Scott Plagenhoef

Scott Plagenhoef’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 52 reviews, going back to 2003, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Electronic 33%
  • Indie & Alternative 25%
  • Rock 15%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 12%

Find Scott Plagenhoef

By the numbers

6A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
5albums given a perfect score
16years of their reviews we track, 2003 to 2018
How their scores spread
  • 0–494
  • 50s4
  • 60s7
  • 70s10
  • 80s17
  • 90+10

Their favorites

  1. The BeatlesMagical Mystery Tour 100 Pitchfork
  2. The BeatlesRubber Soul 100 Pitchfork
  3. The BeatlesSgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band 100 Pitchfork
  4. RadioheadThe Bends 100 Pitchfork
  5. The BeatlesRevolver 100 Pitchfork

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

6 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 6 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Belle and SebastianThe Boy with the Arab StrapPitchfork via Wikipedia85 8.5/10782018
Sigur RósValtariThe A.V. Club via Wikipedia85 A-742012
SpiritualizedSweet Heart Sweet Light“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: April 17, 2012Label: Double Six"Spiritualized is used to treat the heart and soul," boasted the liner notes to the”Spin via Wikipedia80 8/10762012
Tyler, the CreatorGoblin“Following months of anticipation and hype, Odd Future’s anarchic leader drops his second full-length: the bleak and uncompromising Goblin.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10752011
LadytronBest of 00–10“Few would have expected Ladytron to last a full decade, but here they are in 2011 with a well-chosen comp that includes two new tracks.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia82 8.2/10772011
PJ HarveyLet England Shake“The always-unpredictable singer-songwriter returns with a haunting and beautiful meditation on war that ranks with her finest records.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia88 8.8/10892011
Nicki MinajPink Friday“One of the most exciting new voices in hip-hop makes her proper full-length debut, doing a lot of singing and not nearly enough rapping.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10682010
Die Antwoord$O$Pitchfork via Wikipedia55 5.5/10702010
MGMTCongratulations“MGMT follow the surprise hit Oracular Spectacular by teaming with Spacemen 3’s Sonic Boom for a leftfield psych-pop LP bereft of obvious singles.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10672010
Hot ChipOne Life Stand“Dialing back some of their eccentricities and embracing personal songwriting, Hot Chip have crafted their most consistent album yet.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10772010
The BeatlesMagical Mystery TourPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10872009
The BeatlesRubber SoulPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10972009
The BeatlesSgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club BandPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10952009
Major LazerGuns Don’t Kill People… Lazers Do“Diplo and Switch recruit vocalists such as Santigold, the women of Nina Sky, Vybz Kartel, and more for an eclectic dancehall-heavy party record.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10782009
RadioheadPablo Honey“Radiohead's first three albums are given expanded 2xCD reissues.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia54 5.4/10592009
RadioheadThe BendsPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/10832009
GlasvegasGlasvegas“Heavily touted in the UK press after an excellent single for their combination of girl-group pop structures, wall of sound production, and Jesus and Mary Chain-style guitar buzz, Scotland's Glasvegas…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10702009
Lady GagaThe Fame MonsterPitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10752009
Kanye West808s & HeartbreakPitchfork via Wikipedia76 7.6/10722008
Monkey: Journey to the WestJourney to the WestPitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10702008
BlondieParallel LinesPitchfork via Wikipedia97 9.7/10902008
Liz PhairExile in GuyvillePitchfork via Wikipedia96 9.6/10932008
RadioheadRadiohead: The Best Of“The inevitable Radiohead "best of" comes as either a 17-track single disc or a 30-track 2xCD package– and both are heavy on material from the 1990s.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia40 4/10652008
Arctic MonkeysWho the Fuck Are Arctic Monkeys?“2006’s most buzzed-about band address the onset of fame and the inevitabililty of backlash on this five-song EP.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia59 5.9/10562006
Arctic MonkeysWhatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m NotPitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10812006
