Will Layman

Will Layman’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 69 reviews, going back to 2005, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Jazz 78%
  • Pop 12%
  • R&B & Soul 4%
  • Rock 3%

Find Will Layman

By the numbers

1A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
22years of their reviews we track, 2005 to 2026
2outlets their reviews here ran in
How their scores spread
  • 0–494
  • 50s6
  • 60s11
  • 70s16
  • 80s22
  • 90+10

Their favorites

  1. Gregory PorterTake Me to the Alley 90 PopMatters
  2. Esperanza SpaldingEmily’s D+Evolution 90 PopMatters
  3. Ambrose AkinmusireThe Imagined Savior is Far Easier to Paint 90 PopMatters
  4. Jason MolinaMagnolia Electric Co. 90 PopMatters
  5. Tedeschi Trucks BandRevelator 90 PopMatters

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

A-Sides they reviewed

1 album that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 1 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Meshell NdegeocelloSynonym“Meshell Ndegeocello's Synonym is a superb modern soul album filled with sensual grooves, compelling vocals, and ingenious arrangements.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/1075Oct 1, 2026
Meshell NdegeocelloThe Omnichord Real Book“Meshell Ndegeocello always creates a mood around the music that puts rhythm, harmony, and melody in delicious orbits. This is a real genre-crossing soul album.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10802023
David CrosbyFor Free“As he approaches 80, David Crosby makes his best solo album, climaxing his late career with poignant lyrics, strong grooves, and jazz harmonies.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10812021
Dave HollandAnother Land“On Another Land, jazz bassist Dave Holland returns to the guitar trio format with Kevin Eubanks of The Tonight Show band flying by his side.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10782021
John ScofieldSwallow Tales“The first time I heard guitarist John Scofield, he was playing on an unusual date on CTI Records, working as a sideman with Gerry Mulligan and Chet Baker on a”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10812020
Ambrose AkinmusireOn the Tender Spot of Every Calloused Moment“There is considerable excitement in hearing an artist with the ambition and accomplishment of trumpeter Ambrose Akinsusire as he pares back the tools he”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10792020
Joe LovanoTrio Tapestry“Joe Lovano keeps on discovering. And surprising.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10742019
Mark TurnerTemporary KingsSpectrum Culture via Wikipedia60 3/5732019
Cécile McLorin SalvantThe WindowPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10762018
Lucinda WilliamsVanished GardensPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10752018
Wadada Leo SmithSolo: Reflections and Meditations on Monk“Wadada Leo Smith is having a great run in the critical eye. In 2016 he topped many polls with his meditative but free composing and presentations,”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10762017
Wadada Leo SmithNajwa“At this point, the long arc of fascinating music from trumpeter Wadada Leo Smith can't be summarized at the top of a review. He goes back to the early days…”PopMatters70 7/10852017
Sonny ClarkSonny Clark Trio“The most elusive concepts in music are rhythmic ones—what it means to "rock", "lay back", to be "funky". In jazz, that tricky concept is "swing". We know it”PopMatters80 8/10832017
Gary PeacockTangents“Gary Peacock is now 82 years old, and he is playing with wisdom, experience, and a certain timelessness on his side. After his 30 years being featured as the”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10732017
Andrew CyrilleProximity“If a drums/saxophone duet album sounds a bit austere to you, well, I get it. Is it going to swing without a bass player? Without a piano or guitar, where…”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10702016
John ScofieldCountry for Old MenPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10742016
Pat MethenyCuong Vu Trio Meets Pat Metheny“Trumpeter Cuong Vu is the real deal on so many levels that fans of great music should all know his name. He hasn’t been shy about getting it out there—he…”PopMatters80 8/10802016
Gregory PorterTake Me to the Alley“In 2013, Gregory Porter made his debut with jazz’s premiere label, Blue Note, with Liquid Spirit, a record that was just about perfect in its way. Porter had”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10802016
Esperanza SpaldingEmily’s D+Evolution“Esperanza Spalding’s new recording, Emily’s D+Evolution is an astonishing beauty, a set of a dozen songs that artfully and persuasively bridge genres. It is”PopMatters90 9/10812016
The Bad PlusThe Bad Plus Joshua Redman“There’s been so much revolution among jazz piano trios in recent years, and accounts of the trend inevitably point to the Bad Plus: Ethan Iverson (piano),”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10802015
