Garth Brooks Albums Ranked

Garth Brooks’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 12 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 66 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is Garth Brooks’ best album?

By the critics, it’s No Fences (1990), with a B-Side Breakdown of 91 (Heavy Rotation) from 3 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: Scarecrow (76) and The Chase (74). Lowest rated: Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas (37).

Garth Brooks albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. No Fences (1990): 91 Heavy Rotation
  2. 2. Scarecrow (2001): 76 Keeper
  3. 3. The Chase (1992): 74 Keeper
  4. 4. Ropin’ the Wind (1991): 74 Keeper
  5. 5. Garth Brooks (1989): 72 Keeper
  6. 6. Man Against Machine (2014): 69 Mixed Bag
  7. 7. In Pieces (1993): 68 Mixed Bag
  8. 8. Gunslinger (2016): 65 Mixed Bag
  9. 9. Fresh Horses (1995): 61 Mixed Bag
  10. 10. Sevens (1997): 58 Mixed Bag
  11. 11. Beyond the Season (1992): 50 Back of the Crate
  12. 12. Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas (1999): 37 Back of the Crate

Garth Brooks discography, in release order

Every Garth Brooks studio album, oldest first. 2 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1989Album cover for Garth Brooks by Garth BrooksGarth Brooks72 Keeper
  2. 1990Album cover for No Fences by Garth BrooksNo Fences91 Heavy Rotation
  3. 1991Album cover for Ropin’ the Wind by Garth BrooksRopin’ the Wind74 Keeper
  4. 1992Album cover for Beyond the Season by Garth BrooksBeyond the Season50 Back of the Crate
  5. 1992Album cover for The Chase by Garth BrooksThe Chase74 Keeper
  6. 1993Album cover for In Pieces by Garth BrooksIn Pieces68 Mixed Bag
  7. 1995Album cover for Fresh Horses by Garth BrooksFresh Horses61 Mixed Bag
  8. 1997Album cover for Sevens by Garth BrooksSevens58 Mixed Bag
  9. 1999Album cover for Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas by Garth BrooksGarth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas37 Back of the Crate
  10. 2001Album cover for Scarecrow by Garth BrooksScarecrow76 Keeper
  11. 2014Album cover for Man Against Machine by Garth BrooksMan Against Machine69 Mixed Bag
  12. 2016Album cover for Gunslinger by Garth BrooksGunslinger65 Mixed Bag
  13. 2016Christmas TogetherNo Breakdown yet
  14. 2023Time TravelerNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love Garth Brooks, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Garth Brooks albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Robert Christgau6 albums+12
  1. Ropin’ the Wind 199185 vs 71 from 4 others +14
  2. Beyond the Season 199255 vs 49 from 4 others +6
  3. The Chase 199275 vs 74 from 4 others +1
  4. In Pieces 199385 vs 64 from 4 others +21
  5. Fresh Horses 199575 vs 57 from 4 others +18
  6. Sevens 199765 vs 55 from 3 others +10

All Robert Christgau reviews

Q3 albums+8
  1. Beyond the Season 199260 vs 48 from 4 others +13
  2. The Chase 199280 vs 73 from 4 others +8
  3. Scarecrow 200180 vs 75 from 3 others +5

All Q reviews

AllMusic12 albums+6
  1. Garth Brooks 198960 vs 76 from 3 others −16
  2. No Fences 1990100 vs 87 from 2 others +14
  3. Ropin’ the Wind 1991100 vs 68 from 4 others +33
  4. Beyond the Season 199260 vs 48 from 4 others +13
  5. The Chase 199280 vs 73 from 4 others +8
  6. In Pieces 199380 vs 65 from 4 others +15
  7. Fresh Horses 199550 vs 64 from 4 others −14
  8. Sevens 199750 vs 60 from 3 others −10
  9. Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas 199940 vs 36 from 3 others +4
  10. Scarecrow 200180 vs 75 from 3 others +5
  11. Man Against Machine 201470 vs 69 from 6 others +1
  12. Gunslinger 201680 vs 60 from 3 others +20

All AllMusic reviews

Rolling Stone5 albums−4
  1. In Pieces 199360 vs 70 from 4 others −10
  2. Sevens 199760 vs 57 from 3 others +3
  3. Scarecrow 200180 vs 75 from 3 others +5
  4. Man Against Machine 201470 vs 69 from 6 others +1
  5. Gunslinger 201650 vs 70 from 3 others −20

All Rolling Stone reviews

Entertainment Weekly10 albums−4
  1. No Fences 199093 vs 90 from 2 others +3
  2. Ropin’ the Wind 199155 vs 79 from 4 others −24
  3. Beyond the Season 199255 vs 49 from 4 others +6
  4. The Chase 199265 vs 76 from 4 others −11
  5. In Pieces 199355 vs 71 from 4 others −16
  6. Fresh Horses 199559 vs 61 from 4 others −2
  7. Sevens 199755 vs 58 from 3 others −3
  8. Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas 199947 vs 33 from 3 others +14
  9. Scarecrow 200165 vs 80 from 3 others −15
  10. Man Against Machine 201475 vs 69 from 6 others +7

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

The Rolling Stone Album Guide7 albums−17
  1. Garth Brooks 198960 vs 76 from 3 others −16
  2. No Fences 199080 vs 97 from 2 others −17
  3. Ropin’ the Wind 199180 vs 73 from 4 others +8
  4. Beyond the Season 199220 vs 58 from 4 others −38
  5. The Chase 199270 vs 75 from 4 others −5
  6. Fresh Horses 199540 vs 66 from 4 others −26
  7. Garth Brooks and the Magic of Christmas 199920 vs 42 from 3 others −22

All The Rolling Stone Album Guide reviews

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home