Justin Cober-Lake

Justin Cober-Lake’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 52 reviews, going back to 2005, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Folk, Country & Americana 33%
  • Indie & Alternative 27%
  • Rock 25%
  • Pop 4%

Find Justin Cober-Lake

By the numbers

22years of their reviews we track, 2005 to 2026
3outlets their reviews here ran in
75%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (52 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–491
  • 50s4
  • 60s14
  • 70s23
  • 80s9
  • 90+1

Their favorites

  1. Old 97'sToo Far to Care 90 PopMatters
  2. Bob DylanShadow Kingdom 83 Spectrum Culture
  3. Willie NelsonThe Border 80 PopMatters
  4. Sleater-KinneyLittle Rope 80 PopMatters
  5. Sufjan StevensJavelin 80 PopMatters

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
Neil YoungSecond Song“Neil Young brings his characteristic looseness to Second Song, and while that ease can be appealing, it seldom leads to anything that sticks.”PopMatters60 6/1079Oct 26, 2026
Foo FightersYour Favorite Toy“Your Favorite Toy presents Foo Fighters doing the one thing they do well: making Foo Fighters songs.”Spectrum Culture72 72/10073May 7, 2026
Brandi CarlileReturning to Myself“Brandi Carlile has returned to herself, but it doesn't mean isolation; she is her own awareness into community, knowing what to treasure and making sure to speak it.”PopMatters70 7/1081Nov 17, 2025
Maren MorrisDreamsicle“D R E A M S I C L E considers a span of life, thinking not only of the past that led to this point but the possibilities apparent…”Spectrum Culture via Wikipedia74 3.7/576May 23, 2025
Elton JohnWho Believes in Angels?“Elton John and Brandi Carlile’s team-up becomes more than an excuse for two friends to get together, and instead turns out to be a vital part of their discographies.”Spectrum Culture75 75/100782025
Ringo StarrLook Up“Starr doesn't aim for anything too fancy, but his love for the genre comes through. His warmth helps make the album a little more than it could have been.”Spectrum Culture70 70/100712025
Willie NelsonLast Leaf on the Tree“Last Leaf on the Tree gives Nelson further space to explore his mortality, something he's been doing explicitly since he reached his mid-80s.”Spectrum Culture77 77/100792024
Lainey WilsonWhirlwind“The star of the show is the vocalist, but the record too often falls short of Wilson's potential.”Spectrum Culture65 65/100752024
Willie NelsonThe Border“Willie Nelson's The Border is one of his best late-era albums thanks to his ability to subtly add heft to an ostensibly straightforward country LP.”PopMatters80 8/10742024
Sleater-KinneyLittle Rope“With careful arrangements, sharp production, and stunning lyrics, Little Rope marks another peak in Sleater-Kinney's stellar career.”PopMatters80 8/10762024
Chris StapletonHigher“Given that Higher serves as a quintessential bit of Stapleton, it's of course consistently listenable — it's just that it does exactly what you’d predict it might.”Spectrum Culture71 71/100752023
Sufjan StevensJavelin“Sufjan Stevens draws on his broad musical experience and stylistic flexibility for his new LP, giving Javelin musical wisdom and making it one of his best.”PopMatters80 8/10872023
Bob DylanShadow Kingdom“Bob Dylan made the career transition from prophet to sage, but now the wear in his voice posits him as simply human.”Spectrum Culture83 83/100822023
Josh RitterSpectral Lines“The music on Spectral Lines marries the ethereal with the earthy, looking beyond our physical complications without rejecting lived experiences.”Spectrum Culture via Wikipedia71 3.55/5752023
Willie NelsonA Beautiful Time“Nelson's vocal timing and phrasing remain impeccable and his band sounds like the experts they are, but the album doesn't quite keep up with its recent predecessors.”Spectrum Culture68 68/100762022
Jack WhiteFear of the Dawn“Taken as discrete pieces, each songs provides its own twisted pleasure, but over the course of the album they congeal into an idiosyncratic expression of jittery anxiety.”Spectrum Culture78 78/100712022
Maren MorrisHumble Quest“The Nashville pop star keeps searching, singing, “I still haven't found it yet,” but with this album, she's locked onto a strong statement, a declarative in the midst of a…”Spectrum Culture76 76/100742022
Judy CollinsSpellbound“Six decades into a renowned folk music career, Judy Collins shows that magic always surprises on her latest album Spellbound.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 4/5702022
Elvis CostelloThe Boy Named If“Costello writes with storyteller's sensibility and a rocker's attitude, and with the Imposters willing to indulge a little id, The Boy Named If becomes as rousing a coming-of-age album as…”Spectrum Culture75 75/100822022
Robert PlantRaise the Roof“Robert Plant and Alison Krauss' Raise the Roof turns the spotlight on craft. It might not quite match its predecessor, but it maintains a high level of artistry.”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10792021
Miranda LambertThe Marfa Tapes“The three artists headed to the desert, did some writing and singing, and captured it on tape with quick first takes and a clear sincerity.”Spectrum Culture74 74/100822021
Carrie UnderwoodMy Savior“Underwood looks both to honor the origins of these hymns and demonstrate their relevance to current times. The first goal comes easily, but she struggles with the second.”Spectrum Culture68 68/100802021
Loretta LynnStill Woman Enough“On the 50th(!) album by one of country’s most vital figures, Loretta Lynn remains powerful enough — but if you mess with her, you'll find out you aren't.”Spectrum Culture75 75/100762021