Diana KrallWallflower“Diana Krall is blessed with a great voice, a distinctive and beautifully frayed alto that sounds hip and vulnerable, cool and polished all at once. She also”PopMatters via Wikipedia30 3/10572014
The Bad PlusThe Rite of Spring“It has got to be a challenge being the Bad Plus. You're not just any jazz piano trio, no sir-eee. You recorded a version of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" on…”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10762014
Ambrose AkinmusireThe Imagined Savior is Far Easier to Paint“Ambrose Akinmusire is a fresh jazz trumpeter who understands mood, who has set about doing things differently, making music that you haven't quite heard”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10782014
Gary BurtonGuided Tour“Gary Burton turned 70 this past year, but he always sounds fresh. Maybe it’s the instrument, the vibraphone, with its chiming bell sound, its rippling runs,”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10782014
Jason MolinaMagnolia Electric Co.“Jason Molina was a man who sang with vulnerability, passion, and eventually power. He emerged in the lo-fi, indie-rock heyday that fell on the far side of the”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10862013
Robert GlasperBlack Radio 2“Last year, Robert Glasper won the "Best R&B Album" Grammy for Black Radio, a recording that blended his roots as a jazz pianist with his history as a”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10642013
Gary PeacockAzure“Pianist Marilyn Crispell and bassist Gary Peacock have a lovely history as recording partners, having made two glowing discs for ECM with Paul Motian on”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10822013
Gregory PorterLiquid Spirit“When I saw Wynton Marsalis's 2013 version of his masterpiece, Blood on the Fields, I was also waking up to a killer talent in vocalist Gregory Porter, a”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10782013
Charles LloydHagar’s Song“Jazz success stories, at least the modern kind that have occurred since the rise of rock music in the 1960s, tend to be strange. How does someone playing”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10782013
Wayne ShorterWithout a Net“Wayne Shorter may be the most respected man in jazz—a member of the legendary Miles Davis ‘60s quintet, a brilliant leader of legendary Blue Note dates during”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10892013
Pat MethenyOrchestrion“There's something very compelling about watching a guitar player make his art. Both the hands are at it, doing different things. The player is usually”PopMatters60 6/10772012
Diana KrallGlad Rag DollPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10782012
Cassandra WilsonAnother Country“No voice in American music is more unique than Cassandra Wilson's. Her dusky contralto can move, within a phrase, from meditative to angry, romantic to”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10682012
Brad MehldauOde“Piano, bass, and drums. In modern jazz, that is the pedestal, the bandstand, the foundation. A million bands build from there, and a million bands play pretty”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10832012
Joshua RedmanMoodswing“In 1994, Joshua Redman was the “It Musician” in jazz – a young guy getting a ton of press because he was a biracial guy who had gone to Harvard…”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10792012
Robert GlasperBlack Radio“It is endlessly the dream of jazz musicians to use contemporary pop music as the fuel for their experiments and improvisations. If jazz once seemed stuck on”PopMatters60 6/10802012
Cannonball AdderleyKnow What I Mean?“The opening strains of this classic Riverside album are pure-pure delicacy that could only come from the fingers of Bill Evans. His chiming piano, playing the”PopMatters80 8/10742011
Tedeschi Trucks BandRevelator“People are hungry for a good song—a verse and a chorus you can count on, but with something different about it too. The same old pop formulas can wear you…”PopMatters90 9/10832011
Cassandra WilsonSilver Pony“You would be hard-pressed to find a jazz singer in the last 20 years who has done a better job of combining popular and artistic success than Cassandra”PopMatters via Wikipedia60 6/10732011
Joni MitchellShinePopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10772011
Geri AllenFlying Toward the Sound“When Geri Allen first appeared on the scene, she caused a thrill for many jazz fans. Here was a new young pianist at once lyrical and risky, precise in her”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10732010
Herbie HancockThe Imagine Project“Is it churlish to find extremely good intentions wrong-footed? Is it unpleasant to criticize one of the finest musicians on the planet because his work in”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10652010
Esperanza SpaldingChamber Music Society“Esperanza Spalding is The Next Big Thing in Jazz. You can tell because she is quietly everywhere: playing for the President, on Marian McPartland's Piano”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10712010
