Sheldon Pearce

Sheldon Pearce’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 93 reviews, going back to 2013, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Hip-Hop & Rap 84%
  • R&B & Soul 6%
  • Indie & Alternative 4%
  • Pop 2%

Find Sheldon Pearce

By the numbers

1album given a perfect score
10years of their reviews we track, 2013 to 2022
9outlets their reviews here ran in
How their scores spread
  • 0–494
  • 50s11
  • 60s26
  • 70s25
  • 80s23
  • 90+4

Their favorites

  1. Dr. DreThe Chronic 100 Pitchfork
  2. Ol' Dirty BastardReturn to the 36 Chambers: The Dirty Version 93 Pitchfork
  3. DMXIt’s Dark and Hell Is Hot 90 Pitchfork
  4. LogicUnder Pressure 90 HipHopDX
  5. Digable PlanetsReachin’ 87 Pitchfork

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Nicki MinajThe Pinkprint“The A.V. Club digs deep into film, TV, music, games, books and more.”The A.V. Club via Wikipedia65 B712022
Juice WrldLegends Never Die“The rapper’s posthumous album opens up to tackle his own legacy, as demons lurk around every corner”The Guardian via Wikipedia60 3/5752020
John LegendBigger Love“The R&B star’s latest ode to the power of love bursts with positive energy, but there’s an emptiness beneath.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10632020
Run the JewelsRTJ4“On their fourth installment, Killer Mike and El-P are back to tune up the ruling class and the racist police state, this time streamlining the process and settling into their…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10882020
Ol' Dirty BastardReturn to the 36 Chambers: The Dirty VersionPitchfork via Wikipedia93 9.3/10772020
Jay ElectronicaA Written Testimony“After years of waiting and mounting hype, Jay Electronica’s fantastic debut is a mystical, distinctive work that nearly lives up to all the lore surrounding the rapper.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10782020
Lil BabyMy Turn“The Atlanta rapper tries to tell the story of his rise to fame on his guest star-packed new album, but the music is all work and no inspiration.”Pitchfork66 6.6/10652020
Lil WayneFuneral“With his big legacy album Tha Carter V out of the way, Weezy is back in the booth and cruising, experimenting with an array of styles and a dizzying maze…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10632020
Mac MillerCircles“The first posthumous album from Mac Miller plays like a companion piece to Swimming. It’s an optimistic epilogue to the life of an aspirational artist.”Pitchfork74 7.4/10822020
Dr. DreThe Chronic“Each Sunday, Pitchfork takes an in-depth look at a significant album from the past, and any record not in our archives is eligible. Today, we revisit the timeless 1992 debut…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10812019
Gang StarrOne of the Best Yet“It’s thrilling to hear them again, but once the glow wears off, there’s a hollowness to this posthumous project, cobbled together from unreleased Guru vocal takes.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia63 6.3/10722019
Brittany HowardJaime“The exceptional solo debut from the Alabama Shakes singer-songwriter is a thrilling opus that pushes the boundaries of voice, sound, and soul to new extremes.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10842019
CommonLet Love“Common’s latest is a loungy meditation on love and its many forms. It is at turns hopeful and naive.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10682019
RapsodyEve (Rapsody album)“Rapsody’s third record is a triumph. The North Carolina MC unlocks her full skillset and brings her creativity and ingenuity to the fore.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10882019
BrockhamptonGinger“After a brief hiatus, the restlessly creative group returns with a compelling but disjointed record about self-fulfillment.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10712019
Trippie Redd!“Trippie Redd’s sprawling album is designed to show his versatility, but it’s not nearly wild enough to distract from its lack of coherent ideas.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia55 5.5/10582019
Burna BoyAfrican Giant“The Nigerian singer blends the personal and political into a new benchmark of Afro-fusion music.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10772019
Chance the RapperThe Big Day“Chance’s sprawling, 77-minute “debut” is an exuberant and often wonderful celebration of love and family that struggles to bring depth to his newlywed dad-raps.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10722019
