Jon Caramanica

Jon Caramanica

Jon Caramanica’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 128 reviews, going back to 2000, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia CommonsSend us your own photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Hip-Hop & Rap 63%
  • R&B & Soul 13%
  • Pop 7%
  • Electronic 6%

Find Jon Caramanica

By the numbers

2A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
3albums given a perfect score
21years of their reviews we track, 2000 to 2020
How their scores spread
  • 0–4919
  • 50s19
  • 60s44
  • 70s17
  • 80s23
  • 90+6

Their favorites

  1. De La Soul3 Feet High and Rising 100 The Rolling Stone Album Guide
  2. Jay-ZReasonable Doubt 100 The Rolling Stone Album Guide
  3. N.W.A.Straight Outta Compton 100 Rolling Stone
  4. De La SoulBuhloone Mindstate 90 The Rolling Stone Album Guide
  5. De La SoulDe La Soul Is Dead 90 The Rolling Stone Album Guide

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Albums they revisited

A-Sides they reviewed

2 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 2 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
UsherConfessionsBlender via Wikipedia60 3/5712020
Princess SuperstarPrincess Superstar Is“The authority on kitchen blender appliance for the home or business, providing expert blender reviews to help consumers make the best buying decision.”Blender via Wikipedia60 3/5732020
Glenn BrancaThe Ascension“The authority on kitchen blender appliance for the home or business, providing expert blender reviews to help consumers make the best buying decision.”Blender via Wikipedia80 4/5862020
Lil WayneTha Carter IIIEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-802008
Dashboard ConfessionalThe Shade of Poison Trees“Chris Carrabba's early songs were lovelorn, wussy morsels — crisp, tautly melodic, and deeply felt. He was concise, and he was heartbroken, and then he”Spin via Wikipedia70 7/10652007
Petey PabloStill Writing in My Diary: 2nd EntryRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5672006
Three 6 MafiaDa UnbreakablesRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5502006
Gretchen WilsonAll Jacked Up“Mainstream country music has always been popular, but last year it got idiosyncratic, with songs that quoted OutKast, video cameos from Kid Rock, and a”Spin via Wikipedia55 C+642005
dead prezRBG: Revolutionary but GangstaThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia50 2.5/5592005
JuvenileProject EnglishRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5652005
Kanye WestLate Registration“8SPIN Rating: 8 of 10Release Date: August 30, 2005Label: Roc-A-Fella/Def JamThis review was originally published in the September 2005 issue of SPIN and”Spin80 8/10842005
Augustus PabloKing Tubbys Meets Rockers UptownRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5902005
Sage FrancisPersonal JournalsVibe via Wikipedia60 3/5802005
Brooke ValentineChain Letter“The 35th issue of Blender magazine, cover dated April 2005. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Jennifer Lopez is featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia60 3/5692005
Bright EyesDigital Ash in a Digital UrnSpin via Wikipedia55 C+642005
Bright EyesI’m Wide Awake, It’s MorningSpin via Wikipedia85 A-802005
LCD SoundsystemLCD SoundsystemSpin via Wikipedia75 B+832005
Beanie SigelThe B. Coming“The 36th issue of Blender magazine, cover dated May 2005. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Eminem and 50 Cent are featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia60 3/5692005
Lil' KimThe Naked Truth“The 42nd issue of Blender magazine, cover dated November 2005. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Natalie Portman is featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia80 4/5692005
Bun BTrill“The 43rd issue of Blender magazine, cover dated December 2005. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Ashlee Simpson is featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia80 4/5782005
Rufus WainwrightWant TwoSpin via Wikipedia59 B-752005
Lil JonCrunk JuiceRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5622004
FabolousReal TalkRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672004
DiploFloridaSpin via Wikipedia59 B-672004
Brian EnoAmbient 1: Music for AirportsRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5832004
ChingyPowerballin’Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5602004
John LegendGet LiftedRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5822004
R. KellyUnfinished BusinessRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5542004
Yasiin BeyThe New DangerSpin via Wikipedia65 B662004
Jay-ZIn My Lifetime, Vol. 1The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia70 3.5/5742004
MaseWelcome BackRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5572004
ShyneGodfather Buried AliveRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5582004
Boyz II MenThrowback, Vol. 1Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5502004
Young BuckStraight Outta CashvilleRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5712004
PitbullM.I.A.M.I.Blender via Wikipedia40 2/5622004
JadakissKiss of DeathRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5742004
Angie StoneStone LoveRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5672004
Lloyd BanksThe Hunger for MoreRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5682004
Aesop RockFloatSpin via Wikipedia70 7/10772004
Gretchen WilsonHere for the PartyRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5732004
MadvillainMadvillainyRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5842004
Lil' FlipU Gotta Feel MeRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5642004
TV on the RadioDesperate Youth, Blood Thirsty BabesRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762004
Kanye WestThe College DropoutRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5822004
Drag-OnHell and BackRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5502004
T.I.Trap MuzikRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5712004
De La Soul3 Feet High and Rising“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia100 5/5932004
Kool G Rap4,5,6The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia60 3/5652004
De La SoulBuhloone Mindstate“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia90 4.5/5832004
De La SoulDe La Soul Is DeadThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia90 4.5/5752004
Sean PaulDutty Rock RevisitedThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia60 3/5712004
CiaraGoodies“The 32nd issue of Blender magazine, cover dated December 2004. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Gwen Stefani is featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia60 3/5592004
