Philip Sherburne

Philip Sherburne’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 73 reviews, going back to 2006, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

  • Pitchfork 2006–2026 · 56 reviews
  • Spin 2011–2014 · 17 reviews

What they review

  • Electronic 75%
  • Indie & Alternative 14%
  • Pop 7%
  • R&B & Soul 3%

Find Philip Sherburne

By the numbers

2albums given a perfect score
21years of their reviews we track, 2006 to 2026
2outlets their reviews here ran in
How their scores spread
  • 0–492
  • 50s7
  • 60s5
  • 70s19
  • 80s31
  • 90+9

Their favorites

  1. Aphex TwinSelected Ambient Works Volume II 100 Pitchfork
  2. BjörkHomogenic 100 Pitchfork
  3. PortisheadDummy 95 Pitchfork
  4. StereolabMars Audiac Quintet 91 Pitchfork
  5. Hercules & Love AffairHercules and Love Affair 91 Pitchfork

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
ORMusic for Empty StadiumsPitchfork69 6.9/10not yetNov 16, 2026
Boards of CanadaInfernoPitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/1084May 29, 2026
Oneohtrix Point NeverTranquilizerPitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/1081Nov 17, 2025
JusticeHyperdramaPitchfork via Wikipedia63 6.3/10692024
Laurel HaloAtlasPitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10802023
DisclosureAlchemyPitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10742023
Beach HouseOnce Twice MelodyPitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10812022
ArcaKICK iiPitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10772021
ArcaKicK iiiPitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10782021
ArcakiCK iiiiiPitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10772021
Arcakick iiiiPitchfork via Wikipedia77 7.7/10772021
SealSealPitchfork74 7.4/10712021
The AvalanchesWe Will Always Love YouPitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10812020
Oneohtrix Point NeverMagic Oneohtrix Point Never“Daniel Lopatin’s latest doesn't swerve in a new direction but instead serves as an overlook for his career, highlighting his skill at splicing the old and the new in continually…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia77 7.7/10752020
Adrianne LenkerSongs and Instrumentals“Read Philip Sherburne’s review of the albums.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia88 8.8/10852020
AutechreSIGNPitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10752020
Four TetSixteen Oceans“Kieran Hebden’s latest album of club-ready barnstormers and downbeat daydreams feels like a companion to 2017’s New Energy.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10702020
Dan SnaithSuddenly“Dan Snaith’s latest is as sly and layered as ever, but he finds ways to be more direct with his songwriting. There are no bum notes, no wasted motions, no…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10842020
The KLFChill Out“Each Sunday, Pitchfork takes an in-depth look at a significant album from the past, and any record not in our archives is eligible. Today, we revisit the KLF’s sample-heavy dreamscape,…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia89 8.9/10792020
Bill CallahanKnock KnockPitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10832020
SwansLeaving Meaning“Michael Gira reshuffles his famous band's lineup, inviting collaborators like the Necks and Ben Frost for a record that emphasizes elegiac beauty over raging catharsis.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia77 7.7/10762019
StereolabMars Audiac Quintet“Stereolab's third album, the hardest-rocking and most hypnotic music the band ever set to tape, is the closest they came to replicating the jet-engine roar of their live shows.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10792019
Everything but the GirlAmplified Heart“Though their 1994 album became most famous for a surprise hit remix, Tracey Thorn and Ben Watt’s spare, pensive style never sounded more fully realized than here.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10812019
Flying LotusFlamagra“On Steven Ellison’s sixth album, his sweeping jazz-funk feels limitless. It sounds more like a sketchbook with FlyLo crafting each minute with great care and technical dexterity.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10782019
Aphex TwinSelected Ambient Works Volume IIPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10752019
Toro y MoiOuter Peace“Chaz Bear delivers a smartly crafted, comfortably mid-fi album of grooves and melancholy—one of his best albums in years.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10712019
James BlakeAssume Form“There’s a suffocating seriousness that runs through the singer and producer’s fourth album, one that bogs down genuine moments of levity and love.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia58 5.8/10812019
