Jonathan Smith

Jonathan Smith’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 60 reviews, going back to 2018, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Metal & Punk 95%
  • Rock 5%

Find Jonathan Smith

By the numbers

9years of their reviews we track, 2018 to 2026
66%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (59 albums)
8points, on average, between their release-week reviews and where the other critics ended up (49 reviews)
How their scores spread
  • 0–491
  • 50s0
  • 60s0
  • 70s2
  • 80s37
  • 90+20

Their favorites

  1. Blind GuardianThe God Machine 96 Sonic Perspectives
  2. Eternity's EndTitanblood 95 Sonic Perspectives
  3. At the GatesThe Ghost of a Future Dead 95 Sonic Perspectives
  4. PossessedRevelations of Oblivion 95 Sonic Perspectives
  5. Grave DiggerFields of Blood 94 Sonic Perspectives

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Eternity's EndTitanblood“The blood of legends shall flow. Although recent years have seen more refinement of existing practices than new ground being broken, progressive metal’s various subsets have managed a few astounding…”Sonic Perspectives95 9.5/10not yetNov 4, 2026
ForbiddenForbidden“A rebirth is born of bold new ambition. Contrary to the opinions of some, thrash has always been a subgenre of heavy metal focused on innovation and progression since it…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/1077Oct 21, 2026
At the GatesThe Ghost of a Future Dead“A bleak future begets the perfect swansong Death metal has never been a medium to shy away from the real-world ramifications of its namesake. One might even venture to say…”Sonic Perspectives95 9.5/1083Apr 21, 2026
ExodusGoliath“The mighty metallic giant returns. Much like the Old Testament figures contained within their namesake, Exodus is a historically significant institution that has seen its fair share of trials and…”Sonic Perspectives88 8.8/1081Mar 17, 2026
Lamb of GodInto Oblivion“Welcome to pure sonic oblivion. With just over 25 years now in the rearview, or more than 30 if counting their formative years in the mid to late 90s under…”Sonic Perspectives81 8.1/1081Mar 11, 2026
SylosisThe New Flesh“Long live the new flesh! It is sometimes stipulated that concise songwriting and progressive stylings are opposites, but whoever proposed such a dichotomy likely never encountered the handiwork of British…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/1084Feb 19, 2026
MayhemLiturgy of Death“Embrace the existential darkness Transcending a cultural phenomenon might seem a fool’s errand, particularly one born of infamy and immortalized by a mainstream media that is, at best, ambivalent to…”Sonic Perspectives88 8.8/1078Feb 1, 2026
KreatorKrushers of the World“Leveling the world, one city at a time. The road that thrash metal has taken since its early 80s inception has been anything but a straightaway track, especially for those…”Sonic Perspectives89 8.9/1088Jan 9, 2026
TestamentPara Bellum“The war for the future has been declared. Some look to the future with the eyes of optimism, while others see tomorrow through a bleak lens, but wisdom dictates that…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/1082Oct 15, 2025
EpicaAspiral“Aspiring to ever greater heights. As surely as the sun rising in the East, the prospect of a new studio offering from Dutch symphonic metal titans Epica will carry the…”Sonic Perspectives89 8.9/10862025
Arch EnemyBlood Dynasty“The dynasty continues undaunted. There is something to be said for not messing with a winning formula, but this does not mean that innovation needs to fall by the wayside.…”Sonic Perspectives91 9.1/10802025
SeetherThe Surface Seems So Far“For well over 20 years South African-born alternative metal stalwarts Seether have been one of the most consequential players in what has come to be labeled as the post-grunge scene,…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/10782024
Dark TranquillityEndtime Signals“The apocalypse turns melancholy. Though which pioneering act of the Gothenburg melodic death metal movement of the 90s is an open question, few will argue that Dark Tranquillity was anything…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/10812024
AcceptHumanoid“Vintage traditionalism meets the biomechanical age. Technology seems to be an ever-encroaching influence on music, spanning every genre from the likely targets of EDM to a greater extent while also…”Sonic Perspectives89 8.9/10822024
SevendustTruth Killer“Fourteen times is definitely a charm. When a band has come within a stone’s throw of crossing the 30 year threshold of a career marked by critical acclaim and massive…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/10822023
OverkillScorched“The Wrecking Crew scorches all in its path. For a band that has been trudging the dank swamps of metal’s thrashing edge for as long as the rest, Jersey’s original…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/10822023
ObituaryDying of Everything“A new laboratory of lethal germs has been opened. Opinions may vary as to which subset of American death metal is the sickest, with a convincing case being made that…”Sonic Perspectives91 9.1/10832023