M.I.A.Arular“After her much-loved Piracy Funds Terrorism mixtape collaboration with Diplo, and a series of delays, the debut album from London-via-Sri Lanka club artist M.I.A. proves worth the wait.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10842005
The Chemical BrothersPush the ButtonPitchfork via Wikipedia70 7.0/10712005
EminemEncorePitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10682004
AnnieAnniemal“Featuring production from Richard X, R?yksopp's Torbj?rn Brundtland, and Op:l Bastards' Timo Kaukolampi, Annie's debut …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia88 8.8/10822004
Dizzee RascalShowtime“On the heels of last year's groundbreaking debut and his subsequent signing to Matador, the king of UK garage issues his wildly anticipated follow-up.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia86 8.6/10822004
The ProdigyAlways Outnumbered, Never Outgunned“Liam Howlett returns with his first album since 1997's smash *Fat of the Land* was hailed by mainstream media as the future of "electronica." Kool Keith, Juliette Lewis, Princess Superstar,…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia39 3.9/10462004
OrbitalBlue Album“Revered electronic duo Orbital call it quits with their seventh and final album, a nostalgic throwback that's being touted as a culmination of their 15-year run.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10692004
Junior BoysLast Exit“These days I tend not to "root" for many musicians, to pledge loyalty to an artist I loved when we …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia89 8.9/10832004
The StreetsA Grand Don’t Come for FreePitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10842004
Scissor SistersScissor Sisters“There's something about the kitchen-sink approach to music that makes me suspicious. Excessive genre-hoppingn or wearing stylistic flexibility …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia83 8.3/10752004
UnkleNever, Never, Land“Six years on from its release, Psyence Fiction– the long-simmering pet project of Mo'Wax founder James Lavelle and his …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia50 5.0/10612004
Camera ObscuraUnderachievers Please Try Harder“Many of the most enchanting and popular indie pop records of the past few years have been filed under lap-pop …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia80 8.0/10812004
KelisTasty“When you've been the house chanteuse for The Neptunes for the past five years, you'd expect to have …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia65 6.5/10772004
The Handsome FamilySinging BonesPitchfork via Wikipedia74 7.4/10802003
ClientClient“Client value their anonymity. As the first signing to Depeche Mode keyboardist and founding member Andy Fletcher's Toast Hawaii …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia60 6.0/10492003
Basement JaxxKish Kash“Over the past few months, some of the more conservative members of British music press have put their Coraln …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia91 9.1/10782003
The DarknessPermission to LandPitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10712003
Belle and SebastianDear Catastrophe Waitress“One of the most beloved, bewitching, misunderstood, and eventually disappointing bands in recent history, Belle & Sebastian did the near-impossible in …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia75 7.5/10782003
Ricardo VillalobosAlcachofa“For most of the first 45 seconds of Chilean producer Ricardo Villalobos' debut album Alcachofa the only sound is provided …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia81 8.1/10912003
Danger MouseGhetto Pop Life“I'm not sure there's a duller discussion to be had about music than the one about hip-hop's …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia78 7.8/10832003
Saint EtienneFinisterreStylus Magazine via Wikipedia65 B752003
Kings of LeonYouth and Young Manhood“The Kings of Leon have some sort of mythical backstory that I'm contractually obligated to relate: they're all …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia42 4.2/10772003
TrickyVulnerable“Earlier this month, I paused for a moment while noticing that Tricky's debut album, Maxinquaye, was released in 1995 …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia49 4.9/10602003
Orchestral Manoeuvres in the DarkArchitecture & Morality“Most American music fans don't seem to know it, but Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark were around long before …”Pitchfork via Wikipedia87 8.7/10902003
Dizzee RascalBoy in da CornerPitchfork via Wikipedia94 9.4/10882003
Happy MondaysBummedStylus Magazine via Wikipedia79 7.9/1081
The BeatlesRevolverPitchfork via Wikipedia100 10/1099

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home