Spin Alternative Record Guide

Spin Alternative Record Guide’s 713 album reviews that count toward Breakdowns, going back to 1995, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Record guide (book)

Top critics

See all 47 critics

267 reviews with no named critic yet.

What it reviews

  • Rock 39%
  • Indie & Alternative 18%
  • Metal & Punk 13%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 9%
  • Pop 8%

By the numbers

73average score it gives, on the 0 to 100 scale (713 reviews)
71%of its reviews score an album 70 or higher
20points: how far a typical review lands from its own average score
How its scores spread
  • 0–4984
  • 50s42
  • 60s84
  • 70s121
  • 80s161
  • 90+221

Its top scores

  1. Ornette ColemanOf Human Feelings 100
  2. Throwing MusesThrowing Muses 100 Evelyn McDonnell
  3. CanSoon Over Babaluma 100
  4. Meat PuppetsMeat Puppets II 100 Rob Sheffield
  5. The Modern LoversThe Modern Lovers 100 Rob Sheffield
  6. Young Marble GiantsColossal Youth 100 Eric Weisbard
  7. Richard ThompsonShoot Out the Lights 100
  8. Richard & Linda ThompsonI Want to See the Bright Lights Tonight 100

Its newest 200 reviews

Critic
Graham ParkerBurning Questionsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10572023
Fela KutiBeasts of No Nationnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10622022
Gilberto GilSoy Loco por Ti Americanot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10692022
Caetano VelosoCirculadônot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10762022
The Gun ClubLucky Jimnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10702021
Giant SandRampnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10732021
Linton Kwesi JohnsonTings an’ Timesnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10762021
Fela KutiFela’s London Scenenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10762014
Fela KutiNo Agreementnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10792014
Fela KutiShuffering and Shmilingnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832014
The Modern LoversJonathan Richman and the Modern LoversRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10742013
Red KrayolaMalefactor, Adenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10462012
Red KrayolaThe Red Krayolanot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10682012
Red KrayolaKangaroo?not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10642012
Red KrayolaSoldier-Talknot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10642012
Half JapaneseFire in the Skynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10702011
Johnny ThundersHurt Menot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10632010
Sun RaOther Planes of Therenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10842009
Ornette ColemanOf Human Feelingsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10852009
Teena MariePassion PlayJonathan Bernstein
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10572009
Nick LoweThe Abominable Showmannot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10542009
The CrampsPsychedelic JungleJesse Berrett
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10742009
WipersSilver Sailnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10632008
Lee "Scratch" PerryBattle of Armagideonnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10632008
PainkillerGuts of a Virginnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10572008
John ZornLocus Solusnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10762008
Jungle BrothersJ Beez wit the Remedynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10622008
The BeatWha’ppen?Will Hermes
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10732008
Tom VerlaineWords from the Frontnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10632008
Cabaret VoltaireRed MeccaMark Sinker
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10802008
Royal TruxTwin InfinitivesSimon Reynolds
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10732007
Schoolly DWelcome to Americanot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10562007
Schoolly DAm I Black Enough for You?not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10632007
Schoolly DHow a Black Man Feelsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
30 3/10482007
The LemonheadsLickRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10732007
Cabaret VoltaireInternational LanguageMark Sinker
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10702007
MC LyteLyte as a RockRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10742007
ChicTongue in Chicnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10652007
ChicReal PeopleBarry Walters
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10782007
Teena MarieWild and PeacefulJonathan Bernstein
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10692007
Public Image Ltd.That What Is Notnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 2/10472007
Mark LaneganWhiskey for the Holy GhostMichael Azerrad
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10812007
SwansLove of LifeAndy Newman
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6.0/10672007
SwansWhite Light from the Mouth of Infinitynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10802007
Cabaret Voltaire2×45Mark Sinker
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10702007
Glenn BrancaThe AscensionByron Coley
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852007
Brian EnoFourth World, Vol. 1: Possible MusicsAnn Powers
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852007
Lyle LovettLyle LovettGreg Sandow
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10782007
Lyle LovettLyle Lovett and His Large BandGreg Sandow
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10722007
AC/DCDirty Deeds Done Dirt CheapEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10712007
Rollins BandLife TimeJames Hannaham
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10632007
Throbbing GristleD.o.A: The Third and Final Report of Throbbing GristleNeil Strauss
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10752007
Throbbing GristleThe Second Annual ReportNeil Strauss
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10692006
ChicC’est ChicBarry Walters
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832006
Everything but the GirlBaby the Stars Shine BrightRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10602006
Everything but the GirlLove Not MoneyRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10622006
Everything but the GirlThe Language of LifeRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10612006
Everything but the GirlWorldwideRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10572006
Iggy PopBlah Blah BlahMark Rubin