Thom YorkeSuspiria“Luca Guadagnino’s remake of a horror classic features Yorke tackling a broader range of styles and ideas than any of his previous solo work, and all of them shine.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10772018
MGMTLittle Dark Age“MGMT’s fourth album marks a shift in tactics. Abandoning the belabored excess of their last two albums, they opt for streamlined synth-pop.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia70 7.0/10742018
Fever RayPlunge“On her second album as Fever Ray, Karin Dreijer is more conflicted, more manic—and more in love, too.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10842017
OdeszaA Moment Apart“The electronic duo Odesza are at the center of the current movement in stadium-filling ”chill” music. Their latest is full of billowing vocal harmonies, seismic rumble, and turbo-charged trap beats.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia58 5.8/10672017
PortisheadDummyPitchfork via Wikipedia95 9.5/10892017
The ChainsmokersMemories…Do Not OpenPitchfork via Wikipedia42 4.2/10462017
BjörkHomogenic“Homogenic embraced all of Björk’s most provocative contradictions. The main theme is the wish to rush headlong into a life lived to the fullest—an unbridled yearning for the sublime.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10852017
Deadmau5W:/2016ALBUM/“On his latest, EDM titan deadmau5 continues to hint that he might have a better, richer album in him. Once more, he has not made it.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10562016
CassiusIbifornia“The French duo resurface with their first album in 10 years, slamming together the Balearic reverie of Ibiza and the pop-chart tank-top vibe of California, not always to great effect.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10612016
ArcaEntrañas“The electronic artist Arca's latest unclassifiable release is darker than his stunning 2015 LP Mutant; it’s heavier and more unrelenting.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10792016
Beth OrtonKidsticks“Written and produced in Los Angeles with Andrew Hung of Fuck Buttons, Beth Orton's latest is anxious, playful, and sounds little like anything the singer/songwriter has done before.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10772016
Tim HeckerLove Streams“Love Streams marks a subtle shift in Tim Hecker's habitual style, a pivot away from his hazy trademark.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10792016
The FieldThe Follower“The Field's Axel Willner is among electronic music's most doggedly consistent musicians. Virtually all of his songs are built atop techno's steady pulse, but they share ambient music's domestic utility:…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10742016
Eric PrydzOpusPitchfork via Wikipedia62 6.2/10742016
This HeatThis Heat“This Heat perfected a strange and volatile new strain of avant-garde rock—by turns thundering and ephemeral, hopeful and wry, surgically precise and caveman-crude. You can hear in their slim catalog,…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia90 9.0/10872016
SwansLove of Life“In a half-decade span beginning in the mid '80s, Swans swiftly transformed from bone-crushing no wave brutalists to God-fearing gothic rockers, and then to featherweight neo-folkies. White Light from the…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10672015
SwansWhite Light from the Mouth of Infinity“In a half-decade span beginning in the mid '80s, Swans swiftly transformed from bone-crushing no wave brutalists to God-fearing gothic rockers, and then to featherweight neo-folkies. White Light from the…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10802015
Oneohtrix Point NeverGarden of Delete“Garden of Delete is unlike anything that Daniel Lopatin has done, in terms of technique, mood, or scope. It is denser than his previous albums, by several orders of magnitude.…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10762015
Jean-Michel JarreElectronica 1: The Time Machine“In many ways, French producer Jean-Michel Jarre is a natural fit for today's electronic music culture, with its fireworks and bombast. Borrowing a page from Giorgio Moroder's playbook, he returns…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia40 4.0/10662015
Martin GoreMG“Martin Gore of Depeche Mode's new solo album is an all-synthesizer affair, and in its restraint and its moodiness, it turns inward, not outward. To listen to it feels a…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia72 7.2/10652015
The ProdigyThe Day Is My EnemyPitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10732015
ArcaXen“So far, Arca is best known as a producer. He's already produced some of FKA twigs' best work, he's co-producing Björk's next album, and he had a hand in four…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10792014
