Jimmy Newlin

Jimmy Newlin’s album reviews that count toward B-Side Breakdowns: 42 reviews, going back to 2006, each next to the album’s Breakdown.

Is this you? Send us a photoOnly send a photo you took or have the rights to share.

Writes for

  • Slant 2006–2009 · 42 reviews

What they review

  • Indie & Alternative 45%
  • Rock 26%
  • Hip-Hop & Rap 14%
  • Folk, Country & Americana 7%

Find Jimmy Newlin

By the numbers

2A-Sides reviewed, the albums the critics rate highest
2albums given a perfect score
4years of their reviews we track, 2006 to 2009
How their scores spread
  • 0–495
  • 50s3
  • 60s8
  • 70s8
  • 80s12
  • 90+6

Their favorites

  1. Liz PhairExile in Guyville 100 Slant
  2. The NationalBoxer 100 Slant
  3. Nick Cave and the Bad SeedsDig, Lazarus, Dig!!! 90 Slant
  4. Richard ThompsonSweet Warrior 90 Slant
  5. PavementWowee Zowee 90 Slant

A-Sides they reviewed

2 albums that earned an A-Side, the critics’ top tier; they scored 2 of them 70 or higher.

Every review

Outlet
Au Revoir SimoneStill Night, Still Light“Au Revoir Simone is a bit of a one-note band, and their latest album, Still Night, Still Light, is a bit of a one-note album.”Slant80 4/5782009
Randy NewmanHarps and Angels“Newman’s arrangements, first of all, have never seemed quite this obvious and theatrical.”Slant70 3.5/5832008
NasUntitled“The lyrics are all terrific; the beats, not so much.”Slant70 3.5/5762008
Liz PhairExile in Guyville“Liz Phair's 'Exile in Guyville' has the phrase “blowjob queen” on it and the singer’s nipple on the cover, but it’s so much more.”Slant100 5/5932008
Nick Cave and the Bad SeedsDig, Lazarus, Dig!!!“There are quite a few moons on Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!!, the 14th Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds studio album.”Slant90 4.5/5842008
The BreedersMountain Battles“It’s tempting to greet Mountain Battles with a jaded indie-rock kid’s petulant shrugging and chorus of “whatever.” Don’t.”Slant80 4/5722008
She & HimVolume One“Volume One is primarily a She affair.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5752008
U2The Joshua Tree“U2's The Joshua Tree might not be as magnificent as the masses claim, but it’s not without its share of magnificence.”Slant80 4/5902007
Jay-ZAmerican Gangster“Even when he’s trying to raise consciousness, Jay-Z doesn’t really have any valid solutions.”Slant80 4/5792007
Neil YoungChrome Dreams II“Throughout, Young seems to be questioning the same rock ‘n’ roll tropes that he fondly reminisced about on Harvest Moon.”Slant60 3/5662007
Bruce SpringsteenMagic“I’ll grant you that Magic is uneven, but I cannot admit that it is anything other than constantly captivating.”Slant80 4/5842007
Lyle LovettLyle Lovett“Hopefully in the next four-to-seven, he’ll come back a little reenergized.”Slant70 3.5/5782007
Rilo KileyUnder the Blacklight“Under the Blacklight is less of a major label debut for indie-poppers Rilo Kiley than it is a coming out party.”Slant80 4/5702007
Ryan AdamsEasy Tiger“Though often criticized for over-saturation, Ryan Adams is as efficient as he is prolific.”Slant80 4/5712007
Richard ThompsonSweet Warrior“Sweet Warrior is a minor release from a major artist.”Slant via Wikipedia90 4.5/5822007
BattlesMirrored“Battles sound exactly like Steve Reich and Philip Glass jamming with Don Caballero.”Slant60 3/5802007
The NationalBoxer“As wraithlike as Air’s moon-rock, Boxer is also as focused and rugged as a great punk record.”Slant via Wikipedia100 5/5822007
Bright EyesCassadaga“Even the angrier, more polemical moments on Cassadaga are too rooted in allegory to energize the listener.”Slant80 4/5792007