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10552006
Red KrayolaParable of Arable LandByron Coley
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10862006
The Afghan WhigsUp in Itnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10602006
Babes in ToylandSpanking MachineJohnny Huston
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10632006
SwansThe Great AnnihilatorAndy Newman
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10762006
The Gun ClubFire of LoveSteve Anderson
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10802006
The Gun ClubMiamiSteve Anderson
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10802006
BuzzcocksA Different Kind of TensionBarry Walters
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10812006
BuzzcocksLove BitesBarry Walters
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10842006
Everything but the GirlIdlewildRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10692006
Throwing MusesThrowing MusesEvelyn McDonnell
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10872006
The ChillsSubmarine BellsEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10802006
Cabaret VoltaireMicro-PhoniesMark Sinker
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10702006
John CaleVintage ViolenceAnn Powers
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10742006
Soul AsylumWhile You Were OutCharles Aaron
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10662006
The Human LeagueReproductionRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
20 2/10642006
John ZornThe Big Gundownnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10932006
SwansChildren of Godnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10682006
SwansGreednot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10632006
Yo La TengoFakebooknot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10782006
Neneh CherryHomebrewCharles Aaron
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10812006
Yo La TengoMay I Sing with Menot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10602006
Yo La TengoPresident Yo La TengoRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10792006
George ClintonThe Cinderella Theorynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10722006
FlipperGone Fishin’not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10652006
SuicideSuicide: Alan Vega and Martin Revnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10852006
David ByrneUh-Ohnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10622006
The ShaggsPhilosophy of the WorldAndy Newman
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10822006
Pere UbuSong of the Bailing Mannot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10632006
MobyMobynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10782006
Kool Moe DeeInterludenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10572006
The Go-BetweensTallulahEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10832006
The Go-BetweensLiberty Belle and the Black Diamond ExpressEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10862006
The Go-BetweensBefore HollywoodEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10782006
The Go-BetweensSpring Hill FairEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10842006
Slick RickThe Ruler’s Backnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10672006
Digital UndergroundSex Packetsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10772006
Boogie Down ProductionsBy All Means NecessaryDream Hampton
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10892006
The BeatSpecial Beat Servicenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10792006
John CaleSlow DazzleAnn Powers
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10842006
EPMDStrictly BusinessCheo Coker
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10902006
The Psychedelic FursThe Psychedelic FursJames Hannaham
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10752006
The Psychedelic FursTalk Talk TalkJames Hannaham
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10872006
Tom VerlaineDreamtimeRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10742006
Prefab SproutSwoonAndrew Goodwin
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10752006
Marianne FaithfullBroken EnglishGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10852006
Everything but the GirlEdenRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10822006
Jon Spencer Blues ExplosionExtra WidthRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10822006
Prefab SproutFrom Langley Park to MemphisAndrew Goodwin
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10722006
The Jesus LizardGoatNatasha Stovall
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10792006
SwansFilthAndy Newman
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10752006
The KLFWho Killed The JAMs?not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10732006
Napalm DeathFear, Emptiness, Despairnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10762006
Graham ParkerStick to MeGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10752006
The KLF1987not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10682006
Billy BraggBrewing Up with Billy BraggGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10762006
Lou ReedLegendary HeartsNeil Strauss
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10812006
Graham ParkerSqueezing Out SparksGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10862006
Lou ReedThe Bellsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10612006
The Magnetic FieldsDistant Plastic Treesnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10642006
Graham ParkerHeat TreatmentGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852006
Aztec CameraHigh Land, Hard RainJohnny Huston
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10892006
The PretendersLearning to CrawlAnn Powers
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10882006
Bad BrainsRock for LightNatasha Stovall
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10752006
RockpileSeconds of PleasureRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10832006
Screaming TreesBuzz FactoryMichael Azzerad
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10732006
CanCannot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10552006
CanLandednot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10602006
CanSoon Over Babalumanot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10742006
Soul II SoulClub Classics Vol. OneJonathan Bernstein
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10872006
Brian EnoMusic for Filmsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10752006
FugaziMargin Walkernot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10782006
