2 The opening song, "We Sound Amazed," has a reference to a "new religion.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4672004
PJ HarveyUh Huh Her“PJ Harvey "Uh Huh Her" (Island) **** As might be expected of a notoriously reclusive singer-songwriter, Harvey has repeatedly warned us against looking at her songs as autobiographical.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4762004
UsherConfessions“Usher "Confessions" (Arista) *** For someone who has sold more than 8 million albums over the last decade, Usher Raymond remains a fairly anonymous presence on the R&B-pop; scene: a…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4692004
Franz FerdinandFranz FerdinandLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4862004
Alicia KeysThe Diary of Alicia KeysLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4782003
Ryan AdamsRock n Roll“Ryan Adams "Rock n Roll" (Lost Highway) *** Ever since Bob Dylan revolutionized pop music by moving from folk music to rock in the '60s, some of our most valuable…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4652003
Rufus WainwrightWant One“Rufus Wainwright "Want You" (DreamWorks) **** This New Yorker seemed so obscenely ambitious and endlessly talented in his 1998 debut album that even a listless, undernourished follow-up three years later…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4722003
Annie LennoxBare“Metallica "St. Anger" (Elektra) *** 1/2 No slow songs. No guitar solos.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4712003
The White StripesElephantLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4882003
Whitney HoustonJust WhitneyLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia38 1.5/4472002
Rage Against the MachineRage Against the MachineLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4842002
Johnny CashAmerican IV: The Man Comes Around“Justin Timberlake "Justified" (Jive) ** Teenage girls aren't the only ones enamored with 'N Sync's most popular member.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4772002
Faith HillCry“Faith Hill "Cry" * 1/2, Warner Bros. Nashville Memo to Warner Bros.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia38 1.5/4532002
Sinéad O'ConnorSean-Nós Nua“*** JURASSIC 5 "Power in Numbers" Interscope On its sophomore album (due in stores Tuesday), Jurassic 5 proves that it's the spiritual evolution of not only South-Central hard-core such as…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4662002
Ryan AdamsDemolition“**** RYAN ADAMS "Demolition" Lost Highway Rather than release the four (!)”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4652002
The ChicksHome“*** 1/2 DIXIE CHICKS, "Home", Open Wide/Columbia The Chicks aim for music that offers a message as well as entertains, and the female country trio blends those objectives engagingly in…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4792002
Solomon BurkeDon’t Give Up on Me“*** 1/2 SOLOMON BURKE "Don't Give Up on Me" Fat Possum Burke is one of the all-time great soul singers, an artist with the character and command of such legendary…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4832002
OasisHeathen ChemistryLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia50 2/4522002
AshantiAshanti“***1/2 BADLY DRAWN BOY "About a Boy" ARTISTdirect Records/ XL Recordings Damon Gough nearly ruined the goodwill and momentum generated by his stylish 2000 album debut, "The Hour of Bewilderbeast,"…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4572002
Norah JonesCome Away with MeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4772002
Alanis MorissetteUnder Rug SweptLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4662002
Bob DylanLove and TheftLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4892001
Alicia KeysSongs in A Minor“* * * ALICIA KEYS "Songs in A Minor" J If this debut arrived as a demo on a label president's desk, chances are there'd be so much excitement that…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4752001
TravisThe Invisible BandLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4752001
R.E.M.RevealLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4702001
Erykah BaduMama’s Gun“Erykah Badu can't match the punch of 'Baduizm,' while Nine Inch Nails fares better with remixes. : *** ERYKAH BADU, "Mama's Gun," Motown”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4762000
Marilyn MansonHoly Wood“** MARILYN MANSON "Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)" Nothing / Interscope”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia50 2/4772000
Emmylou HarrisRed Dirt GirlLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4742000
GrandaddyThe Sophtware Slump“**** GRANDADDY, "The Sophtware Slump," V2”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4832000
EminemThe Marshall Mathers LP“*** 1/2, EMINEM, "The Marshall Mathers LP", Aftermath/Interscope”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4862000
