Matt LeMay

Matt LeMay’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 45 reviews, going back to 1999, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 62%
  • Rock 20%
  • Electronic 9%
  • Pop 7%

Find Matt LeMay

By the numbers

3A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
3albums given a perfect score
24years of their reviews we track, 1999 to 2022
How their scores spread
  • 0–493
  • 50s3
  • 60s5
  • 70s8
  • 80s10
  • 90+16

Their favorites

  1. R.E.M.Reckoning 100 Pitchfork
  2. Elvis CostelloThis Year’s Model 100 Pitchfork
  3. …And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadSource Tags & Codes 100 Pitchfork
  4. Elvis CostelloMy Aim Is True 98 Pitchfork
  5. WeenGodWeenSatan: The Oneness 96 Pitchfork

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

3 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 3 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
The Magnetic FieldsLove at the Bottom of the SeaThe A.V. Club via Wikipedia59 B-652022
R.E.M.Collapse into Now“Their first LP since the 1997 departure of Bill Berry that sounds unmistakably like themselves, this is also R.E.M.'s best record in that time.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10702011
The Soft BoysUnderwater Moonlight“These reissues forgo liner note-heavy fanfare and supplement Soft Boys' two proper full-lengths with a wealth of illuminating demos, live tracks, and EP cuts.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10932010
Paul BanksJulian Plenti is… Skyscraper“Interpol's Paul Banks resurrects his Eurotrash-y recording alias and puts out a solo album not-so-hot on the heels of his band's first truly not-good record.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia62 6.2/10652009
R.E.M.ReckoningPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10882009
Nick LoweJesus of Cool“Equal parts shimmering disco and dingy pub, with frequent surprisingly coherent stylistic asides, Nick Lowe's clever, fierce, and far-reaching 1978 album is re-released with a handful of well-chosen bonus tracks…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia93 9.3/10892008
Fountains of WayneTraffic and Weather“Adam Schlesinger's group follows its surprise hit "Stacy's Mom" with a record of more of the same– chugging verses, big choruses, and utter mediocrity.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia30 3.0/10652007
Bat for LashesFur and GoldPitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10832007
The ShinsWincing the Night AwayPitchfork via Wikipedia70 7.0/10772007
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadSo Divided“The Austin band aims to rectify indie backlash and mainstream indifference with this elaborately orchestrated and structured new album.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia55 5.5/10672006
Will OldhamThe Letting Go“On his latest record, Will Oldham enlists the help of Faun Fables vocalist Dawn McCarthy to create a record that presents the humor, dread, and resignation that inform his best…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10802006
The Dresden DollsYes, Virginia…“On its second LP, this theatrical two-piece smoothes out some of the rougher edges of its debut but still transforms misery into pleasurable artifice– making music that's at once accessible…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10742006
The Beta BandHeroes to Zeros“It's been said that any truly great song can remain just as recognizable and distinctive when broken down to …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10742004
Modest MouseGood News for People Who Love Bad News“Early in their career, Modest Mouse accomplished what may be the ultimate goal of any band: to forge a…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10812004
Xiu XiuFabulous Muscles“Ever since the release of their 2002 debut Knife Play, Xiu Xiu frontman Jamie Stewart has been hard at work …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10722004
PeachesFatherfucker“There are plenty of perfectly good ways to say "I don't give a fuck." Unfortunately, screaming "I don't …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia35 3.5/10672003
The ShinsChutes Too Narrow“Reality television, actors-turned-governors, and wrestlers-turned-rappers aside, it's hard to think of many things that elicit cynicism and offhand dismissal …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia89 8.9/10842003
M83Dead Cities, Red Seas & Lost Ghosts“Sometimes I think it can't be a matter of simple coincidence that sound, when rendered visually, appears as ever-changing …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia92 9.2/10802003
The New PornographersElectric Version“Generally speaking, "supergroup" isn't a word that gets thrown around a lot. The term is usually reserved for one-off …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10752003
Elvis Costello & the AttractionsArmed ForcesPitchfork via Wikipedia95 9.5/10862003
The Postal ServiceGive Up“To tell you the truth, it never even occurred to me. Sure, there were the countless nights spent listening only …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10832003
Guided by VoicesUniversal Truths and CyclesPitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10622002
Elvis CostelloThis Year’s ModelPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10922002
Elvis CostelloMy Aim Is True“Once upon a time, being a bitter, frustrated male musician didn't mean being a jerkass. Perpetually wronged and rarely …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia98 9.8/10902002
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadSource Tags & Codes“Some music begs to be explored. Promising fascination and intrigue beyond your wildest dreams, its distant melodies beckon you towards …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia100 100/100792002
Modest MouseEverywhere and His Nasty Parlour Tricks“There's a very fine line between insight and clichxE9. It's common logic that then things that …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10692001
WeenGodWeenSatan: The Oneness“It's easy to scoff at juvenile humor. You hear a single utterance of "fuck" or "pussy," and you turn …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia96 9.6/10742001
They Might Be GiantsMink Car“If Hollywood has taught us anything, it's that every hardcore geek is nothing but a popular kid in bulky …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia28 2.8/10602001
MúmYesterday Was Dramatic – Today Is OK“Surprises are the best. Once, when I was in kindergarten, my mom pulled men out of school in the …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10872001
The Beta BandHot Shots II“There's a reason that shampoo bottles tell you to rinse and repeat. And no, it isn't just to …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10762001
R.E.M.RevealPitchfork via Wikipedia50 5.0/10702001
MogwaiRock Action“There are a few things in this world I'm pretty sure of. One of them is that,n in …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10742001
Bill CallahanSewn to the SkyPitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10602001
Will OldhamEase Down the Road“Throughout history, prophecy and insight have been regarded as two of the greatest misfortunes that can befall a human being …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10812001
Guided by VoicesIsolation Drills“Tonight, the people of Dayton, Ohio will sleep a sound sleep. Children, tuckedn tight in their beds, will dream …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia70 7.0/10752001
TortoiseStandards“There's something inherently non-anthemic about the type of music that's comen to be known as "post-rock." In …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia92 9.2/10762001
GoldfrappFelt Mountain“If you'd told me a few weeks back that I'd be lusting after some chickn named Goldfrapp …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10752000
The MicrophonesIt Was Hot, We Stayed in the Water“Rock musicians have always drawn inspiration from fairly eclectic sources. Painters,n poets, writers, and filmmakers have been providing fodder …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia92 9.2/10822000
Shellac1000 Hurts“A few days ago, a friend of mine asked what the difference between a film producern and a music …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10742000
Super Furry AnimalsMwng“For a territory only slightly larger than New Jersey, Wales has done pretty well for itself.n Besides having its …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10772000
WeenWhite Pepper“White Pepper. It took me a while to get it. It wasn't until I opened up Ween's latest …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10712000
Bill CallahanDongs of Sevotion“Recently, my mind has been occupied with the knowledge that death is not only inevitable, but can occur at any …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia93 9.3/10792000
Thee Silver Mt. ZionHe Has Left Us Alone but Shafts of Light Sometimes Grace the Corner of Our Rooms…“Is it me, or was Y2K a total bust? Call me crazy, but I was genuinely hoping thatn something …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10832000
DwarvesCome Clean“Here at Pitchfork, we do our best to take an unbiased approach to music criticism. But, like itn or …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10652000
The AvalanchesSince I Left YouPitchfork via Wikipedia95 9.5/10831999

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home