Rob Mitchum

Rob Mitchum’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 67 reviews, going back to 2002, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Rock 39%
  • Indie & Alternative 38%
  • Electronic 12%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 5%

Find Rob Mitchum

By the numbers

1A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
1album given a perfect score
22years of their reviews we track, 2002 to 2023
How their scores spread
  • 0–4910
  • 50s10
  • 60s18
  • 70s11
  • 80s11
  • 90+7

Their favorites

  1. The Rolling StonesExile on Main St. 100 Pitchfork
  2. Sleater-KinneyOne Beat 91 Pitchfork
  3. Neil YoungChrome Dreams 90 Uncut
  4. Brittany HowardJaime 90 Uncut
  5. Grizzly BearPainted Ruins 90 Uncut

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

1 album that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 1 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Neil YoungChrome DreamsUncut via Wikipedia90 4.5/5822023
Brittany HowardJaimeUncut via Wikipedia90 9/10842019
Grizzly BearPainted RuinsUncut via Wikipedia90 9/10792017
Neil YoungStorytone“Neil Young's new album Storytone involves ten tracks recorded live in front of an orchestra. Despite the manic activity of Neil Young's 2014—which involves a tech startup, anti-oil advocacy, a…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia48 4.8/10602014
U2Songs of Innocence“U2 have aligned with their old friends Apple to insert Songs of Innocence into all of our libraries without consent. This indisputably queasy approach to the "surprise release" gambit might…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia46 4.6/10612014
of MontrealFalse Priest“Kevin Barnes delivers more ambitious psych-pop in the vein of Hissing Fauna or Skeletal Lamping, here with help from Jon Brion and Janelle Monáe.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10702010
The Rolling StonesExile on Main St.“The 1972 classic is given a remaster and a deluxe reissue.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10992010
Titus AndronicusThe Monitor“Titus' sophomore record, a sprawling concept album loosely about the U.S. Civil War, is packed with anthems and brimming with energy and ambition.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10802010
The Flaming LipsThe Flaming Lips and Stardeath and White Dwarfs with Henry Rollins and Peaches Doing The Dark Side of the Moon“Originally conceived for a New Year's Eve show, the Flaming Lips and guests Peaches and Henry Rollins cover the Pink Floyd classic.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia52 5.2/10632010
WeezerRaditude“Melodic sing-alongs, fuzz-guitar riffs– Weezer are going back to basics, making music that sounds for (but also often by) 13-year-olds.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia45 4.5/10562009
Neil YoungChrome Dreams II“Scrapped in 1977, the original Chrome Dreams is one of rock's great lost records; 30 years later, Neil Young has decided that his new album is a sequel to that…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia56 5.6/10662007
Architecture in HelsinkiPlaces Like This“More unorthodox arrangements from a diverse Australian assemblage that is able to appear at various times as a blippy dance-punk outfit, a marching band, an a capella group, a children's…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10612007
The New PornographersChallengers“Matador's all-star power poppers return with a record that's mellow mood and baritone guitar obsession mark it more as a sequel to frontman Carl Newman's solo record The Slow Wonder…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10692007
They Might Be GiantsThe Else“Recent converts to children's rock, Johns Linnell and Flansburgh here go somewhat gracefully into their middle ages by recalling their tighter, tauter early days, when they were closer to Devo…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia53 5.3/10682007
Beastie BoysThe Mix-Up“Adam Yauch, Mike D, and Adam Horovitz are joined by longtime keyboardist Money Mark and percussionist Alfredo Ortiz on their first all-instrumental non-compilation full-length.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia46 4.6/10602007
The White StripesIcky Thump“After the straightforward radio-rock trappings of the Raconteurs, the back-to-basics Icky Thump packs an unexpected freshness, resulting in the best White Stripes album in years.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10812007
WilcoSky Blue Sky“Despite the experimental pedigree of their new lineup, Wilco's sixth album finds them receding into the comfort zone. The result is an album that exposes the dad-rock gene the band…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia52 5.2/10752007
Modest MouseWe Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank“Modest Mouse follow the unlikely success of "Float On" by recruiting former Smiths guitarist Johnny Marr and gently nudging toward new directions. The Shins' James Mercer guests.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10752007
Electric Light OrchestraOut of the BluePitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10732007
of MontrealHissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?“Of Montreal's darkest and most experimental record to date, Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer gorily chronicles frontman Kevin Barnes' recent relationship woes, all while rebuilding the band as a…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10752007
Tom WaitsOrphans: Brawlers, Bawlers & Bastards“This 3xCD box set is compartmentalized into style-segregated discs and features 30 new songs alongside a smattering of outtakes, soundtrack cuts, and other rarities.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10862006
MogwaiZidane: A 21st Century Portrait (soundtrack)“Scottish post-rockers provide the soundtrack for an experimental feature that follows Zinedine Zidane throughout the course of one full Real Madrid match.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10622006
The WhoEndless WirePitchfork via Wikipedia47 4.7/10662006
The KillersSam’s Town“Much-maligned band follows the crossover hit Hot Fuss by switching its influences from the Cure and 1980s UK new wave to Bruce Springsteen and 1970s earnest U.S. classic rock.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10672006
The Whitest Boy AliveDreams“Kings of Convenience leader and self-proclaimed "singing DJ" Erlend Øye returns with his most "rock" effort to date.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia71 7.1/10742006
MSTRKRFTThe Looks“Death From Above 1979 bassist Jesse Keeler's spinoff project makes rock/dance hybrids that buck the fizzling trend of loose-limbed post-punk in favor of a more classically house-minded approach.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10692006