Lamb of GodOmens“A prophecy of impending heaviness is proclaimed. Since the early 90s the American metal scene has been on a perennial quest for the ultimate expression of heaviness, spearheaded by the…”Sonic Perspectives83 8.3/10782022
Blind GuardianThe God Machine“An older legacy rises anew. Nothing tests the mettle of a musical movement like adversity, and following a massive crash in popular interest in the early 1990s and the ascendance…”Sonic Perspectives96 9.6/10832022
SoilworkÖvergivenheten“Superior ambition begets new horizons. The ongoing relationship between the melodic death metal style originally spearheaded by the Gothenburg scene and their younger metalcore cousins on both sides of the…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/10792022
Arch EnemyDeceivers“Deception has never been so honest. A discussion of the melodic death metal craze that swept northern Europe during the 90s and flourished into the new millennium cannot be had…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia88 8.8/10822022
Amon AmarthThe Great Heathen Army“Battalions of the Norse assemble! For the better part of 30 years, the metal institution that is Amon Amarth has been a stalwart standard bearer for the Swedish melodic death…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia90 9/10762022
Dark FuneralWe Are the Apocalypse“Let the end times rage! It might be said that a style that cleaves to an established orthodoxy will eventually go stale like unsealed bread, but it’s near impossible for…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/10792022
Swallow the SunMoonflowers“Sadness blooms by moonlight. Though no sensible person seeks after tragedy, it can often provide the inspiration for some of the greatest works of art that the world has known.…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia86 8.6/10852022
VolbeatServant of the Mind“Familiarity begets unpredictability. While an obvious far cry from the 90s death metal mayhem that originally typified his career with Dominus, guitarist and vocalist Michael Poulsen and his outfit Volbeat’s…”Sonic Perspectives88 8.8/10782021
ExodusPersona Non Grata“The banner of discontent flies high. Long breaks in output can often signal a career that is winding down, but nothing could be further from the truth in the case…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia90 9.0/10812021
Beast in BlackDark ConnectionSonic Perspectives via Wikipedia89 8.9/10872021
KK's PriestSermons of the Sinner“Sometimes two priests isn’t a crowd. Metal icons never really retire, they just go on holiday for just under a decade before coming back as strong as ever, or at…”Sonic Perspectives88 8.8/10762021
TremontiMarching in Time“A mainline player brings the metal mainstream. It is said that you never get a second chance to make a first impression, and for many the name Mark Tremonti will…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia90 9/10782021
CarcassTorn Arteries“A more artful display of surgical precision emerges. Having sliced and diced their way into the annals of death metal’s rich and extensive history since 1986, Liverpool’s own Carcass could…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia88 8.8/10832021
EstuaryWolves In The Throne Room“Pondering metaphysics from the forest gloom. Often times the nature of a given craft will be determined by its surroundings, and this is doubly so in the case of the…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/10792021
At the GatesThe Nightmare of Being“The paradox of universal hatred unfolds. Phrases like meteoric rise and from out of nowhere tend to be thrown around a bit too often of late in reference to consequential…”Sonic Perspectives84 8.4/10792021
Fear FactoryAggression Continuum“Break free of the dystopian prison. The industrial metal icons Fear Factory have been no strangers to chaos over the years, not solely as a prime subject of their lyrical…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/10812021
Myles KennedyThe Ides of MarchSonic Perspectives via Wikipedia85 8.5/10752021
Cannibal CorpseViolence Unimagined“Dissonant horrors shake the human subconscious. Though not necessarily the first band to fly the decrepit banner of death metal, it’s all but impossible to have a conversation about said…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/10802021
SireniaRiddles, Ruins & Revelations“Enter the revitalized Gothic Vikings! The lovelorn laments of Scandinavia’s Gothic metal scene were all the rage by the closing days of the 1990s when Tristania unleashed its iconic sophomore…”Sonic Perspectives89 8.9/10792021
SodomGenesis XIX“Where there’s smoke, there’s Blackfire! When it comes to the most vicious end of the thrash metal spectrum, few can claim to have blazed the trail for the style’s unholy…”Sonic Perspectives88 8.8/10792020
DraconianUnder a Godless Veil“The veil obscures a sorrowful estate. Perhaps the only way to truly market the ugliness of death metal to a wider audience without robbing it of its dark character is…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia88 8.8/10852020
