Thompson D. Gerhart

Thompson D. Gerhart’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 18 reviews, going back to 1996, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

What they review

  • Metal & Punk 67%
  • Rock 28%
  • Indie & Alternative 6%

Find Thompson D. Gerhart

By the numbers

1album given a perfect score
31years of their reviews we track, 1996 to 2026
39%of their scores landed within 10 points of the other critics’ average for the same album (18 albums)
How their scores spread
  • 0–490
  • 50s0
  • 60s3
  • 70s7
  • 80s1
  • 90+7

Their favorites

  1. Devin Townsend ProjectGhost 100 Sputnikmusic
  2. The Dear HunterAct IV: Rebirth in Reprise 90 Sputnikmusic
  3. Animals as LeadersThe Joy of Motion 90 Sputnikmusic
  4. Devin Townsend ProjectDeconstruction 90 Sputnikmusic
  5. SavatageDead Winter Dead 90 Sputnikmusic

Artists they keep coming back to

Their scores for each artist, in release order.

Every review

Outlet
MegadethMegadeth“Megadeth – Megadeth review: The snarl farewell”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/561Jan 23, 2026
Devin Townsend ProjectTranscendenceSputnikmusic via Wikipedia60 3/5812016
HakenAffinity“Haken – Affinity review: Caught in the shade of The Mountain.”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5832016
The Dear HunterAct IV: Rebirth in Reprise“The Dear Hunter – Act IV: Rebirth in Reprise review: There's that subtle smile that did me in.”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5772015
Act of DefianceBirth and the Burial“Act of Defiance – Birth and the Burial review: 3.3/5. The Chris Broderick pathway through metal sure is an interesting one. From the power metal of Jag Panzer…”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia66 3.3/5752015
PeripheryJuggernaut: Alpha“Periphery – Juggernaut: Alpha review: A melodic refocus results in Periphery's best album to date.”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia80 4/5832015
Devin Townsend ProjectZ²“Devin Townsend Project – Z2 review: More a contemporary inspiration than a sequel. Hang on to your coffee!”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia76 3.8/5752014
OpethPale CommunionSputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5802014
Animals as LeadersThe Joy of Motion“Animals As Leaders – The Joy of Motion review: A modern freerunning landscape complete with scenic vistas, complex obstacles, and luxurious rest stops that ensure you’ll frequent the course”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5872014
AyreonThe Theory of EverythingSputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5792013
Dream TheaterDream TheaterSputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5682013
The OceanPelagial“The Ocean – Pelagial review: Though its depths vary, The Ocean is largely consistent from one end to another.”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia70 3.5/5852013
Devin Townsend ProjectGhost“Devin Townsend Project – Ghost review: If you're looking for HevyDevy, this isn't him. He's gone somewhere else. This is Devin Townsend. And maybe he's just a ghost, but he's…”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia100 5/5872011
Devin Townsend ProjectDeconstruction“Devin Townsend Project – Deconstruction review: Woah, good lord it's a Cheeseburger! A double! BEER! BEER! BEER!”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5852011
SavatageDead Winter Dead“Savatage – Dead Winter Dead review: An album to make you appreciate life both lyrically and musically.”Sputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5892008
King DiamondThe GraveyardSputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/5721996
AyreonInto the Electric CastleSputnikmusic via Wikipedia90 4.5/583
TriviumVengeance FallsSputnikmusic via Wikipedia60 3/575

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home