PhoenixIt’s Never Been Like That“Third album from the meticulous French band finds its members loosening their ties, unbuttoning their cuffs, and coming across as the soft-rock Strokes.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10732006
The RaconteursBroken Boy Soldiers“The White Stripes' Jack White heads this Midwest supergroup, which also includes fellow Michigander Brendan Benson and the rhythm section from I-75 commuters the Greenhornes.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10712006
Red Hot Chili PeppersStadium Arcadium“2xCD set of arena-friendly songs about California, sex, and having sex in California is split between slightly askew mid-tempo pop and regrettable relapses into funk and muso noodling.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia47 4.7/10712006
Nine Inch NailsPretty Hate MachinePitchfork via Wikipedia56 5.6/10772006
The DarknessOne Way Ticket to Hell… and BackPitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10662005
Fiona AppleExtraordinary MachinePitchfork via Wikipedia62 6.2/10812005
The New PornographersTwin Cinema“The Canadian power-pop supergroup's latest full-length is its most consistent, confident, and best album to date.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10812005
R. KellyTP.3 Reloaded“After a 2xCD examination of stepping and Jesus, Kels returns with an album about sex.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10672005
GorillazDemon Days“Most musicians have their own toy boxes, the places they hide away all the obsessions and experiments that don't …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10772005
WeezerMake Believe“After a couple of free passes, the third album from the 21st century incarnation of Weezer uses up the band's last shred of nostalgia-driven goodwill.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia4 0.4/10582005
Architecture in HelsinkiIn Case We Die“The Aussie octet's latest LP is reminiscent of the ecstatic impatience and pretentious-pop charm of the Fiery Furnaces' Blueberry Boat and Animal Collective's Sung Tongs, with multiple metamorphoses within each…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia88 8.8/10722005
EelsBlinking Lights and Other Revelations“Latest from the pop depressive is a sprawling, ambitious, two-disc work.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10812005
BeckGuero“Contemporary rock's top chameleon gives the people what they want, drafting in the Dust Brothers to try to recapture his Odelay persona and sound.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia66 6.6/10772005
Scott HerrenSurrounded by Silence“Scott Herren follows two LPs of pioneering glitch-hop with a more guest-heavy third full-length, one that includes appearances from the Books, El-P, and a handful of Wu-Tang Clan members.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10682005
MobyHotelPitchfork via Wikipedia24 2.4/10522005
Nine Inch NailsThe Downward Spiral“Interscope takes further advantage of the holiday shopping blowout with this deluxe edition of yet another 90s alt-rock staple. Here's Trent Reznor's best-known (and most highly regarded) work, The Downward…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10832004
Kings of ConvenienceRiot on an Empty Street“Following the breakthrough success of Erlend Øye's phenomenal DJ Kicks, as well as his more dance-oriented solo material and a Kings of Convenience remix record, it would make sense for…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10722004
WilcoA Ghost Is Born“At the time of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot's non-traditional 2001 "release," I was in the midst of a two-year exile …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia66 6.6/10742004
Kanye WestThe College DropoutPitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10822004
The StrokesRoom on FirePitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10782003
Neil Young and Crazy HorseAmerican Stars ‘n BarsPitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10732003
Neil YoungHawks & DovesPitchfork via Wikipedia57 5.7/10632003
Neil Young and Crazy HorseRe·ac·torPitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10632003
Death in VegasScorpio Rising“Much ado is being made lately about rock bands masquerading as electronic acts. From Radiohead's voyages into squiggly experimentation …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10682003
Junior SeniorD-D-Don’t Don’t Stop the BeatPitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10732003
CursiveThe Ugly Organ“Hey you. Yeah, you, holding a copy of A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius with an Adaptation ticket stub for …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia70 7/10802003
Erlend ØyeUnrest“When you think of a diva, probably the last person that comes to mind is Erlend xD8ye. In terms of …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10802003
Nada SurfLet Go“Alright, let's just get this out of the way right up front, real fast: I'mheadoftheclassI'mPOPULARI'maquarterbackI'mPOPULAR …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia38 3.8/10702003
Cody ChesnuttThe Headphone MasterpiecePitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10812003
The Mountain GoatsTallahassee“MINUTES FROM THE 2002 ANNUAL MEETING OF THE CONCEPT ALBUM SOCIETY As I'm sure you are all aware, 2002 …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10792002
Death Cab for CutieYou Can Play These Songs with Chords“Wanna make a home copy of You Can Play These Songs with Chords for free, without taking your chances of …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10592002
of MontrealAldhils Arboretum“Everyone knows the traditional band progression goes something”Pitchfork via Wikipedia61 6.1/10742002
Ben KwellerSha Sha“Welcome to the Hall of Bens, young master Kweller. We've had our eyes on you for some time now …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10642002
IdlewildThe Remote Part“I remember when people thought I was going to be the next Radiohead. From morning to night, I was tailed …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10752002
Sleater-KinneyOne Beat“I have issues with women in rock. Not so much the actual act of female human beings playing that rock …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10832002
The StreetsOriginal Pirate Material“Hey, did you hear? Hip-hop is a world phenomenon now! Yes, spend some time poking around your favorite music magazine …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10862002
OasisHeathen Chemistry“Q: So I'm told you have a rather controversial theory about art, is that true? A: Yes, and it …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia12 1.2/10522002
Sonic YouthMurray StreetPitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10782002
WeezerMaladroitPitchfork via Wikipedia54 5.4/10692002
Zero 7Simple ThingsPitchfork via Wikipedia53 5.3/10762002
Neil YoungAre You Passionate?Pitchfork via Wikipedia75 7.5/10592002

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home