David Amidon

David Amidon’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 37 reviews, going back to 2009, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Hip-Hop & Rap 84%
  • R&B & Soul 11%
  • Indie & Alternative 5%

Find David Amidon

By the numbers

5years of their reviews we track, 2009 to 2013
2outlets their reviews here ran in
43%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (37 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–498
  • 50s5
  • 60s6
  • 70s8
  • 80s9
  • 90+1

Their favorites

  1. Curren$yPilot Talk 90 PopMatters
  2. BilalA Love Surreal 80 PopMatters
  3. JeezyTM:103 Hustlerz Ambition 80 PopMatters
  4. The RootsUndun 80 PopMatters
  5. ASAP RockyLive. Love. ASAP 80 PopMatters

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Freddie GibbsESGNPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10722013
Mac MillerWatching Movies with the Sound Off“Two years ago, when Mac Miller's independent debut Blue Slide Park appeared, out of the blue, at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 for its first week sales, I”PopMatters70 7/10712013
Gucci ManeTrap House III“I'm almost ready to argue that Trap House III's existence is entirely justified by its opening title track, produced by Southside & TM88, both longtime”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10572013
TygaHotel CaliforniaPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10442013
BilalA Love SurrealPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10822013
Big BoiVicious Lies and Dangerous Rumors“Even if you weren't aware that Big Boi's follow-up to 2010's critical smash Sir Luscious Left Foot was originally going to be called Daddy Fat Sax: Soul Funk”PopMatters60 6/10662012
CeeLo GreenCeeLo’s Magic Moment“I found joy through all my pain / I just wanna be happy with being me," sang Cee-Lo on Common's 1997 album One Day It'll All Make Sense. At the…”PopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10632012
Wiz KhalifaTaylor Allderdice“Taylor Allderdice is so weird to me. It's the sort of mixtape I should totally be predisposed to demanding yet I'm decidedly not. Atmosphere-wise it's a”PopMatters50 5/10632012
JeezyTM:103 Hustlerz AmbitionPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10642012
CommonThe Dreamer/The Believer“Common's a rapper rap fans can't help but root for. Over his career he's consistently been one of the most introspective, insightful presences on a beat,”PopMatters60 6/10722012
The RootsUndun“undun is a deceptively tough nut to crack. On its surface, undun feels like another step in the mature, indie-oriented direction the Legendary Roots Crew set”PopMatters80 8/10822011
ASAP RockyLive. Love. ASAPPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10792011
WaleAmbitionPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10662011
Danny BrownXXXPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10822011
The-DreamTerius Nash: 1977“According to release schedules, I was supposed to be reviewing The-Dream's new Def Jam album Love IV this week. But as is often the case with mainstream urban”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10582011
DJ KhaledWe the Best Forever“DJ Khaled is something like the Prop Joe (HBO's The Wire) of hip-hop, if Prop Joe weren't ever able to supply the best ideas or the best product in Baltimore,”PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10562011
Kendrick LamarSection.80PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10782011
Pharoahe MonchW.A.R.“Like Desire before it, We Are Renegades (W.A.R. for short) is a departure from what the audience expects from Pharoahe Monch. After four years of waiting,”PopMatters50 5/10782011
RaekwonShaolin vs. Wu-Tang“It's interesting to me how many of the basic arguments for and against Apollo Kids can be made for Shaolin vs. Wu-Tang as well. If Only Built 4 Cuban Linx…”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10732011
J. ColeFriday Night Lights“When The Warm Up dropped, I hopped on the bandwagon fast and early. Between J. Cole and Freddie Gibbs, it was hard to tell who'd made a quicker imprint on”PopMatters60 6/10782011
Talib KweliGutter Rainbows“Talib Kweli is certainly one of the more consistent artists hip-hop has to offer. Going into his music, there's always an implicit understanding that you're”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10652011
Lloyd BanksH.F.M. 2PopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/10652010
Waka Flocka FlameFlockaveliPopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10722010
of MontrealFalse Priest“Even as an ancillary member of Athens, Georgia's psych-pop outfit Elephant Six (home to Neutral Milk Hotel, Apples in Stereo, Circulatory System, et al) Kevin”PopMatters50 5/10702010
Slum VillageVilla Manifesto“As sad as Villa Manifesto's storyline is, this record is also without a doubt the strongest in the group's post-Dilla catalog. Like fellow goofballs De la”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10722010
Bun BTrill OGPopMatters via Wikipedia40 4.0/10702010
Dashboard ConfessionalAlter the EndingPopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10552010
JuvenileCocky & ConfidentPopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10602009
Big K.R.I.T.4eva N a DayPopMatters via Wikipedia80 4/579
Big K.R.I.T.4eva N a DayQ via Wikipedia80 4/579
Jamie FoxxBest Night of My LifePopMatters via Wikipedia20 2/1056
Joe BuddenNo Love LostPopMatters via Wikipedia40 4/1060
Curren$yPilot TalkPopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/1076
Gucci ManeThe Return of Mr. Zone 6PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/1059
Ace HoodTrials & TribulationsPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/1070
Ghostface KillahTwelve Reasons to DiePopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/1078
Ghostface KillahWu BlockPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/1063

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home