dead prezLet’s Get Free“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia80 4/5802004
Anita BakerMy Everything“The 30th issue of Blender magazine, cover dated October 2004. Published in the US by Dennis Publishing, Inc. Hilary Duff is featured on the…”Blender via Wikipedia60 3/5682004
Jay-ZReasonable DoubtThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia100 5/5892004
Kool G RapRoad to the Riches“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia70 3.5/5732004
Roots ManuvaRun Come Save Me“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia80 4/5752004
ScarfaceScarface – Greatest Hits RevisitedThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia80 4/5772004
Dizzee RascalShowtimeSpin via Wikipedia85 A-822004
De La SoulStakes Is High“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia80 4/5732004
LL Cool JThe DEFinitionBlender via Wikipedia60 3/5632004
ScarfaceThe UntouchableThe Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia60 3/5602004
PinkTry ThisSpin via Wikipedia65 B672004
Jay-ZVol. 2… Hard Knock Life“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia70 3.5/5712004
Kool G RapWanted: Dead or Alive (Kool G Rap & DJ Polo album)“Previously published as: Rolling Stone album guide”The Rolling Stone Album Guide via Wikipedia90 4.5/5832004
Ja RuleBlood in My EyeRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5502003
Clay AikenMeasure of a Man“Check out our album review of Artist's Measure of a Man on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5412003
112Hot & WetRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5532003
Mandy MooreCoverage“Check out our album review of Artist's Coverage on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5602003
Joss StoneThe Soul SessionsRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5632003
Obie TriceCheersRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5782003
OutKastSpeakerboxxx/The Love Below“OutKast's fifth album, 'Speakerboxxx/The Love Below' is as divided as its title”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5872003
Erykah BaduWorldwide Underground“Check out our album review of Artist's Worldwide Underground on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5622003
Jessica SimpsonIn This Skin“Check out our album review of Artist's In This Skin on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5492003
Hilary DuffMetamorphosis“Check out our album review of Artist's Metamorphosis on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5522003
Juelz SantanaFrom Me to UVibe via Wikipedia50 2.5/5502003
Keith MurrayHe’s Keith MurrayVibe via Wikipedia60 3/5632003
Joe BuddenJoe BuddenRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5782003
Gillian WelchSoul JourneyRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5732003
ScarfaceBalls and My WordRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5652003
The Black KeysThickfreaknessRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5722003
Ice CubeDeath CertificateRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5822003
FreewayPhiladelphia FreewayRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5752003
Lil' KimLa Bella MafiaRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5682003
The Mountain GoatsTallahasseeRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5792003
MursThe End of the BeginningRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5742003
Romeo MillerGame TimeRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5472003
SalivaBack into Your SystemEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-602003
Talib KweliQualityRolling Stone via Wikipedia80 4/5782003
Ms. DynamiteA Little DeeperSpin via Wikipedia75 B+722003
CommonElectric CircusSpin via Wikipedia60 6/10742003
Whitney HoustonJust WhitneyRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5502002
Snoop DoggPaid tha Cost to Be da BossEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia85 A-782002
Sean PaulDutty Rock RevisitedRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5712002
Bone Thugs-n-HarmonyThug World OrderEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia65 B672002
ScarfaceScarface – Greatest Hits RevisitedRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5772002
LeAnn RimesTwisted AngelEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia55 C+492002
N.W.A.Straight Outta Compton“Check out our album review of Artist's Straight Outta Compton (Reissue) on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia100 5/5842002
AtmosphereGod Loves UglyRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5742002
N.O.R.E.God’s FavoriteRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5632002
Boyz II MenFull CircleEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia51 C522002
Cam'ronCome Home with MeRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5702002
MúmFinally We Are No OneRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5782002
AshantiAshantiEntertainment Weekly via Wikipedia59 B-572002
The X-EcutionersBuilt from ScratchRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5742002
Jean GraeAttack of the Attacking ThingsSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10792002
CeeLo GreenCee-Lo Green and His Perfect ImperfectionsSpin via Wikipedia60 6/10762002
The StreetsOriginal Pirate MaterialSpin via Wikipedia80 8/10862002
Cypress HillStoned RaidersThe Source via Wikipedia60 3/5632002
Cannibal OxThe Cold VeinRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5852001
Luther VandrossLuther VandrossRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5742001
Matthew HerbertBodily FunctionsRolling Stone via Wikipedia70 3.5/5852001
Tupac ShakurUntil the End of TimeRolling Stone via Wikipedia50 2.5/5642001
Foxy BrownBroken SilenceSpin via Wikipedia70 7/10702001
Ryan AdamsGold“The authority on kitchen blender appliance for the home or business, providing expert blender reviews to help consumers make the best buying decision.”Blender via Wikipedia80 4/5782001
Ike TurnerHere and NowVibe via Wikipedia60 3/5612001
KMDBlack BastardsSpin via Wikipedia70 7/10712000
Slum VillageFantastic, Vol. 2Spin via Wikipedia50 5/10752000
LL Cool JG.O.A.T.Spin via Wikipedia50 5/10692000
MF DOOMOperation: DoomsdaySpin via Wikipedia80 8/10792000
ShyneShyneSpin via Wikipedia60 6/10592000
Too ShortYou NastySpin via Wikipedia60 6/10612000
G-UnitBeg for MercyBlender via Wikipedia60 3/564
ShaggyClothes DropBlender via Wikipedia20 1/556
ChingyHoodstarBlender via Wikipedia50 2.5/542
Mario WinansHurt No MoreRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/565
Trick DaddyThug Matrimony: Married to the StreetsBlender via Wikipedia60 3/575
Timbaland & MagooUnder Construction, Part IIRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/563

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home