Suzanne VegaClose-Up Vol. 1, Love SongsPopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10672010
Dee Dee BridgewaterEleanora Fagan (1915-1959): To Billie with Love from Dee Dee Bridgewater“Dee Dee Bridgewater is a full-service jazz singer, She has a powerful voice and the flexibility and musical chops to sing with the band, But she also has”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10712010
Melody GardotMy One and Only Thrill“Melody Gardot is singer with a great sound — intimate rather than overblown, tinged with smoke rather than hype, a retro-ish kind of now. My One and Only”PopMatters60 6/10722009
Melinda DoolittleComing Back to You“The debut album by American Idol season six finalist Melinda Doolittle is another in the recent string of throwback soul albums that reach after the spirit of”PopMatters70 7/10732009
Diana KrallQuiet NightsPopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10702009
Chick CoreaCrystal Silence“The 1972 album Crystal Silence paired two relatively young jazz musicians, playing a gorgeous and filigreed set of duets on piano and vibraphone. As one of”PopMatters60 6/10862008
Sheryl CrowDetours“In pop music, 15 years is a lifetime-plus. Artists who release relevant music over than span of time are few, particularly in the last 15 years.”PopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10762008
Pat MethenyDay Trip“For decades, jazz guitar traded in a certain degree of tonal anonymity. Sure, Charlie Christian, Barney Kessel, Wes Montgomery, and Grant Green had different”PopMatters70 7/10682008
Stacey KentBreakfast on the Morning Tram“Stacey Kent is singing jazz. She has that particular jazz singing tone, the one that is like a dry ice version of a little girl's voice: cute and”PopMatters60 6/10652008
Dee Dee BridgewaterRed Earth“Young jazz singers should certainly apprentice themselves by singing standards, and no one begrudges them a recording or two where they place their stamp on”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10862007
Meshell NdegeocelloThe World Has Made Me the Man of My Dreams“Meshell Ndegeocello is a pop anomaly, a supremely talented artist who has the goods to be truly popular but also has the ideology and integrity to doggedly”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10762007
Queen LatifahTrav’lin’ Light“Who is Queen Latifah? Her name is Dana Elaine Owens of Newark, New Jersey. She's 37 years old and she played power forward on her high school basketball team.”PopMatters50 5/10622007
Tord Gustavsen TrioBeing There“Being There is the third CD from the Tord Gustavsen Trio, who hail from Norway. Like the prior two discs (Changing Places from 2003 and The Ground from 2005”PopMatters40 4/10732007
Terence BlanchardA Tale of God’s WillPopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10812007
Boz ScaggsSilk Degrees“The pop music of every era risks being locked in time. That is the bargain of pop music — to be of the moment it risks being only of the…”PopMatters60 6/10862007
Pat MartinoEl Hombre“Pat Martino was just 22 when he stepped through the hallowed doors of Rudy Van Gelder's Englewood Cliffs studio to record his first date as a leader. A”PopMatters70 7/10742007
Robert GlasperIn My Element“In jazz, there is always much talk about the "new", but the music rarely feels new. After all, the obvious barriers to greater freedom were all broken down”PopMatters via Wikipedia90 9/10852007
Katharine McPheeKatharine McPhee“The American Idol Phenomenon is in full swing again, with many of the contestants looking like professionals already and others so hopelessly amateurish that”PopMatters30 3/10522007
Rickie Lee JonesThe Sermon on Exposition Boulevard“Rickie Lee Jones is one of the most remarkable and distinctive voices in American pop music. And though she is primarily known for the jazzy snap and”PopMatters30 3/10652007
Branford Marsalis QuartetBraggtown“When Branford Marsalis first emerged from under the double-Grammy-winning shadow of his brother Wynton — leaving Wynton's group to play saxophone with the”PopMatters70 7/10792006
Cassandra WilsonThunderbird“Cassandra Wilson is the only jazz singer worth listening to these days, and now she's not even a jazz singer anymore.”PopMatters90 9/10682006
Bobo StensonGoodbye“Bobo Stenson is one of the premier pianists in modern jazz, but you rarely hear him mentioned in the same breath with Tyner, Jarrett, or Hancock. Born in”PopMatters80 8/10832005
Bill WithersJust as I AmPopMatters via Wikipedia80 8/10902005
Jack DeJohnetteMusic from the Hearts of the Masters“Fans may rightly dread the proliferation of artist imprints, record label subgroups dedicated to a single musician's personal vision. Like the Travolta movie”PopMatters via Wikipedia50 5/10662005
Faith EvansThe First Lady“The First Lady, Faith Evans' fourth album of modern R&B, is a complex package to decode. Before you listen to a single note, the disc makes an interesting”PopMatters via Wikipedia70 7/10652005
Marcus MillerSilver Rain“Who is buying this music?”PopMatters60 6/10622005

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home