Elliott SmithFigure 8“Elliott Smith has another go at the treacherous pond called love on 'Figure 8.' : *** 1/2 ELLIOTT SMITH, "Figure 8," DreamWorks”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4752000
Stevie WonderFulfillingness’ First FinaleLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4882000
Stevie WonderInnervisions“There's a scene in the marvelous new film "High Fidelity" in which a middle-aged man walks into a record store to buy his daughter a copy of Stevie Wonder's "I…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4992000
Stevie WonderMusic of My Mind“There's a scene in the marvelous new film "High Fidelity" in which a middle-aged man walks into a record store to buy his daughter a copy of Stevie Wonder's "I…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4812000
Stevie WonderTalking Book“There's a scene in the marvelous new film "High Fidelity" in which a middle-aged man walks into a record store to buy his daughter a copy of Stevie Wonder's "I…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4982000
EelsDaisies of the Galaxy“*** 1/2 EELS, "Daisies of the Galaxy," DreamWorks”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4752000
Dr. Dre2001Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4771999
StingBrand New DayLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4691999
Nine Inch NailsThe Fragile“*** 1/2 NINE INCH NAILS, "The Fragile," Nothing Records”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4741999
The ChicksFly“DIXIE CHICKS "Fly" Monument * * * Given that the Dixie Chicks' major-label debut, last year's "Wide Open Spaces," is the biggest-selling recording ever by a country duo or group…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4801999
Tom WaitsMule VariationsLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4801999
Beth OrtonCentral Reservation“*** BETH ORTON "Central Reservation" Arista Orton's 1997 album "Trailer Park" was one of the most enticing debuts in years, and this follow-up should earn the English singer-songwriter even more…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4811999
EelsElectro-Shock Blues“**** EELS "Electro-Shock Blues" DreamWorks”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4791998
HoleCelebrity SkinLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4781998
Elliott SmithXO“**** ELLIOTT SMITH "XO" DreamWorks Listening to Smith's often downcast tales of dislocation and doubt, it's not hard to place him physically in your imagination–say, the same seat at the…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4801998
Pearl JamYieldLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4771998
Curtis MayfieldSuperfly – The Original Motion Picture Soundtrack“*** CURTIS MAYFIELD, "Superfly" soundtrack.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4961998
Bob DylanTime Out of Mind“In the '60s, he said it all. But that doesn't mean Bob Dylan has run out of things to say. 'Time Out of Mind,' his new album, is despairing, hopeful,…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4871997
The ProdigyThe Fat of the LandLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4811997
k.d. langDrag“*** 1/2 k.d. lang, "Drag" Warner Bros.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4701997
The StoogesRaw Power“**** IGGY & THE STOOGES "Raw Power" Columbia/Legacy”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4931997
U2PopLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4761997
EelsBeautiful Freak“Calendar's pop staff surveyed 40 of the nation's most popular or critically acclaimed albums.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4781996
R.E.M.New Adventures in Hi-Fi“The last thing we need is another song–much less an entire album–about a band on the road.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4841996
Pearl JamNo CodeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4691996
Ani DiFrancoDilate“Even as one marveled at Ani DiFranco's wide-ranging looks at social and sexual politics on her earlier albums, one yearned for her to apply all her force to a single…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4791996
Gillian WelchRevival“GILLIAN WELCH "Revival" Almo Sounds * * * * You've got to be awfully good or unusually confident to record a song that has already been committed to disc by…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4751996
StingMercury Falling“Since leaving the Police, Sting has challenged himself so aggressively as a songwriter and musician that his best albums have come with a heavy layer of creative tension–so much so…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4671996
Lou ReedSet the Twilight Reeling“Just as Neil Young showed no sign of slowing down creatively in last year's uplifting "Mirror Ball" album, Reed–one of rock's other great elder statesmen–demonstrates that he, too, hasn't lost…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4791996
