Andy Baber

Andy Baber’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 70 reviews, going back to 2011, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 54%
  • Rock 17%
  • Pop 13%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 7%

Find Andy Baber

By the numbers

8years of their reviews we track, 2011 to 2018
64%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (70 albums)
9points, on average, between their release-week reviews and where the other critics ended up (50 reviews)
How their scores spread
  • 0–495
  • 50s7
  • 60s18
  • 70s18
  • 80s16
  • 90+6

Their favorites

  1. The xxI See You 90 musicOMH
  2. Young FathersWhite Men Are Black Men Too 90 musicOMH
  3. Jamie TCarry on the Grudge 90 musicOMH
  4. Wild BeastsPresent Tense 90 musicOMH
  5. Hot ChipIn Our Heads 90 musicOMH

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Frank TurnerBe More Kind“The message at the heart of Frank Turner’s seventh solo record Be More Kind is a simple one on the face of it – and is spelled out by its…”musicOMH via Wikipedia70 3.5/5742018
BlossomsCool Like You“Since bursting onto the scene in 2015 with their best-known tune, the irresistibly addictive single Charlemagne, Blossoms have made no bones about what they aim to achieve through their music.”musicOMH via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762018
EditorsViolence“On the surface, everything about the sixth album from Editors suggests the perpetual gloom-mongers are about to explore new depths of darkness. Described”musicOMH via Wikipedia70 7/10752018
The WombatsBeautiful People Will Ruin Your Life“It is testament to The Wombats’ staying power that they have defied their detractors over the years and established themselves one of the most reliable”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5622018
Foo FightersConcrete and Gold“When a band has been around for as long as Foo Fighters, it’s understandable that a feeling of indifference might grow towards each new album release.”musicOMH70 3.5/5692017
Arcade FireEverything Now“Marketing has become increasingly intertwined with every new Arcade Fire release as the years have passed and the band’s profile has soared. It appeared”musicOMH70 3.5/5722017
StormzyGang Signs & Prayer“When Kanye West enlisted the help of the UK’s biggest grime artists for his performance at the Brits in 2015, few imagined that it would be the start of a”musicOMH80 4/5812017
The xxI See You“No matter how you frame it, January is widely regarded as a bit of a bummer. Whether it’s because of the Christmas comedown, the horribly cold weather or”musicOMH90 4.5/5802017
Jimmy Eat WorldIntegrity Blues“After more than two decades as a band and with eight studio albums under their belt, it would have been easy for Jimmy Eat World to stick to what they”musicOMH60 3/5722016
Green DayRevolution Radio“Green Day’s long career has often been punctuated by remarkable highs and difficult lows. From the monumental success of their major-label debut Dookie”musicOMH60 3/5722016
Danny BrownAtrocity Exhibition“Atrocity Exhibition may be Danny Brown’s fourth LP, but the Detroit rapper doesn’t look at it that way. “I feel like this is the first Danny Brown album,”musicOMH80 4/5832016
Kaiser ChiefsStay Together“There is very little that Kaiser Chiefs haven’t done over the years to keep themselves relevant. Appear on a talent show? Done it. Release an album”musicOMH40 2/5572016
White LiesFriends“It is often all too easy for bands to be pigeonholed. First impressions count in the music industry and White Lies are a perfect example of a band who”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5562016
BastilleWild WorldmusicOMH via Wikipedia70 3.5/5702016
Jake BuggOn My One“There is a lot riding on On My One for Jake Bugg – according to the man himself, that is. “You wanna do this job forever, don’t you?” the Nottingham”musicOMH40 2/5512016
The KillsAsh & Ice“The magnetic pairing of Jamie Hince and Alison Mosshart have been coming together to thrill audiences as The Kills for more than 15 years now. While the”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5672016
LadyhawkeWild ThingsmusicOMH via Wikipedia80 4/5662016
The Last Shadow PuppetsEverything You’ve Come To Expect“No one knew quite what to expect when Arctic Monkeys’ frontman Alex Turner and Miles Kane teamed up to form The Last Shadow Puppets in 2007. Arctic”musicOMH60 3/5712016
WeezerWeezer“For many, Weezer’s last outing, Everything Will Be Alright In The End, marked something of a return to form for the band. While their ninth effort was not”musicOMH70 3.5/5642016
Iggy PopPost Pop Depression“It's quite remarkable to think that almost forty years have passed since Iggy Pop released his first two solo albums, 1977's The Idiot and Lust For Life.”musicOMH70 3.5/5802016
The 1975I like it when you sleep, for you are so beautiful yet so unaware of it“Despite their obvious mainstream appeal, The 1975 have been divisive since they burst onto the scene with their already extensive collection of”musicOMH60 3/5732016