METZAtlas Vending“The trio flexes a little, offering more complicated song structures and a palette that varies a little more.”Spectrum Culture via Wikipedia71 3.55/5772020
IdlesUltra Mono“IDLES don't care what you think. Or at least they don't care what you think about them. Or they care enough to make sure you know they don't care. After…”PopMatters80 8/10732020
Kelsea BalleriniKelsea“Ballerini sounds her best when allowing complex feelings to remain unresolved.”Spectrum Culture via Wikipedia65 3.25/5732020
Ingrid AndressLady Like“Ingrid Andress was just behind the scenes, and then suddenly she was here. First there were the appearances on The Sing-Off – a fact likely to become a”PopMatters70 7/10732020
CalexicoYears to Burn“Calexico and Iron & Wine make for a perfect collaboration. Their songwriting skills and musical interests overlap enough for smooth assembly but not so”PopMatters70 7/10752019
The Mountain GoatsIn League with Dragons“Fans might think they know what's coming. As the Mountain Goats, John Darnielle has put out however many albums over however many years with whoever else.”PopMatters80 8/10752019
Carrie UnderwoodCry PrettyPopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10672018
Miles DavisMiles Davis & John Coltrane The Final Tour: The Bootleg Series, Vol. 6PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10872018
Thurston MooreRock n Roll Consciousness“Thurston Moore spent a long time with that one band, but he's continually collaborated with a variety of artists. Whether from jazz, rock, or another”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10752017
Neil YoungPeace Trail“I fully expect Neil Young's next album to be a carefully composed orchestral suite, devoid of topical references and recorded over a period of several months.”PopMatters50 5/10562017
Old 97'sToo Far to CarePopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10812012
GossipA Joyful Noise“When Gossip (then with a “the” in its name) started on K Records at the end of the '90s and then Kill Rock Stars, it was a lo-fi garage act.…”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10582012
ElbowBuild a Rocket Boys!“It takes patience and memory to follow Elbow. The group first got together in 1990, but didn't realize an album until 2001's Asleep in the Back. The album”PopMatters80 8/10812011
Eric ClaptonClaptonPopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10742010
Levon HelmDirt Farmer“It would be unnecessary to point out the Band's contributions to rock, and it would be equally unnecessary to point out Levon Helm's percussion and vocal”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10702007
The BlackbyrdsThe Blackbyrds“The liner notes to Happy Music: The Best of the Blackbyrds explicitly hits the primary reason for these new Blackbyrds compilations (the band's largely been”PopMatters60 6/10772007
The WhoEndless Wire“The Who took a deep breath for 24 years before releasing this new album. That pause gave them time to, variously, make solo albums, act, repeatedly reunite,”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 3.5/5662006
BeirutGulag Orkestar“Blogs, track-leaking, and peer-to-peer networks were built for albums like this one. Beirut sounds like the remnants of an eastern European caravan, but turns”PopMatters60 6/10762006
Bubba SparxxxThe CharmStylus Magazine via Wikipedia65 B652006
The Flaming LipsAt War with the Mystics“This record's a big one for the Flaming Lips. Their last two albums, The Soft Bulletin and Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots brought them more critical respect”PopMatters70 7/10772006
The SoundsDying to Say This to You“They've got the name the Sounds, they come from Sweden like everyone else, and it took them four years to produce the 35-minute follow-up to their debut”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10632006
Remy MaThere’s Something About Remy: Based on a True Story“She wants to make sure you know that There's Something About Remy, and she's going to pound it into your big, fat head. Here's what that something is: she's”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10682006
John CaleBlackAcetateStylus Magazine via Wikipedia51 C632005
Stevie WonderA Time to Love“On my second listen to A Time to Love, I finally figured out what it is that makes Stevie Wonder's music so successful (if you thought you were going to…”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10672005
DeerhoofThe Runners Four“You might have trouble accepting this idea if you're a long-time fan: Deerhoof is a pop band. I know you used to love them because they were spazzy and noisy”PopMatters70 7/10752005
Jason MrazMr. A–Z“Only four lines into his new album, Jason Mraz sings, "There is no end to what I'm saying." Only four lines into his new album, I believe him.”PopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10482005
I Am KlootGods and Monsters“Sometimes when you have no direction, your best bet is to just start reaching. The narrators of I Am Kloot's third full-length do just that, sometimes to”PopMatters60 6/10602005
TélépopmusikAngel Milk“They've got a song in a Mitsubishi commercial, draw too frequent comparisons to Air, and have a direct vocal descendant of Billie Holiday. That should pretty”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10552005
Memphis Bleek534“If you're standing completely in someone's shadow, I'm not sure if it's the best idea to have that shadow-caster take over the third track on your new,”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10552005

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home