Willow SmithWillow“The latest album from the child star turned Star Child can be pretty in a tuned-out sort of way, but her psychedelic soul music is no closer to showing us…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia62 6.2/10612019
MaseHarlem World“Each Sunday, Pitchfork takes an in-depth look at a significant album from the past, and any record not in our archives is eligible. Today, we revisit the debut album from…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10772019
Denzel CurryZuu“The South Florida rapper puts on for his city and delivers the best, most dynamic, and altogether hardest album of his career.”Pitchfork83 8.3/10782019
YG4Real 4Real“YG pays heartfelt tribute to the late Nipsey Hussle on his latest while still reserving plenty of vitriol for his favorite targets: broke dudes, snitches, broke dudes who also snitch.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia72 7.2/10672019
Anderson .PaakVentura“After the hard left turn of Oxnard, Paak sinks back into the bubbly smooth grooves that got him noticed.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10792019
Little SimzGrey Area“The third album from the 25-year-old UK fire-spitter is a wickedly assured, highly entertaining, coming-of-age marvel.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10862019
2 ChainzRap or Go to the League“The Atlanta rapper rewrites the rulebook on winning on his most thoughtful album.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10772019
GunnaDrip or Drown 2“The drowsy Atlanta rapper polishes his style and submits some of his best songs, but the same thing that makes Gunna dependable also makes him predictable.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10762019
The CartersEverything Is Love“With 'Everything Is Love,' Jay-Z and Beyonce complete their trilogy of albums with a powerful celebration of love, family and legacy.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5782018
BTSLove Yourself: TearPitchfork via Wikipedia71 7.1/10722018
YoungBoy Never Broke AgainUntil Death Call My Name“The 18-year-old Baton Rouge rapper’s debut album is packed with allegories on power that illuminate but don’t apologize for his well-publicized history of violence.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10652018
SmokepurppBless Yo TrapPitchfork via Wikipedia48 4.8/10592018
Jean GraeEverything’s Fine (Jean Grae and Quelle Chris album)“Part biting satire, part cognitive behavioral therapy, Jean Grae and Quelle Chris’ collaboration is a hilarious, caustic, and gorgeous consideration of what it really means to be “fine” today.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10762018
Young FathersCocoa Sugar“The latest from the experimental rap trio is chaotic but sleek, a streamlined presentation of the singular style Young Fathers have crafted.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10812018
Lil YachtyLil Boat 2“A sequel in name only, Yachty’s leaden, rap-heavy album demands that the listener accept Yachty on his terms and shamelessly argues that he can be anything he wants to be.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia58 5.8/10512018
Nipsey HussleVictory Lap“The long-awaited debut from the Los Angeles rapper cashes in on its promise. It’s the most gripping record in his catalog.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10772018
Digable PlanetsReachin’“The jazz rap trio’s 1993 debut questions the very fabric of our existence while celebrating its nuances.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10842018
Rich BrianAmen“The debut from Rich Brian has the fun, wit, and snark of a choice tweet but lacks the essential qualities of a solid well-made rap album.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10632018
JeezyPressurePitchfork via Wikipedia63 6.3/10642017
BrockhamptonSaturation III“It's on their third album this year that rap crew BROCKHAMPTON’s whole gestalt comes into focus. There are more memorable performances, and more fascinatingly unorthodox compositions servicing them.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia75 7.5/10762017
21 SavageWithout Warning“The two rappers and producer strike a devious, almost perfect balance on their mixtape released on Halloween, where supernatural frights are replaced by guns and goons.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10692017
Young ThugSuper Slimey“This surprise-released collaboration sees the Atlanta rappers finally finding common ground, though neither is in peak form. Super Slimey forgoes explosiveness and poignancy for streamlined action.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia71 7.1/10652017