Bruce SpringsteenThe Ghost of Tom Joad“BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN "The Ghost of Tom Joad" Columbia * * * * It's easy to see why Springsteen evoked for the album's title the name of the main character in…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4761995
Rocket from the CryptScream, Dracula, Scream!“ROCKET FROM THE CRYPT "Scream, Dracula, Scream!”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4751995
Oasis(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4821995
Elton JohnMade in EnglandLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4671995
PJ HarveyTo Bring You My LoveLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4931995
The Stone RosesSecond ComingLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4631995
Pearl JamVitalogyLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4841994
R.E.M.MonsterLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4811994
various artistsNatural Born Killers“*** 1/2; VARIOUS ARTISTS, "Natural Born Killers," soundtrack ( Nothing/Interscope ) This has been a career year for Trent Reznor, who exhibits as an artist and producer the daring instincts…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4901994
The Rolling StonesVoodoo LoungeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4611994
Nine Inch NailsThe Downward SpiralLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4841994
U2ZooropaLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4831993
Wynonna JuddTell Me Why“WYNONNA JUDD "Tell Me Why" Curb/MCA * * * In her strongest moments with mama Naomi in the Judds, young Wynonna showed the vocal passion and command to become the…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4821993
PJ HarveyRid of MeLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4861993
Dinosaur Jr.Where You BeenLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4821993
Arrested Development3 Years, 5 Months & 2 Days in the Life Of…“How does Madonna's musical product compare with her literary and film endeavors?.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4811992
SugarCopper Blue“How does Madonna's musical product compare with her literary and film endeavors?.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4871992
Ice CubeThe PredatorLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4751992
Trisha YearwoodHearts in Armor“This is the album that Wynonna Judd should have made–a collection that digs deeply into the rich character of country music without ending up a prisoner of it.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4841992
PJ HarveyDryLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4861992
U2Achtung BabyLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4931991
Ice CubeDeath CertificateLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia75 3/4821991
Guns N' RosesUse Your Illusion ILos Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4811991
Guns N' RosesUse Your Illusion II“*** 1/2 GUNS N' ROSES "Use Your Illusion I" **** "Use Your Illusion II" Geffen By releasing two 76-minute albums simultaneously, Guns N' Roses lives up to its reputation as…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4821991
Garth BrooksRopin’ the Wind“** 1/2 GARTH BROOKS "Ropin' the Wind" Capitol How has Brooks been able to become the hottest figure in country music in ages with just four compelling songs an album?”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia50 2.5/5741991
Pet Shop BoysBehaviourLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia60 3/5811990
Neil Young and Crazy HorseRagged Glory“Young's "Freedom" was arguably the most compelling album of 1989 and certainly the artist's personal best in more than a decade, but one element was missing for many longtime Young…”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia80 4/5851990
Social DistortionSocial Distortion“Mike Ness is a frustratingly uneven songwriter.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia60 3/5761990
Randy TravisNo Holdin’ BackLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia50 2.5/5721989
Roy OrbisonMystery Girl“What's behind the spectacular sales of Roy Orbison's posthumous "Mystery Girl" album?”Q via Wikipedia100 5/5771989
Roy OrbisonMystery Girl“ROY ORBISON "Mystery Girl.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4771989
Tracy ChapmanTracy ChapmanLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4871988
U2Rattle and Hum“****U2. "Rattle and Hum." Island Records.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4741988
Patti Smith GroupEasterLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4851988
The SugarcubesLife’s Too Good“****THE SUGARCUBES. "Life's Too Good." Elektra.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4801988
PrinceLovesexy“****PRINCE. "Lovesexy." Paisley Park.”Los Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4801988
Tina TurnerPrivate DancerLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4851984
Cyndi LauperShe’s So UnusualLos Angeles Times via Wikipedia100 4/4841984

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home