Patti SmithTwelve“Playing it safe could not be more inappropriate for a Patti Smith album.”Slant30 1.5/5612007
Charlotte Gainsbourg5:55“Gainsbourg’s first album since she was 13 is European to the core, and like most things European, it’s extravagant, elegant, and overpriced.”Slant80 4/5762007
DntelDumb Luck“Listening to Dumb Luck is kind of like listening to a robot cry for 40 minutes.”Slant via Wikipedia40 2/5612007
Modest MouseWe Were Dead Before the Ship Even Sank“Is it possible to write a review of the new Modest Mouse record without mentioning “Float On”?”Slant70 3.5/5752007
Okkervil RiverBlack Sheep Boy“Black Sheep Boy is nearing classic status, at least as far as emo concept albums based on old folk songs are concerned.”Slant via Wikipedia80 4/5812007
AirPocket Symphony“The worst of Pocket Symphony is dull and overly familiar, and the best is familiar and gently gorgeous.”Slant60 3/5642007
The StoogesThe Weirdness“The Weirdness never sounds like anything more than a competent but ultimately unremarkable band that sounds a little like the Stooges.”Slant50 2.5/5482007
PavementWowee Zowee“With Sordid Sentinels you get the joy of Pavement’s top-shelf rarities without the hassle of tracking them down.”Slant90 4.5/5702006
Kevin FederlinePlaying with Fire“Playing with Fire settles into its mediocre groove early.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5242006
Sarah McLachlanWintersong“Wintersong is a seasonal showcase for McLachlan’s cathedral-ready soprano.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5692006
The DecemberistsThe Crane Wife“It’s too inconsistent to be declared the masterpiece of which Colin Meloy and company are capable.”Slant70 3.5/5792006
The Gothic ArchiesThe Tragic Treasury: Songs from A Series of Unfortunate Events“The masses are urged to wait for when Treasury’s best tracks are compiled on the boxed set.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5702006
The LemonheadsThe Lemonheads“The Lemonheads is nearly as great as the band’s masterpiece, It’s a Shame About Ray.”Slant90 4.5/5682006
Jason MolinaLet Me Go, Let Me Go, Let Me Go“Let Me Go, Let Me Go, Let Me Go too often confuses tedium with poignancy.”Slant via Wikipedia50 2.5/5702006
The Mountain GoatsGet Lonely“Like all Mountain Goats albums, of course, there are some gems.”Slant60 3/5682006
Kool KeithThe Return of Dr. OctagonSlant via Wikipedia60 3/5602006
Mr. LifMo’ Mega“Mr. Lif’s Mo’ Mega keeps the bar set pretty high.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5722006
Peeping TomPeeping Tom“A failure as spectacular as Peeping Tom only drums up higher hopes for a redemptive follow-up.”Slant via Wikipedia20 1/5582006
The Bouncing SoulsThe Gold Record“The Gold Record is more dependable than it is spectacular.”Slant via Wikipedia70 3.5/5762006
Scott WalkerThe Drift“This year might just be The Year Avant Garde Broke.”Slant80 4/5862006
The CoupPick a Bigger Weapon“The problem is not the Coup’s OutKast influence, but that the comparison illuminates Riley’s significantly weaker flow.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5752006
Red KrayolaThe Red Krayola“If The Red Krayola frontman Mayo Thompson should be lauded for anything, it’s persistence.”Slant80 4/5682006
MogwaiMr Beast“Their deafening exterior is only there to mask the only quality worse than derivativeness: tedium.”Slant40 2/5782006
TortoiseThe Brave and the Bold“The toughest part about being as weird as Will Oldham is keeping your wackiness from becoming predictable.”Slant via Wikipedia60 3/5682006

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home