Meek MillWins & Losses“After freeing himself from the feuds and narrative that dragged him down, Meek Mill’s third studio album is a comeback by any measure, honest and gripping.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10642017
Tyler, the CreatorFlower Boy“On Tyler’s sincere and most accomplished album, he gets to the essence of what he's been chiseling at: the angst of a missed connection, the pain of unrequited love, and…”Pitchfork85 8.5/10802017
French MontanaJungle RulesPitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10722017
21 SavageIssa Album“The ambitious debut from 21 Savage features some of the best producers around, but the young rapper doesn't have the finesse to break out beyond his horror-film style.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10672017
Jay-Z4:44“The most crafty and evasive MC lays bare his complicated life. This late-career gem is soulful and diamond-sharp, confronting the failings and legacy of Shawn Carter and America.”Pitchfork84 8.4/10812017
Vince StaplesBig Fish Theory“On his second album, Vince Staples teams with producers like SOPHIE, Jimmy Edgar, and Flume on a collection of sleek club-rap bangers. But his eye for detail and observational skills…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10842017
Lil YachtyTeenage Emotions“Yachty is our master of joy. His debut album is well-polished and full of pop-rap confections, but his polarizing style hardly captures the nuance suggested by the album’s cover and…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10612017
LogicEverybodyPitchfork via Wikipedia52 5.2/10622017
Puff Daddy & The Diddymen FamilyNo Way Out“Puff Daddy's luxurious 1997 debut plays as both a cautionary tale and an affront to mortality. We examine its history on the 20th anniversary of the death of Christopher Wallace.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10652017
DMXIt’s Dark and Hell Is HotPitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10692017
FutureFuturePitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10692017
Run the JewelsRun the Jewels 3“RTJ3 is essentially the Run the Jewels manifesto, an outpouring of rage and defiance that never loses sight of the objectives: rallying the troops, holding all accountable, and toppling oppression.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10832017
Ab-SoulDWTWPitchfork via Wikipedia44 4.4/10632016
J. Cole4 Your Eyez Only“The rapper and activist takes aim at mass incarceration, police brutality and toxic masculinity on his much anticipated follow up to Forest Hill Drives”The Guardian via Wikipedia60 3/5672016
FugeesBlunted on RealityPitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10642016
Mac MillerThe Divine Feminine“As a loose concept record about the many subtleties of love and distance, the Pittsburgh rapper’s new release is the most surprising, concise, and accomplished album of his career.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10682016
Young ThugJeffery“The rap iconoclast returns with his best album since Barter 6, daring and chameleonic, filled with hooks about identity, love, and that undefinable future swag.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia85 8.5/10782016
AtmosphereFishing Blues“The Minneapolis rapper-producer duo Atmosphere over-share on their sloppy and tedious new album, though it still contains a few gripping moments.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia56 5.6/10652016
Rae SremmurdSremmLife 2“SremmLife 2, the follow-up to the turbocharged rap duo's joyous debut SremmLife, is stranger, artsier, and flat-out ballsier than its predecessor.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10722016
Lil Uzi VertThe Perfect Luv Tape“Lil Uzi Vert's latest mixtape comes at a moment of fever-pitch buzz for the young rapper, reaffirming his talent for synthesizing trends into a catchy melodic soup.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10622016
KaHonor Killed the SamuraiSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10832016
YGStill Brazy“Compton rapper YG's follow up to 2014's My Krazy Life parts with DJ Mustard's snaps and dips into rich, classic g-funk, while YG grapples with the contradictions of being a…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10802016
Aesop RockThe Impossible KidPitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10782016
A$AP FergAlways Strive and Prosper“5SPIN Rating: 5 of 10Release Date: April 22, 2016Label: A$AP Worldwide / Polo Grounds / RCAA$AP Ferg was always on pace to, at best, be A$AP Mob’s Scottie”Spin via Wikipedia50 5/10682016
