David Gilmour Albums Ranked

David Gilmour’s albums, ranked by what the critics we trust thought of each one. 6 have a B-Side Breakdown, averaging 71 (Keeper). See the discography in release order.

What is David Gilmour’s best album?

By the critics, it’s Luck and Strange (2024), with a B-Side Breakdown of 80 (Keeper) from 12 reviews. 100% of them liked it.

Next best: Rattle That Lock (73) and About Face (73). Lowest rated: David Gilmour (64).

David Gilmour albums ranked

Best to worst by B-Side Breakdown.

  1. 1. Luck and Strange (2024): 80 Keeper
  2. 2. Rattle That Lock (2015): 73 Keeper
  3. 3. About Face (1984): 73 Keeper
  4. 4. Metallic Spheres (2010): 69 Mixed Bag
  5. 5. On an Island (2006): 65 Mixed Bag
  6. 6. David Gilmour (1978): 64 Mixed Bag

David Gilmour discography, in release order

The career, by Breakdown

Every David Gilmour album with a B-Side Breakdown, in release order. Above the dashed line, most critics liked it.

5010070likedDavid Gilmour (1978): 64641978About Face (1984): 73731984On an Island (2006): 65652006Metallic Spheres (2010): 69692010Rattle That Lock (2015): 73732015Luck and Strange (2024): 80802024

Every David Gilmour album we track, oldest first.

  1. 1978Album cover for David Gilmour by David GilmourDavid Gilmour64 Mixed Bag
  2. 1984Album cover for About Face by David GilmourAbout Face73 Keeper
  3. 2006Album cover for On an Island by David GilmourOn an Island65 Mixed Bag
  4. 2010Album cover for Metallic Spheres by David GilmourMetallic Spheres69 Mixed Bag
  5. 2015Album cover for Rattle That Lock by David GilmourRattle That Lock73 Keeper
  6. 2024Album cover for Luck and Strange by David GilmourLuck and Strange80 Keeper

Which critics love David Gilmour, and which don’t

Each outlet’s scores set against the other critics on the same albums. Outlets that scored at least 3 David Gilmour albums.

Outlet by outlet

Average points above or below the other critics. Tap an outlet for its scores album by album.

Q3 albums+13
  1. On an Island 200680 vs 63 from 9 others +17
  2. Metallic Spheres 201080 vs 68 from 10 others +13
  3. Rattle That Lock 201580 vs 71 from 7 others +9

All Q reviews

Uncut3 albums+10
  1. On an Island 200670 vs 65 from 9 others +5
  2. Metallic Spheres 201080 vs 68 from 10 others +13
  3. Luck and Strange 202490 vs 79 from 11 others +11

All Uncut reviews

Mojo4 albums+9
  1. On an Island 200680 vs 63 from 9 others +17
  2. Metallic Spheres 201080 vs 68 from 10 others +13
  3. Rattle That Lock 201580 vs 71 from 7 others +9
  4. Luck and Strange 202480 vs 80 from 11 others 0

All Mojo reviews

AllMusic6 albums0
  1. David Gilmour 197850 vs 68 from 3 others −18
  2. About Face 198490 vs 65 from 2 others +25
  3. On an Island 200670 vs 65 from 9 others +5
  4. Metallic Spheres 201060 vs 70 from 10 others −10
  5. Rattle That Lock 201570 vs 73 from 7 others −3
  6. Luck and Strange 202480 vs 80 from 11 others 0

All AllMusic reviews

musicOMH3 albums−5
  1. On an Island 200660 vs 66 from 9 others −6
  2. Metallic Spheres 201060 vs 70 from 10 others −10
  3. Luck and Strange 202480 vs 80 from 11 others 0

All musicOMH reviews

PopMatters3 albums−6
  1. On an Island 200660 vs 66 from 9 others −6
  2. Metallic Spheres 201060 vs 70 from 10 others −10
  3. Rattle That Lock 201570 vs 73 from 7 others −3

All PopMatters reviews

Rolling Stone4 albums−15
  1. About Face 198460 vs 80 from 2 others −20
  2. On an Island 200640 vs 68 from 9 others −28
  3. Rattle That Lock 201570 vs 73 from 7 others −3
  4. Luck and Strange 202470 vs 81 from 11 others −11

All Rolling Stone reviews

Missing an album? Our back catalog is still filling in, and every artist’s other studio albums are on the list to be added, so this page should be complete soon.

All artists · B-Side Breakdowns home