Peyton Thomas

Peyton Thomas’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 15 reviews, going back to 2019, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 40%
  • Pop 27%
  • Electronic 20%
  • Rock 13%

Find Peyton Thomas

By the numbers

5years of their reviews we track, 2019 to 2023
67%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (15 albums)
12points, on average, between their release-week reviews and where the other critics ended up (11 reviews)
How their scores spread
  • 0–490
  • 50s3
  • 60s7
  • 70s4
  • 80s1
  • 90+0

Their favorites

  1. U2Zooropa 84 Pitchfork
  2. Gwenno SaundersTresor 73 Pitchfork
  3. Declan McKennaZeros 73 Pitchfork
  4. Purity RingWOMB 73 Pitchfork
  5. Mark RonsonLate Night Feelings 72 Pitchfork

Every review

Outlet
HozierUnreal UnearthPitchfork via Wikipedia50 5.0/10752023
The HivesThe Death of Randy FitzsimmonsPitchfork via Wikipedia69 6.9/10762023
Rahim RedcarParanoïa, Angels, True LovePitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10772023
BullyLucky for YouPitchfork66 6.6/10822023
Tove LoDirt FemmePitchfork via Wikipedia54 5.4/10732022
Gwenno SaundersTresorPitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10802022
St. VincentDaddy’s HomePitchfork via Wikipedia67 6.7/10832021
U2ZooropaPitchfork via Wikipedia84 8.4/10842020
Declan McKennaZeros“Nodding to Bowie and the Beatles on songs about climate change and capitalism, the 21-year-old songwriter roots his political critique in the rich tradition of British protest rock.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10802020
Maya HawkeBlush“The Stranger Things actor’s move into music is refreshingly thoughtful and understated, with emotionally incisive songwriting and a featherlight voice wrapped up in Laurel Canyon arrangements.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10752020
Purity RingWOMB“The electro-pop duo’s first album in five years muses on bodies, blood, and a girl’s coming of age; it benefits from the group’s newfound musical maturity and more exacting editorial…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia73 7.3/10752020
Sufjan StevensAporia“Eleven years after Music for Insomnia, Stevens and his stepfather reunite on a collection of warm, improvisatory synth-wave epics; intimate and unvarnished, they double as a testament to the power…”Pitchfork via Wikipedia68 6.8/10732020
Mark RonsonLate Night Feelings“Produced by Mark Ronson and performed and co-written by a suite of female vocalists, this compilation explores the many shades of heartbreak in current pop.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia72 7.2/10692019
The RaconteursHelp Us Stranger“After an 11-year hiatus, the first album from Jack White’s other other band floats in weightless, haughty bliss through a perpetual 2008.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia64 6.4/10772019
Marina DiamandisLove + Fear“Marina Diamandis’ first album since shedding her “Marina and the Diamonds” identity slides from affecting poetry to cold calculation.”Pitchfork via Wikipedia54 5.4/10632019

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home