Early reviews. Critics give I’ll Be Your Girl an early B-Side Breakdown of 60 (Mixed Bag), from 5 reviews so far. It will settle as more outlets weigh in.
The verdict on I’ll Be Your Girl
Most critics weren't won over: 2 of 5 liked it.
- Highest 70 XS Noize and AllMusic
- Outlier 40 Slant, 20 points below the next-lowest score
- Career #8 of The Decemberists's 8 albums with a Breakdown
- By the numbers The Decemberists's best-reviewed album here since What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World (2015).
I’ll Be Your Girl reviews: all 5 critics
| The gist | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| XS Noizeby Lori Gava | 7/10 | 70 | 2018 | “The Decemberists new release, “I’ll Be Your Girl” evinces a notable departure from their trademark Folk infused Alternative sound. Their eighth album released” |
| AllMusic via Wikipediaby Stephen Thomas Erlewine | 3.5/5 | 70 | ||
| Pitchfork via Wikipediaby Evan Rytlewski | 6.1/10 | 61 | 2018 | “Buoyed by a fresh coat of synths and a streamlined energy, the Decemberists’ latest is a curious middle-of-the-road album, teasing a number of directions without committing to any of them.” |
| Rolling Stone via Wikipediaby Will Hermes | 3/5 | 60 | 2018 | “On 'I'll Be Your Girl,' Colin Meloy swaps britches for leather jeans, stylistic fusions and confusions ensue” |
| Slantby Jeremy Winograd | 2/5 | 40 | 2018 | “Aiming for playful rebirth, the Decemberists instead land on cloying kitsch with I’ll Be Your Girl.” |
Would you spin it again?
Be the first to answer. Results show once 3 listeners weigh in.
Every Sunday: the week's new albums, scored by the critics. Plus our own reviews when we post them. Free, and one click to leave.
I’ll Be Your Girl in The Decemberists's catalog
How these critics usually treat The Decemberists
- Slant Harsher than usual25 points below the other critics here. Usually 13 points below on The Decemberists's other albums (4).
- AllMusic Kinder than usual12 points above the other critics here. Usually level with the others on The Decemberists's other albums (7).
- Pitchfork About usual for them1 point above the other critics here. Usually 3 points below on The Decemberists's other albums (7).
- Rolling Stone About usual for themLevel with the other critics here. Usually 1 point above on The Decemberists's other albums (5).
More from The Decemberists
← Earlier What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World (2015)
More Indie & Alternative from around 2018
How the Breakdown works
Every outlet’s score is converted to 0–100 (2/5 is 40, 5.9/10 is 59) and averaged. A letter grade counts as the score the other critics gave the same albums: across 3,000+ letter-grade reviews, a B+ sat with about three and three-quarter stars from everyone else, so it counts as 75, and a B counts as 65. Verdicts: Heavy Rotation is 85 and up, Keeper 70–84, Mixed Bag 55–69, Back of the Crate below 55. Approval is the share of critics who scored it 70 or higher (7/10, three and a half stars); the Breakdown shows green at 70 and up, red below. Divisiveness asks a different question: not how many critics liked it, but how close their scores are to each other. Five critics who all give it 50 are Unanimous, even though none of them liked it. The labels run Unanimous, Broad agreement, Some debate, Divided, and Contentious. Replay rate comes from listeners, not critics: yes counts fully, a few tracks counts half, no counts zero. The gist quotes each outlet’s own summary of its review. Published is the date on the review itself, read from the outlet’s page, so you can see whether an album’s reputation came at release or years later. Scores marked est. come from reviews that publish no number. Scores marked via Wikipedia are archive ratings, mostly for older albums, taken from the “Professional ratings” box on the album’s Wikipedia page (published openly through Wikidata); each links to the original review when we can find it online, and to that Wikipedia entry when we can’t. When an outlet reviewed an album twice, years apart (often for a reissue), both scores count, each labeled with its year.
A-Side marks the critics’ top tier. An album earns it automatically, from its numbers alone: a Breakdown of 90 or higher, from at least 5 reviews, with at least 75% approval. Nobody hands it out and nobody can buy it; if new reviews pull an album below the line, it loses the badge.










Leave a Reply