Patrick Gill

More numbers (how close they land to the other critics, release-week calls) appear once we track 15 of their reviews.

Every review

All genresFolk, Country & AmericanaIndie & AlternativePopRockAll years202620252024

Album	Outlet	Their score	Breakdown	Published
Broken Social SceneBroken Social Scene“Broken Social Scene's Remember the Humans takes time to develop but celebrates their wonderful convergence of sounds.”	PopMatters	80 8/10	75	May 13, 2026
The CharlatansWe Are Love“On their 14th studio album, We Are Love, the Charlatans sound invigorated and have made some of their most important music to date.”	PopMatters	80 8/10	69	Oct 27, 2025
Big ThiefDouble Infinity“On Double Infinity, Big Thief return as a trio to deliver their loosest compositions and some of their most moving work to date.”	PopMatters	80 8/10	81	Sep 3, 2025
Wolf AliceThe Clearing“On The Clearing, Wolf Alice appear to be searching and, for once, lack the originality that made them household names. It's a mid-career misstep.”	PopMatters	60 6/10	83	Aug 18, 2025
Bon IverSABLE, fABLE“Bon Iver's fifth studio LP SABLE, fABLE shifts from the stark beauty of the original EP to include uplifting sounds that are as enjoyable as they are personal.”	PopMatters	80 8/10	80	2025
Sharon Van EttenSharon Van Etten & the Attachment Theory“Sharon Van Etten & The Attachment Theory incorporate synths and darker sonic textures that suit the singer's cerebral thoughts and powerhouse vocals.”	PopMatters via Wikipedia	80 8/10	82	2025
Fontaines D.C.Romance“Fontaines D.C.'s 'Romance' should be considered a high-water mark for them, a work that is equally challenging and considerably more gratifying.”	PopMatters	90 9/10	86	2024

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home