Soul Asylum Albums Ranked

Soul Asylum’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 8 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 64 (Mixed Bag). See the discography in release order.

What is Soul Asylum’s best album?

By the critics, it’s Grave Dancers Union (1992), with a B-Side Breakdown of 72 (Keeper) from 6 reviews. 67% of them liked it.

Next best: Hang Time (70) and Made to Be Broken (68). Lowest rated: Candy from a Stranger (49).

Soul Asylum albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Grave Dancers Union (1992): 72 Keeper
  2. 2. Hang Time (1988): 70 Keeper
  3. 3. Made to Be Broken (1986): 68 Mixed Bag
  4. 4. Let Your Dim Light Shine (1995): 67 Mixed Bag
  5. 5. While You Were Out (1986): 66 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. And the Horse They Rode In On (1990): 65 Mixed Bag
  7. 7. The Silver Lining (2006): 53 Back of the Crate
  8. 8. Candy from a Stranger (1998): 49 Back of the Crate

Soul Asylum discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every Soul Asylum album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

3010070likedMade to Be Broken (1986): 68681986While You Were Out (1986): 66661986Hang Time (1988): 70701988And the Horse They Rode In On (1990): 65651990Grave Dancers Union (1992): 72721992Let Your Dim Light Shine (1995): 67671995Candy from a Stranger (1998): 49491998The Silver Lining (2006): 53532006

Every Soul Asylum studio album, oldest first. 3 don't have a Breakdown yet; each gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1984Say What You Will, Clarence… Karl Sold the TruckNo Breakdown yet
  2. 1986Album cover for Made to Be Broken by Soul AsylumMade to Be Broken68 Mixed Bag
  3. 1986Album cover for While You Were Out by Soul AsylumWhile You Were Out66 Mixed Bag
  4. 1986Time's IncineratorNo Breakdown yet
  5. 1988Album cover for Hang Time by Soul AsylumHang Time70 Keeper
  6. 1990Album cover for And the Horse They Rode In On by Soul AsylumAnd the Horse They Rode In On65 Mixed Bag
  7. 1992Album cover for Grave Dancers Union by Soul AsylumGrave Dancers Union72 Keeper
  8. 1995Album cover for Let Your Dim Light Shine by Soul AsylumLet Your Dim Light Shine67 Mixed Bag
  9. 1998Album cover for Candy from a Stranger by Soul AsylumCandy from a Stranger49 Back of the Crate
  10. 2006Album cover for The Silver Lining by Soul AsylumThe Silver Lining53 Back of the Crate
  11. 2020Hurry Up and WaitNo Breakdown yet

Which critics love Soul Asylum, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Soul Asylum albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Entertainment Weekly4 albums+15
  1. And the Horse They Rode In On 199085 vs 61 from 5 others +24
  2. Grave Dancers Union 199293 vs 68 from 5 others +25
  3. Let Your Dim Light Shine 199565 vs 67 from 7 others −2
  4. Candy from a Stranger 199859 vs 47 from 7 others +12

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

Rolling Stone6 albums+7
  1. Hang Time 198880 vs 67 from 4 others +13
  2. And the Horse They Rode In On 199070 vs 64 from 5 others +6
  3. Grave Dancers Union 199270 vs 73 from 5 others −3
  4. Let Your Dim Light Shine 199580 vs 65 from 7 others +15
  5. Candy from a Stranger 199850 vs 48 from 7 others +2
  6. The Silver Lining 200660 vs 50 from 2 others +10

All Rolling Stone reviews

Robert Christgau6 albums0
  1. Made to Be Broken 198665 vs 68 from 6 others −3
  2. While You Were Out 198675 vs 63 from 3 others +12
  3. Hang Time 198859 vs 73 from 4 others −14
  4. And the Horse They Rode In On 199055 vs 67 from 5 others −12
  5. Let Your Dim Light Shine 199575 vs 66 from 7 others +9
  6. Candy from a Stranger 199855 vs 48 from 7 others +7

All Robert Christgau reviews

Q5 albums0
  1. Made to Be Broken 198660 vs 69 from 6 others −9
  2. Hang Time 198880 vs 67 from 4 others +13
  3. And the Horse They Rode In On 199060 vs 66 from 5 others −6
  4. Grave Dancers Union 199260 vs 75 from 5 others −15
  5. Let Your Dim Light Shine 199580 vs 65 from 7 others +15

All Q reviews

AllMusic8 albums−1
  1. Made to Be Broken 198670 vs 68 from 6 others +3
  2. While You Were Out 198660 vs 68 from 3 others −8
  3. Hang Time 198880 vs 67 from 4 others +13
  4. And the Horse They Rode In On 199060 vs 66 from 5 others −6
  5. Grave Dancers Union 199280 vs 71 from 5 others +9
  6. Let Your Dim Light Shine 199540 vs 71 from 7 others −31
  7. Candy from a Stranger 199850 vs 48 from 7 others +2
  8. The Silver Lining 200660 vs 50 from 2 others +10

All AllMusic reviews

Spin Alternative Record Guide5 albums−5
  1. Made to Be Broken 198680 vs 66 from 6 others +14
  2. While You Were Out 198670 vs 65 from 3 others +5
  3. Hang Time 198850 vs 75 from 4 others −25
  4. And the Horse They Rode In On 199060 vs 66 from 5 others −6
  5. Grave Dancers Union 199260 vs 75 from 5 others −15

All Spin Alternative Record Guide reviews

The Rolling Stone Album Guide3 albums−7
  1. Made to Be Broken 198660 vs 69 from 6 others −9
  2. While You Were Out 198660 vs 68 from 3 others −8
  3. Grave Dancers Union 199270 vs 73 from 5 others −3

All The Rolling Stone Album Guide reviews

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home