Noel Gardner

Noel Gardner’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 31 reviews, going back to 2001, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 26%
  • Rock 23%
  • Electronic 23%
  • Metal & Punk 19%

Find Noel Gardner

By the numbers

16years of their reviews we track, 2001 to 2016
2outlets their reviews here ran in
65%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (31 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–492
  • 50s1
  • 60s4
  • 70s10
  • 80s14
  • 90+0

Their favorites

  1. HindsLeave Me Alone 80 NME
  2. Roots ManuvaBleeds 80 NME
  3. Tim HeckerVirgins 80 NME
  4. Fuck ButtonsSlow Focus 80 NME
  5. DeerhoofBreakup Song 80 NME

Every review

Outlet
HindsLeave Me Alone“Spanish indiepoppers Hinds have already found a larger audience for their music than would seem likely from its boisterous, lo-fi clatter. Only operating as a full band since 2014, last…”NME via Wikipedia80 4/5712016
Roots ManuvaBleeds“Ever since Roots Manuva’s first foray into UK hip-hop in the mid-’90s, he’s been celebrated for what he isn’t as much as what he is. When the 43-year-old (real name…”NME via Wikipedia80 4/5722015
LowOnes and Sixes“As long as Minnesota’s minimal rock institution Low can continue making albums, there will surely be people eager to buy them. ‘Ones And Sixes’ is their eleventh in just over…”NME via Wikipedia70 7/10762015
MelvinsTres Cabrones“Toasting 30 years of surliness this year, the line-up of Pacific Northwestern sludge-rock absurdists the Melvins has rarely been fixed: if it’s founder member Buzz Osborne plus two grannies on…”NME via Wikipedia60 6/10682013
Tim HeckerVirgins“Compulsive iTunes genre taggers might wind up hating Tim Hecker. The Canadian musician works at a foggy spaghetti junction of ambient drone, modern classical composition and speaker-testing noise, but never…”NME via Wikipedia80 8/10832013
Fuck ButtonsSlow Focus“There have been noise acts in the past who have achieved some degree of commercial success, and there will be plenty more in the future. But the career arc of…”NME via Wikipedia80 8/10772013
Yo La TengoFade“Having spent nearly 30 years in a self-sufficient well-liked band is probably fair compensation, but you do wonder if New Jersey indie vets Yo La Tengo are vexed by everyone…”NME via Wikipedia70 7/10792013
DeerhoofBreakup Song“Eighteen years since their first baby steps as a band, Deerhoof honour Aaliyah by confirming that age ain’t nothing but a number. The quartet are pretty much middle-aged now, but…”NME via Wikipedia80 4/5732012
BaronessYellow & Green“The first couple of releases from Baroness packed a fair old punch. ‘Red Album’ and ‘Blue Record’ were concoctions of crusty sludge-metal as baking as a summer in their home…”NME via Wikipedia60 6/10792012
Dirty ProjectorsSwing Lo MagellanNME via Wikipedia70 7/10812012
Laurel HaloQuarantine“In previous years, Field Day’s had a bit of a bad rep – only two toilets, only 12 per cent volume, moan moan moan, etc. This year: problems resolved. So,…”NME via Wikipedia60 6/10782012
James FerraroFar Side Virtual“There’s a lot to admire about James Ferraro, and for better or worse there’s no-one really like him in modern underground music, but you need to be…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia70 7/10692011
The FieldLooping State of MindNME via Wikipedia80 8/10842011
Wolves in the Throne RoomCelestial Lineage“It’s largely futile to try and define Wolves in the Throne Room by the standards of American black metal, or the genre as a whole.”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia80 8/10842011
BorisHeavy Rocks“The thing about going about your biz in the way Boris have done for most of their existence, switching styles from release to rele”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia70 7/10702011
Queens of the Stone AgeQueens of the Stone Age“Recalls a time when to see a band list Queens Of The Stone Age as an influence wouldn’t have told you they were going to be shit, as it now…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia80 8/10732011
SwansMy Father Will Guide Me up a Rope to the Sky“My Father Will Guide Me Up A Rope To The Sky sounds more like the essence of Michael Gira than the Angels Of Light ever did, and ought to also…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia80 8/10822010
RobynBody Talk Pt. 1“It would be a shame to abandon her essence, but at this point she could probably cast aside chart-topping thoughts and go for it.”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia70 7/10762010
808 StateEx:el“They’re a definitive ‘less is more’ band, 808 State. When they just had some clonky synths and a fresh’n’frightening new batch of records to fuel t…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia70 7/10782010
Andrew W.K.Close Calls with Brick WallsNME via Wikipedia70 7/10712010
High on FireSnakes for the Divine“Although this doesn’t quite scale the heights of their two previous LPs, Death Is This Communion and Blessed Black Wings, it shouldn’t be thought o…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia70 7/10832010
ConvergeAxe to Fall“While not quite as revelatory as 2001’s Jane Doe – the band’s staunchest fans wouldn’t believe such a claim anyway – Axe To Fall makes good with an…”Drowned in Sound via Wikipedia80 8/10862009
Fu ManchuCalifornia CrossingNME via Wikipedia80 4/5662005
Puddle of MuddCome Clean“As a trawl through the archives sparks a resurgent flurry of interest in the Nirvana legend, this turns up with alarming punctuality. A cockle-warmingly all-American success story, Wes Scanlin was…”NME via Wikipedia50 2.5/5522005
MinistryGreatest Fits“At the time it seemed silly; Ministry’s shock-rock oxymoron of high camp machismo. Like who wants some dick called Al banging on about “anal fuckfests” and shagging cows onstage when…”NME via Wikipedia70 7/10752005
Sébastien TellierL’incroyable VéritéNME via Wikipedia80 4/5562005
IncubusMorning View“Oh, but aren’t Incubus just the full package? That tan-centric Californian gestation. A cast-iron pin-up vocalist, Brandon Boyd, who has the name and the looks of a vaguely recognisable ‘Home…”NME via Wikipedia40 2/5652005
Gary NumanPure“He may have been roundly mocked by the populace in his alleged halcyon days for being a Tory, a fifth-rate Bowie impersonator, and having difficulty landing his plane, but squat…”NME via Wikipedia20 2/10462005
Kings of ConvenienceQuiet Is the New Loud“Well, that’s a mighty bold statement, plastered across the sleeve of Kings Of Convenience’s debut album. Especially when it’s overlaying a picture of the Norwegian duo themselves, droid-like archetypes of…”NME via Wikipedia80 8/10682005
FantômasThe Director’s Cut“For Mike Patton, it’s all about walking the knife edge; dedicating oneself to doing the last thing people expect of you. When the scatological excesses of Faith No More became…”NME via Wikipedia80 8/10822005
Linkin ParkHybrid TheoryNME via Wikipedia60 6/10752001

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home