Everything but the GirlAmplified HeartRenée Crist
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10812006
Mark LaneganThe Winding SheetMichael Azerrad
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10702006
Throbbing Gristle20 Jazz Funk GreatsNeil Strauss
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10812006
Scritti PolittiCupid & Psyche 85Rob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10882006
Lou ReedThe Blue Masknot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10882006
American Music ClubCaliforniaEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832006
Billy IdolCyberpunknot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
10 1/10392006
Queen LatifahBlack Reignnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10642006
Soul AsylumMade to Be BrokenCharles Aaron
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10682006
Meat PuppetsMeat Puppets IIRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10902006
Nick LoweJesus of CoolRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10892006
The Only OnesEven Serpents ShineJim Walsh
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832006
Yo La TengoPainfulRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10882006
Screaming TreesInvisible LanternMichael Azzerad
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10632006
Neil YoungLanding on Waternot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10462006
Neil Young and Crazy HorseRagged Glorynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852006
Linton Kwesi JohnsonBass Culturenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10812006
The Birthday PartyJunkyardSimon Reynolds
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10712005
P.M. DawnOf the Heart, of the Soul and of the Cross: The Utopian Experiencenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10872005
John CaleMusic for a New Societynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852005
Big StarNumber 1 RecordEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10872005
The Afghan WhigsGentlemenEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832005
Lou ReedConey Island BabyNeil Strauss
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10772005
Tom VerlaineTom VerlaineRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10812005
New York DollsToo Much Too Soonnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10812005
Lou ReedGrowing Up in Publicnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10592005
The OrbThe Orb’s Adventures Beyond the Ultraworldnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832005
The UndertonesThe UndertonesJonathan Bernstein
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10872005
The Modern LoversThe Modern LoversRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10992005
Los LobosThe NeighborhoodEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10792005
Galaxie 500On FireRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10852005
John CaleThe Academy in PerilAnn Powers
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10662005
The OrbU.F.Orbnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10852005
The Jesus and Mary ChainDarklandsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10822005
Gang of FourSolid GoldIvan Kreilkamp
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10852005
Young Marble GiantsColossal YouthEric Weisbard
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10882005
A Flock of SeagullsA Flock of Seagullsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10712005
A Flock of SeagullsListennot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10592005
Richard ThompsonShoot Out the Lightsnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10992005
Richard ThompsonHenry the Human Flynot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10762005
Richard & Linda ThompsonI Want to See the Bright Lights Tonightnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10912005
L7Hungry for StinkNatasha Stovall
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10772005
Mission of BurmaVs.not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10872005
Billy BraggLife’s a Riot with Spy Vs SpyGina Arnold
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10782005
Fripp & Eno(No Pussyfooting)not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10812005
Patti Smith GroupRadio EthiopiaRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10742005
Living ColourStainChris Norris
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10622005
The FallThe Infotainment ScanMike Rubin
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10812005
Soul AsylumAnd the Horse They Rode In OnCharles Aaron
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10652005
Nick LoweLabour of LustRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10822005
Ice CubeDeath CertificateMichael Eric Dyson
Read the review via Wikipedia
100 10/10822005
XMore Fun in the New Worldnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10862005
XSee How We Arenot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10542005
Cocteau TwinsBlue Bell KnollJames Hannaham
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10752005
The BanglesEverythingRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10602005
ParliamentGloryhallastoopidnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10652005
The BanglesGreatest HitsRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10742005
The FallThe Wonderful and Frightening World of The FallMike Rubin
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10832005
The FallPerverted by LanguageMike Rubin
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10772005
The FallDragnetMike Rubin
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10842005
MinutemenWhat Makes a Man Start Fires?not named
Read the review via Wikipedia
90 9/10822005
BananaramaBananaramaRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10582005
The ReplacementsHootenannyRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
70 7/10782005
Screaming TreesEven If and Especially WhenMichael Azzerad
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10652005
WipersOver the EdgeGrant Alden
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10862005
WipersYouth of AmericaGrant Alden
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10752005
The Jesus LizardHeadnot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
50 5/10692005
The BanglesAll Over the PlaceRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
80 8/10792005
The BanglesDifferent LightRob Sheffield
Read the review via Wikipedia
60 6/10662005
Yo La TengoRide the Tigernot named
Read the review via Wikipedia
40 4/10602005

All outlets · All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home