David McElroy

David McElroy’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 20 reviews, going back to 2014, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 35%
  • Electronic 30%
  • Rock 25%
  • Pop 10%

Find David McElroy

By the numbers

1album given a perfect score
9years of their reviews we track, 2014 to 2022
60%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (20 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–492
  • 50s0
  • 60s0
  • 70s5
  • 80s9
  • 90+4

Their favorites

  1. Hot ChipWhy Make Sense? 100 XS Noize
  2. SuedeNight Thoughts 90 XS Noize
  3. Belle and SebastianGirls in Peacetime Want To Dance 90 XS Noize
  4. Aphex TwinSyro 90 XS Noize
  5. SuedeAutofiction 80 XS Noize

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
SuedeAutofiction“This album arrived on the day I managed to get tickets for Suede's March 2023 gig at the O2 Academy in Glasgow, a gig I'll be going to with my…”XS Noize80 8/10812022
Dinosaur Jr.Give a Glimpse of What Yer Not“It's an indisputable fact that Dinosaur Jr's Freak Scene is one of the greatest songs of all time. That track, together with their wonderful cover of Just”XS Noize70 7/10782016
M83Junk“It's rare that an album manages to entirely live up to its name. I've never been fully convinced by M83 as Saturdays = Youth lacked a punch and Hurry Up…”XS Noize10 1/10602016
Primal ScreamChaosmosis“11 albums in and Primal Scream show no signs of slowing down. Chaosmosis is , ultimately, a pop album, the moment where the Scream shed most, if not all, of”XS Noize80 8/10642016
The 1975I like it when you sleep, for you are so beautiful yet so unaware of it“A second album is always a challenge, especially after near universal love for your debut. Some bands wilt under the pressure and present a near carbon copy”XS Noize80 8/10732016
SuedeNight Thoughts“Suede's 2013 album Bloodsports was a sensational comeback for a band whose last album, 2002's underwhelming A New Morning seemed destined to be a flat end to”XS Noize90 9/10812016
ChvrchesEvery Open Eye“Chvrches arrival on the music scene in 2013 was a wonderful thing. Their debut, The Bones of What You Believe, was one of the finest electronic pop albums since the…”XS Noize80 8/10762015
Ryan Adams1989“Taylor Swift's 1989 is one of those rare albums that unites the vast majority of music fans all of whom rightly bow down to its pop majesty. No matter how…”XS Noize80 8/10722015
The LibertinesAnthems for Doomed Youth“Bands reuniting after a gap of 11 years seldom produce something satisfying so it's pleasing that The Libertines third album, Anthems For Doomed Youth contains many traces of what made…”XS Noize70 7/10702015
WilcoStar Wars“On 17 July, Star Wars, The first album from Wilco since 2011, appeared as a free download on their website. At only around 34 minutes long, it's shorter than any…”XS Noize70 7/10802015
Tame ImpalaCurrents“Having refined psychedelic rock for a new generation with his previous culminating in 2012's riff laden Lonerism , Kevin Parker a.k.a Tame Impala has taken something of a surprise step…”XS Noize70 7/10822015
Jamie xxIn Colour“Jamie XX debut solo album follows the excellent Gil Scott Heron collaboration We’re Not Here which was one of 2011’s best albums. Like the first The XX album, it was…”XS Noize40 4/10802015
Hot ChipWhy Make Sense?“Hot Chip return with a sixth album, recorded against a background of the band’s concerns about whether or not they remain relevant in today’s dance and electronic scenes. They really…”XS Noize100 10/10782015
BjörkVulnicura“Rush released due to stupid arses leaking the album, Bjork's Vulnicura arrived suddenly on Thursday 22 January, immediately plunging the listener into a world of orchestral pain and suffering. Written…”XS Noize80 8/10822015
Panda BearPanda Bear Meets the Grim Reaper“Recently, Noah Lennox a.k.a. Panda Bear gave an interview to The Quietus where he talked about his favorite thirteen albums. They ranged from the 'Enter The”XS Noize80 8/10782015
Belle and SebastianGirls in Peacetime Want To Dance“I have to start this review with a confession – I've never quite got Belle and Sebastian. They've had moments of indisputable genius in the past but I've”XS Noize90 9/10772015
TV on the RadioSeeds“TV On The Radio are a peculiar beast. Their output has always, rightly, been critically acclaimed, but I’ve always felt they’ve been too reticent in places, masking some extraordinary tunes…”XS Noize80 8/10742014
Aphex TwinSyro“That, however is a very good thing. There are spectacular moments of beauty to be found within the chaos. 'CIRCLONT6A ' sounds like a distant relative of”XS Noize90 9/10872014
ErasureThe Violet Flame“For most people of my age (39 plus 15 months), Erasure hold a special place in their childhood hearts. Along with the Pet Shop Boys, Erasure dominated the”XS Noize80 8/10652014
Karen OCrush Songs“Yeah Yeah Yeahs' album 'It's Blitz' remains one of my favourite albums of recent years. The band's change from what you might call traditional indie to a”XS Noize70 7/10652014

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home