Royce da 5'9"Layers“Royce 5’9” has done his most visible rapping as a plus-one. Trying to move beyond that supporting role, he loads his sixth solo album with big-time producers, skits, and careful…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10742016
Big SeanTwenty88“Twenty88 is the chosen name of the duo of rapper Big Sean and R&B singer Jhené Aiko. As a pair, they complement each other well, and the battle-of-the-sexes theme manages…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10722016
Young ThugSlime Season 3“The final installment of Young Thug's Slime Season trilogy is a lean, 8-track offering without filler that moves rather seamlessly. It also feels like the end of a holding pattern,…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10732016
Lil YachtyLil Boat“This Atlanta rapper with a cult hit under his belt ("1 Night") brings to mind iLoveMakonnen. He inhabits a post-regionalist rap universe, a space defined by digital platforms rather than…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia48 4.8/10592016
2 ChainzColleGrove“2 Chainz made a name for himself by following his mentor Lil Wayne’s lead, but the pair’s new collaborative album finds the teacher struggling to keep up with his student.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10672016
FutureEvol“With every passing release, Future grows more confident, and more callous.”Consequence via Wikipedia75 B+702016
Anderson .PaakMalibu“7SPIN Rating: 7 of 10Release Date: January 15, 2016Label: EMPIRE / OBE / Steel Wool / Art ClubTime has always been of the essence for Brandon Paak”Spin via Wikipedia70 7/10812016
G-EazyWhen It’s Dark Out“G-Eazy is a white indie rapper from the Bay Area who has built a sizable cult fanbase. His second record, When It's Dark Out, is a deliberately serious affair that…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10692015
!!!As If“Dance-punk outfit continues to lose the remaining remnants of punk in their sound.”Consequence via Wikipedia51 C712015
Fetty WapFetty Wap“Get your hip hop album reviews, rap and R&B reviews from the best music review website on the web. We have all the latest music reviews from today’s top artists.”HipHopDX via Wikipedia50 2.5/5682015
DrakeWhat a Time to Be AlivePitchfork via Wikipedia70 7.0/10672015
Travis ScottRodeoPitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10642015
The WeekndBeauty Behind the MadnessThe A.V. Club via Wikipedia65 B692015
Dr. DreComptonThe A.V. Club via Wikipedia75 B+772015
Chief KeefBang 3“Get your hip hop album reviews, rap and R&B reviews from the best music review website on the web. We have all the latest music reviews from today’s top artists.”HipHopDX via Wikipedia70 3.5/5702015
Public EnemyMan Plans God Laughs“The group is back from a three-year hiatus with its 13th studio album, Man Plans God Laughs*,* a timely release that repackages classic Public Enemy motifs for a renewed struggle.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia62 6.2/10652015
Albert Hammond, Jr.Momentary Masters“The Strokes guitarist's latest is the husk of a great rock album without a personality to inhabit it.”Consequence via Wikipedia51 C682015
Ghostface KillahTwelve Reasons to Die II“If Twelve Reasons to Die was based on a comic, then its sequel is the cinematic adaptation or a reboot of the franchise; the source material is the same, but…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia72 7.2/10712015
ShlohmoDark Red“Sophomore LP barrels through existential dread with blaring, distorted noise, as if shouting into the void.”Consequence via Wikipedia59 B-672015
LogicUnder PressureHipHopDX via Wikipedia90 4.5/5672014
Yung LeanUnknown Memory“Yung Lean (formerly Yung Lean Doer) is a Sad Boy. That isn’t so much a literal or definitive label — a representation of his mood or psyche — as it…”Tiny Mix Tapes via Wikipedia70 3.5/5622014
BirdmanRich Gang: Tha Tour Pt. 1HipHopDX via Wikipedia80 4.0/5802014
Dilated PeoplesDirectors of Photography“An album that preserves the "real" rap that purists fawn over.”Consequence via Wikipedia59 B-742014
50 CentAnimal AmbitionHipHopDX via Wikipedia40 2.0/5502014
Led ZeppelinLed Zeppelin“How did the critics miss this one?”Consequence via Wikipedia85 A-872014
FutureHonest“In a class of eccentrics, only one can stand as the most dynamic.”Consequence via Wikipedia75 B+752014
Rick RossMastermindHipHopDX via Wikipedia60 3.0/5642014
HopsinKnock MadnessXXL via Wikipedia80 4/5702013
f(x)4 WallsPitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/1074

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home