Metallica’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 12 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 75 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.
What is Metallica’s best album?
By the critics, it’s Master of Puppets (1986), with a B-Side Breakdown of 95 (Heavy Rotation) from 8 reviews. 100% of them liked it.
Next best: Ride the Lightning (87) and Kill ‘Em All (82). Lowest rated: Lulu (46).
Metallica albums ranked
Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.
- 1
Master of Puppets1986
95 Heavy Rotation - 2
Ride the Lightning198487 Heavy Rotation - 3
Kill ‘Em All198382 Keeper - 4
Metallica199180 Keeper - 5
Death Magnetic200878 Keeper - 6
…And Justice for All198877 Keeper - 7
72 Seasons202375 Keeper - 8
Hardwired… to Self-Destruct201674 Keeper - 9
Load199673 Keeper - 10
St. Anger200364 Mixed Bag - 11
Reload199764 Mixed Bag - 12
Lulu201146 Back of the Crate
Metallica discography, in release order
The career, by Breakdown
Every Metallica album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.
Every Metallica studio album, oldest first. One doesn't have a Breakdown yet; it gets one once three critics' reviews turn up.
- 1982No Life 'til LeatherNo Breakdown yet
- 1983
Kill ‘Em All82 Keeper - 1984
Ride the Lightning87 Heavy Rotation - 1986
Master of Puppets95 Heavy Rotation - 1988
…And Justice for All77 Keeper - 1991
Metallica80 Keeper - 1996
Load73 Keeper - 1997
Reload64 Mixed Bag - 2003
St. Anger64 Mixed Bag - 2008
Death Magnetic78 Keeper - 2011
Lulu46 Back of the Crate - 2016
Hardwired… to Self-Destruct74 Keeper - 2023
72 Seasons75 Keeper
Which critics love Metallica, and which don’t
Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 Metallica albums.
Outlet by outlet
Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.
Kerrang!3 albums+11
- Kill ‘Em All 1983100 vs 79 from 7 others +21
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6
NME7 albums+9
- Load 199670 vs 73 from 10 others −3
- Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- St. Anger 200390 vs 61 from 9 others +29
- Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
- Lulu 201170 vs 45 from 12 others +26
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6
Uncut3 albums+8
- …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
- St. Anger 200380 vs 63 from 9 others +17
- Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
Los Angeles Times4 albums+8
- Metallica 199170 vs 81 from 9 others −11
- Load 199688 vs 72 from 10 others +16
- Reload 199788 vs 60 from 7 others +28
- Death Magnetic 200875 vs 78 from 12 others −3
Rolling Stone9 albums+6
- …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
- Metallica 199180 vs 80 from 9 others 0
- Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
- Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- St. Anger 200380 vs 63 from 9 others +17
- Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
- Lulu 201160 vs 45 from 12 others +15
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6
AllMusic12 albums+4
- Kill ‘Em All 1983100 vs 79 from 7 others +21
- Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- …And Justice for All 198890 vs 76 from 10 others +14
- Metallica 199190 vs 79 from 9 others +11
- Load 199650 vs 75 from 10 others −25
- Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- St. Anger 200360 vs 65 from 9 others −5
- Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
- Lulu 201160 vs 45 from 12 others +15
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- 72 Seasons 202370 vs 75 from 17 others −5
The Guardian5 albums+3
- Kill ‘Em All 198380 vs 82 from 7 others −2
- Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
- Death Magnetic 200880 vs 77 from 12 others +3
- Lulu 201140 vs 47 from 12 others −7
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
Chicago Tribune6 albums+1
- Kill ‘Em All 198388 vs 81 from 7 others +7
- Ride the Lightning 198475 vs 89 from 7 others −14
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- …And Justice for All 198863 vs 79 from 10 others −16
- Metallica 199188 vs 79 from 9 others +9
- Reload 199775 vs 62 from 7 others +13
Louder4 albums0
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201660 vs 75 from 12 others −15
- 72 Seasons 202380 vs 74 from 17 others +6
Entertainment Weekly6 albums−2
Q5 albums−4
- Kill ‘Em All 198380 vs 82 from 7 others −2
- Ride the Lightning 198480 vs 88 from 7 others −8
- …And Justice for All 198880 vs 77 from 10 others +3
- Metallica 199160 vs 82 from 9 others −22
- Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
The Rolling Stone Album Guide7 albums−7
- Kill ‘Em All 198360 vs 85 from 7 others −25
- Ride the Lightning 198480 vs 88 from 7 others −8
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- …And Justice for All 198890 vs 76 from 10 others +14
- Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
- Reload 199740 vs 67 from 7 others −27
- St. Anger 200350 vs 66 from 9 others −16
Pitchfork11 albums−11
- Kill ‘Em All 198386 vs 81 from 7 others +5
- Ride the Lightning 1984100 vs 85 from 7 others +15
- Master of Puppets 1986100 vs 94 from 7 others +6
- …And Justice for All 198893 vs 76 from 10 others +17
- Metallica 199177 vs 80 from 9 others −3
- Load 199666 vs 74 from 10 others −8
- St. Anger 20038 vs 71 from 9 others −63
- Death Magnetic 200849 vs 80 from 12 others −31
- Lulu 201110 vs 50 from 12 others −40
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201665 vs 75 from 12 others −10
- 72 Seasons 202364 vs 75 from 17 others −11
PopMatters4 albums−12
- Death Magnetic 200870 vs 78 from 12 others −8
- Lulu 201110 vs 50 from 12 others −40
- Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 201680 vs 74 from 12 others +6
- 72 Seasons 202370 vs 75 from 17 others −5
Encyclopedia of Popular Music8 albums−14
- Kill ‘Em All 198360 vs 85 from 7 others −25
- Ride the Lightning 198460 vs 91 from 7 others −31
- Master of Puppets 198680 vs 97 from 7 others −17
- …And Justice for All 198860 vs 79 from 10 others −19
- Metallica 199180 vs 80 from 9 others 0
- Load 199680 vs 72 from 10 others +8
- Reload 199760 vs 64 from 7 others −4
- St. Anger 200340 vs 67 from 9 others −27
Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.
