Jim DeRogatis

Jim DeRogatis

Jim DeRogatis’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 54 reviews, going back to 1992, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Photo: Don Hall, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia CommonsSend us your own photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 35%
  • Rock 33%
  • R&B & Soul 9%
  • Pop 7%

Find Jim DeRogatis

By the numbers

5A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
10albums given a perfect score
18years of their reviews we track, 1992 to 2009
How their scores spread
  • 0–494
  • 50s1
  • 60s3
  • 70s13
  • 80s23
  • 90+10

Their favorites

  1. Public EnemyHe Got Game 100 Chicago Sun-Times
  2. Macy GrayThe Id 100 Chicago Sun-Times
  3. MobyPlay 100 Chicago Sun-Times
  4. Beastie BoysHello Nasty 100 Chicago Sun-Times
  5. The Smashing PumpkinsAdore 100 Chicago Sun-Times

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

5 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 5 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Joss StoneColour Me Free!Chicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia50 2/4642009
JapandroidsPost-NothingChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4802009
UsherHere I StandChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4642008
Spin DoctorsYou’ve Got to Believe in SomethingRolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5482007
Public EnemyHe Got GameChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4802006
PassengersOriginal Soundtracks 1Rolling Stone via Wikipedia40 2/5642005
Peter GabrielUsChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4702005
Dropkick MurphysDo or DieChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia70 3.5/5672004
Peter GabrielPeter GabrielChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4812004
PrinceMusicologyChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4702004
Death Cab for CutieTransatlanticismChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4772003
Green DayDookieChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4892003
Cat PowerYou Are FreeChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4792003
Neko CaseBlacklistedChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4782002
Aimee MannLost in SpaceChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4682002
…And You Will Know Us by the Trail of DeadSource Tags & CodesChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4792002
Bob DylanLove and TheftChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4892001
Macy GrayThe IdChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4742001
LowThings We Lost in the FireChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4862001
PJ HarveyStories from the City, Stories from the SeaChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4812000
U2All That You Can’t Leave BehindChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4812000
RadioheadKid AChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4812000
The Dandy WarholsThirteen Tales from Urban BohemiaChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4742000
WeenWhite PepperChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4712000
Macy GrayOn How Life IsChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4781999
Randy NewmanBad LoveChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4831999
MobyPlayChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4831999
SparklehorseGood Morning SpiderChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4831999
Marilyn MansonMechanical AnimalsChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4751998
Beastie BoysHello NastyChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4841998
Monster MagnetPowertripChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4821998
WilcoMermaid AvenueChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4821998
The Smashing PumpkinsAdoreChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4741998
Brian WilsonImaginationChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia60 3/5541998
Mark SnowThe X-Files: The AlbumChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia38 1.5/4591998
Tori AmosFrom the Choirgirl HotelChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4781998
TortoiseTNTChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4811998
Brian EnoSpinner“Check out our album review of Artist's Spinner on Rolling Stone.com.”Rolling Stone via Wikipedia20 1/5651995
The Smashing PumpkinsMellon Collie and the Infinite SadnessRolling Stone via Wikipedia60 3/5811995
PJ HarveyTo Bring You My LoveChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4931995
OasisDefinitely MaybeChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4921995
Pearl JamVitalogyChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4851994
ShellacAt Action ParkChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4781994
WeenChocolate and CheeseChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4791994
PavementCrooked Rain, Crooked RainChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4891994
Pearl JamVs.Chicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4761993
Liz PhairExile in GuyvilleChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4931993
NirvanaIn UteroChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/4921993
U2ZooropaChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4841993
Pere UbuDub HousingChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia88 3.5/4911993
Depeche ModeSongs of Faith and DevotionChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4741993
Mike OldfieldTubular BellsChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia100 4/41001993
Ice CubeThe PredatorChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia75 3/4761992
MadonnaEroticaChicago Sun-Times via Wikipedia63 2.5/4691992

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home