More numbers (how close they land to the other critics, release-week calls) appear once we track 15 of their reviews.

Every review

All genresFolk, Country & AmericanaIndie & AlternativePopRockAll years20262014201320122010

Album	Outlet	Their score	Breakdown	Published
Robbie WilliamsBritpop“Not only has it been some time since the last ‘normal’ studio album from Robbie Williams, but it has also been quite a while since the campaign began for”	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	73	Jan 16, 2026
Sophie Ellis-BextorWanderlust“Sophie Ellis-Bextor – 'Wanderlust'. The singer's fifth long-player proves to be quite the impressive surprise”	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	60	2014
TravisWhere You Stand“Clash reviews 'Where You Stand', the new album by Scottish indie-poppers Travis – "they’re currently producing some of the finest music of their career…”	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	70	2013
Will OldhamI See a Darkness	Clash via Wikipedia	90 9/10	88	2012
Manic Street PreachersPostcards from a Young Man“Leave your prejudices at the door and open up your ears. After the militant basslines and scorching vocals of ‘Journal For Plague Lovers’, the Manics are going for your heart.”	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	74	2010
Manic Street PreachersGeneration Terrorists	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	83
Manic Street PreachersRewind the Film	Clash via Wikipedia	80 8/10	83
Marina DiamandisThe Family Jewels	Clash via Wikipedia	60 6/10	71

Is this you? Send a correction. Scores marked via Wikipedia come from the album’s Wikipedia ratings box, which names the critic in its citation. All critics · B-Side Breakdowns home