Metallica Albums Ranked

Metallica’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 12 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 75 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.

What is Metallica’s best album?

By the critics, it’s Master of Puppets (1986), with a B-Side Breakdown of 95 (Heavy Rotation) from 8 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: Ride the Lightning (87) and Kill ‘Em All (82). Lowest rated: Lulu (46).

Metallica albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Master of Puppets (1986): A-Side95 Heavy Rotation
  2. 2. Ride the Lightning (1984): 87 Heavy Rotation
  3. 3. Kill ‘Em All (1983): 82 Keeper
  4. 4. Metallica (1991): 80 Keeper
  5. 5. Death Magnetic (2008): 78 Keeper
  6. 6. …And Justice for All (1988): 77 Keeper
  7. 7. 72 Seasons (2023): 75 Keeper
  8. 8. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct (2016): 74 Keeper
  9. 9. Load (1996): 73 Keeper
  10. 10. St. Anger (2003): 64 Mixed Bag
  11. 11. Reload (1997): 64 Mixed Bag
  12. 12. Lulu (2011): 46 Back of the Crate

Metallica discography, in release order

Every Metallica studio album, oldest first. One doesn't have a Breakdown yet; it gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.

  1. 1982No Life 'til LeatherNo Breakdown yet
  2. 1983Album cover for Kill ‘Em All by MetallicaKill ‘Em All82 Keeper
  3. 1984Album cover for Ride the Lightning by MetallicaRide the Lightning87 Heavy Rotation
  4. 1986Album cover for Master of Puppets by MetallicaMaster of Puppets95 Heavy Rotation
  5. 1988Album cover for …And Justice for All by Metallica…And Justice for All77 Keeper
  6. 1991Album cover for Metallica by MetallicaMetallica80 Keeper
  7. 1996Album cover for Load by MetallicaLoad73 Keeper
  8. 1997Album cover for Reload by MetallicaReload64 Mixed Bag
  9. 2003Album cover for St. Anger by MetallicaSt. Anger64 Mixed Bag
  10. 2008Album cover for Death Magnetic by MetallicaDeath Magnetic78 Keeper
  11. 2011Album cover for Lulu by MetallicaLulu46 Back of the Crate
  12. 2016Album cover for Hardwired… to Self-Destruct by MetallicaHardwired… to Self-Destruct74 Keeper
  13. 2023Album cover for 72 Seasons by Metallica72 Seasons75 Keeper

Which critics love Metallica, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Metallica albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Kerrang!3 albums+11
  1. Kill ‘Em All 1983100 vs 79 from 7 others +21
  2. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  3. 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6

All Kerrang! reviews

NME7 albums+9
  1. Load 199670 vs 73 from 10 others −3
  2. Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
  3. St. Anger 200390 vs 61 from 9 others +29
  4. Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
  5. Lulu 201170 vs 45 from 12 others +26
  6. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
  7. 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6

All NME reviews

Uncut3 albums+8
  1. …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
  2. St. Anger 200380 vs 63 from 9 others +17
  3. Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3

All Uncut reviews

Los Angeles Times4 albums+8
  1. Metallica 199170 vs 81 from 9 others −11
  2. Load 199688 vs 72 from 10 others +16
  3. Reload 199788 vs 60 from 7 others +28
  4. Death Magnetic 200875 vs 78 from 12 others −3

All Los Angeles Times reviews

Rolling Stone9 albums+6
  1. …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
  2. Metallica 199180 vs 80 from 9 others 0
  3. Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
  4. Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
  5. St. Anger 200380 vs 63 from 9 others +17
  6. Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
  7. Lulu 201160 vs 45 from 12 others +15
  8. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
  9. 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6

All Rolling Stone reviews

AllMusic12 albums+4
  1. Kill ‘Em All 1983100 vs 79 from 7 others +21
  2. Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
  3. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  4. …And Justice for All 198890 vs 76 from 10 others +14
  5. Metallica 199190 vs 79 from 9 others +11
  6. Load 199650 vs 75 from 10 others −25
  7. Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
  8. St. Anger 200360 vs 65 from 9 others −5
  9. Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
  10. Lulu 201160 vs 45 from 12 others +15
  11. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
  12. 72 Seasons 202370 vs 75 from 17 others −5

All AllMusic reviews

The Guardian5 albums+3
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198380 vs 82 from 7 others −2
  2. Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
  3. Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
  4. Lulu 201140 vs 47 from 12 others −7
  5. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6

All The Guardian reviews

Chicago Tribune6 albums+1
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198388 vs 81 from 7 others +7
  2. Ride the Lightning 198475 vs 89 from 7 others −14
  3. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  4. …And Justice for All 198863 vs 79 from 10 others −16
  5. Metallica 199188 vs 79 from 9 others +9
  6. Reload 199775 vs 62 from 7 others +13

All Chicago Tribune reviews

Louder4 albums0
  1. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  2. …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
  3. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201660 vs 75 from 12 others −15
  4. 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6

All Louder reviews

Entertainment Weekly6 albums−2
  1. Metallica 199175 vs 81 from 9 others −6
  2. Load 199665 vs 74 from 10 others −9
  3. Reload 199765 vs 63 from 7 others +2
  4. St. Anger 200375 vs 63 from 9 others +12
  5. Death Magnetic 200875 vs 78 from 12 others −3
  6. Lulu 201139 vs 47 from 12 others −8

All Entertainment Weekly reviews

Q5 albums−4
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198380 vs 82 from 7 others −2
  2. Ride the Lightning 198480 vs 88 from 7 others −8
  3. …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
  4. Metallica 199160 vs 82 from 9 others −22
  5. Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8

All Q reviews

The Rolling Stone Album Guide7 albums−7
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198360 vs 85 from 7 others −25
  2. Ride the Lightning 198480 vs 88 from 7 others −8
  3. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  4. …And Justice for All 198890 vs 76 from 10 others +14
  5. Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
  6. Reload 199740 vs 67 from 7 others −27
  7. St. Anger 200350 vs 66 from 9 others −16

All The Rolling Stone Album Guide reviews

Pitchfork11 albums−11
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198386 vs 81 from 7 others +5
  2. Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
  3. Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
  4. …And Justice for All 198893 vs 76 from 10 others +17
  5. Metallica 199177 vs 80 from 9 others −3
  6. Load 199666 vs 74 from 10 others −8
  7. St. Anger 20038 vs 71 from 9 others −63
  8. Death Magnetic 200849 vs 80 from 12 others −31
  9. Lulu 201110 vs 50 from 12 others −40
  10. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201665 vs 75 from 12 others −10
  11. 72 Seasons 202364 vs 75 from 17 others −11

All Pitchfork reviews

PopMatters4 albums−12
  1. Death Magnetic 200870 vs 78 from 12 others −8
  2. Lulu 201110 vs 50 from 12 others −40
  3. Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
  4. 72 Seasons 202370 vs 75 from 17 others −5

All PopMatters reviews

Encyclopedia of Popular Music8 albums−14
  1. Kill ‘Em All 198360 vs 85 from 7 others −25
  2. Ride the Lightning 198460 vs 91 from 7 others −31
  3. Master of Puppets 198680 vs 97 from 7 others −17
  4. …And Justice for All 198860 vs 79 from 10 others −19
  5. Metallica 199180 vs 80 from 9 others 0
  6. Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
  7. Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
  8. St. Anger 200340 vs 67 from 9 others −27

All Encyclopedia of Popular Music reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home