Kanye WestThe Life of Pablo“There’s only one Kanye West. Love him or hate him, the man is out there on his own when it comes to his creative output. Whether it’s through his music,”musicOMH80 4/5742016
Benjamin ClementineAt least for now“From being homeless in Camden and busking on the Paris streets to having a Mercury Prize-nominated début album, there are not many rises to prominence”musicOMH80 4/5782015
The Dead WeatherDodge and Burn“When he is not preoccupied with (allegedly) trying to start a fight with one half of The Black Keys, Jack White is usually busy making music. The former”musicOMH60 3/5712015
Chris CornellHigher Truth“There are few voices in rock that are quite as distinctive as Chris Cornell's. It is a vocal that has been around for almost three decades, ever since the”musicOMH60 3/5612015
Lana Del ReyHoneymoon“Lana Del Rey has managed to carve out a nice little niche for herself ever since her debut single Video Games propelled her into the spotlight. After”musicOMH70 3.5/5742015
The LibertinesAnthems for Doomed Youth“It was a rise and fall like no other. In fact, if the story of The Libertines was pitched as a film to someone with no prior knowledge of the…”musicOMH80 4/5702015
Jess GlynneI Cry When I Laugh“It feels like Jess Glynne has been around for years. In reality, the 25-year-old was a complete unknown until her name popped up on Clean Bandit’s”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5542015
The WombatsGlitterbug“There are few albums with the infectious charm of The Wombats’ debut, A Guide To Love, Loss And Desperation, which was released in 2007. No, it wasn’t the”musicOMH40 2/5532015
Young FathersWhite Men Are Black Men Too“Few people had really heard of Young Fathers before they were nominated for the 2014 Mercury Prize for their debut studio album Dead. That changed when”musicOMH90 4.5/5832015
James BayChaos and the Calm“There really is no getting around it. Other than Madonna’s dramatic fall and Kanye West’s controversial performance, this year’s BRIT Awards were a”musicOMH50 2.5/5552015
Mark KnopflerTracker“Despite the obvious pedigree of former Dire Straits frontman Mark Knopfler, few could have expected his seventh solo effort, 2012’s double album”musicOMH60 3/5682015
Charli XCXSucker“Timing is everything in the music industry; just ask Azealia Banks how damaging album release delays can be. It is even more important in the world of”musicOMH70 3.5/5752015
José GonzálezVestiges and Claws“>An eight-year gap between albums is a long time for any artist, let alone someone as successful as José González. The Swedish singer-songwriter”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5722015
OK GoHungry Ghosts“Mention OK Go to most music sorts in the know and the first thing that comes to mind is the Los Angeles-based band’s unique videos. While the alternative”musicOMH70 3.5/5702015
Jessie WareTough Love“If she was under pressure to replicate her debut's success, it certainly doesn’t show. Here exudes the confidence of an artist at the peak of her powers”musicOMH80 4/5722014
Jamie TCarry on the Grudge“His third record ends a process that has seen him write 180 songs over the last five years, with only 12 making the final cut”musicOMH via Wikipedia90 4.5/5812014
Vance JoyDream Your Life Away“For Australian singer-songwriter James Keogh, better known as Vance Joy, his debut album could not be more appropriately titled. Dream Your Life Away sums”musicOMH via Wikipedia50 2.5/5642014
alt-JThis Is All Yours“Coming just weeks after the nominations for the 2014 Mercury Prize were announced, it seems highly appropriate that the winners of the award two years”musicOMH70 3.5/5702014
The VinesWicked Nature“Much has changed in the world of The Vines since they first made a name for themselves 12 years ago with their highly acclaimed debut album, Highly”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5542014
Paolo NutiniCaustic Love“Eight long years have passed since Scottish singer-songwriter Paolo Nutini burst onto the scene as a young 19-year-old with his poignant love ballad Last”musicOMH80 4/5822014
Kaiser ChiefsEducation, Education, Education And War!“Kaiser Chiefs have never again reached the heights of their 2005 debut album Employment. In fact, it wouldn’t be unfair to say that the career of the”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5592014
Paloma FaithA Perfect Contradiction“It has often been a case of style over substance when it comes to the career of London singer-songwriter Paloma Faith, ever since she arrived on the scene”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5562014
Wild BeastsPresent Tense“The rise of Wild Beasts since the release of their critically-acclaimed debut Limbo, Panto in 2008 has been nothing short of remarkable. Providing a much”musicOMH90 4.5/5852014
