Their favorites

1. InterpolTurn on the Bright Lights 95 Pitchfork
2. The LibertinesUp the Bracket 85 Pitchfork
3. The DistillersCoral Fang 80 Pitchfork
4. Neko CaseBlacklisted 79 Pitchfork
5. Queens of the Stone AgeSongs for the Deaf 79 Pitchfork

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

• David Bowie 2 reviews78Heathen73Reality
• The Libertines 2 reviews85Up the Bracket71The Libertines

Every review

Album	Outlet	Their score	Breakdown	Published
MogwaiHappy Songs for Happy People	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	71 7.1/10	79	2003
InterpolTurn on the Bright Lights“As you read this, there are likely a number of people in your midst summoning up all the backlash powers …”	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	95 9.5/10	83	2002
Johnny CashAmerican IV: The Man Comes Around“The Man in Black's vision of the American west is one of a rugged, mournful land, where outlaws carry …”	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	69 6.9/10	81
Neko CaseBlacklisted	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	79 7.9/10	81
The DistillersCoral Fang“It's unfairly easy to play the crotchety, old-guard punk in an era when even The Offspring can manage to …”	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	80 8.0/10	68
Yeah Yeah YeahsFever to Tell	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	74 7.4/10	85
David BowieHeathen	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	78 7.8/10	76
Nick Cave and the Bad SeedsNocturama	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	70 7.0/10	68
Foo FightersOne by One	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	54 5.4/10	73
David BowieReality	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	73 7.3/10	74
Iggy PopSkull Ring	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	41 4.1/10	60
Queens of the Stone AgeSongs for the Deaf	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	79 7.9/10	86
The LibertinesThe Libertines	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	71 7.1/10	79
The Black KeysThickfreakness	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	77 7.7/10	77
The LibertinesUp the Bracket“And so it's come to pass: the great wheel of revivalism spins, dredging up the next phase of music …”	Pitchfork via Wikipedia	85 8.5/10	82