FKA twigsLP1“FKA twigs' first full-length is a monumental debut. On a formal level, it takes the kinds of risks that few pop artists, and few "experimental" artists, for that matter, are…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia88 8.8/10862014
SwansTo Be Kind“9SPIN Rating: 9 of 10Release Date: May 13, 2014Label: Young GodIt will come as no surprise to learn that one of the most frequently used words on Swans”Spin via Wikipedia90 9/10862014
Duck SauceQuack“5SPIN Rating: 5 of 10Release Date: April 15, 2014Label: Fools GoldDuck Sauce ain't rocket science. From the beginning, the genius of A-Trak and Armand Van”Spin via Wikipedia50 5/10692014
SkrillexRecess“7SPIN Rating: 7 of 10Release Date: March 18, 2014Label: OWSLA/Big Beat/Atlantic"Dance like it hurts to stand still," sings Chance the Rapper on "Coast Is”Spin via Wikipedia70 7/10592014
Neneh CherryBlank ProjectSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10822014
Tim HeckerVirgins“9SPIN Rating: 9 of 10Release Date: October 15, 2013Label: KrankyAt the risk of falling prey to the Intentional Fallacy, it seems safe to surmise that Tim”Spin via Wikipedia90 9/10832013
AviciiTrueSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10632013
Julia HolterLoud City Song“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: August 20, 2013Label: DominoWhile the sidewalk vultures cluck over their Frappuccinos and the sun slices up the”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10852013
RudimentalHome“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: August 06, 2012Label: Atlantic/Big BeatThey grow up so fast! In the summer of 2011, London's Rudimental released their”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10692013
Fuck ButtonsSlow Focus“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: July 24, 2013Label: ATPThe line between the dance floor and the void has rarely felt more porous than in 2013, a year”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10772013
DisclosureSettle“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: June 03, 2013Label: PMRDisclosure's debut album opens with an extended sample swiped from a motivational speaker's pep”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10812013
The KnifeShaking the Habitual“9SPIN Rating: 9 of 10Release Date: April 09, 2013Label: muteThe run-up to the Knife's new album has been treated like some vast, baffling performance-art”Spin via Wikipedia90 9/10792013
ZeddClaritySpin via Wikipedia50 5/10572012
Laurel HaloQuarantine“7SPIN Rating: 7 of 10Release Date: June 05, 2012Label: HyperdubNY synth-pop lone wolf enacts spine-tingling stare-down between gauzy synths and hard,”Spin via Wikipedia70 7/10782012
Oneohtrix Point NeverReplica“The futurist Ray Kurzweil believes that we'll upload ourselves to the Net, abandoning mortal meatspace to live forever in silicon. He calls it the”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10792011
SBTRKTSBTRKT“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: June 28, 2011Label: Young Turks/XLStop me if you've heard this one before: U.K. producer dons mask, breaks with his”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10742011
James BlakeJames Blake“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: March 22, 2011Label: Atlas/A&MJames Blake is an unlikely subject for the hype machine. His first EP, in 2009, skulked”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10782011
Oneohtrix Point NeverReturnal“After the sprawling Rifts, one of drone's top new artists returns with a more focused yet more complex album.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10802010
Jamie LidellJim“On Jim Jamie Lidell remains obsessed with the themes of emotional imbalance, self-doubt, and dual identity that he introduced on 2005's Multiply, and the singer deepens his engagement with classic…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia79 7.9/10772008
Hercules & Love AffairHercules and Love Affair“DFA introduces Andrew Butler, a compelling new voice in American dance music. His debut album is a self-contained, self-assured set that runs vintage styles through a restless compositional imagination to…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10812008
BurialUntrue“The dubstep artist follows his critically acclaimed debut with the even richer*,* more complex, and more enveloping Untrue, a record of reverb-heavy and mournful songs that feel almost like beautiful…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10892007
TrentemøllerThe Last ResortPitchfork via Wikipedia72 7.2/10842006
Ellen AllienOrchestra of Bubbles“This immersive record combines Allien's melodic, electro-infused techno and Apparat's often melancholic, detail-packed, granular bit-crunchings.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia85 8.5/10822006
Deadmau54×4=12Spin via Wikipedia50 5/1065

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home