Angel OlsenBurn Your Fire for No Witness“Following on from her engrossing debut album Half Way Home, Missouri-born Angel Olsen has turned things up a notch with her latest effort Burn Your Fire”musicOMH70 3.5/5802014
EminemThe Marshall Mathers LP“More than 13 years have passed since Eminem released 2000’s seminal The Marshall Mathers LP, a record that is still to this day rightly considered to be”musicOMH80 4/5862013
Cage the ElephantMelophobia“Following the release of their self-titled debut album and its standout single Ain’t No Rest For The Wicked in 2008, it seemed only a matter of time”musicOMH80 4/5722013
BirdyFire WithinmusicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5622013
London GrammarIf You Wait“Of the buzz bands that have come through in 2013, London Grammar’s rise has probably been the most steady and natural. They formed in 2009 when vocalist”musicOMH70 3.5/5722013
Naughty BoyHotel Cabana“Before the release of his super catchy Number 1 single La La La, it’s highly likely that many would have been unaware of the name Naughty Boy, aka Shahid”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5662013
BabyshamblesSequel to the Prequel“What can you say about Pete Doherty that has not already been said? There is rarely a dull moment in the life of Babyshambles’ frontman, but unfortunately”musicOMH80 4/5622013
King Krule6 Feet Beneath the Moon“For those who have followed King Krule, a.k.a. teenager Archy Marshall, since he first started releasing music under his previous guise of Zoo Kid, it has”musicOMH80 4/5742013
Robin ThickeBlurred Lines“For many, the name Robin Thicke meant very little before the American R&B artist took the charts by storm this year with his megahit Blurred Lines,”musicOMH20 1/5582013
Crystal FightersCave Rave“It’s almost three years since Crystal Fighters released their debut album, Star Of Love, to a good, if somewhat mixed, reception. While their unique style”musicOMH via Wikipedia70 3.5/5632013
30 Seconds to MarsLove Lust Faith + Dreams“As you would expect for a band led by a film star, 30 Seconds To Mars are not a band to do things by halves when it comes to promoting…”musicOMH40 2/5642013
Fall Out BoySave Rock and Roll“After announcing that they would be taking an indefinite hiatus in November 2009, few would have expected to see the return of Fall Out Boy so soon. Yet,”musicOMH50 2.5/5692013
Eric ClaptonOld SockmusicOMH via Wikipedia50 2.5/5512013
Laura MvulaSing to the Moon“It’s been a remarkable rise for Birmingham soul singer Laura Mvula since she made the decision to send off two demos in the hope of escaping her job as a”musicOMH50 2.5/5732013
Biffy ClyroOpposites“Since the release of 2007’s magnificent Puzzle, Biffy Clyro have seen their popularity slowly rise, working hard to establish themselves as one of the”musicOMH70 3.5/5702013
Bat for LashesThe Haunted Man“After releasing two albums to universal critical acclaim, it would be easy to struggle under the weight of expectation when taking on album number three.”musicOMH80 4/5762012
Mark KnopflerPrivateering“Mark Knopfler will always be known as the lead guitarist and songwriter for British rock band Dire Straits, but his solo work since that band disbanded in”musicOMH80 4/5752012
Of Monsters and MenMy Head Is an Animal“It’s been a strange old rise to prominence for Icelandic six-piece Of Monsters And Men. They have been kind of a big deal in their homeland since they won”musicOMH80 4/5782012
Lianne La HavasIs Your Love Big Enough?“Lianne La Havas’ debut album has been a long time coming compared to some of her fellow artists shortlisted for BBC Sound Of 2012. In fact, her name was”musicOMH70 3.5/5702012
Hot ChipIn Our Heads“Their best album from start-to-finish continues to show their deft range – from infectious disco hits to soulful ballads”musicOMH90 4.5/5782012
alt-JAn Awesome Wave“Coming up with a band name that’s original enough to stand out from the crowd can be a taxing task. Four-piece ∆ (or alt-J) hit upon the jackpot when”musicOMH90 4.5/5722012
Joey RamoneYa Know?“There is always something rather unsettling about posthumous releases. This is partly due to the fact that they tend to be an effective vehicle for”musicOMH50 2.5/5602012
Patrick WatsonAdventures in Your Own Backyard“Canada's recent, documented-to-death tendency of producing fine musical treats is not restricted to Broken Social Scene and the brilliant Arcade Fire.”musicOMH70 3.5/5712012
of MontrealParalytic Stalks“With 11 albums in 15 years, it’s fair to say that American psychedelic rock group Of Montreal aren’t ones for sitting around and twiddling their thumbs in”musicOMH50 2.5/5682012
BirdyBirdy“With a voice that defies her tender years, Birdy, aka Jasmine Van den Bogaerde, has found herself very quickly touted as one of the brightest”musicOMH via Wikipedia60 3/5592011
Plan BIll ManorsmusicOMH via Wikipedia80 4/579

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home