Leaves' EyesThe Last VikingSonic Perspectives via Wikipedia89 8.9/10802020
EnsiferumThalassic“They’ve become one with the waves and their past. All trends come and go like crashing waves upon the shore, but what separates a temporary craze from a legitimate art…”Sonic Perspectives93 9.3/10802020
Six Feet UnderNightmares of the Decomposed“Even corpses have bad dreams. Metal is something that few can walk away from, though departing from a particular band within said genre seems a fairly frequent occurrence. Among the…”Sonic Perspectives75 7.5/10732020
Napalm DeathThroes of Joy in the Jaws of Defeatism“Where losing becomes winning. It seems that wherein any brand of extreme metal is concerned; all roads seem to lead towards the hardcore scene of the early 80s. Few understand…”Sonic Perspectives81 8.1/10852020
Primal FearMetal Commando“Onward, speed metal soldiers! While the old adage of the times continuing to change has largely held true, there are certain bands where it applies only to the bare minimum.…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/10842020
Grave DiggerFields of Blood“The clans have risen yet again! It’s difficult to realize a great idea and then avoid returning to it, especially within a grand career that has spanned four decades. Whether…”Sonic Perspectives94 9.4/10842020
TestamentTitans of Creation“A titanic explosion to rock the pillars of creation. It would be quite a stretch to say that Testament, one of the premier thrash outfits to come roaring out of…”Sonic Perspectives91 9.1/10842020
SepulturaQuadra“Invisible borders bind us all. Not unlike the bulk of iconic bands associated with the original thrash metal explosion of the 80s, Brazil’s own Sepultura has experienced a career defined…”Sonic Perspectives91 9.1/10812020
NileVile Nilotic Rites“Pharaoh of the American South. Some bands stick to what they know, others will seemingly reinvent themselves with each new studio effort, but South Carolina’s inhabitants of little Egypt dubbed…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/10872019
Alter BridgeWalk the Sky“Triumphant hymns tread the distant skyline. There is a common sentiment these days that hard rock has become a passé mode of expression, having been supposedly supplanted by the barrage…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/10792019
Lacuna CoilBlack Anima“Withering flowers meet a pummeling colossus. As one of the early Gothic metal bands to emerge out of the early aftermath of the mid-90s death/doom craze, Lacuna Coil has naturally…”Sonic Perspectives85 8.5/10792019
Sonata ArcticaTalviyö“The war of seasons gets convoluted. It goes without saying that the name Sonata Arctica is an iconic brand within the power metal realm. They were a major factor in…”Sonic Perspectives49 4.9/10572019
Killswitch EngageAtonement“Forgiveness favors the ambitious. The U.S. metalcore scene has seen some rough times since the end of the previous decade. Whether it was due to the fatigue that generally follows…”Sonic Perspectives78 7.8/10802019
HammerFallDominion“Another storm rages from the blacksmith’s forge. For those who remember the resurrection that heavy metal experienced in the late 1990s in Europe, the name Hammerfall embodies the most nostalgic…”Sonic Perspectives91 9.1/10852019
Death AngelHumanicide“Old wolves know the best tricks. Apocalyptic imagery and thrash metal have been common bedfellows for about as long as the latter has been in existence, but the concept of…”Sonic Perspectives90 9.0/10832019
PossessedRevelations of Oblivion“A new classic wrapped in modernized traditionalism. Modern trustees of death metal based brutality may not be familiar the early exploits of its forerunner, San Francisco’s twisted, thrash-steeped purveyors of…”Sonic Perspectives95 9.5/10842019
EluveitieAtegnatos“Celtic lore and mighty mountain heights. Over the past couple decades there has been a fair degree of tribute paid to Celtic culture among various folk metal outfits. From the…”Sonic Perspectives86 8.6/10832019
Battle BeastNo More Hollywood Endings“From rivalry, improvement is born. Music is not something that you can just quit, according to the 1992 Beethoven Lives Upstairs depiction of said legendary composer, but it would seem…”Sonic Perspectives81 8.1/10772019
Grave DiggerThe Living Dead“Legions of the undead at Grimm’s command. When in the graveyard, do as the corpses do, or at least this would be the advice given to those venturing into the…”Sonic Perspectives84 8.4/10792018
DeicideOvertures of Blasphemy“Every vile soundtrack needs a prelude, or 12. Melancholy occasions are often wont to make one forget his sense of objectivity, for good or for ill, and few saddening moments…”Sonic Perspectives81 8.1/10772018
PowerwolfThe Sacrament of Sin“The dark liturgy of the Lycanthrope continues… The legendary creatures associated with classic horror cinema tend to have a common root in the land spanning the northwestern portion of Romania,…”Sonic Perspectives via Wikipedia85 8.5/10822018
Dark TranquillityMomentSonic Perspectives via Wikipedia83 8.3/1086

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home